AQW 19476/22-27


Mrs Diane Dodds
Democratic Unionist Party
Upper Bann


Tabled Date: 06/12/2024
Answered On Date: 19/12/2024
Priority Written: No


Question:
To ask the Minister of Health to detail (i) the total costs incurred from the proposed energy centre project in the Belfast Health and Social Care Trust; and (ii) the reasons for the project being abandoned.


Answer:
Total spend to date (10th December 2024) on the Energy Centre is £9,514,155.00.
The preferred tenderer price for the energy scheme, received in April 2023, was four times the approved OBC cost and more than double the pre-tender estimate. The pre tender estimate was provided by the consultant design team to reflect the extant conditions in the construction and supply landscape. The construction period determined by the tenderer as part of their submission for tender was 260 weeks, almost two times longer than the estimate provided at OBC stage.
A Gateway Review carried out for the Energy Centre in January 2024 received a delivery confidence rating of red. The review panel recommended that the project should not proceed to the next phase until several issues are managed to an acceptable level of risk and the viability of the project/programme has been re-confirmed. The Trust accepted the findings and recommendations of the draft Gateway Review and acknowledged the shortcomings in terms of assurances around strategic need, options appraisal and procurement.
Following the concerns raised by the Gateway Team the Trust sought to develop an interim energy solution which would ensure that the Trust were able to continue to deliver sufficient and reliable electrical and heating supplies to existing facilities on the Royal Hospitals site. This interim solution aims to provide an energy solution for the site for circa 10 years, whilst also accommodating the additional requirements of the New Children’s Hospital.
The project SRO, with the support of the Trust’s Executive Team and Trust Board, agreed to proceed with an interim solution developed in conjunction with the Trust Estates team, on the basis that this will ensure sufficient energy capacity for the RVH site for circa 10 years, including the supply of energy to the New Children’s Hospital.
Furthermore, the interim plan allows the Trust to introduce a significant pause to the energy centre project which would result in a number of benefits for the organisation as set out below:
The renewable technology market is going through a period of rapid change and a pause period would allow these technologies to be embedded before the Trust commits to a major project.
DoH are currently producing their response to the ‘Path to Net Zero’. A pause in the project would allow us to ensure that we deliver a project which is better aligned with future Departmental policy.
Should the market not change significantly in the short to medium term, an alternative procurement approach could be adopted which might deliver better value for money.