AQW 30795/22-27 Mrs Diane Dodds Democratic Unionist Party Upper Bann
Tabled Date: 10/09/2025 Answered On Date: 25/09/2025 Priority Written: No
Question: To ask the Minister of Health to detail the procurement process undertaken for the construction of the new Children’s Hospital in Belfast.
Answer:
A procurement strategy for the New Children’s Hospital (NCH) was prepared by CPD Health Projects (now DoH Health Estates) and approved by the Belfast Health and Social Care Trust (BHSCT). Following consideration of various options, the most appropriate procurement route was determined to be the Restricted Procedure with contract award being assessed on the basis of cost alone. The pre-qualification stage established a shortlist of 5 suitably experienced contractors with the capability to deliver a project of the size and complexity of the NCH using objective criteria. One of the suitably experienced contractors shortlisted, withdrew from the procurement process on 1 December 2020. Tender documentation was issued to the remaining four suitably experienced shortlisted contractors in May 2021 with the tender return date being set as 28 November 2021 15:00hrs. Following requests from a number of tenderers the tender period was ultimately extended until 5th April 2022 15:00hrs. During the tender period three further contractors withdrew from the process for a variety of reasons at differing times ranging between 25 May 2021 and 5 April 2022. The tender submission period ended on 5 April 2022 15:00hrs with one tender received from the Graham BAM Healthcare Partnership (GBHP). It is the assertion of the CoPE, CPD Health Projects (now Health Estates), that the tender received from GBHP was a competitive tender in that the tender received was submitted in advance (5 April 2022 12:02hrs) of the late withdrawal of the other remaining tenderer (5 April 2022 14:45hrs). The tender received has been benchmarked against a range of healthcare schemes at various stages across the United Kingdom and Ireland. Whilst the cost per m2 of the new children’s hospital is 12.29% higher than the average of the benchmark schemes, it is the view of CPD Health Projects (now Health Estates) that the tender received represents value for money given the plethora of factors impacting on the construction industry at present including but not limited to: Constantly evolving impact of BREXIT and COVID 19 pandemic; Worldwide raw material shortages caused by supply/demand imbalance; Fuel and energy cost increases exacerbated by the situation in Eastern Europe; Labour rate increases resulting from supply/demand imbalance as a result of ‘pull’ of Dublin and UK mainland construction projects along with inflation driven upward wage pressure; National insurance rate increase; and Red diesel fuel levy. The impact of these inflationary factors will not have been reflected in the majority of the benchmark projects given that the base dates pre date the time period when the inflationary factors occurred. It would be the view of CPD Health Projects (now Health Estates) that the factors listed could be in excess of the 12.29% difference between the benchmark cost per m2 and the cost per m2 of the New Children’s Hospital. In summary CPD Health Projects (now Health Estates), on behalf of the BHSCT, can confirm that the project has been procured using the most appropriate method.
|