Official Report: Minutes of Evidence

Committee for the Economy, meeting on Wednesday, 4 November 2026


Members present for all or part of the proceedings:

Ms Diane Forsythe (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr Pádraig Delargy
Mr David Honeyford
Mr Declan Kearney
Ms Sinéad McLaughlin
Mr Peter Martin
Mr Mike Nesbitt
Ms Kate Nicholl


Witnesses:

Mr Gerard Deane, Community Foundation Northern Ireland
Ms Mairead McMahon, Community Foundation Northern Ireland
Dr Mairead McCormack, Glenshane Community Development Ltd
Mr Colum McNicholl, Glenshane Community Development Ltd



Regional Balance Bill: Community Foundation NI; Glenshane Community Development Ltd

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): This session will be recorded by the Official Report. I welcome Colum McNicholl and Dr Mairead McCormack, respectively chairman and chief executive of Glenshane Community Development Ltd; and Mairead McMahon and Gerard Deane, respectively the director of policy and a trustee of Community Foundation Northern Ireland (CFNI). Before I hand over to you, I want to commend the witnesses and thank you for the high-quality written evidence that you have submitted and for agreeing to come to the Committee together. We really appreciate that. I invite you to make some opening remarks, after which members will have plenty of questions.

Dr Mairead McCormack (Glenshane Community Development Ltd): Thank you, Chair and members, for inviting Glenshane Community Development Ltd to contribute to your scrutiny of the Regional Balance Bill. I have led Glenshane Community Development Ltd as its chief executive since 1998. The organisation was established as a limited company in 1989 and has now served the community for 37 years. Our chairman Colum McNicholl was one of the founding members, and his involvement predates incorporation and extends back some 40 years when, as a local businessman, he became involved in efforts to build and retain community wealth, create employment and secure a stronger economic future for the area.

We are a cross-community and community-anchor organisation, serving everyone regardless of background. We combine local economic development, community ownership of assets, enterprise support and access to services to sustain Dungiven and its rural hinterland. We have developed 48,000 square feet of workspace at Glenshane Enterprise Centre and Glenshane Business Park, purchased retail properties and eateries at McCloskey House and on New Street, and we own residential properties and our community hub at Glenshane House.

We restored Dungiven Castle, initially for tourist accommodation, and it is now home to a secondary school, Gaelcholáiste Dhoire. Approximately 489 people are employed in businesses established across our premises. Our work has included being an Action for Community Employment (ACE) awards sponsor in the 1990s, and part of the new deal consortium. Glenshane House has an independent advice clinic, and we offer educational courses in partnership with North West Regional College, as well as hosting activities including kinesiology, meditation, yoga and Pilates classes. We operated a seedcorn loan fund, which, according to a 2000 audit by BDO Stoy Hayward, revolved approximately 3·5 times. It was the highest recorded in NI and generated £525,000 in accumulative local reinvestment. As loans were repaid, the money was lent again, demonstrating how locally managed finance can build and retain community wealth.

Community ownership enables our properties to serve successive generations with income to support their maintenance and continued local development, as well as subsidising our advice service. We are delighted to be partners in the Causeway Coast and Glens growth deal project alongside the council and DAERA, working on the development of an enterprise hub for Dungiven, alongside streetscape and environmental improvements. As a community anchor, we are self-sustaining, and such continuity, supported by our local voluntary board, is central to meeting the needs of our community.

Successive strategies and funding programmes have enabled valuable developments but regional disparities persist. We welcome the proposed statutory regional balance strategic framework, with departmental responsibilities, funding plans, measurable targets and a timescale. The Bill offers an opportunity to make regional balance a sustained responsibility across the Executive. As we stated in our written submission, "regional balance" does not mean identical provision everywhere. It means ensuring that people and businesses have a reasonable opportunity to prosper wherever they are located, with investment responding to the barriers that they face. A cross-departmental approach is essential. Affordable rates and workspace can help a business to establish itself but growth also depends on transport, skills, childcare, digital connectivity and infrastructure. Government decisions must reinforce one another if investment is to achieve lasting results.

We have divided our support of the Bill into three key priorities. Our first recommendation is that disparities are measured at a sufficiently local level. It cannot be assumed that Dungiven and its rural hinterland share the circumstances of larger settlements such as Coleraine and Ballymoney just because we are in the same council area, and improving council-wide averages may conceal communities where investment remains limited and access to opportunity has changed very little. We welcome the Bill's flexibility to use smaller statistical geographies and functional economic areas. That must inform how priorities are established and progress is assessed. Measurements should capture practical barriers such as journey times to employment and training, childcare availability, broadband reliability, affordable enterprise premises and access to services. Outward youth migration also matters. When young people must leave to secure suitable employment, the consequences extend to local businesses, the future workforce and community sustainability.

Our second recommendation is that Departments demonstrate how regional balance has influenced significant policies, spending proposals and investment decisions. Our submission proposes proportionate regional impact assessments that draw on the experience of rural proofing. They should take place while options remain open and decisions can still be changed.

Where a proposal could widen a disparity, Departments should explain the alternatives considered and the measures proposed to mitigate that impact. Investment appraisal must recognise the circumstances of places with a weaker economic base. If funding repeatedly follows existing concentrations of employment, infrastructure and development capacity, those concentrations will continue to strengthen. Our experience demonstrates how investment can build capacity locally. The framework should recognise community anchors as partners in shaping and delivering regional development, drawing on their assets, knowledge and enduring commitment to their communities.

Our third priority is that reporting should demonstrate whether disparities are narrowing and identify what will change when progress is insufficient. The proposed departmental information, annual report and ministerial statement provide a basis for scrutiny. Their value will depend on the evidence presented and the action that follows. Reporting should examine investment by financial value, per capita distribution and outcomes, including the quality of employment, household incomes, business survival and access to opportunity. Counting projects alone will not establish whether disparities are reducing. Where targets are missed, Departments should explain why and identify collective actions, responsibilities and timescales. Persistent or widening disparities should prompt a response before the five-year review.

Our central request is that the Bill connect statutory responsibility to practical decisions about resources, infrastructure and opportunity. Its success should be judged by whether people in places such as Dungiven have better prospects of establishing a business, securing good employment and building a future in their own community. Thank you.

Ms Mairead McMahon (Community Foundation Northern Ireland): Thank you very much to the Committee for inviting us here today to represent the Community Foundation Northern Ireland. As you know, my name is Mairead, and I am delighted to be joined by Gerard, who is one of our trustees.

For those of you who are not familiar with the Community Foundation, we are the largest independent grant maker. We have been around since 1979 — not me personally but the organisation — and we have three connected roles: funding community action; delivering programmes in partnership with communities; and using what we learn from all that experience to influence and to advocate for systemic change. Over that period, we have distributed around £100 million to communities. Last year, it was around £6 million through 776 grants to voluntary and community organisations in every part of Northern Ireland. The value of those grants ranges from £250 to almost £180,000. That gives you a sense of the role that we play and why we are here today to talk about our support for the Bill, which we welcome.

We particularly welcome the Bill's ambition to place a sustained statutory focus on reducing the disparities in economic performance, living standards and well-being across Northern Ireland. From the work that we do day and daily with communities, donors and voluntary organisations, we see the strength of local places and the persistent inequities that prevent some communities from benefiting fully from economic growth and public investment. Therefore, while we support the Bill, our evidence focuses on how we think it could be strengthened, and a lot of that will align with what the other Mairead just said about the Bill becoming a practical driver of change rather than just creating another reporting requirement on any given Department.

Our first recommendation is about establishing a robust and transparent evidence base. Put simply, that is just us saying that we need to know where we are right now to be able to determine whether anything that we subsequently do is making a difference and moving things in the right direction. We think that that assessment should examine social, economic and financial well-being. It should look at differences within regions and council areas as well as between them, and it should draw on the work that the Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency (NISRA) is doing to link administrative datasets across government and align with the development of the updated measure of the index of multiple deprivation. That better data should not just describe inequity better; it should help the Government to determine where intervention is needed, guide their investment decisions and provide a transparent basis to measure progress. We want the legislation to establish the clear expectation that policy, investment and service delivery will reduce the disparities that are identified in that data over time and avoid creating new ones.

Mr Gerard Deane (Community Foundation Northern Ireland): The other thing that we want to mention is regional balance at the neighbourhood level. The other Mairead talked about that, and it is really important to echo that. Regional balance, as you know, should not be seen as just beyond Belfast. It is more than that. Some significant inequalities exist between neighbourhoods located in the same council area. In fact, following the review of public administration (RPA) and the merger of councils — this is my take, not necessarily CFNI's — you can see disparities within council areas. At times, there is a need to balance those up as well, which can create its own challenges. If we monitor only at a broad regional level, improvements in one part of an area could mask persistent disadvantage elsewhere. We therefore encourage the Committee to consider how councils and other public bodies could support the delivery of the strategic framework at a neighbourhood level as well. That should complement, not dilute, the Executive's responsibilities on regional balance. No one should be left behind in that process.

Ms McMahon: The Bill provides for consultation on the strategic framework, and we think that there is an opportunity to take that a step further. Communities should not simply be consulted and invited to comment on proposals that have already been agreed and developed. Residents, community organisations and local stakeholders should play a meaningful role in identifying the local priorities for those places, as well as the assets that already exist and how they could be used to greater effect. They should be able to shape the outcomes that matter in their communities, inform decisions about investment and service delivery and, ultimately, be part of reviewing whether the framework is achieving tangible change. That would improve the quality and legitimacy of decisions and widen civic participation among people and communities whose voices are often under-represented in those formal democratic decision-making processes.

Mr Deane: We also need to recognise that investment in relationships, as well as places, will be important throughout the process. It is not just about the allocation of funding, though it would be nice to have funding. It does not have to be restricted to that. Investment will have a greater and more sustainable impact on communities where they are also supported to build relationships, share their learning and work together. There is a strong sense of pride in place in Northern Ireland and a significant tradition of locally rooted community action and giving. We need to build on that. The strategic framework should harness those strengths by creating opportunities for communities to learn from successful approaches elsewhere in the sector and beyond, collaborate across geographical boundaries and develop stronger local leadership.

We also need to recognise that this has to be cross-sectoral. Regional imbalance will not be addressed by just one Department. We may be sitting at this Committee, but the scope is broader. Success will require sustained collaboration across Departments, local government, businesses, the community and voluntary sector, philanthropic organisations and local residents. The strongest place-based approaches combine public investment, community knowledge, business expertise, civic leadership and long-term partnership. The strategic framework should recognise and enable those contributions, rather than treating regional balance as an exclusively governmental programme.

Ms McMahon: Our final recommendation is on philanthropy and community investment. The Bill is an opportunity to consider the contribution of philanthropy to regional development. In our experience, philanthropic giving is often closely connected to people's attachment to a place. Some of our funds, for example, are exclusively for the benefit of people who live in a particular area, because that is what the funder or donor wants. Access to philanthropic funding and networks, however, is not evenly distributed across Northern Ireland. There is an opportunity for the Government, funders and local partners to explore how philanthropic and community investment can be encouraged in places that have historically attracted fewer resources. That philanthropic giving should not replace statutory investment, but, when used appropriately, it can certainly support innovation, strengthen community capacity and attract additional resources alongside government funding.

In summary, we support the ambition of the Bill. It will be most effective if it establishes a robust baseline and transparent measures of progress; recognises the inequities that exist within regions as well as between them; embeds co-design by people and communities and their meaningful participation; strengthens connections and shared learning between communities; enables collaboration across government, businesses and civil society; and recognises the contribution of philanthropy and locally rooted investment. Taken together, those measures will help to ensure that regional balance is not simply an obligation to produce a framework or report on disparities but that the Bill becomes a practical mechanism for changing how decisions are made and delivering stronger, more connected and more prosperous communities across Northern Ireland. Thank you very much, and we are happy to take questions.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Thank you, all, very much for that, and thank you for the detail in your written submissions. Points were well made and have been reiterated in your opening remarks. I am keen to get members in. Pádraig?

Mr Delargy: Thanks, Chair. Thank you very much for your two presentations. They were really useful. I have two questions. The first is on the community and voluntary sector in general. At Committees and in debates in the Chamber, we often hear about the "third sector", and that term really turns me, because the community and voluntary sector is actually the first interface that most people have and is often the sector that reaches people who are not reached by statutory services. I commend you both on the work that you do.

You used the term "co-design". It is a really important concept, not just at this stage but in how we monitor things going forward, so I am glad that you talked about the monitoring and development of the regional balance framework. I want to delve into that a bit to understand what that looks like for you. How would it report back? What would the mechanisms be? What would you see as success? What do you see as proper co-design, including monitoring?

Ms McMahon: Gerard will be able to add to this, I am sure. There are loads of models. I am certainly happy to follow up with a bit more detail for the Committee, if that would be helpful. It is about things such as participatory budgeting, which means communities having a say in how the budget is allocated in their area. There are civic engagement models. There is no one-size-fits-all model. It is about bringing more voices into the conversation.

Philanthropy has an important role in that. There are lots of ways in which that is misunderstood. Sometimes, people think that that is about American donors coming in. In fact, there is an awful lot more local giving than, perhaps, is visible to most people day and daily. A lot of those people are willing to put their hand in their pocket and give their money, but they also want to give their ideas, suggestions, expertise and knowledge. It is sometimes quite difficult to find the route into that. It is about bringing all that resource together around one table and asking, "What does this place need, and how can we all play a part in that, work together and fund things differently?" Philanthropic funding can take risks that government funding cannot take. It can do the edgy, innovative and risky things that may be harder for local or central government to fund. It can learn from what works and what does not and help to scale ideas and share learning across different areas.

I am absolutely happy to follow up with some practical models and how-tos, but, as a point of principle, the more people who are brought in to make those decisions for their place, the better.

Mr Deane: On the measurement point, Pádraig, we need to baseline it properly in order to get accurate statistics, especially on multiple deprivation. We could also weight them slightly differently, particularly for people in rural communities. For example, distance from and access to services could be given a wee bit more priority. Above all, we need to look at the time frame. This cannot be seen as something that will effect change for people within one mandate. That is not the case. There is a longitudinal approach. We are talking about generations of change. We need to change practice that has been in place for generations here. The measurement of that will be key. Baselining is important, but so is being realistic and saying, "We will not do this within three, five or even 10 years, but we are going to start".

Dr McCormack: We would also like, perhaps, not just the positive attributions about job creation and so on to be measured but the barriers to be identified, such as transport, the distance to work that people travel, childcare and digital inclusion, and to make sure that that disaggregated data is collected in a neighbourhood area or a more confined geographical area rather than council-wide. We are aware that some villages could be concealed if they are not improving in a council area for which the average is increasing. We do not want that data or information being lost.

Mr Delargy: One hundred per cent. Everything that has been said chimes with my views on the matter.

My second point has been touched on, and I asked the previous witnesses about it as well. It is about deprivation indices and the metrics around those. One thing that I am really keen to understand is how we can future-proof the Bill so that we do not miss any deprivation factors that we might have excluded to date. As community representatives, do you have any views on that? Is there anything that we can put in the Bill to further enhance it?

Dr McCormack: I believe that you should keep it open and keep revisiting it and tweaking it. Start with a proposal, then review it. It is set to be reviewed every five years, but, if something is not working, review it. Things have manifested that we had not experienced previously: COVID came through, and the cost-of-living crisis is coming through now. Whenever you become aware that there is a change in people's circumstances and the relevant data is not being collected, revisit it. It is not difficult to add in, record and accumulate an extra piece of data so that you have the statistics needed to see what is and is not working.

Ms McMahon: As Gerard said, I do not know whether it is the case that we are not measuring the right things; I think that it may sometimes be about the weighting that we apply. Access to services is more challenging in rural places than in many urban places. The other day, I saw a tweet about the fact that we do not all have the same 24 hours in one day. A journey that takes 20 minutes to drive would take someone relying on public transport two and half hours. That is not the same. It is not equity of access to services. The impact of that on rural communities is, perhaps, more significant than on urban areas. Measuring the right things but weighting them slightly differently could be the answer.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): I pass over to Sinéad, the Bill sponsor.

Ms McLaughlin: Thank you very much for the detail that both your organisations provided in your responses. I will go through the areas where you suggested amendments. Mairead, would it be appropriate or useful to add a co-design process to the lists at clause 1(4)? Would that go into the depth that we need and provide the necessary direction or instruction? I am trying to make sure that any amendments that we may bring forward meet the needs. Would the inclusion of a co-design process be enough to give direction? We can go further and deeper into what we actually mean by that in the explanatory notes.

Ms McMahon: Yes.

Ms McLaughlin: The other Mairead mentioned the legislative language of "due regard" not being a procedural mechanism. Will you explain what you mean by that, Mairead?

Dr McCormack: We were frightened that "due regard" may lead to a tick-box exercise, "Yes, we have given "due regard". We want it to be more quantifiable: what exactly qualified as "due regard" when you were looking at this? If something is identified, what actions will be taken to minimise or strengthen the impact of that? We want more than "due regard". We want there to be something enforceable that is actually investigated, not someone saying, "Yep, we've checked that and taken it on board", which may have been just at surface level.

Ms McLaughlin: I appreciate that. That is why we picked an evaluation process and prioritised that against it. It has to be about action, timelines and evaluation.

You also mentioned the evaluation process and questioned the five years referred to in the Bill. Five years should be a maximum. Do you feel that we should look at that time frame in the Bill?

Dr McCormack: That should be built in. If it can be seen at an early stage that something is going wrong, why wait five years without some sort of intervention to try to get it back on track? That is what we were concerned about. We welcome the five-year review, but, if there is something going wrong and there is an awareness of that, it should be possible to take some sort of immediate action.

Ms McLaughlin: I was conscious of that, so I put in the requirement for an annual report on the framework. I agree with both organisations that it is fundamental that we get a proper baseline, because, going forward, that is how we will measure. This will not happen in one mandate; it is generational. It is long-term legislation that will cover many years because we are trying to correct something that has been missing from the culture of government, meaning that places were ignored.

On data, you both talked about the work of NISRA and the index of multiple deprivation. Some of the data that we have is so out of date. I have acknowledged that in clause 6 through an instruction, more or less, that the Department must commission data and research. Is that enough? Is that instruction strong enough, or do we need to strengthen it?

Ms McMahon: To your earlier point about culture and whether the word "co-design" is sufficient, the honest answer is that it depends. It depends how a Department chooses to interpret that. If it decides that "co-design" means a longer consultation or an event in a community hall, it can say, "Tick, we have co-designed", but, really, it has just delivered consultation slightly differently. It is all about how it will be implemented in practice. The explanatory notes will be quite important.

To do the meaningful, annual reporting and monitoring that Mairead talked about, you need data that is updated a bit more frequently. You cannot report on these things too quickly. It will take time to change. However, you would hope that there will be indicators of a change in direction at least. Even if the legislation does not ultimately achieve balanced outcomes within a short time frame, you will see a direction of travel in annual reported data. If, however, the data does not change from year to year and you are working off 10-year-old data to monitor whether the previous year's intervention worked, it will be difficult to report on whether it has made an impact. That is an unresolved challenge in the system that needs to be considered.

Ms McLaughlin: Another response that we received was that it may take multiple years to find the baseline. We may have to look at that in respect of the deprivation levels. Are there any glaring gaps in the indicators in clause 7 that we need to address? The list in clause 7 is very flexible and non-exhaustive. Is anything jumping out at you to make you ask, "Oh, what about that?"? During the previous evidence session, we talked about the importance of road and rail connectivity for rural communities in particular. Mairead, I liked your comment about the fact that not everybody has the same 24 hours. It takes me two hours to travel here, so it is not the same for everybody, and I am not going slowly [Laughter.]

Is anything jumping out at you?

Ms McMahon: Nothing beyond what you have already covered. Not at this stage.

Dr McCormack: If the inequalities that are being measured do not narrow, we want the Departments to identify what actions they intend to take to progress that.

Mr Nesbitt: Thank you, all, for your important engagement. If we are to achieve this, there will need to be an awful lot of top-down work by Departments, but there has to be a lot of bottom-up work as well. The representatives from the Centre for Cross Border Cooperation gave us a very good example of a financial services hub-and-spoke cluster in the Republic. There is the hub at the International Financial Services Centre (IFSC) in Dublin, and they talked about the fact that there is a spoke in, I think, Kilkenny. There are multiple reasons for that. For example, the local FE college teaches the right skills so that there is an appropriate workforce. That is something that government can do quite easily. They also said that a small number of individuals in Kilkenny wanted to make it happen, which is where you come in, Colum. I imagine that, over the past 40 years, you have made things happen despite rather than because of government.

Mr Colum McNicholl (Glenshane Community Development Ltd): Very much so.

Mr Nesbitt: How do we inspire and enable people such as you who have not started out yet?

Mr McNicholl: It is a challenge, even in our community. I sit on five or six community groups and four or five charities. Recruiting new blood has been a serious problem over the past 10 or 15 years. That seems to have improved, however, over the past two or three years. I do not know whether there is a feeling in the community or in the North as a whole, but younger people are coming forward and looking to join our boards, and we are enthused by that.

Mr Nesbitt: Do you have any idea why that is? There are so many regulations and responsibilities these days.

Mr McNicholl: It is quite surprising. I am approaching the last stages of my career, but there are people, who are mostly in their 30s — perhaps their kids are at school or whatever stage their life is at — who are coming in to volunteer for charities or community groups. I am quite enthused by that.

Mr Nesbitt: What do we do as the Government that helps, and what do we do that hinders —?

Mr McNicholl: Keep the money coming. [Laughter.]

Mr Nesbitt: Is there anything that we should be doing that we do not do? Those are the three key questions.

Mr Deane: The Bill is part of it. The Bill needs to be seen as an opportunity rather than a pain for some people. This is a recognition by government that they need to do things better and get things right, and resources should follow. That is the thing that will encourage people to get involved. We have had exactly the same challenges over the past few years as Colum has had. Things have been really difficult in the community and voluntary sector. As you say, with the legislation and the increasing demands of being on a board, people are less willing to get involved. They are also less willing to get involved when they look at the sector overall and see that there is a funding challenge ahead. Public services are restricted, and a large part of the sector delivers public services, sometimes below cost, as you will know from your time in Health.

We need to see things like this as an opportunity. We need brave, broad statements from government to say, "Here is how we are going to make this place better not only for you right now but for your children in future". That is about government leading by example and saying, "We are taking the brave steps to work together" and moving across the traditional lines. That is not easy, but that is what leadership should look like. When that leadership happens, it is reflected in local communities. By and large, local communities are already working together. We would like that to be reflected in places such as this, and we believe that resources should follow in that regard.

Mr Nesbitt: Pádraig does not like the expression "third sector". I do not like the fact that some officials — there are some — still look at the community and voluntary sector as a cheap, second-class alternative. You can reach into communities and do things that the statutory sector will never ever get to. I find sometimes, however, that voluntary and community sector groups come to government and say, "We have a problem, and you need to solve it for us with money". You could come to government and say, "You have a problem, according to your Programme for Government, and we are the solution. Work with us".

Mr Deane: Yes.

Mr McNicholl: That is what we do.

Ms McMahon: Yes, we are saying that, but we do not always find that the doors are open to those solutions.

Mr Nesbitt: There needs to be a cultural change in government.

Dr McCormack: Or a receptive ear sometimes, yes.

Ms McMahon: I mentioned that we gave out £6 million in grants last year, but we are only one funder. There are lots of other funders across Northern Ireland. If you bring those all together, you are talking about something in the region of £80 million to £100 million a year. They all have their own strategies and priorities and reasons for wanting to invest in different initiatives in different places. That will happen, regardless of anything that happens in this Building, but there is a missed opportunity there if you do not at least try to align somehow with government priorities. If government can work with the funding sector more effectively, you might find some better solutions.

Mr Nesbitt: When you mentioned barriers, I was quite surprised that you did not mention health. The number 1 cause of economic inactivity, for example, is poor mental and physical health.

Dr McCormack: I think back to our Action for Community Employment (ACE) programme, which was excellent. Unfortunately, the Government decided to do away with it. It was a hand-holding exercise for people, and it would be worth looking at reintroducing it. It was for people who had anxieties or thought that they were not good enough or could not do things. They got the opportunity to take up a six-month or 12-month placement and had access to courses, even for essential skills in English, maths and word processing, to give them confidence.

You should have seen them at the end of it, with their shoulders back and their heads held high. It made such a difference. It was good that they knew that, if it did not work out, they could go back to their benefits. For a lot of people, unfortunately, benefits are a safety blanket, and they do not realise what they could achieve — what they are capable of — if they just gave it a chance. Perhaps the Economy Committee should look at reintroducing ACE or doing something similar. It was such a successful programme here. I know that Tony Blair cut it because of what was happening in GB — he did not take on board what happened here — and brought in the New Deal consortia, which just did not deliver.

Mr Nesbitt: The loss of the European social fund did the same damage.

Mr Honeyford: Thank you both for coming in. You have really challenged how I have thought of this, and I appreciate that. The previous session was about the overall, helicopter view and infrastructure perspective on how to do regional balance, but you have brought it right down to the people on the ground, which is what this is all about. The concept of "concealed inequality" changes how we think about it, once we challenge our thinking. In my area, I think of Resurgam Trust, which, the week before last, won the title of "Social Enterprise of the Year". Resurgam has transformed the most deprived area in my constituency. People who did not want to live there want to do so now, and those who live there are proud of their area. What it has done for the economy of the area, in economic benefit and productivity, is absolutely outstanding.

I will say first that I totally support regional balance; I am not having a go at the Bill. I am worried, however, about adding to the burden of the people who do the work by requiring them to tick boxes and fill in surveys. How do we make sure that they get support? The change will ultimately come from the ground up rather than from anything done by anyone in this Building. Nobody in this Building could ever do what Resurgam did in Old Warren in Lisburn. Is there anything that needs to be put into the Bill to make sure that communities are empowered to take control? You talked about councils' delivery of it: how do we make sure that that happens so that people do not end up with just the burden of filling in surveys?

Mr Deane: The burden of filling in surveys should never rest with communities.

Mr Deane: Any risk associated with such legislation or programmes should rest with the Department. For too long, the risk has been passed down to community level; we see that with every funder that has ever funded in the sector. Who owns the risk? The risk should be owned by the person who gives out the money. It is about trusting the people on the ground to deliver. We are sick, sore and tired: admin is 60% or 70% of the job, which should never be the case. We need to look at who owns the risk. We should also look at the risk of not doing this right. I have a fear that this is our one shot and that, if we do not do it right, there will be more decades of regional imbalance in this place. Collectively, we cannot afford that.

Mr Honeyford: Sinéad has done phenomenal work in getting this on to the agenda and bringing the Bill forward; I salute her for that. Is there anything that we need to put into the Bill to make sure that that happens?

Ms McMahon: We come back to the conversation being about not the "what", which is the legislation, but the "how": how it is implemented and delivered and how we achieve cultural change in how the Department for the Economy and the Government think about these things. That bit of it is harder to define. It is not about specific words in any clause of any Bill; it is about leadership and the narrative of the stories that are told. As Gerard said, it is not about devolving statutory responsibility to communities; it is about the Government taking a leadership role and saying, "We want to work differently with you. We want to engage differently with you. We want to listen to what you think is the priority for your place and to figure out what we can do together to achieve your objectives".

Mr Honeyford: Thank you.

Ms Nicholl: I have only a quick question, because you have covered so much and your evidence has been really rich; thank you for that. My question is about data. I like the point that was raised about better linkage of datasets across Departments, which, it turns out, is a bigger piece of work than was anticipated. Can I hear more of your thoughts on this? Multiple deprivation was also mentioned, but what are the key data gaps that are making it difficult to assess regional disparities?

Mr Deane: Youth movement is one of the things that we need to capture. If opportunities do not exist, as Colum and Mairead referred to, people will leave their area. They will all go to Belfast, Dublin, London or wherever, and that will not help. It is really important to capture that. It is also about the stuff that Sinéad talked about: Invest NI's statistics on foreign direct investment in each area, the tax take in each area, what could be improved and which areas we need to focus on. It might touch on big questions like what the tax take is. We may need to look at bigger issues like water charges, because, perhaps, that could help to address regional imbalance and major infrastructural challenges.

Dr McCormack: We are also concerned that, perhaps, there is data that is being captured but not shared. There could be some sort of portal that is available to everyone and provides easier access to that data.

Ms Nicholl: As I said to the previous witnesses, we are so data-rich in Northern Ireland. Evidence is captured from the minute we are born until the minute we die, but it is not linked. If we were able to use those large administrative sets, we would solve everything, I think.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Thank you all very much. Thanks for the detailed written submissions as well. Thank you for coming in together and taking the time with us. It has been really informative. You will be in touch with a couple of follow-ups; there are documents to be sent. Thank you all so much for helping us with our scrutiny of the Bill.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up