Official Report: Minutes of Evidence

Committee for the Economy, meeting on Wednesday, 4 November 2026


Members present for all or part of the proceedings:

Ms Diane Forsythe (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr Pádraig Delargy
Mr David Honeyford
Mr Declan Kearney
Ms Sinéad McLaughlin
Mr Peter Martin
Mr Mike Nesbitt
Ms Kate Nicholl


Witnesses:

Dr David Jordan, Northern Ireland Productivity Forum



Regional Balance Bill: Northern Ireland Productivity Forum

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): I welcome Dr David Jordan from the Northern Ireland Productivity Forum. Sorry for keeping you waiting. We are delighted to have you here. I invite you to provide an opening oral statement, after which members will have a few questions for you.

Dr David Jordan (Northern Ireland Productivity Forum): Thank you very much for the invitation to give evidence today. I will give a very brief overview of the evidence that we submitted, and I will be happy to take questions. The evidence that we responded with is based on our work in the Northern Ireland Productivity Forum and with my colleagues at Queen's Business School, Professor John Turner and Ruth Donaldson. We approached our evidence very much from the perspective of productivity and what we have learnt through our research, and we applied that to the Bill.

I will give a quick overview of the four aspects that we highlight. The first is our suggestion that productivity is a central priority. Productivity is central to our living standards and is ultimately what drives our living standards over the long term. We think that a focus on productivity will help tackle regional disparities, given that the aim of the Bill is to focus on trying to remove those disparities across Northern Ireland. The idea of having more of a central priority is because the data will point in potentially contradictory directions depending on what measure you are looking at. The Bill lists 10 measures for those disparities. If you are trying to direct policy, you need to try to prioritise the interventions across different areas, particularly because the Bill is trying to avoid silo policymaking. In our research and in our 'NI Productivity 2040' report, which we published in 2025, we really focused on the issue of silo policymaking. We think that having a central objective will help avoid those silo policymaking issues, particularly if you want to think about whether the Bill is a strategic policy tool or an accountability tool. Potentially, those tools pull in different directions, and that is why we recommend the idea of a central priority.

The second area is the measure of productivity and, specifically, labour productivity. The Bill mentions gross value added (GVA) per employee, which we agree should be there. However, we recommend that GVA per hour worked should also be explicitly included in the Bill, particularly because those values can give quite different results for different local government districts in Northern Ireland. If you look at GVA per job, Belfast is really good: it is the top region in Northern Ireland; however, if you look at GVA per hour worked, Belfast is seventh of the 11 local government districts. You get quite a different outcome depending on which one you use. Derry City and Strabane is last — eleventh — in productivity per job, but it is eighth in productivity per hour worked. You get different results depending on the measure, so bringing those together is important.

However, it is worth noting that the Office for National Statistics (ONS), in its most recent regional productivity publication, which was last year, did not include a publication of productivity per job at local government district level for Northern Ireland. Our most recent statistics for that are from 2022, so they are quite old. The ONS has delayed its publication of this year's regional productivity publication due to issues that it is having with measurement. The publication is not due to come out until 24 November, and that will only tell us the figures for 2024, so there is quite a delay with the data.

The third area is the use of baseline years. We want to highlight the uncertainties that can exist with the data. In our work, we highlight the uncertainty around COVID-19 and how that affected measures of productivity. We are also aware that the ONS has had issues with its own data publications. For example, the Labour Force Survey for Great Britain has had issues with a low response rate, and revisions of it have led to revisions of productivity statistics for the UK and its regions. There can be uncertainty associated with those surveys, but there can also be uncertainty when it is measured by smaller geographic areas, like local government districts, as you will get more volatility in the numbers. You can see the relative position of local government districts moving simply because of the uncertainty associated with measurement each year. I mentioned that data on productivity is published with a two-year delay. It can create issues if you are thinking about the effect of policy but can only see data from two years ago. One of our suggestions is that, rather than using a single baseline year, a group of two or three years should be used as a baseline to try to mitigate some of those issues.

Fourthly, and finally, we highlight the interdependencies between regions within Northern Ireland. Importantly, the Bill recognises the cross-border element for local government districts here. We think that it is important to also explicitly recognise the interdependencies between local government districts, particularly given the relatively small geographic area of Northern Ireland. That is a particular issue in respect of commuting, for example. Statistics for certain areas do not look great simply because people are commuting: they are living in that area but working in another. The measures mentioned are a mixture of what would be measured at a business level — where people work — and where people live. Therefore, simply because the place of work is different from where the people who work there live, you might erroneously try to fix an issue that does not actually exist. It is important to consider those interdependencies to avoid trying to solve an issue that may not actually exist.

That is a quick summary of our evidence. I am happy to answer any questions on it.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Thank you very much, David. I will go to the Bill sponsor, Sinéad.

Ms McLaughlin: Thank you, David. I always love it when you come to give evidence because of the detail. You mentioned gross value added per hour and per employee and the difference between those. We could add GVA per hour and have both. Does looking at both give a deeper understanding of exactly what is happening in different areas?

Dr Jordan: It does. Looking at both highlights the fact that there are structural differences between local government districts here. Belfast looks good on GVA per job but falls back on GVA per hour because it is service dominated compared with other parts of Northern Ireland. In the Belfast service economy, hours worked tends to be a bit higher, and that is what pulls it down. When both measures are taken together, that gives a better and more fuller picture in trying to understand what is happening and the patterns over time.

Ms McLaughlin: You spoke about the nuances of people working in one local government district and living in another. How can we deal with that in the context of the Bill? How should we include that in our measurements?

Dr Jordan: It is about recognising that there is a split between the measures that are business orientated and those that are orientated more towards people in wider society. It would be difficult to write down explicitly what that would mean, but, when that is looked at, there needs to be an awareness in respect of interpretation. There is not much that can be done on the data collection side, because that is simply the way it is. It is just about having that awareness, so that you are not chasing a solution to a problem that may not exist.

Ms McLaughlin: Should I add that to the explanatory notes?

Dr Jordan: Yes, that might be good.

Ms McLaughlin: You spoke about the baseline. Everyone who has given evidence today has spoken passionately about the need for good baseline information in order to be able to look at the opportunities and measure and evaluate success. Global events can change productivity rates quite sharply. You mentioned COVID and Brexit, and the cost of living is another. For how many years should productivity be measured in order to get a good benchmark? It does not have to be just productivity; it could be economic inactivity, health outcomes and life expectancy. Where do you stop when looking at a baseline?

Dr Jordan: That will relate partly to the underlying data. Business surveys, for example, tend to look at a proportion of the business population, whereas some administrative surveys, perhaps those looking at health matters, have a bigger sample. Those surveys tend to be more stable, so their baseline would not have to be over as many years.

To give an example of productivity, the ONS publishes, alongside its annual estimates, a calculation of the productivity number and gives a smooth estimate. The ONS does that over five years, which, I think, would be too long in a policy context. That would be going back so far and removing so much variation that it could not really be used to evaluate what had been happening. A compromise is somewhere around the two- to three-year point, because that smoothes out the year-to-year variation but still gives an indication of where the poor performance has been.

Ms McLaughlin: That is really interesting. There is a lot of flexibility in the instructions on how data should be gathered, how research should be done and how it should be updated and evaluated. However, it is important that it is right at the very beginning, otherwise it would continue to give us bad output at the other end. Thank you very much, David, for your responses today and for your paper.

Mr Nesbitt: David, hi. I am going to play devil's advocate and challenge why you think that productivity is the central measure of economic success. You know the rates of economic inactivity. If we get one person economically active, with them producing a very low GVA per hour but having an increased sense of well-being, is that not a win? Could I not argue that well-being rather than productivity should be the central measure of economic success?

Dr Jordan: I agree with you that someone no longer being inactive is a good outcome. In the short term, that has the potential to make our productivity look not as good, but we think about long-term productivity as the Northern Ireland economy reaching its full potential. Having more people in work — having fewer inactive people — means that people can be allocated around the economy better in order to make best use of their skills and talents. That is how we think of inactivity. There are people who are inactive who could make a very worthwhile contribution to the economy. If they did so, other people could be in other jobs. There are issues with long-term inactivity due to sickness and ill health. Measuring productivity per hour worked would take account of some of those issues by allowing people to contribute what they can, rather than focusing on simply whether or not they are in work.

Ms Nicholl: Given that you are from the Productivity Institute, I would expect you to argue that productivity should be the primary measure of regional disparity. You will note that this is the first time that I am not asking you to explain how productivity is measured, because I now understand it. How reliable are productivity measures at a subregional level or the level of local authority areas in Northern Ireland?

Dr Jordan: They tend to have much more variation than what we see at the headline level for Northern Ireland. The ONS does not publish its margin of error simply because it brings together different surveys and sources in its work. When you look at productivity measures over a couple of years, that gives you a sense of the relative positioning. Ultimately, that is the most useful aspect that comes from them. We did a piece of work in 2023, which used, for the first time, some of the annual business inquiry data from the Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency (NISRA) to look at year-to-year productivity measurements, and we saw a lot of variation in local government districts. Productivity is driven by the top-performing firms, and it is often those top performers that make the difference. That can be a good-news story, because, if you have a few top performers, you improve productivity, which can have a spillover effect. From one particular year to another, there is a margin of error, but we are not aware of precisely what it is.

Ms Nicholl: OK. That is really interesting. You talked about the significant data limitations in Northern Ireland. What are the biggest gaps that could hinder implementation of the Bill?

Dr Jordan: One is the delay in the data. We are very reliant on the ONS for productivity statistics. Obviously, the ONS produces those statistics on a regional level for the UK, but, as a devolved Government, it would be great to have those earlier. NISRA is doing some work, which is funded by the Department, to try to better understand our productivity statistics. It would be great if we were in a position to measure productivity more quickly.

From a research perspective, in trying to understand what can be quite complex relationships, it would be great to have better access to linked data in different areas. NISRA has recently improved access to linked datasets. We have projects that will look at that, but, ultimately, to make good policy decisions, we need good data. That is key. It would be great if the Bill or something like it could lead to support for greater capacity. My one concern is that, without greater capacity for analysing what happens underneath, it will simply become a tick-box exercise, rather than something that promotes strategic policy improvement.

Ms Nicholl: Absolutely. That was so useful. Thank you.

Mr Martin: Thank you, David, for coming in. I want to check a couple of bits. Your evidence is that productivity should be the central priority when we consider regional balance. To pick up on Sinéad's point, a key part of that is the additional measurement of GVA per employee.

Dr Jordan: Yes.

Mr Martin: That is fine. I want to pick up on the baseline stuff, which has also been touched on. Clause 1(3)(f)(i) identifies the baselines. I will read it out, because you probably do not have it there:

"identification of a baseline year against which progress in reducing regional disparities is to be measured".

You have made a very sound argument that measuring a baseline per year is not always best but that measuring it over five years makes some of the data too historical to be relevant. Would measuring it over three years be reasonable?

Dr Jordan: Three years would be reasonable. In some situations, two years could be reasonable. It comes down to how you want to use the data.

Mr Martin: It comes down to how you want to use the data, but, essentially, one year is probably not the best. I am sure that the Bill sponsor will have a look at that. That is fine. That was good evidence. Thank you for coming along today.

Mr Honeyford: This is really fascinating; it has been a really good morning and early afternoon. All of this is about people and communities. It is about people accessing jobs, skills and services. Correct me if I am wrong, but you are saying that we are measuring productivity where the business is based and not necessarily where the people who work there live. Therefore, there is a discrepancy. If we are trying to support a community, it is not necessarily about where a business is located. How can we have a regional target that encourages investment but makes a difference to the people in a community?

Dr Jordan: That is a very good question. It comes back to better understanding commuting patterns and access to jobs across Northern Ireland. It may be that the jobs are located on one side of a local government district border and the people who work there live on the other side, although, really, that is one economic area. However, local government district is as good as we get for measurement. Understanding that aspect is really important in understanding how we can improve outcomes for people. I do not necessarily have an answer as to how it should look, but that awareness is needed. At the moment, there is the potential that the Bill will not take that into account.

Mr Honeyford: OK. In your submission, you write about creating major economic centres, wherever they are located, to which people in surrounding communities and rural areas will commute. You talked about greater capacity. If there is something that we could do to strengthen the Bill, what would generally improve the lives of people rather than it just being about information gathering?

Dr Jordan: The way that I look at it is that the information helps to action better lives. There is the idea of fulfilling people's potential. The indicators that have been chosen give a good indication of where there are issues. The way that we have thought about it is that, if you want to improve people's lives, that is about fulfilling their potential, but you will not understand fully the place-appropriate response unless you have the place-related data at that level. One of the aims of the Bill is to think about place-based responses. At least, I think that an outcome that you want from the Bill is for the policy responses to be based on and appropriate to the experiences of the people in a particular area. My argument is that, in order to do that, you need the data before you make decisions and that you must have action from them.

Mr Honeyford: Thank you very much.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): I want to pick up on what you said about the two-year delay in the ONS productivity data. Is there such a delay for everywhere in the UK or just Northern Ireland?

Dr Jordan: It is a generic publication delay.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): It is not just the data for here that has fallen behind.

Dr Jordan: It is not just here. The ONS produces equivalent statistics for regions in England, but that does not, perhaps, have the same consequences for policymaking as it does here. Having faster publication would be an advantage, but that would potentially require resources to go with it. It would help inform policymaking and, therefore, hopefully, help with both choosing which policy interventions to make and evaluating them in a timely way.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Absolutely. I sit on the Finance Committee, and I know that NISRA's data analysis structures and resources are pretty stretched. There might be a good opportunity to link with NISRA, the Department of Finance and the Finance Committee in respect of the Bill. We should highlight the fact that, if we are to create regional balance frameworks and measures, we will need to look at Department of Finance data as well.

Thank you very much, David, for your written evidence and for taking the time to come in to answer all of our questions. We really appreciate it.

Dr Jordan: Thank you.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up