Official Report: Minutes of Evidence
Committee for Communities, meeting on Thursday, 5 November 2026
Members present for all or part of the proceedings:
Mr Colm Gildernew (Chairperson)
Miss Nicola Brogan (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr Andy Allen MBE
Ms Kellie Armstrong
Mr Maurice Bradley
Mrs Pam Cameron
Mr Mark Durkan
Ms Sian Mulholland
Witnesses:
Ms Colleen Bell, Department for Communities
Mr Raymond Caldwell, Department for Communities
Mr Martin Ireland, Department for Communities
Mr Gerard Reilly, Department for Communities
Charities (Amendment) Bill: Department for Communities
The Chairperson (Mr Gildernew): I welcome from the Department for Communities Raymond Caldwell, director of the voluntary and community division; Colleen Bell, head of the charities policy and legislation team; Martin Ireland, deputy principal, charities policy and legislation team; and Gerard Reilly, also from that team.
Raymond, I invite you to make a brief opening statement, and we will then move to questions from members.
Mr Raymond Caldwell (Department for Communities): Good morning, Chair and Committee members. Thank you for the opportunity to attend today. Chair, if you are content, I will keep my opening remarks brief to maximise the time for Colleen, Gerard, Martin and me to respond to your queries.
Following the Committee's deliberations on the Charities (Amendment) Bill, the Department responded to a series of Committee queries and items of correspondence in recent weeks, including its letters of 6, 7, 15 and 21 October. The Department provided clarification on a range of issues raised during the Committee's deliberations and evidence sessions. We welcome the Committee's detailed scrutiny of the Bill and are grateful to members for highlighting issues. That scrutiny has helped identify a small number of drafting and explanatory issues in the supporting documentation and has informed improvements in the Bill and its accompanying materials.
In recent weeks, the Department has responded to Committee correspondence on matters including the registration threshold, implementation and resourcing arrangements, reporting requirements, information sharing, automatic disqualification, the definition of "office holder", commencement arrangements and scrutiny of regulations. We have sought to provide timely and comprehensive responses to assist the Committee in its deliberations.
The Department's engagement with the Committee has directly informed the amended drafting of clause 2 and clarification of a number of provisions in the Bill and aspects of the supporting documentation. As agreed, we have provided the Committee with revised drafting for clause 2 to address concerns about the definition of "office holder", particularly in relation to information-sharing provisions and their application to elected representatives. The Department worked closely with the Charity Commission on the revised drafting, and the Charity Commission has confirmed that it is content with the proposed amendment.
At a high level, the Department's position remains that the Bill delivers a series of targeted reforms to improve the regulatory framework for charities in Northern Ireland, strengthening, where appropriate, the effectiveness of the Charity Commission's powers and reducing unnecessary administrative burdens on smaller charities, while retaining appropriate safeguards and oversight and removing uncertainty for cross-border charities by the repeal of section 167 of the Charities Act (Northern Ireland) 2008.
We recognise and appreciate the Committee's constructive engagement throughout the scrutiny process. The Department has sought to respond positively where clarification or amendment has been deemed necessary. We believe that the Department has responded to all points raised through the Committee's correspondence and evidence sessions. However, should members require further clarification on the Bill or the responses that we have provided to date, we are happy to assist.
Thank you, Chair. We are happy to answer members' questions.
The Chairperson (Mr Gildernew): Thank you for that. On clause 7, how will the Department monitor the impact of the new arrangements on transparency, accountability and the public sector on an ongoing basis?
Ms Colleen Bell (Department for Communities): Is your query on the duty to consult?
Ms Bell: Let me check clause 7. This is on the Charity Commission regulations after the Department makes the regulations under clause 7. The Charity Commission is a public body and has a duty in public law to consult if it is making any significant policy changes or doing something that will affect charities. It has used the power to make regulations in the past, under section 70, and consulted on those. The commission expects to consult on the template reporting, because it is a change for charities with an annual income of under £20,000. It is therefore an expectation in public law that the commission does that.
Ms Bell: We are meeting the Charity Commission next week to kick-start that process and get an understanding of its systems so that we know what needs to go into the instructions for the regulations. We hope to have the regulations early in the new mandate.
Mr Bradley: Religious charities are exempt, but what safeguards are in place to protect their charitable assets, benefactors, donors, etc? What would prevent their information being made public under clause 5?
Ms Bell: Clause 5 is in respect of:
"Power to direct specified action not to be taken".
I am trying to think about where you are going with your question; sorry, Maurice.
Mr Bradley: If a charity that is under investigation has benefactors, donors and other people who feed into it, how can their information be prevented from being made public through investigations under the Bill?
Ms Bell: The benefactors' information?
Mr Bradley: Information on benefactors, donors and anybody else who puts money into the charity.
Mr Martin Ireland (Department for Communities): The Charity Commission, and the powers that it can use, are bound by data protection — GDPR. Those processes are already built into its actions. Clause 5 builds on the powers that the Charity Commission already has in sections 33 to 37 of the Act, and it would use the same safeguards as it uses currently with all of its other powers.
Mr Bradley: So you are telling me that that information will not go into the public domain. I am happy with that, if that is how the Bill reads.
Mr Caldwell: It would be subject to the standard GDPR regulations that operate in those ways.
Mr Bradley: Chair, I forgot to declare an interest as a member of the Harry Gregg Foundation; sorry.
Ms K Armstrong: Thank you very much, guys. One of my areas of questioning is about charities with an annual income of less than £20,000 and the registration process. Can those charities still register?
Ms K Armstrong: Quite a lot of funding bodies require that registration, even from smaller charities.
Charities get plagued with this all of the time; it is about protecting money-laundering laws and things like that. A lot of charities contact me to ask, "Have you heard of this charity?", and I can look up the charity register and see it whether it is doing door-to-door collections, collecting clothes or whatever. The very small charities will not be on that register, so how can we be absolutely certain that the money-laundering rules are covered there?
Ms Bell: Your query is about the regulations for the registration threshold. We have not yet brought those regulations to the Committee, as the Minister has not yet made a decision on them. Under the Bill, small charities will be able to avail themselves of the template reporting. We will come to the Committee with the registration threshold regulations and go into full detail on them when they are agreed, because they will be subject to the draft affirmative procedure.
Ms K Armstrong: I wanted to make sure that that template, for instance, is in the guidance for small charities. Will they get that template only if they are registered?
Ms Bell: They will use the template if they are registered. With the registration threshold, charities can choose to deregister or stay on the register. The likes of funders, who require registration, will obviously choose to register. The registration threshold is really for small kitchen-table charities such as historical societies that comprise a man and his wee lad. That is what it is it is intended for.
Mr Caldwell: It is about proportionality, Kellie, while not diluting any of the safeguards that are in place. That will be taken forward through the regulations when they are drafted.
Ms K Armstrong: Given that we are talking about regulations or guidance that may come forward, I am a wee bit concerned that clause 3 is due to come into effect the day after Royal Assent and we still have not seen the guidance on that. We have raised concerns about the warning mechanism and such things. Would it be prudent to hold back on enacting clause 3 until that guidance is produced?
Ms Bell: The Charity Commission has said that, yes, the power will come into effect the day after Royal Assent but it will not use that power until it has consulted on it and published the guidance. There is therefore no harm in it coming into effect, because it will not be used until the Charity Commission has the systems ready and the guidance has been issued.
Mr Caldwell: I will pick up on an associated point. There was quite a bit of discussion at the previous Committee session about resources for the Charity Commission. We gave an assurance that we would engage and that those pressures would be met. That information has been shared with the Charity Commission, and it will be moving towards securing the additional resource that it needs to implement the Bill.
Ms K Armstrong: On clause 4, I have concerns about the Charity Commission's ability to remove employees. I will not get into the detail, but I know that it has been said that that has been on the books for a long time. Being on the books for a long time, however, does not mean that it is right. Does the Department intend to consider an amendment to the 2008 Act to address that? I have a concern that we are putting the commission in a difficult position. In clause 4, new subsection (3A) states:
"the Commission may proceed to make the order"
to remove someone. Removing a trustee is fine, but how can it remove someone from employment when it is not the employer? Will the Department take a further look at that?
Ms Bell: As the Charity Commission told you, it has never used that power because there are employment implications. We intend to introduce another charities Bill in the next mandate, so, if there is a strong feeling that that should be looked at, we could do it in the next Bill.
Ms K Armstrong: That is great. We are giving the Charity Commission powers that, as the commission said, it has never used, that have never been used in England and that leave the commission open to legal ramifications. Thank you very much for that.
The Chairperson (Mr Gildernew): Leading on from that, what are your intentions in respect of ongoing monitoring and review of the effectiveness of the legislation post implementation? What are your plans for assessing how it has worked out and whether further legislation may be beneficial?
Ms Bell: The Department is the sponsor of the Charity Commission as well as being responsible for the charity policy and legislative framework. We have a strong relationship with the commission. The Charity Commission carries out public trust and confidence surveys, and those will continue as part of its normal governance. If issues come up about the Bill as implemented, those will be brought to our attention fairly quickly. As I say, we intend to introduce more legislation in the next mandate, so any issues can be addressed then.
Mr Caldwell: Sponsorship and oversight sit with another team in my division. We have regular accountability, risk and assurance meetings with the Charity Commission. We have a strong working relationship with the commission.
The Chairperson (Mr Gildernew): Are there any other questions, members? I am conscious that, as we move towards formal consideration of the Bill, this is our last opportunity to ask questions.
I thank you all for your engagement with the Committee on the Bill. You have provided a really strong example of a team that is across its brief and is willing to listen and engage with the Committee, so thank you. I appreciate that.
Are there any further questions for the departmental officials before we move on? Members are content.
Thank you very much. Good luck. We will see you again, I am sure, in due course.