Official Report: Minutes of Evidence

Committee for Finance, meeting on Wednesday, 4 November 2026


Members present for all or part of the proceedings:

Mr Matthew O'Toole (Chairperson)
Ms Diane Forsythe (Deputy Chairperson)
Dr Steve Aiken OBE
Mr Gerry Carroll
Miss Deirdre Hargey
Mr Harry Harvey
Mr Brian Kingston
Miss Áine Murphy
Mr Eóin Tennyson


Witnesses:

Ms Margaret Kelly, Northern Ireland Public Services Ombudsman
Mr Sean Martin, Northern Ireland Public Services Ombudsman



Inquiry into the Performance and Culture of the Northern Ireland Civil Service: Northern Ireland Public Services Ombudsman

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): Hansard staff are not going to be present, but are members content for Hansard to report the meeting?

Members indicated assent.

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): Our witnesses today are Margaret Kelly, the Northern Ireland Public Services Ombudsman (NIPSO), and Sean Martin, the deputy ombudsman. You are both very welcome. We are particularly keen to hear your perspective, because you are a watchdog, but — to say that you are "interlocutors" would be putting it incorrectly — you often also engage directly with devolved government and civil servants, so your strategic and day-to-day perspectives will be interesting. Margaret, will you give us an opening statement? As always, members, indicate if you want to ask a question.

Ms Margaret Kelly (Northern Ireland Public Services Ombudsman): Thank you very much. I thank the Committee for giving me the opportunity to provide evidence and to reflect on the role of complaints in culture and performance.

Complaints, and how public bodies respond to them, really matter for several reasons. They matter to the individual citizen and their experience of government and services. They should matter to the public body because they are a key indicator of the broader culture and performance of any organisation. They are an indicator of transparency, responsiveness and accountability, and they provide a unique opportunity for a public body to hear directly how someone has experienced its service. If properly recorded, considered and analysed, they can offer an early warning system, indicating that something may be going more fundamentally wrong. They also matter for governance and accountability because they go to the heart of public trust. Therefore, it is vital that senior leaders in our public bodies, and those charged with governance, are curious about complaints and have the relevant data and analysis to understand what complaints are showing them.

I recognise that this is a challenging time for all those who deliver public services in Northern Ireland and that we are operating in a difficult context, globally and locally, with real economic pressures. The majority of public servants go to work every day to deliver services in the public interest and do so in that challenging and difficult context. However, it is also the case that public servants work in a system and a culture, and it is vital that that culture actively enables openness, transparency, engagement and accountability.

Most people are unwilling to complain, and that is reflected in NIPSO surveys on public awareness and public attitudes. We have done three such surveys in Northern Ireland since 2021. Those surveys show an increase in the percentage of people here who said that they had received poor public service from a fairly consistent 30% to 55% in our most recent survey. Of those who had received poor public service, a fairly consistent 30% had been willing to complain, but that increased to 45% in the most recent survey. However, the proportion of those who said that the public body had resolved their complaint remained static, at around a quarter, across the surveys. When we asked in every one of the surveys why someone would not complain to a public body if they received poor service, the answer was the same: they did not think that anything would change.

In order to complain to NIPSO, you first have to take your complaint to the public body, which is not always an easy process. In undertaking research for our complaints standards programme across Departments and their arm's-length bodies (ALBs), we found a wide variety of complaints approaches. Many bodies had three, four and sometimes more stages in their approach to complaints. That meant that some of those who complained found themselves in an ongoing loop with the public body or Department, going through different stages and struggling to reach a conclusion. Making a complaint requires determination and perseverance; bringing that complaint to NIPSO is even more demanding.

I always say that NIPSO is the tip of the tip of the iceberg: we see only a tiny proportion of what will have gone to public bodies. However, we have seen an absolutely unprecedented rise in the number of complaints coming to us, with just over 1,700 complaints last year, representing an in-year increase of 31% and an 88% increase over the past five years.

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): An 88% increase in —?

Ms Kelly: In the number of complaints coming to the office.

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): Could we focus it on our Civil Service inquiry? That is related to public services overall, which —

Ms Kelly: It relates to public services.

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): — may include the health service, whose staff are not civil servants.

Mr Sean Martin (Northern Ireland Public Services Ombudsman): Yes.

Ms Kelly: Yes.

We currently do not have exact figures for the number of complaints received across the Northern Ireland Civil Service (NICS) and its ALBs. Complaints are often not recorded, which is a significant issue. Complaints are supposed to act as part of your trend analysis and as an indicator of when something is going wrong, so, if complaints are not recorded, it is hard to identify what the trend is. I hope that, once complaints standards are fully in place, that will be addressed. Complaints need to be fully recorded, but they also need to be published. It is difficult to set my complaints in context if you do not know the wider picture. We have that information for Health and Social Care, so we can set the complaints that we receive in context as a percentage of all complaints of that type. However, we cannot do that in the same way for the NICS and its ALBs. That also makes it really difficult for senior leaders and those in governance positions to understand what their complaints are telling them.

I have drawn attention in the paper to some of the main issues that have arisen with Departments. I have also included housing, given that the Housing Executive is an ALB, and the Education Authority (EA). I will give the Committee a sense of the themes that I see as specifically linked to the Civil Service and its ALBs. One issue is poor communication or a failure to provide full and accurate information. I will give you brief examples. We had a complainant with an unresolved issue relating to the revocation of his driving licence. When the Department communicated with him, it failed to tell him that there was a reconsideration process, and that he could ask for a reconsideration. That information was not in the Department's letter, so he did not know that. It was only after he had finished the complaints process and brought the matter to NIPSO that that came out, and he was then able to use that reconsideration process to get the matter resolved.

There is often an unwillingness to accept and resolve a complaint, even when all the indicators point to an underlying issue. We saw that in our systemic investigations, and, particularly in relation to the personal independence payment (PIP), we saw repeated and ongoing complaints that had not been translated into broader lessons.

We also see a failure to accept that guidance may be wrong, and that a Department, on the basis of a complaint, may need to reconsider what guidance is in place. One complainant had enduring power of attorney for his mother. When he tried to communicate with the Department about his mother's benefits, it consistently refused him on the basis that he did not have the authority to do so because the power of attorney had not been stamped by the Office of Care and Protection. He made several complaints, but it was only when the matter reached our office and we picked it up that the Department realised that its guidance on the matter was wrong and needed to be changed.

The impact of generalist employees operating in a specialist or regulatory context has also been raised in complaints. One long and very complex investigation concerned a specialist role in a Department that involved the management and oversight of insolvency practitioners. The issue had a real impact on the complainant, highlighting the fact that generalist employees did not have the expertise required to provide regulatory oversight.

Finally, poor complaints handling and poor record-keeping are recurring themes.

I will say one last thing. The Public Office (Accountability) Bill, which is in progress, offers a real opportunity to address the issue of culture. To my knowledge, the Department of Finance is taking the lead on that Bill. Parts of it could make a real difference to the overall culture when it comes to transparency and accountability.

I will stop there to give you the opportunity to ask questions. I hope that that is helpful.

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): That was really helpful. Thank you very much, Margaret and Sean, for coming. I have a few questions, after which members will come in.

You talked about persistent themes of poor communication, a failure to accept that something — guidance — might be wrong, and generalist officials working in specialist roles, which can slow things down or create competence issues in the handling of certain matters. You also mentioned poor complaints handling, which is something that you see a lot during the course of your work, and poor record-keeping. A lot of those issues will ring bells for people who followed the Coghlin renewable heat incentive (RHI) inquiry. I do not know whether either of you is able to reflect on whether NIPSO has seen any improvement in those issues since, I suppose, 2020, when that report first came out, or during the past decade.

Ms Kelly: I have been in post since August 2020. I would like to be able to say that I have seen a real improvement in those matters, but I have not seen one. Sometimes, there is improvement on a case-by-case basis. It is when matters come to us, our investigators become involved and we go back and say, "Actually, look at this again" that we can secure some shift.

However, there are some public bodies in which we have seen very little shift. On one occasion — this is in the public domain; the public body concerned put it there — I had to write to the chair of a public body because I was so concerned about its complaints handling and what was happening. I would like to be able to say that I have seen improvements. I hope that the complaints standards programme that we have put in place will have an impact. Public bodies have engaged with us and worked with us on complaints standards. In June, we launched the central government complaints standards programme. We know from Scotland's experience that that will take a few years to bed in. I hope that better recording and publication and more analysis and accountability will assist us in that.

In general, there is a need for independent oversight of compliance with public inquiry recommendations.

We have a compliance role in relation to our recommendations: we follow those up and provide data about the level of compliance with them. However, there is a need for oversight of how, and how effectively, public inquiry recommendations are implemented.

Mr Martin: I will not take up much more time on that. I have been with NIPSO for 12 years. Have I seen significant improvement in those areas? I do not think that I can say that I have seen significant shift. Those recurring themes keep coming up, which, I suppose, is part of the concern about learning lessons. Margaret and I have looked at the cost of public inquiries here and whether we are getting benefit from having invested so much time and energy into identifying the core issues. In looking at whether recommendations have been implemented, rather than having some piece of paper that suggests that they have, it is about looking at whether they have effected the change that we sought. Ensuring that there is a certain level of oversight of whether implementation has achieved the desired outcome of the recommendation is something that we need to get better at. There is room for improvement.

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): Your view on now versus 2020, or post-RHI inquiry, is helpful and clear. I have one more question, which is about record-keeping: data on complaints. You indicate that about 20% of the complaints that come to NIPSO relate to central government, which, in this context, I presume, means devolved government rather than the British Government.

Ms Kelly: We do not cover them.

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): Margaret, in your opening statement, you said that complaints recording is poor in the North. Is the Civil Service here worse at recording complaints than our neighbouring jurisdictions, the South of Ireland, Scotland and Wales?

Mr Martin: The one area in which we have good data and have been able to compare it is Health and Social Care, because it publishes that data. Interestingly, looking at the number of complaints coming in about our GP services showed that it was tiny — the Business Services Organisation (BSO) said, I think, that GP practices reported fewer than 200 complaints a year — but we all know that that is not the case. The figure for England and Wales is something like 120,000, so there is clearly an issue.

Since the introduction of the model complaints handling procedure, something in the region of 200 complaints a month have been reported. It is not that complaints are not being made but that there is a lack of recording and transparency about them, so we lose the opportunity to analyse that data. If we can amalgamate centrally data on GP services, for instance, we will see the key themes in people's concerns, and we can use technology to help us do that. Part of our programme is about the whole public sector starting to meaningfully collect data. We do not expect the number of complaints to go down; quite the opposite, because proper recording will allow us to analyse and learn from the data. That is one of our key tenets.

Ms Kelly: You asked about the other jurisdictions. Data on health in England and Wales is much clearer than it is here. I have struggled to find centrally held data on Northern Ireland complaints. Scotland has had complaints standards for longer, and it has a requirement to publish data. We see a bit more data there than we see here. It is definitely a work in progress.

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): A significant chunk of the complaints about how devolved government here works relate to things such as vehicle testing and driver licensing. I presume that does not mean people complaining about their car failing the MOT.

Ms Kelly: No, it is about access to services.

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): That happens; it is no big crime.

You are basically saying that the data that you have is what comes through your door. You know how many complaints you get about driver and vehicle testing, for example, but you do not know how well the Department or its agency collects the data, or even whether it collects that.

Ms Kelly: That is accurate — or about the extent to which it does so. That is partly what the changes that we are trying to bring in are about.

Ms Forsythe: Thank you for being here. From my time on the Audit Committee, I know that you have a huge caseload, and I know the severity of some of those cases. When I was on that Committee, I heard you say that about half of your cases related to health and that a lot of those had involved adverse and traumatic outcomes. There is serious work for your staff in that.

For our inquiry, I am keen to tease out whether you capture and report how much of that caseload comes to you through internal whistle-blowing. Does that happen? For example, in coming to you with a complaint, does someone say, "I tried to raise this internally, as an employee of a Department, but I haven't been able to, so I am now coming to you"? Do you see that or capture information on it?

Ms Kelly: We do not have a whistle-blowing role in that regard. Under the legislation, that role needs to be taken by the person, or by someone acting on behalf of the person, who is in receipt of a public service or has had some kind of interaction with a Department and thinks that there has been maladministration. Staff of public bodies across the jurisdiction come to me to raise whistle-blowing issues, but, under the legislation, I cannot deal with those.

Ms Forsythe: Do you bounce it back to them and say, "Use your whistle-blowing policy"?

Ms Kelly: I say, "Use your whistle-blowing policy", or, if it is about something financial, I tell them to try the Audit Office. We have a real gap here in relation to whistle-blowing. In Scotland, the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman is the whistle-blowing champion for health and social care, which means that it is possible for someone, once they have raised a concern with their employer, to take it to that ombudsman. I am not saying that hordes of staff come to me with whistle-blowing complaints, but I regularly hear from people from different public bodies who wish to raise them with me. It is simply outwith my statutory remit.

Ms Forsythe: That is an important point to capture. People get in touch with me to ask, "Where do I raise this?", because they have tried to go to people such as you. If, as you mentioned, there is a trend of complaints coming through and people not feeling that they are being heard, that is a real indication of the culture of the Department or other body.

I am thinking about the Departments and the other parts of the Civil Service and about the Civil Service as a whole. Do you have any framework for formal or informal meetings or other engagement with the Head of the Civil Service or the permanent secretaries to check in with them and say, "Here are the kinds of complaints that I am getting about your Department right now", or does that all just take place through the formal complaints process? Do permanent secretaries know what is coming through from you, or is that not the case because you are an outside body carrying out that process? I am keen to understand that.

Ms Kelly: It is a bit of a mix. Through the complaints process, we will have engagement. If I get a serious or complex complaint — something that really needs to come to the attention of the Department at that very senior level — I will raise it by writing directly to the permanent secretary or to the Minister. If I am doing a systemic investigation, I will engage with the Department at that level. On an ongoing basis, however, the office probably does not have that engagement. That may be something for us to consider. We met the permanent secretaries' group to discuss the introduction of complaints standards, but we do not meet on an ongoing basis to reflect, for example, on what we see across Departments each year.

Ms Forsythe: Obviously, that is not your primary responsibility. It is what it is, and it is designated, but that kind of HR oversight would be a useful tool, and it would definitely be useful to the Finance Committee —

Ms Kelly: That might be interesting.

Ms Forsythe: — if you were able to feed back on that. I understand that that is not your priority, however.

I spoke to Alma from Caleb's Cause, who told me about a number of themes that came through in its survey. Do you see similar themes? You mentioned themes in your opening remarks: will you touch on the types of themes that come through in complaints?

Ms Kelly: The themes that came out of that survey — difficulty in accessing services and complaints processes and how difficult it is to get information and a response — are, to be honest, things that we see all the time. While we try to fix those things on a complaint-by-complaint basis, I hope that the complaints standards work will drive a bigger, cultural change. We have really engaged with all the public bodies. We divided them into sectors and had significant engagement with them before we launched the new complaints approach. We tried to embed the idea that complaints are not a process issue but a cultural issue. It is about listening and hearing and about acting on the learning that comes out of that. It is not just about saying, "I will put your complaint through in two stages".

I could have given it to all public-sector bodies and said, "Here you are; it is two stages", but it is about trying to shift some of those attitudes. In a way, nothing has come out of the survey that does not reflect the complaints that I have seen in the office. We have launched an own initiative investigation of learning disability and will possibly take forward some other work on that issue.

Ms Forsythe: I am pleased to hear that. Alma does amazing work —

Ms Kelly: Amazing work.

Ms Forsythe: — in that area. I reiterate your point: people hear the word "complaint", and they think that it means criticising or causing difficulty, but, across the board, if people do not submit their challenge, complaint or issue, public bodies may not realise that there is a gap. The process is adding value and breaking down some of the barriers, and it is helpful for people. I look forward to seeing the work on learning disabilities coming through.

Mr Carroll: Thanks, Margaret. I met you a few months ago about your work, and thank you for that as well.

I have two questions. I have my own view on why the complaints have increased over the last number of years, but can you give me an assessment of why that has been the case?

Mr Martin: There is a gap between people's expectations of public services and what they receive. 'The State of the State' report shows that there is a huge drop in the satisfaction levels for public services right across the board, and that is mirrored across the UK. People's expectations of public services are not being met. Sometimes, it is not about the level to which the service is delivered but about its absence, such as the lack of services that Alma's work highlighted when people need help. There are two things: the lack of access to a service when people expect public services to be there to support them when they need them; and the quality of the delivery of the service.

We have seen a significant increase in the number of complaints about housing. Interestingly, the complaints are not about the lack of access to or the availability of housing; they are about the standard of repairs, dealing with antisocial behaviour and other issues that matter to people on the ground. You would expect the complaints that we get to be about access to housing, given that we are not building enough houses to meet the demand, but they are about the quality of the service delivery, and that is quite often the case that comes through to us.

From our tracking of complaints trends, it is clear that people's expectations are not being met. People are more willing to complain than they were previously. To pick up on Diane's point, we need to change how we see complaints, because they provide an interesting insight into how people perceive public services and should not be viewed negatively. We tell public services that complaints give them an insight that many public bodies pay for through surveys. The complaints give the public bodies the insights without the need to spend money, but they need to be recorded and analysed properly, and then the lessons need to be learned. That goes back to the point that Margaret will — I do not doubt — make about culture.

Ms Kelly: I have a couple of points on that. The Committee will know that public services are under pressure — I think that we all accept that — and that is part of what is driving the increase in complaints. However, since 2020, there has been a 161% increase in the number of complaints about housing coming to my office. If you look at the complaints recorded in any of the housing bodies and the Housing Executive, you will probably find that the numbers are very low. There is a disconnect, which tells me that people are struggling to get their complaint heard. We know from our work that, when people raise housing complaints, they go round in a circle of a first-time call, second-time call, third-time call and tenth-time call, and it is not treated as a complaint at any point. If the lesson is not being learned, the outcome will not change.

Public services are under pressure; people are more dissatisfied; and they are clearly more willing to complain. It is about trying to make sure that, when people complain, they get a response and something changes. I am probably telling you all something that you already know from your constituency offices.

Mr Carroll: That is useful for the inquiry.

On Sean's point, people's rates and taxes have been going up consistently in the past 10 to 20 years, so they should be getting more access to public services when they are actually getting less. In a broad sense, my experience is that people with a real and valid individual grievance tend, in the most part, to complain to make sure that what happened to them does not happen to somebody else, which is altruistic and noble.

It is also connected to a point about the Civil Service. I have heard from people who work in the Civil Service that they are doing the jobs of two or three people because of the review of public administration (RPA) and that kind of thing. Therefore, you are going to get a worse service because somebody is being pulled in three or four different ways.

My final question relates to housing. Margaret, we have spoken about aspects of this before in a different setting. More people would complain, especially about housing, if the process was not so long, stretched out, complicated and delayed. People do not record things — that is me being polite about it. Obviously, there has to be a chance for an organisation to respond, but I would like you to intervene at an earlier stage so that a complaint could be speeded up. Do you have any views on that or have you had a discussion about that in your organisation?

Ms Kelly: It is important, for all sorts of reasons, that a complaint goes directly to the public body, not least because we could not cope at that level. Public bodies need to hear the complaint and be able to respond, and that is about them knowing what is going on. That is about them knowing that something needs to be fixed or, "That's not quite working in the way we thought it was" or, "We've had 10 complaints about that team in the last few months. What's going on there?". It is important for the person to have that relationship with the public service and for the public service so that it gets fixed.

Part of what I hope to have from the complaints standards, which is partly why I am keen to make sure that I have them all done before my term ends, is that there will be a much clearer two-stage process and a much clearer point at which both the person and the public body say, "This is done now". Broadly, public bodies will have five days to respond to a complaint and to try to resolve it, and most complaints are best resolved at the initial point of contact. That can be expanded to 10 working days. If it is not resolved, they have 20 days to look at an investigation. They can expand that, but they need to keep the person updated. They will then reach a point at which it will be clearer for the person to say, "Well, actually, I can't get this resolved, so now I can go to NIPSO", and they do not end up in a process for several years.

It will take a while to bed in and to become effective, but I am hopeful that it will make it clearer for people about when they can come to us. That can have a knock-on effect on us as an organisation, which is why it is important that public bodies get a handle on their complaints and better understand what they are and what they are telling them.

Mr Martin: An old but relevant piece of research by the National Audit Office looked at benefits complaints handling in the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP). It is 40 times more expensive to deal with a complaint at stage 3 of a process than if it is resolved at stage 1. That is why we have a great focus on trying to resolve an issue. First, you have a happier customer with whom trust has been restored. Constant back and forth consumes public resource that is better directed at the delivery of services, so our focus is on resolving complaints at stage 1, if possible, rather than getting into a process. The complaints process should not feel like a process. We have to have one so that somebody knows where they are and when it has ended, which opens it up to us. The metrics show that having multi-layer stages is not a good use of resource.

Mr Kingston: Thank you both for your evidence. People have to go to the public body's own complaints process first. How well are those processes promoted? People who come to my office want to go to NIPSO, and I say, "No. First, you have to go through the public body" and they say, "How do I do that?", and I look that up for them. Could public bodies be doing more to promote their own complaints processes?

Ms Kelly: Public bodies could do more on signposting. My own initiative team has reviewed, when doing investigations, how easy it is to find information about the health and social care complaints process and how easy it is to find information about how to complain to DFC about personal independent payments (PIP). It is not always clear, and we try to highlight that fact to public bodies. It is one of the things that we are trying to address by saying, "You need to have really clear information on your website. You need to have clear information about how long it should take and when someone can escalate to the next stage". There is definitely more work for public bodies to do on that.

We have a developing problem with AI, because, often, if you do a Google AI search about how to complain to a public body, it will send you to us. As a result, the person comes to us, and we have to say, "Sorry, you need to go to the public body first", and they are, understandably, frustrated by that. There are therefore a couple of issues that we could do with sorting out.

Mr Martin: We did a piece of research in 2018 that looked at how easy it was to find information about how to complain about a public body. We looked at hundreds of public body websites — I cannot remember the exact number — and found that you had to click through layer after layer after layer on a website to find the right information about how to complain. That is one of the reasons for our having very clear requirements for public bodies to make their complaints process easy to access and to adapt the procedures to meet their needs.

Ms Kelly: There is some compliance monitoring around that. Once we have agreed model complaints handling procedures with a particular public-sector body, it has six months to get its house in order and organise a process for recording and publicising. We then look at the complaints handling that it submits to us and do a bit of compliance checking to ensure that it reflects what it should be doing. I have a small team of two staff and a manager, and we have a big jurisdiction, so it will take a wee while to see that change.

Mr Kingston: It is useful to know that you monitor that.

I will put two questions together. How strong is the ethos of accountability in the Civil Service? In our work, one of the most satisfying things is being able to help somebody. If people feel lost in the big system, we are able to go to someone who can address their issue or at least highlight their concerns. At the end of the day, the Civil Service provides a public service, and it should, through elected reps and others, be accountable for providing that service to a certain standard. Linked to that, in your reports, you will, at times, make recommendations, I assume.

Ms Kelly: Yes.

Mr Kingston: How do you find the response to your recommendations, and do you have the time to monitor the responses?

Ms Kelly: I see the issue of complaints and the culture around it as sitting within the broad accountability framework. When I came in, we commenced work on the complaints standards, because accountability was not as clear as it could have been. Sometimes, even my office runs into difficulties when seeking a response, and I think, "If I run into difficulties, how much more does a member of the public run into difficulties?". That is an area where we need to do more work. That is why I am quite focused on data and outcomes.

It is variable: some people are very transparent, open and accountable and look to resolve an issue, while others are not. Overall, the culture is linked a little bit to risk and fear. There is a need for our public servants and civil servants to feel that — it is OK — they have the authority to move forward and solve things for people rather than feeling that they cannot take that risk or that, if they do so, there will be some comeback. That very much fits with some of the themes that the Committee has considered.

We make recommendations. In general, people comply with ombudsman recommendations, and we report on compliance. I am just about to publish my ombudsman report for last year, which will detail the level of compliance that we have seen. We follow up on our reports. We will send our report to the individual who has complained, and it is not unusual for them to come back and ask, "Did that happen? Has anything come from it?". We therefore try to follow up on them.

Mr Martin: Accountability is a big issue for people who come to us. They believe that there is a lack of accountability in the system. We have been doing a lot of work on the fact that organisations with boards need to be interested in what complaints are telling them, which requires good recording and reporting. We tell them that they should report publicly, which allows all of us, including Assembly Committees, to scrutinise performance on complaints, and internally to their boards and audit and risk committees. When Margaret wrote to the chair of the board of one of our large ALBs, the person who really took an interest and took the issue forward was the chair of the audit and risk committee. We thought that that was a good sign, because they understood that there were risks associated with their not dealing properly with complaints, which they needed to address.

People who come to us say what Gerry said: they do not want other people to experience what they experienced. They expect a level of accountability, but, quite often, they do not feel that that accountability exists at a senior level.

Mr Kingston: Do you feel that, in general, the response to your recommendations is positive?

Mr Martin: We have really good acceptance of our recommendations. Our reports set out very clearly the basis on which they are made. I cannot remember the exact figure, but it is around 80% — it is certainly in the 70s —

Ms Kelly: We can certainly send you something.

Mr Martin: — for recommendations that are complied with. It takes a little bit of time. We would like to see that happen more quickly, but there is an acceptance of the recommendations, and, when we go back, we see implementation.

Ms Murphy: I will try to be as concise as possible, because I have a few questions.

I am from an incredibly rural constituency. Throughout the investigations that your organisation has handled, have you identified any differences in complaint patterns or outcomes for people who live in rural areas? Sean, you mentioned the data gap for BSO. I think about how difficult it is at a constituency level for people to access GP services. Last week, I dealt with three different complaints from constituents who were trying to access a GP appointment.

Ms Kelly: This does not directly answer your question, but we are just about to put up on our website an interactive complaints data map for across Northern Ireland, which we have had to do by council area. You will be able — this is for our data, rather than complaints across the public sector; we do not have that information — to look at, per 10,000 of the population, how many complaints we have received for an area, what that is like compared with other areas and what the main issues of complaint are. It is still a work in progress for us. We pick up stuff to do with rural farm grants, and we have started to do some of that analysis. I hope that the map will be available in the next week or two. We are looking at where the complaints are coming from and where we are not getting complaints. If you are asking me about the Northern Ireland public sector as a whole, however, that information is not available at the moment.

Mr Martin: We are doing that to show what is possible, and that is our complaints dataset. If we had good data right across public services, we would have a good picture of whether there is a difference between the complaints raised by people from urban and rural areas. Margaret is from Belfast, and I am from the countryside, so we often have that kind of debate. I get where you are coming from. Sometimes, different issues affect people in rural areas.

Ms Kelly: Rural broadband has been a big issue.

Mr Martin: We received complaints about access to rural broadband when that was being rolled out. Sometimes, the issues are the same: health service issues affect us all. However, some issues are unique to either being in a city or being in a rural area.

As I said, we are attempting to show what is possible. Our dataset shows that we received 1,700 complaints last year, but, if we captured the public-sector dataset meaningfully and used technology to analyse it, that would tell us a lot about what people want from their public services and where they believe the gaps to be. Last week, I went out to meet people whom I used to work with. There were eight or 10 of us there, and two of them complained about access to GP services.

Ms Murphy: It is a huge issue across the North, but it seems to be particularly pertinent to those in rural areas.

In cases where the process for handling complaints has been weak or sub-par, do you generally find that it is reflective of a broader cultural issue in the Civil Service, organisation or public body?

Ms Kelly: We always try to remember that anybody can be having a bad day when somebody comes and complains to them, so there has to be balance. In broad terms, however, the fact of an organisation having poor complaints handling speaks to its organisational culture and to the need for a culture of openness, transparency and accountability. That is a key indicator, but it is a key indicator that we do not look at very often across the Northern Ireland Civil Service or the public service. That is part of why some of our drive really matters. It is also part of why I was keen to bring some of those issues to the Committee while it considers the culture and performance of the Civil Service.

Ms Murphy: Absolutely, Margaret. From your experience of investigating cases with public bodies, do you feel that some public bodies may, unfortunately, be overly defensive?

Ms Kelly: Absolutely.

Mr Martin: The Public Office (Accountability) Bill, as it stands, covers inquests and inquiries in the requirement to be open and frank. There are delegated powers in the Public Office (Accountability) Bill that could be extended. We would certainly ask that they be extended to our office in future, and maybe to our colleagues in the Audit Office and so on, so that we would have cooperation because the bodies are duty-bound to give us the information, rather than us having to ask the right question.

Ms Kelly: Our receiving a response is often predicated on our staff asking precisely the right question to get a public body to dig down or asking for the right document, as opposed to there being a duty, such as that which the Public Office (Accountability) Bill would impose on the public body, to give freely of information. That duty would be important.

Ms Murphy: Sean, my final question relates to an answer that you gave to Brian about the public having to spend possibly hours going through Google and websites to access an online form or even a complaints process itself. Do you think that public bodies are doing enough to make their complaints procedures available and accessible to members of the public?

Mr Martin: One thing that we will make sure that public bodies do, through the process that we are running throughout the public sector, is to make sure that those procedures are accessible, and not just online, because we do not want to leave anyone out. Not everybody is digitally able, so other mechanisms have to be available. As Margaret said, when we publish a model complaints handling procedure, as we did for central government, we allow the body six months and then go to check that the process is accessible — that we can easily find out how to complain and so on. By June next year and March 2028, all public bodies should have an accessible, visible complaints process, and we will monitor that.

Miss Hargey: I have seen it from both sides. The system can get very defensive. It often looks at systems and at people as numbers, rather than as actual people. For me, it is about a cultural shift, because there is, obviously, a culture. You touched on the Public Office (Accountability) Bill. Do you believe that putting a duty in place is the only thing that will shift the culture, or are there other things that would do that? Is it a necessity to have, for example, a duty of candour in order to do that?

Ms Kelly: I look at the experience that I have had with public bodies, at the experience of public inquiries in Northern Ireland and at the many recommendations about candour and openness, and I see that, despite all that, the culture has not fully shifted. Having candour and openness is complex. There are things in organisational culture to do with safety and how safe employees feel when matters of complaint come up. Ultimately, to shift that, you need a statutory duty. Unless you have that statutory duty, things will not shift. I have been open and on record around a duty of candour for health officials in particular, and that has been a matter of much debate. Sometimes, when I have engaged in that debate, health officials have said, "We have our professional duty". Actually, a statutory duty of candour that requires you to be open is also a protection for individual employees, because you can fall back on saying that you are now individually required to do that. While I understand why people can see that as threatening, I think that it can be a protection. I think that the experience to now says that it is necessary in order to create a degree of shift. It will not be the only thing that creates that shift, but I think that it is necessary.

The Chairperson (Mr O'Toole): No one else has indicated that they want to ask a question. I think that we have covered quite a lot of ground. Thank you very much, Margaret and Sean, for coming to see us. We appreciate your time.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up