Official Report: Minutes of Evidence

Committee for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, meeting on Thursday, 12 November 2026


Members present for all or part of the proceedings:

Ms Diana Armstrong (Chairperson)
Mr John Blair
Mr Tom Buchanan
Ms Aoife Finnegan
Mr Daniel McCrossan
Miss Michelle McIlveen
Miss Áine Murphy
Mr Gareth Wilson


Witnesses:

Mr Declan McAleer MLA, Northern Ireland Assembly



Areas with Natural Constraints (Payments) Bill: Committee Deliberations

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): We can now bring the Bill sponsor to the table to address the queries that we discussed in closed session. The Committee Clerk will summarise the closed session discussion.

The Committee Clerk: In the closed session, the Chair went through the discussions that we had last week on each of the Bill's clauses. There was a discussion about a proposal to amend clause 1(2) to extend the 12-month period for making regulations. Declan, the Bill sponsor, stated that he was content for either the Committee or him to take forward that amendment to extend the period to implement regulations to 24 months in order to allow the Department to put systems in place. The Committee was not minded to take forward that amendment. Declan, will you confirm for the record that you are content to table that amendment?

Mr McAleer: Yes. The Department has emphasised the importance of updating its systems in order to align with the regulations. I am content to amend the timeline from 12 months to 24 months.

The Committee Clerk: Thank you. Sorry, I skipped clause 1(1). There were no comments on clause 1(1).

The Chair ran through the discussions that we had last week on clause 1(3)(a) concerning the potential to add environmental outcomes. The Bill sponsor stated that the Bill would give the Department a completely clean slate to devise regulations, which could include environmental outcomes were the Department so minded. The Committee was not minded to make any amendments.

Mr McAleer: It is a very straightforward, single-clause Bill, the purpose of which is to set payments for areas with natural constraints (ANCs) at the 2018 rate. The regulations would give the Department the opportunity to set that out in more detail. Importantly, the regulations would, of course, come back to the Committee and the Assembly for ratification, amendment or whatever.

The Committee Clerk: Thank you. The Bill sponsor confirmed that he had looked at the potential to remove the index-linked inflationary increases at clause 1(3)(b) and clause 1(3)(c). In the evidence sessions, Committee members had made the point that no other farm payment scheme has an index-linked inflationary increase and that, if the Department's budget did not increase, it could put pressure on other schemes. The Committee was not minded to table an amendment in that regard. However, the Bill sponsor has agreed to table that amendment. Will you confirm that, Declan, please?

Mr McAleer: Yes. I have taken on board all the comments made and the fact that, if the payment was linked to inflation, it would be an increasing amount within, perhaps, a static overall budget. I am willing to table an amendment to remove the RPI reference and, perhaps, to look at a review period after a number of years of the scheme.

The Committee Clerk: Clause 1(4) concerns the definition of "areas with natural constraints". The Bill sponsor reiterated to the Committee that the regulations would be draft affirmative and would be considered by the Committee and the Assembly. He also confirmed that ANC as defined in the Bill means what were formally known as severely disadvantaged areas (SDAs). The Bill sponsor introduced the knowledge exchange seminar series (KESS) seminar yesterday on behalf of the Committee and said that a strong case had been made for the inclusion of floodplains within ANC. The Department may wish to look at that in regulations, should the Bill pass. Declan, do you want to speak to that?

Mr McAleer: I made the point that a lot of floodplain land is already in ANC, including, perhaps, in your county, Chair. That was just an anecdotal reference at the KESS seminar yesterday. It is interesting that there may be areas of floodplain that are not included in ANC but are used for productive agricultural purposes. That is not necessarily for this Bill, which is just an enabling Bill; it could perhaps be considered in the next mandate, when the regulations are being agreed under the draft affirmative procedure.

The Committee Clerk: There were no further comments or discussions on clause 2.

Overall, the Committee was not minded to amend the Bill, but the Bill sponsor has stated for the record the amendments that he will table. We will move on to our informal and formal clause-by-clause consideration at next week's meeting.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): I do not see any further questions. Declan, thank you for your attendance.

Mr McAleer: Thank you.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up