Official Report: Minutes of Evidence

Committee for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, meeting on Thursday, 12 November 2026


Members present for all or part of the proceedings:

Ms Diana Armstrong (Chairperson)
Mr Declan McAleer (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr Tom Buchanan
Ms Aoife Finnegan
Mr Daniel McCrossan
Miss Michelle McIlveen
Miss Áine Murphy
Mr Gareth Wilson


Witnesses:

Mr John Blair MLA, Northern Ireland Assembly



Hunting with Dogs Bill: Committee Deliberations

[No recording available.]

Mr Blair: — they call trail hunting and legitimate rodent control. I point out that rodents that we commonly know as rats and mice are not covered by the Bill to start with and that there are already exemptions in the Bill for pest control in relation to livestock, human health and land management.

During our discussions, I have heard interesting takes on and points raised about the potential for trail hunting to be a replacement for what is currently called hunting. Examples have been given of differences between what is known as trail hunting, although there does not seem to be any of that on the island of Ireland, and drag hunting and the fact that different landscapes might be used. I think that both trail hunting and drag hunting could be done on a variety of landscapes. That is my take on it. There is nothing to suggest that anything in law would have to say that drag hunting has to be on a particular type of land, so options would be open to people if they want to pursue that route.

On landscape location and choice of location, those things are already done, as far as I am aware, in agreement with landowners, so it should never be the case that somebody can simply go out and hunt wherever they like and on whatever land or terrain they like. There would have to be local agreements. I do not know for sure, but it may well be that someone will give permission for some parts of their land to be used but not other parts. It is not always as straightforward as flat ground or rougher terrain, etc.

Points have also been raised about dog walking. An example was given in the session today of somebody — it is a legitimate point — who is out walking with six dogs and might look like a hunter, perhaps given where they are or by their attire or what they are carrying or doing. My reply to that is that, if anyone needs to see the difference between the average dog walker and what I would portray as an organised hunt, they can look at the websites of the relevant bodies, some of which have presented to us.

Apart from that, I know responsible dog owners who make every effort, when they are out walking, to stop their dog from following the scent of a wild mammal. They do so for a host of reasons. First, the dog could go missing if it started running across a field to chase after a wild mammal. A responsible dog owner would not want their dog to do that, with it perhaps being out of sight. They also would not want to risk their dog being injured by a wild mammal. There are already people who, through responsible dog ownership, avoid such scenarios.

Turning to today's conversation about the potential risks for firearms holders, I understand the concerns that have been raised; those have previously been raised with me directly. A lot of this will be down to the fact that, should the Bill become law, if you are not willingly or deliberately breaking the law in a way that is defined in the law, there should not be a problem. By the same token, a firearms holder who is caught inadvertently in some kind of affray might be at risk. A family member of mine has dealt with those types of situations, and members here may have too. There are situations that are, quite frankly, well beyond the scope of my Bill. That is a matter of responsible behaviour in the first instance and of ensuring that the person has a defence. I do not see a situation where that would be an issue. Although it was not raised today, I will point out again that the Bill is not aimed at those who are conducting normal gun dog hunting in the first place.

In conclusion, since we last met, I have responded to a number of points that have been raised in the Committee by the Assembly's Research and Information Service (RaISe). I remain open to discussions on those points, or any of the points raised today, with members or their parties.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Thank you very much. There are two matters that I want to ask you about, John. First, do you want to address the declaration of interest issue?

Mr Blair: Yes, Chair. It has been raised with the Committee that, although I was present when the League Against Cruel Sports presented to us, I did not declare that I had been nominated for an award by that organisation. I hope, Chair, that you and Committee colleagues can accept the rationale that I gave earlier, when I explained that I had originally considered that in the context of what we call the register of Members' interests. That is where we register ongoing interests. The advice in that regard is that:

"any unremunerated interests which might reasonably be thought by others to influence how you act in the capacity as a Member of the Assembly"

should be registered. I had previously introduced the Bill many years ago and publicly declared that I would do so again. I did not judge that anybody would immediately perceive that anything that I received by way of an award could influence an action that I was taking, especially in the context that it was an action that I had already taken when I introduced the Bill some time before that nomination and award.

However, I have further considered the wider requirements on declarable interests, such as those that we declare at Committee when things are under consideration. The guidance on that states that one should declare:

"any relevant interest which might reasonably be thought by others to influence your approach to the matter under consideration."

The phrase "under consideration" is key to the Committee discussion and to those who presented to us on that day. I fully accept that I should have declared that I had been nominated for that award. I do so now, and, in the interests of full disclosure, I will also enter it on the register of interests.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Thank you; we have that on the record.

Mr Blair: Chair, I apologise for any confusion that I have caused for you or for the Committee.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Your apology is accepted; thank you.

John, will you now address the concerns about inaccuracies relating to an evidence session on the two-dog limits?

Mr Blair: Yes, Chair. I do not have that transcript in front of me. However, I am mindful of correspondence to the Committee. I am sure that those people had their reasons. The people who corresponded with the Committee wrote to every Committee member other than me, otherwise I would have been able to respond to them directly.

I am happy to point out, through the Committee, that what I did there was misspeak. If anything that I said could have been perceived as denying that my Bill would not allow animals underground, it was clearly a misspeak. I apologise for any confusion that was caused. It was clearly a misspeak, because I had already declared on many occasions, including at our evidence session, that the Bill would not allow dogs underground. I have said that publicly. I repeat: if those who presented were confused in any way by what I said, I apologise. I hope that, if they read the full text of what was said, they will understand that, had I simply added the words "above ground", all would have been covered.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Thank you for clarifying that, John.

We will return to this next week when we will go back to the deliberations on the report from the Clerk. Thank you, John, for your attendance.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up