Official Report: Minutes of Evidence

Committee for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, meeting on Thursday, 12 November 2026


Members present for all or part of the proceedings:

Ms Diana Armstrong (Chairperson)
Mr Declan McAleer (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr John Blair
Mr Tom Buchanan
Ms Aoife Finnegan
Mr Daniel McCrossan
Miss Michelle McIlveen
Miss Áine Murphy
Mr Gareth Wilson


Witnesses:

Mr Christopher Andrews, Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs
Ms Catherine Goligher, Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs



Welfare of Animals (Supply of Puppies and Kittens) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2026: Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): I now welcome from the Department Christopher Andrews, deputy director of the animal health and welfare policy division, and Catherine Goligher, head of the animal welfare and dog control policy branch. Please brief the Committee.

Mr Christopher Andrews (Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs): Thank you, Chair. The regulations represent significant and long called-for legislation. Members will be aware that public animal welfare organisations and, indeed, elected representatives have sought the introduction here of measures equivalent to those in Great Britain to protect puppies and kittens when they are offered for sale or sold.

Unlike in the rest of the UK, it remains legal for third parties to sell puppies and kittens in Northern Ireland. By "third party", I mean someone who is not connected with the breeding of the animals. Such people are, in essence, dealers or traders. They tend to have no interest in the animals, their primary motive is profit, and they deliberately obscure the new owners from the original breeder. That, crucially, makes it more difficult to establish where and how puppies and kittens were bred and raised. These regulations intend to change that. By making third-party sales illegal, the regulations will improve transparency and mean that puppies and kittens under six months of age must be obtained directly from the person who bred them. It is useful to point out that the regulations will make it illegal for a third party to supply a puppy. We felt that it was important to bring the supply of puppies into scope to prevent the ban on selling being circumvented through swaps, exchanges or similar mechanisms.

The Department launched a 12-week public consultation in the middle of 2025. We received 488 responses to the consultation, 447 of which were from members of the public. Over 80% of respondents agreed with all elements of the proposals, demonstrating strong support for changes to the law. As Committee members will be aware, the Department published a summary of responses and way forward document in February this year. As part of the way forward, the Department sought to establish a joint implementation group with councils to oversee the introduction and delivery of the legislation. At that stage, councils raised concerns about resources, enforcement and the practical application of the registration proposals as set out in the consultation.

Having considered those concerns, particularly the time needed to establish the registration scheme and the necessary IT infrastructure, we concluded that there was a real risk that the full package of reforms could not be delivered before the end of this mandate. We then determined that the best approach was to proceed with the ban on third-party sales alongside statutory advertising and record-keeping requirements. The Minister agreed with that approach. Therefore, we have moved forward with the core Lucy's law protections, as originally set out in the Minister's animal welfare pathway.

I stress that, even without a registration scheme, the regulations will establish clear, legally binding requirements that will help to protect animal welfare, criminalise poor practice and enable owners to make informed choices.

I will now hand over to Catherine, who will take you through some of the specific detail in the statutory rule.

Ms Catherine Goligher (Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs): Thank you. As Chris said, the core element of the regulations is the prohibition of third-party sales of puppies and kittens and the supply of puppies. Puppies and kittens are defined as animals under six months of age. That means that anyone selling or supplying a puppy or selling a kitten must have bred the animal themselves. Importantly, the kitten or the puppy must be seen with its biological mother at the premises at which it was bred. That brings the purchaser, the breeder, the animal and the breeding environment together, which means that someone who is considering buying a puppy or kitten can see much more clearly where the animal has come from and the circumstances in which it has been raised. No puppy or kitten should be transferred in a car park or a lay-by, nor should it be delivered to a home.

The new requirements will help prospective owners to understand where they should obtain a puppy and reduce the risk of purchasing an animal despite concerns about its welfare or origin. Once someone has seen a puppy, it can be difficult to walk away, even where there are clear warning signs. Obtaining a puppy in such circumstances, however, can leave owners caring for an unwell animal, facing substantial veterinary bills and experiencing considerable emotional distress. The regulations are therefore an important step towards not only improving animal welfare but protecting prospective owners and tackling illegal breeding.

The regulations will also introduce additional conditions governing the sale, supply and advertising of puppies and kittens. They include that animals must not be sold or supplied before they are weaned or are eight weeks old; suppliers must be at least 16 years old; the sale or supply must take place where the animal was bred; and the prospective buyer or new owner must see the animal with its biological mother at those premises. There are specified exemptions to that requirement, such as instances where the mother has died or where separation has been necessary for the health or welfare of the animals. There will also be requirements for advertising and record-keeping. Suppliers must declare whether the animal is receiving medical treatment. Finally, they must advise the new owner on where to find information on caring for their puppy or kitten. Importantly, for puppies, the transaction must take place at the address recorded on the mother's valid dog licence or the relevant breeding establishment licence. Rescue and rehoming organisations that are registered with the Charity Commission and council dog pounds will be exempt from those requirements. Where an animal is sold from outside Northern Ireland, including the Republic of Ireland, the regulations will apply where the sale takes place in Northern Ireland.

The regulations do not, of course, remove the need for prospective owners to exercise care. They should always exercise due diligence when sourcing a puppy or kitten by asking the appropriate questions, carrying out the relevant checks and being prepared to walk away if something does not look right. Any concern should be reported to the relevant council, because, in line with councils' existing role under the Welfare of Animals Act (Northern Ireland) 2011, it will be responsible for enforcing the regulations. Enabling purchasers to make informed and responsible choices will help to reduce the market for animals that are bred and sold in poor welfare conditions. That is a key part of what the reforms are intended to achieve.

Breaching the relevant sale, supply, advertising or record-keeping requirements will be an offence. On conviction in a Magistrates' Court, a person may face a fine of up to £5,000, imprisonment for up to six months or both.

The new legal requirements provide clear points at which compliance can be assessed by councils, from the advertisement through to the transfer of ownership. For example, officers can compare the age stated in the advertisement with the recorded date of birth and the supply date to establish whether an animal was sold before it was eight weeks old. For puppies, the recorded microchip number can link an individual animal to the seller's records. Councils can also compare the recorded breeding address and the purchaser's account of where the transaction took place with the address on the mother's valid dog licence or the relevant breeding establishment licence. Any inconsistencies provide the basis for further enquiries into a possible third-party sale or transaction away from the breeding premises. Naming the council in the advertisements will also help members of the public to direct concerns to the appropriate authority.

The advertising and record-keeping requirements introduced in the regulations, alongside existing dog licensing and microchipping legislation, will provide councils with a clear trail to identify and investigate suspected breaches. That will support proportionate, intelligence-led enforcement rather than requiring every premises to be inspected. We appreciate that councils need time to prepare for the new requirements, and that is why a three-month lead-in period has been built into the legislation and why, as outlined, registration has been delayed.

As the regulations introduce new offences and penalties and involve the Department of Justice, Executive approval was secured on 6 October. It is intended that the regulations will be laid by the end of 2026 and come into operation in March 2027. During the lead-in period, the Department will explain the changes, provide information and guidance, and continue to engage with councils and relevant stakeholders to support implementation. Through that joint work, we will help those affected to understand what the changes mean in practice.

Mr Andrews: I will make a few closing remarks, Chair. Ultimately, the regulations are about raising the standard of protection that we provide to puppies and kittens at a particularly vulnerable stage in their life. The regulations will make it more difficult for irresponsible breeders to hide behind intermediaries and will give prospective owners greater confidence about where their new pet has come from.

It is important to stress that we are not simply replicating the approach taken elsewhere. As Catherine said, we have tailored the regulations to the Northern Ireland context, including by making use of our existing dog licensing system to provide an additional layer of traceability and accountability. The regulations will also bring parity with other jurisdictions, support responsible breeders and help to tackle the market for animals bred and sold in poor welfare conditions. We believe that the regulations will be an important additional tool to help councils to tackle illegal breeding and demonstrate a clear commitment to higher animal welfare standards and a more responsible and transparent market for puppies and kittens in Northern Ireland. It is important to emphasise that the regulations sit within a wider programme of complementary animal welfare reforms, including the review of dog breeding and the proposed reforms that the Department is bringing forward to strengthen microchipping.

We are happy to take any questions.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Thank you very much. All of us should maybe declare an interest, because I imagine that most people in the room are owners of a dog or cat.

Quite a lot of the respondents referred to the phased approach. For completeness, would it not have been more effective to have all the proposals including registration together as one package? Is there insufficient justification for delaying the registration scheme?

Mr Andrews: Your comment is fair, Chair. Our initial proposal was to have a registration element, underpinned by appropriate IT infrastructure, taken forward in tandem with councils. In about March, we realised that we did not have sufficient time left in this mandate to deliver the IT infrastructure that councils would need. We had hoped, at an early stage, to use the existing council IT infrastructure that is used for dog licensing. That was not possible. It is quite clear to us, having done further examination, that councils probably need a bespoke platform. That remains an ambition for us. We were left with the choice of whether to introduce certain elements of it and bring in some protections, namely the banning of third-party sales, which has been long called for, and advertising and selling protections. We felt that it was better to separate that and then continue to work with councils in the background on the registration scheme and the registration infrastructure. We are still happy to do that.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): In that regard, are you hearing any concerns from councils about resourcing for the additional requirement to provide that registration scheme?

Mr Andrews: Again, that is a fair comment, Chair. We have received numerous comments from councils and have met councils, and they have made it clear that they feel that registration, in particular, would have placed a burden on them. That probably added a bit of evidence for separating the registration element. We have not necessarily had the constructive relationships that we would have wanted with councils on the matter. We remain open to working with councils on that, and we have made it clear that we want to implement this legislation with them. There is still a body of work to do in that particular space.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Thank you. The Deputy Chair has a question to ask.

Mr McAleer: I am glad that you mentioned the councils, because they will be crucial in implementing the regulations. You said that the South is moving towards a similar situation, which is very welcome. Will your systems be robust enough to interface with the systems in the South? That could be a major loophole that could undermine this very welcome legislation. Will you be able to interface with whatever systems they have in place in order to make sure that there is proper traceability and accountability?

Mr Andrews: The first thing to say is that we have a very constructive working relationship with our counterparts in the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM). We meet regularly, and one Department is very aware of what the other is doing. We analysed their recently published report, and we can see where they are trying to mirror things that we are doing. Equally, we will be happy to do that.

We are at a juncture where we do not actually have a system. We have not even specced what such a system would look like. We could do what you have envisaged, Deputy Chair, which is to make sure that, if there is a need to link up with databases or IT systems in the South, we could try to specify or design a system that does that.

Mr McAleer: That will be important. Were the regulations to be properly implemented in the North, it could result in a spike in illegal puppies from the South, if there is not that traceability.

Mr Andrews: I agree. We are always conscious of the issue of displacement. It could be that we would introduce measures to deal with illegal breeding or trading here and that might shift the problem elsewhere to the border counties.

Ms Goligher: DAFM has, helpfully, proposed a prohibition of third-party sales that would be similar to our arrangements with regard to not moving puppies under eight weeks of age and seeing the animal with the mother at the premises where it was bred. That parity will be helpful, because the same arrangements will apply in all areas.

Mr McAleer: Thank you.

Miss McIlveen: Thank you for your presentation. You mentioned that these are long called-for regulations, and I put on record the work of my colleague Robin Newton, the former Assembly Speaker, who introduced a private Member's Bill. I know that John Blair supported him in those efforts.

I am disappointed that there is not a register. My concern is that the box will be ticked, and it may not then be seen as a priority for a future Minister. There are issues on both sides as regards preparedness of an IT system and a reluctance from councils. I would have liked there to be a commencement date, perhaps even 18 months or 24 months down the line, to allow you to get your systems in order. At least then there would have been an understanding that a register was going to be in place, and we would not have to go through the processes again with regard to future secondary legislation.

Mr Andrews: We explored that with our legal advisers. One of the options that we explored with them was to put in place registration requirements and then try to commence them at a later date. Catherine will keep me right on this, but we ran into a couple of legal problems with that. First, it was not deemed to be appropriate to have commencement parts in a piece of legislation. Our legal advisers said that we would have to have a definite date. With the infrastructure around a registration scheme being fluid, and because we did not have a definite date for having that, it would not be appropriate to do so. There was a danger that we would have to amend the legislation again. If we put the date in the legislation that said that we would commence a registration scheme with supporting infrastructure in 18 months' time but could not achieve that, we would have to bring back a new SR and amend that date further. That is not seen to be the way to make legislation in a proper fashion.

I do not know, Catherine, whether there is much more to say on that.

Ms Goligher: No, I agree with all that you have said. We explored all the options, because it was certainly our preference, as well, that it would all come through as a package. That was the original proposal. However, as Chris outlined, it just was not feasible from a legal perspective to put commencement dates in secondary legislation or for us to be in a position at the moment to say accurately when the IT system would be ready to implement. That is why we have taken that approach.

Miss McIlveen: I just think that amending a date would have been easier than having to go through the process again, because, at least then, there would have been an understanding from councils that that was happening regardless. During the past two years, the Committee has been through various pieces of legislation in which there have been issues with councils when it comes to resource etc. That would have put that to bed.

Mr Andrews: I appreciate that, but the legal advice that we had at that point was that we needed to have a definite date and that it would be poor process if we had a date that we could not stand over and then had to amend it because we could not hit it.

Miss McIlveen: Can you assure me that you will explore the register and the required IT system and that that will not then be left?

Mr Andrews: The Minister is already on record as saying that it remains a firm policy proposal for him. We would like to get the legislation made and then work with councils on speccing and procuring an IT system in order to have that underpinning technology to support the registration scheme. As I said, the Minister is on record as saying that that is the way in which he wants things done and wishes things to be done.

Miss McIlveen: I appreciate that. We just have to wait and see, but it is disappointing that we do not have a definitive date.

Mr Andrews: I understand that.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Members, we have two options because of time constraints and business that we have to complete today, and our cut-off time is in 10 minutes. Áine and John, do you still want to pose your questions? We could call the —

Mr Blair: I will be very quick.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): — officials back next week and conclude the business then.

Mr Blair: This will not take long.

The Committee Clerk: We still have another five minutes or six minutes of business to do.

Mr Blair: My question is really short, but, before I ask it, I pay tribute to Robin Newton, the former Member and former Speaker, and current Member Keith Buchanan for the work that has been done on this. Keith was taking it forward in this mandate, but the Department then started this process. It is welcome that it did. I thank the officials for getting it done in a timely way.

I have a quick question for reflection: do you agree that there is probably value in our taking some time over the registration issue, not least because it has always been my understanding that the number of breeders registered and reported by councils probably does not reflect the full picture? There might be a piece of work to be done on scoping whether there are people who are not ready or willing to register and how many there are.

Mr Andrews: If somebody is not willing or ready to register, they may find themselves breaching the regulations. However, I agree with your analysis. There are a number of breeders who fall into the hobby category and would not have any form of registration. They would not have a dog-breeding licence and would not, at the minute, be legally required to have one, either.

Mr Blair: Some council areas have none, and I find it difficult to accept that.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): We have an outstanding question. If you are able, we will invite you back to conclude this item of business next week. We just do not have the time today to bring this to a conclusion. However, I thank you for being here. We will conclude the matter next week. Thank you very much.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up