Official Report: Minutes of Evidence

Committee for the Economy, meeting on Wednesday, 11 November 2026


Members present for all or part of the proceedings:

Ms Diane Forsythe (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr David Honeyford
Ms Sinéad McLaughlin
Mr Peter Martin
Mr Mike Nesbitt


Witnesses:

Ms Clare Guinness, Belfast Chamber of Commerce
Ms Claire Murray, Belfast Chamber of Commerce



Regional Balance Bill: Belfast Chamber of Commerce

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): I welcome, from Belfast Chamber of Commerce, Clare Guinness, chief executive officer, and Claire Murray. I invite the witnesses to provide an opening statement, and members to indicate if they have any questions. Thank you.

Ms Clare Guinness (Belfast Chamber of Commerce): Thanks very much. We very much appreciate the opportunity to come here this morning.

Belfast Chamber of Commerce supports regional balance, as articulated in the regional balance policy and the subregional economic plan. However, with regard to the Bill specifically, we believe that it is important that we avoid measures that could constrain Belfast's growth. Belfast is the beating economic heart of Northern Ireland and absolutely vital to growing the regional economy. Economic outcomes are being improved elsewhere through the existing policy, as the Invest NI 'Performance Report' demonstrates. There exists the potential to slow investment and development in Belfast by limiting the region's established economic centre.

We have laid out six points for consideration. The first of those is that Belfast is the economic engine of Northern Ireland. It generates over one third of Northern Ireland's economic output. Belfast has the region's primary concentration of high-value employment, investment, innovation and internationally competitive business. That extends beyond its administrative boundaries. Belfast's businesses, jobs and commercial ecosystem support households, suppliers and communities throughout Northern Ireland.

The second point is that we do not think in terms of Belfast. Northern Ireland is a small geographic region with a relatively small population. We, in Belfast Chamber, think of it as one interconnected regional economy. Northern Ireland's compact geography and extensive commuting patterns mean that Belfast functions as an employment and commercial hub for a much wider population. Regional balance metrics must reflect functional travel-to-work areas (TTWAs), not simply council boundaries. That is borne out in the statistics. Belfast's travel-to-work area is home to a population of 1·13 million, which is over half of the Northern Ireland population.

Thirdly, we believe that connectivity to Belfast must be a strategic priority. Investment in rail, roads, public transport and integrated transport networks is essential to connect communities across Northern Ireland to Belfast's employment opportunities. Improving journey times, reliability and accessibility will allow more people to share in the city's economic success. The reach and opportunity that Belfast presents could be accessible to more people and the whole region.

Fourthly, it is important to protect and enhance Belfast's international competitiveness. As the second-largest city on the island of Ireland, Belfast competes globally for mobile capital, investment, talent and business activity. Its established economic clusters are strategic assets that should be strengthened rather than diluted by geographically driven investment targets, which may serve to frustrate the investment market. Cluster strengths, which include fintech, cybersecurity and ICT, need to be nurtured and supported with a talent and skills pipeline that enables further growth.

Fifthly, we want to leverage Belfast in order to grow the private-sector economy. Belfast is by no means without its problems. We have serious issues in Belfast, including economically inactive people and areas of deprivation. We have very muted private-sector growth, as borne out by such statistics as the business start-up rates, which are the lowest of any UK city. We believe that we need to help to support and grow Belfast as well as everywhere else. Regional growth is the objective for Belfast Chamber, as a rising tide lifts all boats.

Finally, we need to be careful about creating investment barriers and additional bureaucracy. The Bill, as drafted, is far-reaching, and numerous terms in it appear to be ambiguous and undefined. A full cross-departmental body and some restructuring would potentially be required to enable the Bill to function. Any new legislation needs to demonstrate clear additional benefits, recognise what we already have and avoid introducing requirements that undermine investor confidence, commercial location decisions and Belfast's growth potential.

In conclusion, Belfast should be recognised as the principal engine for growth, which will deliver regional prosperity. Growth in Belfast, complemented by subregional growth, will generate positive socioeconomic gains for a more prosperous region. The ambition should be to connect more of Northern Ireland to Belfast's economic opportunities whilst growing the strength of other regional centres. We do not want to directly or indirectly constrain the capital's economic potential. Thank you.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Thanks very much for that, Claire. We really appreciate it. I represent South Down, and our Chair represents Belfast. He is not here, so you may get a slightly different line of questioning from those who are in the room. South Down is a very rural area that is located away from Belfast. You talked about boosting Belfast and how a rising tide lifts all boats. My constituency has a harbour — no pun intended — and agri-food businesses. I am sure that you know South Down and everything that it has well. Do you recognise that, when it comes to the Bill's intention, some of those things work both ways?

As you said, a rising tides lifts all boats. If areas across Northern Ireland such as mine do well in other things, would that not help Belfast through, for instance, the tourism offering? A lot of people come to do their work in Belfast but then travel to the Mournes and enjoy golf tourism and other things. We have other things in our area. There is a lot of land that could be developed for aircraft factories and the type of things that Belfast would not have the space for. What is your view on that? If areas such as mine were to get a bit of investment to deal with the imbalance, that would boost Belfast as well.

Ms Guinness: Absolutely. That is a great point. It goes back to the fact that we are an interconnected region. For example, the supply chains of a lot of businesses in Belfast, mid-Ulster and south Down are totally interconnected. I never see Belfast — in my various roles, I have had experience of this — as a great panacea and say, "All eyes on Belfast". We need to think about how complementary we are; how small we are; how interconnected we are; and how one region benefits the other. We should never think of it as an inter-region competition. We are trying to compete globally. If we look at the economic challenges, of which there are many, we see that we need to attract capital to Northern Ireland — full stop. Yes, we need that capital to flow to areas other than Belfast, but, at the same time, we have to recognise the strategic assets and the strengths that Belfast provides and recognise that Belfast companies are supported by many companies in the likes of south Down — it is a complex, tangled web.

The Belfast travel-to-work area has a population of 1·1 million. The average salary in Belfast is lower than its gross value added (GVA), because the GVA reflects the fact that an awful lot of people work in Belfast but do not live there. That is why connectivity is vital. Remote working has aided that. People being able to stay in Newry to do their Belfast-based work is a real benefit. I absolutely see the need for us to work collectively. We are competing globally; as I said, we are not competing inter-regionally.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Absolutely. Thanks, Clare. I will bring in members. Sinéad is the Bill sponsor.

Ms McLaughlin: Thank you very much for your paper, Clare. In that paper, you indicated that Belfast accounted for 32·9% of Northern Ireland's GVA in 2023, that Belfast's workplace GVA per head is significantly above the Northern Ireland average and that 30% of all Northern Ireland jobs are based in Belfast, while Belfast's GVA per capita, which is also really important, was 78% above the Northern Ireland average in 2022. You stated that Belfast hosts 58% of Northern Ireland's tradable services, that Belfast's GVA per job filled was 9% above the Northern Ireland average, that median workplace earnings were 14% above the average in 2024 and that Belfast attracted 78% of new FDI jobs between 2015 and 2022. You also indicated that Invest NI's business plan and strategy demonstrate improved regional balance, with 59% of investment being made outside the Belfast metropolitan area. That is an arbitrary figure. The number of jobs is the figure that we need to look at to see the performance of Invest NI.

Ms Guinness: That is 1,500 jobs.

Ms McLaughlin: In the same year, 65% of all jobs were recorded as being in the greater Belfast area, with 6·5% in the north-west. The evidence indicates the need for a statutory obligation. Whilst there are a lot of strategies and regional balance is a main priority and key vision of the Department for the Economy, those things are non-binding: there is no statutory obligation, and that is the problem. Regional imbalances and disparities are growing. That does not just affect economic indices; it has a real knock-on effect on health and well-being and on infrastructure. It is all connected. Every Department has a role to play; it is not just about the Department for the Economy. Do you think that anything in the Bill says that Belfast is not allowed to grow? The purpose of the Bill is to require that opportunities be available to all citizens of Northern Ireland.

I say this with the greatest respect about the Belfast travel-to-work area population of 1·13 million. I know someone — a welder — who would love one of the new jobs in Harland and Wolff that will come shortly. If she got that job, she — it is a girl — would have to be in Belfast at 8.30 am. She would have to be up at 5.30 am to get to Belfast for 8.30 am. It takes her an hour to get out of the house. It would be the same going back. No public transport here is going to get her to Harland and Wolff for 8.30 am. That would mean two hours in the car and two hours back at those times of the day. She would have 20 work-related hours a week over and above what her colleagues do, and it would cost her at least £7,000 in petrol. That is not taking into consideration Tom and Sarah, who are three and five. To do that job, she would have to move.

There are jobs that are not accessible if they are all in one place. That is just an example, because I know that girl well, but there are those types of situations everywhere. We have fabulous clusters in Derry around the building of data centres. The same applies to someone from Belfast who wants to get such a job in Derry. The Bill is about growing the pie; it is not about taking from anywhere else and contracting the pie. It is about growing the productivity of Northern Ireland. The only way to do that is to grow areas outside Belfast. Do you accept, from an economic perspective, that that is a strategy that should be followed for Northern Ireland?

Ms Guinness: I hope that that lady gets a welding job. That is a terrific example, but we cannot replicate what happens in Belfast. We cannot move the port. We fought hard to keep Navantia.

Ms McLaughlin: I am just talking about a welder.

Ms Guinness: There is a really good example with Ryanair. We have really tried to bring Ryanair's new 400-person maintenance facility here, and Derry is on the list for the location. However, there is something about critical mass that we have to recognise. The fact that the population of Belfast's travel-to-work area is one million is important. That tells someone straight away, from an economic perspective, that they can tap into a potential workforce of one million people, easily, to fill their jobs. We cannot replicate elsewhere the assets, investments, characteristics and geography of Belfast.

You make the point well about transport networks, and that is one of my critical points. We should be able to move people 60 miles to work. If you look outside Northern Ireland to other highly functioning economies, you will see that they have excellent transport networks, including rail networks, that enable their citizens to move and access opportunities. We should be doing that.

Ms McLaughlin: That is what the Bill is about, Clare. It is about ensuring that regional balance is at the heart of planning for the future, which is about infrastructure and allowing people from south Down and Fermanagh to work in such jobs. I talked about a girl who wants to do a welding job in Belfast. I do not know what time a person from Fermanagh would need to be up at to get to Belfast for 8.30 am. People in Derry have to get up at 5.30 am.

Ms Guinness: I want people to have opportunities where they live, and I want them to be able to access opportunities in the biggest city that we have, which is Belfast. I agree about the infrastructure. We have a big problem in that we do not have an investment strategy for Northern Ireland, and infrastructure is a major part of that. We, in Belfast Chamber, have just done some analysis on what infrastructure the city needs. We are in an infrastructure deficit, as is the rest of Northern Ireland. The problems of Belfast are not different to the problems that we all see.

What I am saying is that we are taking measures. I actively see it. I have been in many discussions with officials from DFI, DFC and other Departments about trying to prioritise investment infrastructure and the public realm in Belfast. They say, "Hold on, Clare. We have to think of this regionally". I see it in practice all the time. I do not believe that we need more legislation. I am thinking about the huge burden on the public purse here, and I am thinking about the people and the government infrastructure that would need to be created to enable the Bill to function.

Sorry; I do not agree with more legislation as a concept. Those in economic development and those who understand investment markets and that we really need to attract institutional and private investment to Northern Ireland will say that we do not want to be seen as some difficult quagmire of a place that has legislation after legislation after legislation. That comes out, for example, in how our economic development agencies behave. They could become so constrained and afraid — I have some evidence that that is already the case — that they try to push places outside Belfast so much that they put investors off.

We need money to come into Northern Ireland — full stop. We need to be really clever to complement the overall strategy, making sure that there is a rising tide across the board. However, we can never replicate the jobs that are in Belfast by way of any sort of legislation. I did significant research in advance of this session, and I do not know of any other region in the world that does that. The Republic of Ireland is a great example. It has lots of problems too, but it has one of the most successful economies in Europe. The Republic of Ireland did not grow Galway by trying to replicate in Galway everything that Dublin had. Galway had its own strategy and its own cluster. Galway now has one of the top five med-tech clusters in Europe, which is phenomenal. That was nothing to do with trying to balance up with Dublin. Dublin has been forging ahead, but the Republic of Ireland said, "Let's enable all these other regions; let's get them all sparked".

Ms McLaughlin: Clare, you are making my point. That is exactly what the Bill is about.

Ms Guinness: I do not think that it needs to be in a Bill. I am sorry; I do not agree with your point. I agree with the premise, but I do not agree with having legislation.

Ms McLaughlin: The point is that we have tried everything else, including the 2012 regional development strategy. The regional disparities and gaps are getting bigger, not smaller. Whatever we have done to date is not working. We need to put it in legislation and make it binding in order that it works. We cannot do it piecemeal. The regional disparities have to be tackled, because they are having severe consequences.

You talked about good wages and better wages in Belfast. There are massive differences between the disposable incomes of someone who lives in the BT47 or BT48 postcode areas, which are in my constituency, and someone who lives in Belfast. Generally, those gaps are getting bigger. That has severe consequences. With the greatest respect — I love Belfast and have spent many a time in the city, so I am not bashing Belfast — this is about supporting the Northern Ireland economy to grow. We are not growing our economy efficiently enough. You have just mentioned the Republic of Ireland. The productivity gaps between there and here are massive and are getting bigger. With the greatest respect, Belfast is not lifting all boats, nor is it lifting its own boat.

Ms Guinness: Right, OK. I am sorry; I will have to disagree on that point. We have to go back to the fact that many people who work in Belfast and who benefit from the Belfast economy do not live in Belfast. Typically, the private-sector supply chain companies for defence, shipbuilding and so on are not located in and around Belfast; those companies are located in the regions that are supporting Belfast growth. This is a tiny place, and you cannot look at Belfast in isolation. It is a very complex, intertwined part of the overall picture.

Productivity everywhere, including in the Republic of Ireland and certainly in England, will never match up. Manchester, for all its brilliant growth, will never match what is done in London, but Manchester is not trying to do that; it is doing its own thing. I had a great meeting last week with the chief executive of the North East Mayoral Strategic Authority. The north-east is, to my mind, much more like Northern Ireland than any other GB region. It has urban centres — Newcastle, Sunderland and Durham — but it also has a coastal community, as we do, and a rural community. That authority is not trying to bring the jobs in Durham or Newcastle further out into the region. Its aim is to grow the region's revenues for the benefit of those communities and help create the funding to better the other regions that have not been performing as well.

I should also say that the health inequalities in Belfast are as big as those anywhere else. Former Minister Nesbitt is here, and he knows about this from times of old. One of the first meetings that we had was on this very point. If you are born in north Belfast, you have something like 10 years less life expectancy than others. We should have a higher bar than Belfast for our region. Belfast has loads of problems that need to be fixed. It should be recognised that Belfast's huge concentration of businesses make a huge economic impact, but I do not want everywhere else to be like Belfast; I want them to be better than Belfast. Belfast has huge problems that need to be fixed, and I do not want the eye to be taken off the Belfast ball, because, if Belfast does not function or is constrained, the regional balance will improve but that will not be to the betterment of Northern Ireland, as overall revenue will fall.

Ms McLaughlin: Do you accept that having a strong north-west, or strong regions or councils elsewhere, does not make Belfast weaker? It just makes those places stronger. There is nothing in the Bill that would make Belfast weaker. If we make other places stronger, that does not take anything away from anywhere else.

Ms Guinness: Absolutely not.

Ms Claire Murray (Belfast Chamber of Commerce): The only thing there, Minister—.

Ms McLaughlin: I am not a Minister, but I like how it sounds. Keep calling me that if you want, but "Bill sponsor" will do me. [Laughter.]

Ms Murray: Sinéad, it is about the metrics that would be put in place for that. What metrics will show success? For example, Invest NI had a target on investments of 65%, but it has only reached 60%. However, there is a narrative beyond the figures. It has reached 60% because the Bank of America investment skewed the numbers, but nobody will ever say that it is not a good investment. That is a really good success story, but Invest NI has not technically hit the 65% threshold. The argument is not whether the principle of regional growth is good or important; of course it is. The argument is about the statutory framework and metrics that will either enable regional growth or, potentially, put restrictions on it, and that is our fear and where we see a risk. On Clare's point, you could improve regional balance in terms of the hard numbers, but that does not mean that it would be to the benefit of the wider economy.

Ms McLaughlin: Clause 7 lists a number of indices that the measurement would be put against, and a baseline year would be chosen to measure improvement. None of it will happen overnight, because it takes a significant capital investment to make places more competitive, and there is a long-term issue with regional imbalance here. However, there has to be recognition that we cannot go on as we are. People and places have been left behind for too long, and it is having a significant impact.

Ms Guinness: Sinéad, there has been a sea change. As you said, it does not happen overnight. I have already witnessed regional balance, as brought in by the then Minister's economic vision, which was supported by a regional balance policy and a subregional plan underneath it. I see the change happening. It will not happen overnight, but I still do not believe that it needs legislation.

The numerous metrics in clause 7 that you mentioned do not exist in a lot of places. We have huge problems with data. You have mentioned cross-border data. There was a project with the Irish Business and Employers Confederation (Ibec) some years ago. I am not sure where it is now, but I was involved in the early stages of the project. We tried to measure, at the same level, what was happening in Northern Ireland’s economy and what was happening the Republic of Ireland's economy. I have never seen the numbers, as I do not think it has been cracked. We would need to get down to such a level of granularity. When I look at the statistics, I see that very little has been drawn out for Belfast, never mind for the likes of south Down or Fermanagh. Those data points do not exist. It would be a huge undertaking to produce the data, create the baseline and then create a cross-departmental function that somehow measures the data, with the Department for the Economy taking the lead. How would the Department for the Economy influence the housing priorities of the Department for Communities or the infrastructure priorities of the Department for Infrastructure? I cannot see how the Bill, as it is presented, would work.

Ms McLaughlin: The Executive would have to drive it, and that means every Department. Clare, you have just demonstrated well that the Department for the Economy is making inroads, but that does not go across all of government.

Ms Guinness: My point is that it could be done through policy interaction. I can already see it working in one place.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Both points have been well made, so we will bring in other members.

Ms McLaughlin: Thank you, Clare. I have done the job that you do. It would be remiss of you not to promote Belfast, because that is your job.

Ms Guinness: I promote Northern Ireland and the regional economy.

Mr Nesbitt: Good morning. I would be happy to see Belfast as first among equals. Is that where you are, Clare?

Ms Guinness: Yes, absolutely. That is good terminology.

Mr Nesbitt: To grow the economy, Sinéad wants a bigger pie. Peter wants a larger pizza.

Mr Martin: I just want a cup of coffee, Mike. [Laughter.]

Mr Nesbitt: Leaving gastro-economics to one side, we have basically full employment, so, to grow the workforce, we have to look at the level of economic inactivity, which, at 26-plus%, is quite shocking. If we look at the social determinants of economic inactivity, we see that the causes of health inequalities are the same — by the way, it is 14 years —

Ms Guinness: Fourteen, not 10. Thank you, Mike.

Mr Nesbitt: — of healthy life — and that the social determinants of educational achievement are the same. It would therefore require a whole-of-government approach, which, in fairness to the Bill sponsor, is what she is seeking through the Bill. Would you be happy with that?

Ms Guinness: Yes, I want to see a whole-of-government approach. That has already started in Economy, as was said. It is already being demonstrated in Invest NI's approach and in the way that it has set up subregional centres. I absolutely agree with that. As a region, we need to play to our strengths. We need to be complementary. We are a small place. This is a level playing field. What I want to see recognised and appreciated is the fact that we must not have any indirect or direct unintended consequences. We cannot inhibit Belfast's growth. We just cannot do that. That would be an act of self-harm on our regional economy. We have to make sure that we continue to grow Belfast and the rest of Northern Ireland at the same time.

Funding and sustainability are issues for us. I do not want to see us ploughing a lot of resources and effort into something that would take an inordinate amount of time to reap any rewards from and that may never deliver the same rewards, because of productivity constraints and the clustering effect. We have some unique economic assets in Belfast, including, of course, our universities, our tertiary education sector and its scale. Belfast has a certain scale that lets it compete globally, and we cannot inhibit that. To do so would be really detrimental to the Northern Irish economy.

Mr Nesbitt: We all agree that clusters are really important for the economy. Is it better to try to go for a hub-and-spoke approach to existing clusters or to go for new ones?

Ms Guinness: You play to the strengths of the place. Place-based economics and place-based approaches are, of course, in the industrial strategy for the UK. You leverage where you have a distinct advantage, because, as I said, we are not competing interregionally; we are competing on an all-island basis, a UK basis and globally. We need to bear that in mind. We have genuinely unique strengths: for example, Seagate, photonics and all of that. That is brilliant. Let us run with that, make it better and build on it. We need to recognise, however, that some of those strengths just cannot be replicated across a very small region. If we had better transport and better connectivity, many more people would have access to better jobs. Welders should be able to work in Belfast and live in Derry.

Mr Nesbitt: Claire, with an "i", given your day job, are there any lessons from the arts? Will the same play always be better at the Lyric than at Ardhowen or Strule?

Ms Murray: Sometimes, it is the same play, if it is allowed to tour, which is one of the restrictions that may be in place. It is a good point, because Belfast's role is not just economic. It plays a much wider societal role. It is supportive of charities, and the theatre industry is in that charity cluster. The city therefore has a much broader impact through its support of those.

On Clare's point, before COVID, we had all been acting very competitively, because of the way in which financial investment happens in the arts. However, it came to the point where there was a completely level playing field, because we were all closed, and nothing could happen. We realised then how small the geographical area is and that there are so many shared learnings across the industry. We are therefore much closer to our regional theatres now than we maybe were 10 years ago.

Mr Honeyford: Thank you for coming in and for your presentation and paper.

You said that Belfast was the economic driver, yet it is still underperforming compared with other cities on this island and across the rest of the UK. What is holding back that growth?

Ms Guinness: Where do I start? Growth is not being held back: in fact, we are growing. One positive statistic, recently, is that Northern Ireland has grown economically better than any other region in the UK. We are coming off a lower base, but let us run with that positive story. There are a number of facets to explain that. "Deep clusters" is a nice term on a piece of paper, but that is a serious, hardcore economic asset. The fact that Bank of America can come here is a massive endorsement. The fact that we are named the number-one inward investment location for cybersecurity globally is huge.

We have massive potential and are performing, but we have a huge distance to go. I do not like to go intra-Belfast, because that is not the way in which I think, but we have massive problems in Belfast. The economic inactivity rate in Oldpark is one in every two. What we are doing in Belfast is not good enough for our society, never mind the regional disparities as well. We have huge potential. Certain things are happening now that are helping Belfast to grow, such as the Belfast region city deal, innovation centres and increasing our capability. I recently met delegations from Japan, the United Sates and Switzerland that are interested in the Windsor framework and what that can deliver for us. I ran a session at my economic forum last week at which Alastair James, head of dual market access at Invest NI, talked about how that works and UK Export Finance talked about how it supports it. We now have a unique selling point with the Windsor framework, and that is not a Belfast selling point but a regional selling point. We have got our heads around it and see how it can work, and we should now be leveraging that massively for our region.

We have huge potential, but we have problems everywhere. I go back to the analogy that everywhere needs to increase. We need to recognise that there is something special in Belfast for such a small place to have some of those accolades and to attract some of those jobs. Invest NI has been doing a very good job, because I know how hard it is, from an economic development perspective, to get somebody even to think about coming, probably first, to the UK and then to Northern Ireland. I do not want us to look like a difficult place. We need to be welcoming capital flows and investment and then to make sure that that investment is felt by everybody across the region.

Mr Honeyford: I totally agree. Everybody is naming their constituency. Lagan Valley sits on the Dublin/Belfast economic corridor, and we are not making enough of the benefits of that as a region. Can connectivity across the island grow the economy more widely and improve regional balance including for Belfast?

Ms Guinness: One hundred per cent. There are already great figures on that. It is not rocket science, but the hourly train from Dublin to Belfast, for example, has made a massive difference to the number of visitors from the Republic of Ireland to our city and the region generally. It also enables people to work in Dublin and live in Belfast — 100 miles, not 60 miles. We can tap into their economy, and why would we not want even a modicum of their growth? Their economic prowess is phenomenal, and we, in Northern Ireland, should be doing all that we can to strengthen those links and tap into that. We can be helpful to them, because they, too, have skills and employment shortages. However, we have shortages too, and our big challenge is to get those economically inactive people into the workplace. We are not really at full employment. That is a statistic that always bothers me, because there are just too many people who are too far from the workforce. Our big challenge, from an economic perspective, is to get those who are farthest from the workforce to contribute, whether that is through the social enterprise sector, the charity sector or culture and the arts. I do not mind which sector it is done through or where it is done; I just want them all to be engaged, if possible, and for there to be opportunities for employment.

Mr Honeyford: That is brilliant; thank you.

Mr Martin: Apologies for being late: I was not just getting coffee; I was also doing the school run. Thank you for your evidence.

I do not want to use the analogy that Mike used about me, but do you accept, Clare, that, if a finite quantum of support is available and you start moving it around, one area will get less and another will get more? Is that fair enough?

Ms Guinness: Of course. It is an allocation of resources. That is why we need to grow the resources as well. That is —.

Mr Martin: OK, so, on regional balance, your argument is to just put more resources into the Department for the Economy such that Belfast does not lose out but other areas get more. Is that fair to say?

Ms Guinness: Absolutely, yes.

Mr Martin: OK. I am tempted to ask where those resources should come from; it seems that we are heading down that route.

Ms Murray: The question is whether the statutory framework unlocks that resource. Is there something in the Bill that will unlock investment that cannot be accessed now? For me, that is the question to ask. That is a different consideration, because it is general investment across the board that is required here — investment in, for example, transport links or waste management. It is right across the board.

Ms Guinness: We need to be careful about how we allocate resources. We talk about health inequalities and that sort of thing. There is a good example of it from the north-east of England. Transport links are one of the determinants that improve people's quality of life: it improves their ability to earn, their social mobility and so on. We need to look at the hardwiring of the region, if you like. That would automatically help every part of this place to do better.

Mr Martin: OK. You mentioned "deep clusters". I have not come across that term before. From the tenor of your argument, I think that you may have been starting to talk about what economists would consider comparative advantage. That is usually in reference to countries, globally: some countries make things better than others do, so they should concentrate their efforts on doing that rather than on doing something else. Is that what a deep cluster is, in a micro setting?

Ms Guinness: It is. If I look at Northern Ireland plc, which is how I view the world generally, I am looking at our unique selling points: what do we do really well here? From an economic and business perspective, you do not focus on producing all products; you produce the products that you are really good at producing —

Mr Martin: The products that you do well and can make more money on.

Ms Guinness: — that you can export, that produce more jobs and that you know give you a competitive advantage. We have some terrific assets through numerous investments. There are city deals everywhere, not just in Belfast. There are also our digital twin capability and the photonics investments that we have achieved from the UK Government and other entities. Those are giving us deep capability for such a comparatively small place. We have to mine that deep capability and make sure that it benefits everybody in Northern Ireland, whether they are in Enniskillen, Newry or Derry. That is the challenge. Why, for example, would we try to create a brand new cluster on a greenfield site when all those assets are sitting here together? We should clearly double down on those. There is something called "the agglomeration effect" in economics. Belfast is benefiting from an agglomeration effect.

Mr Martin: I have no argument with that. That is a fairly good explanation of where we are. I do not have anything else to ask, Chair. That is fine for me.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): OK. Clare and Claire, thank you so much for your evidence to the Committee. It has been a useful session. Thank you for writing in advance and for coming to the meeting this morning. I really appreciate you giving of your time. Thank you.

Ms Guinness: Thanks very much.

Ms Murray: Thank you.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up