Official Report: Minutes of Evidence
Committee for the Economy, meeting on Wednesday, 11 November 2026
Members present for all or part of the proceedings:
Ms Diane Forsythe (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr Pádraig Delargy
Mr David Honeyford
Ms Sinéad McLaughlin
Mr Peter Martin
Mr Mike Nesbitt
Witnesses:
Mr Alfie Dallas, Derry City and Strabane District Council
Mr Michael Gallagher, Derry City and Strabane District Council
Ms Anna Doherty, Londonderry Chamber of Commerce
Mr Andrew Fleming, Londonderry Chamber of Commerce
Regional Balance Bill: Derry City and Strabane District Council; Londonderry Chamber of Commerce
The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): I welcome Alfie Dallas, the lead finance officer from Derry City and Strabane District Council (DCSDC); Michael Gallagher, the senior economist from Derry City and Strabane District Council; Anna Doherty, the CEO of Londonderry Chamber of Commerce; and Andrew Fleming, a chamber board member of Londonderry Chamber of Commerce. I thank the witnesses for the quality of their evidence that was submitted to the Committee and for agreeing to give evidence together here today.
I hand over to you for some opening remarks. Members should indicate if they have questions.
Mr Alfie Dallas (Derry City and Strabane District Council): Thank you very much, Deputy Chair. I am Alfie Dallas, lead finance officer in Derry City and Strabane District Council. I am accompanied by my colleague Michael Gallagher, the council's senior economist. After we present, we will pass over to our colleagues from the chamber.
First, sincere thanks to the Committee for giving us the opportunity to address the Regional Balance Bill. As you know, we submitted a response to the call for evidence, which our council considered very seriously. As was stated in the response, we strongly support the principle and policy intent of the Bill. We particularly welcome the establishment of the measurable outcomes, reporting requirements and accountability mechanisms across all Northern Ireland Departments, because we believe that those are critical to ensuring the Bill's success.
In our council area specifically, we note the positive progress that has been made in recent years through the city deal investment, the Magee expansion to date, investment in key employers and the work of the north-west strategic growth partnership. Despite that investment, however, stark disparities continue to exist between our council area and other areas of Northern Ireland. Those disparities are reflected in a range of indicators relating to employment, productivity, investment and deprivation. I will pass to Michael in due course, who will take us through those.
One of the specific issues that we highlighted in our response was what we believe to be the urgent need to look at the rating system in Northern Ireland. There are disparities in that system that, we believe, disadvantage our region. The Bill provides a great platform from which to look at that. Obviously, rates are very complex, so a detailed piece of work needs to be done in that regard. However, the Bill provides a strong basis for doing so.
As you will be aware, rates are a wealth-based tax based on property values. The theory is that a ratepayer somewhere in this country with a lower property value should pay lower rates than somebody whose property has a higher value. Unfortunately, that is not the case, and it is certainly not the case in council areas such as ours. In previous years, that inequality was not totally addressed but addressed to an extent through the rates support grant. However, particularly since local government reform in 2015, the grant has been substantially eroded. Originally, it amounted to £20·5 million; it now stands at £3 million. As a council, we are entitled to 23·46% of that grant. You can imagine the impact that that has had on ratepayers in our area. The natural response to that is to suggest that we make cuts and efficiencies to offset that. However, many of our services are statutory services that we need to deliver. We need to collect bins and provide other such services.
The rates support grant is received by seven councils in Northern Ireland: Derry City and Strabane District Council; Causeway Coast and Glens Borough Council; Fermanagh and Omagh District Council; Mid Ulster District Council; Mid and East Antrim Borough Council; Armagh City, Banbridge and Craigavon Borough Council; and Newry, Mourne and Down District Council. When we compare those seven councils with the other four councils, one statistic that jumps out is that the domestic district rates poundages in those areas are 19·7% higher than in the other four council areas, which is very significant. Essentially, that means that ratepayers in those areas pay 19·7% more, as a percentage of their property values, in district rates. In our council area, which has the highest entitlement to the grant, based on overall wealth and deprivation statistics, our rates poundages are 37·9% higher than the Northern Ireland average. There are clear reasons for that, and, as part of the engagement that we have been doing around the rates support grant, we did a detailed report to explain those reasons. We are happy to provide that to the Committee, if it is helpful in any way.
I will pass over to Michael, who will take us through some of the disparities and challenges specific to our council area and the indicators that I mentioned of employment, productivity, investment and deprivation.
Mr Michael Gallagher (Derry City and Strabane District Council): Thanks, Alfie. I will briefly go through a series of statistics. I want members to get a flavour or sense of where the north-west and Derry City and Strabane District Council are at, rather than dealing with them individually. As a whole, the statistics paint a bleak picture of the area and explain why we need an intervention.
To address the need for the Bill, I will briefly outline the depth and extent of the inequalities existing in the north-west and the scale of the challenge within which the Bill was formulated. There are two key pieces of research. Professor Christopher Lloyd is from Queen's University Belfast; his 2024 research examined spatial variations across the UK nations, specifically in local government districts. I will not go into detail about what that meant, but this is the first time that we have had a comprehensive index for the UK as a whole. In the past, it has been done for the individual nations, including Northern Ireland.
One of the key issues that arises when we speak to people here is that Northern Ireland's multiple deprivation measures have not been updated since 2017, with some of the input data being from 2015. That is a major issue when you are looking for objective data to support your arguments. As a council, we have been pushing for resources to be put into that, because it is very important.
The analysis in that research contains few surprises for those living and working in the north-west, but, once again, it reiterates the need for a new approach if we are to see real, sustainable, positive change. Balanced regional development can form a key part of a changing strategy. We need to do something different. When we get to the end of this presentation, members will see what the longer-term impact may be if we do not do something different from the way that we do business at the minute.
I return to Queen's University's analysis. Professor Lloyd examined 382 local authorities in the UK and found that over 45% of Derry City and Strabane District Council areas lie among the 10% most deprived. We all know that; what is shocking is that it ranks us worst in the UK out of 382.
Let us look at other key indicators. The witness in the previous session mentioned the importance of health and transport in dealing with deprivation. In education, we are the worst out of 382, according to Professor Lloyd. In health, we are the third worst in the whole UK. In employment, we are the thirteenth worst. The previous witness mentioned economic inactivity: our employment rate sits at 65%, whereas the Northern Ireland rate is 70% and the UK rate is 75%. We are 10 percentage points below. There are probably another 1,000 or 1,500 people who should be in employment, if we could bring them closer to the workforce. Partly as a consequence, we experience high unemployment. As everyone knows, Derry is synonymous with high unemployment rates. We have done relatively well in the past — we have halved the number of people on the unemployment claimant count — but we are not doing enough. That is evidenced by the fact that we have the highest unemployment rate in Northern Ireland, at 4·1%. That is 46% higher than the Northern Ireland average. That is the loss of a lot of resources for a community and a region.
Given our poor levels of educational attainment and employment, it is not surprising that our income levels are similarly constrained, with a gross disposable household income per capita of £20,000, the lowest in Northern Ireland and less than 78% of the Lisburn figure. That is Office for National Statistics (ONS) data. That shows you the disparity in earnings. The knock-on effect runs right through the community. If you are trying to start a business, people do not have the disposable income to support you. It is very important to push that on. In addition, Invest Northern Ireland productivity data confirms gross value added (GVA) per job in 2022 of £50,000 compared with £58,000 in Northern Ireland, which means that we have 86% of the average. When we look at all those key indicators, we see that we are at the bottom where we want to be at the top, and we are at the top where we want to be at the bottom. That is why there is a need for a key intervention.
As might be expected, deprivation impacts significantly on health outcomes. That is the whole-societal cost of non-early years intervention, which works right through. We then see that, while male life expectancy in Northern Ireland is 78·8, in the most deprived parts of the Derry City and Strabane District Council area, it is 72·5. That is a gap of six years. A man is likely to die six years earlier in a deprived part of the Derry City and Strabane District Council area.
I turn now to a second piece of work, which is from Dr Eoin Magennis from Ulster University's economic policy centre. He explained why we need to do more. His most recent work on balanced regional development, in October 2026, found that, although Derry City and Strabane District Council was improving, with growth in employment and income, we are failing to keep up with other local government districts in Northern Ireland. He concluded that the gap is not narrowing sufficiently to change the economic output for DCSDC. We are doing a lot, but we are not doing enough. In fact, other areas are accelerating and are leaving us behind. We will talk in population terms about what might happen and what is happening at the minute.
In addition, the continuing outward migration that Derry City and Strabane District Council faces gives cause for concern. We have great schools. We prepare people to go to university, but, when they go to university, they do not come back. We then have a weaker labour market and a lower-quality labour market than we should have because the schools are doing fantastic work.
Normally, strong economic growth results in an increase in population, which can be seen in Dublin, Limerick, Galway or London. As individuals move to access opportunities, the converse is also true. For almost 25 years, from 2001 to 2025, the Derry City and Strabane District Council population grew on average by barely 0·25% a year compared with a Northern Ireland rate of double that. We are reaping the whirlwind of that, as you will hear about in a minute.
Consequently and worryingly, the Derry City and Strabane District Council population continues to decline from 8·5% of Northern Ireland in 2001 to 7·9% today. That is worrying in itself. The Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency (NISRA) said, in working local government district projections to 2047, that it is a challenging scenario, with a projected 13% fall in the Derry City and Strabane District Council population by 2047. It is a city in decline, even with the city deal and everything else. Again, I make the point that we need to do more, and we need to do better.
The figures reinforce the case for a strong intervention if Derry City and Strabane District Council is to prosper and not become simply a dormitory town of Belfast, with rural areas being little more than a theme park rather than being working and living communities. The core/periphery argument is that the core sucks in all the resources and other areas are left to move towards the core. We believe that a balanced regional economy will benefit all, as it drives improved productivity and competitiveness right across Northern Ireland.
The Bill can provide the basis of a step change to make that happen, but for it to do so requires a framework that is robust, underpinned by specific, measurable outcomes that apply to all Departments, thus aligning more closely with Northern Ireland Departments' statutory duty in relation to community planning. Proper implementation is critical, and reform requires a whole-of-system approach with respect to government investment in infrastructure, such as the A5; increasing the frequency of rail and bus transport; upskilling our workforce; and expansion of our university, which, we know, is under pressure. With the city deal and all the interventions that we are doing and the success that we are having, the university is a key component to build on that. However, as we know, there are issues around that at the minute.
We also believe that, for the Bill to be effective, we need to ensure that accurate data is available for the evidence base so that we know what we are looking at. Unlike with the multiple deprivation measures that are 10 years old, we need timeliness. Data should be published routinely, and there should be accountability around who should be doing what and who decides on that. There should be transparency around how it is working and an objective, ongoing evaluation of the regional balance approach. That evaluation could be external in the way that the Audit Office comes in and looks at things.
Thank you for your time.
Ms Anna Doherty (Londonderry Chamber of Commerce): Chair and members, thank you for inviting Londonderry Chamber of Commerce to give evidence to you today. We represent around 400 members, and we are based in Northern Ireland's second city. Through our agreements with the Causeway chamber and the Letterkenny chamber, we work across the wider north-west region. Together, our three chambers represent businesses that employ around 40,000 people.
We support the Bill's objectives. A stronger north-west would contribute more to the Northern Ireland economy. Regional balance also means recognising disadvantage where it exists, and that was highlighted by Michael. It should matter to residents on the Strand Road in Derry as much as to those on the Shore Road in north Belfast. For us, regional balance is not a net zero-sum gain. It is about giving everyone an opportunity to grow economically.
There is work under way that deserves recognition. We welcome the subregional economic plan, the local economic partnerships (LEPs) and Invest NI's regional approach. We also welcome the announcement that Invest NI has secured Ebrington Plaza for its new north-west office, thereby continuing its presence in the city and providing a base for businesses and potential investors.
One of Invest Northern Ireland's targets is for 65% of its investments, by number, to be outside the Belfast metropolitan area by 2026-27. In 2025-26, it reported 59%, against an interim target of 62·5%. That measure includes projects with potential benefits across Northern Ireland. Although it exceeded its separate investment-value target, the shortfall in number reinforces the need to track progress in every region, including the value of investments and jobs supported. The framework could ensure that agencies such as Invest NI direct support towards areas of greatest need and economic opportunity.
The city deal, the Magee expansion and work of the north-west strategic growth partnership demonstrate the investment and cooperation that is already under way in our region. The Bill should build on that work by ensuring that Departments coordinate their decisions around agreed regional priorities. Reports show that economic inactivity among people aged 16 to 64 was 31·9% in the Derry City and Strabane District Council area in 2025, compared with 24·1% across Northern Ireland. It must be understood, however, that inactivity figures include students, carers and people who are experiencing ill health.
Public investment should help provide the skills, infrastructure and premises that businesses need in order to grow. The framework should recognise where those conditions are missing and where investment could open up opportunities. The expansion of Magee is a Programme for Government (PFG) priority. Progress to date shows what targeted intervention can achieve. The Minister for the Economy has reported that, in 2026, student numbers are now at 6,750. That is an increase of 27% since the Magee task force was established in 2024. We welcome that progress and support expansion to at least 10,000 students. Further growth beyond that will ultimately be pursued. That growth will help develop the economy further and bring more skills into our region, create opportunities to work with researchers and increase demand for local services. Maintaining that momentum requires confidence in the university's capacity to expand. The task force has identified financial pressure on the university and warns that insufficient government support could slow delivery. Recent financial concerns underline the need for sustainable funding. Students, employers and investors need confidence that the commitment to expansion will be followed through on.
Growth also depends on accommodation, waste water capacity, transport and timely planning decisions. Those responsibilities extend beyond the Department for the Economy's remit. The Bill reinforces the need for Departments to work together so that decisions elsewhere in government support the investment that is being made in the university and the wider region. Before making major policy and investment decisions, Departments should assess and explain their likely regional effects so that the findings can influence the decisions. Where delivery depends on another Department, the responsibility for addressing that dependency should be agreed at the outset.
We also need to measure progress carefully. Assembly Research and Information Service (RaISe) research shows that Belfast has the highest GDP per head, yet its disposable household income per head is below the Northern Ireland average. One measure cannot therefore tell us everything about any area's economy or its residents' living standards. Employment rates, economic inactivity, incomes, productivity and innovation should be considered together, alongside infrastructure, education and housing. We also need to look within council areas, where averages can conceal considerable differences between communities. Reporting should show whether public investment attracts private investment and whether the benefits reach residents.
For border regions, the assessment must reflect how the economy works. The joint Central Statistics Office (CSO) and NISRA census publication, drawing on the 2021 and 2022 censuses, records 3,066 people commuting from Ireland to work in Derry and Strabane. Employers draw on a workforce that crosses the border. We welcome the Bill's recognition of cross-border data and want that evidence to inform decisions on skills, transport and investment.
Local economic partnerships could help shape local economic priorities. They bring together businesses, councils, education providers and other regional stakeholders that understand the area. Their knowledge should help identify barriers, shape interventions and assess results. Annual reporting could explain what has been achieved, what is delayed and who is responsible for resolving the remaining problems. Where an approach is falling short, it should be possible to adjust it before the next five-year review. Existing partnerships and reporting arrangements should be used wherever possible in order to avoid unnecessary duplication.
University expansion and infrastructure investment take longer than one Assembly mandate. Businesses need confidence that agreed priorities will survive changes in Ministers and budgets. That is why we support having a lasting statutory commitment. We ask the Committee to ensure that regional effects are assessed before major decisions are taken, that Departments coordinate delivery and that reporting leads to corrective action wherever needed.
For our members, success would mean better access to skills and infrastructure, greater confidence to invest and more opportunities to build a business and a career in the north-west. A successful north-west is good for everyone, north, south, east and west. Thank you very much for your time.
The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Thank you very much. Two themes have come across from you today that we have heard from a number of witnesses. One is the need for a cross-cutting, whole-of-government approach to regional balance, while the second is about having no objective data and not knowing from where the data will come once the measures are brought in.
There was a lot of detail in your opening remarks. We are a little tight on time for questions, and I have a number of members looking to get in, so I ask everyone to try to be concise.
Mr Nesbitt: Good morning. Thanks for your presentation. I agreed with Clare Guinness from Belfast Chamber of Commerce earlier when she said that talking about employment rates masks the fact that over one in four people of working age are neither in work nor seeking work. We have a 26% rate of economic inactivity in Northern Ireland. You mentioned 31%. Are there pockets where economic activity is much worse?
Mr Gallagher: Yes, there are. As ever in economics, there are differences in definition, so it depends what is being looked at and whether students and retirees are included. The same figure can mean a number of things. For example, areas such as the Causeway coast and north Down have a lot of early retirees, which pushes up the inactivity rate. The same rate can therefore mean something slightly different. You are right, however. A key issue is health. Of those who are economically inactive, 60% report that the reason for that is their health. When we have a health service that is under pressure — I was going to say "a failing health service" — that will spill over into the labour force. That is what we are finding.
Mr Nesbitt: Poor mental health and poor physical health are the number-one factors when it comes to economic inactivity.
Mr Nesbitt: A lack of accessible and affordable childcare is also a major factor. It does require a whole-of-government approach, which, in my experience, is the highest tariff. What would you like to see happen to try to address those shocking rates of economic inactivity?
Mr Gallagher: We have to go back to key intervention points. Anybody who knows me knows that I am talking about putting money into early years. That has been done in the past. Doing it is effective. It is one of those things that people do not like taking preventative measures, because they cost money there and then. They therefore believe that it is better to put off taking them. In somewhere such as Derry, however, the underlying reasons for where we are at go back many decades. There are all sorts of reasons for that. If we are to break that cycle, there needs to be early intervention, which also takes into account affordable childcare. Individuals, particularly women, need to be given confidence, as well as schemes that assist them. There have been a number of such schemes. A few years ago, there was a community work programme in Derry city. The evaluations of that were very positive. Schemes that work are very costly, however, so there is a key decision for people to make: do they want to pay for a scheme now or in the future, taking into consideration all the lifetime costs, be they healthcare costs, criminal justice system costs or welfare costs?
Mr Nesbitt: In the Department of Health, and, indeed, across government, we are running along a track that we can no longer afford to maintain, so from where do we find the money to build the new track? How can we transition in affordable, manageable steps?
Mr Gallagher: An awful lot of money is being spent. It could be spent better.
Mr Delargy: I will declare an interest, Chair, because I know all the panel members.
It is great to see you all at the Committee. You are such strong voices for the north-west.
I will touch on two points. First, Anna, you made a point that is key to driving forward regional balance for the north-west, and it was that we do not just operate in silos but very much as a city region and look at the north-west as a whole. One of the Bill's features of the Bill is all-Ireland working. We are very keen to work out how to enhance that and discover how it works best. I am therefore keen to hear, from a chamber perspective and a council perspective, how we can do that and how we make sure that the data is in law and that we have metrics that we can measure.
Ms Doherty: You make a good point, Pádraig. As you know, we operate in the north-west very much as a functioning cross-border economic region. Many of us, including me, travel across the border both ways every day for work, so we have to make it work. We have been doing that for years in the north-west. We have the north-west strategic growth partnership, which was formed in 2016 and has recently been refreshed. It has additional partnership arrangements, including with us, the Letterkenny Chamber of Commerce, the Health Service Executive (HSE) in the Republic of Ireland and Health and Social Care (HSC) here through the Western Health and Social Care Trust. We therefore already have in place very strong partnership working, and ours is an exemplar of the kind of cross-border data that could be gathered and pulled together in a timely manner.
Mr Andrew Fleming (Londonderry Chamber of Commerce): One thing that is clear from my experience of having businesses on both sides of the border is that, over the decades, because of the border, it has been difficult to grow them. Part of the reason for that is because of how our economic development agencies work back to back. From a business perspective, in order for us to develop and grow, we would love it to be easier to work with the economic development agencies. It is complex to work through the Invest NI processes, and it is complex to work through the Enterprise Ireland and Industrial Development Agency (IDA) processes. Trying to find a way in which to navigate both in a border region is overly complex, overly bureaucratic and difficult for businesses to use to help them scale.
Mr Delargy: Thank you for that. In my opening comments, I neglected to commend you all for your work and for your dedication to the north-west. Those are really important points that you make.
My second point is about the deprivation indices, which you mentioned, Michael. You will all know as well as I do that that deprivation is often masked in Derry by quite a high rate of educational achievement. My background is as a primary-school teacher, and I know that, particularly in the Moor district electoral area (DEA), which is one of the most deprived DEAs in the whole of the North, such figures are skewed by the fact that there is extremely high educational attainment. That is a testament to our school system and the work of parents and the community. In the Bill, great work has been done on deprivation, but it is about how we measure against all the indices. As you said, Michael, in response to Mike, sometimes the data can be skewed or masked. I am therefore really keen to understand how we can make sure that, as far as we can, we are not missing anything. We need to look at all the indices cross-departmentally basis to ensure that areas are not left out because they score higher on one index than they do on another.
Mr Gallagher: I will respond to that. NISRA's view is that, if you are using multiple deprivation measures, you should look at the domain that is most appropriate: pick out health, education or employment. What tends to happen is that, as you say, people take a broad-brush approach and just give the multiple deprivation measure, which could, for a peculiar reason, be high or low. The new systems that NISRA has put in place on the web in the past two years are fantastic, in that they enable people to generate their own maps and datasets.
That represents a vast improvement on a few years ago. NISRA is going to expand its systems, and we are looking forward to that.
Mr Delargy: That is really useful. Sinéad mentioned it previously, but the review mechanism is really important for me. You talked about looking at and responding to data. The availability of data will change, as will its usage across government, North and South.
Thank you for your responses and for your presentations, which, as the Deputy Chair said, were really comprehensive. It is great to have you at the Committee today.
Ms McLaughlin: Thank you, everybody. You have been working individually and collectively for years to crack regional disparities. The Bill will introduce a statutory obligation. The representatives from the Belfast Chamber of Commerce who gave evidence earlier were inclined to think that a statutory obligation is unnecessary and said that things are going relatively well as they are and could be expanded. How important is it for there to be a statutory obligation covering all Departments in order to end the regional disparities that we have talked about? I will ask Michael for his perspective on that, because he is the figures guy.
Mr Gallagher: The data is there: it just needs to be exploited. As you have heard, we have great belief in the NISRA data. The small-area data that it is now producing is very detailed and effective in dealing with some of the issues that Pádraig raised. That is coming to the fore now, as with everything, owing to AI. I do not think that there will be an issue with data. The question then becomes about the metrics that are going to be used for it. In the past, research has shown that people pick the metrics that they feel they can influence, be they the right ones or not, because they know that they are going to be held accountable. It is therefore a double-edged sword. People have changed their behaviour, not to deliver the outcome that you want but to deliver the outcome that will arise from the measurement technique used.
In some countries, it is a requirement that, say, 50% of people should be seen by the emergency services within an hour, or whatever it might be. Triage was brought in for when someone came in through the door, and the clock then stopped. You therefore need to be careful. There needs to be ongoing review: look at what is happening on the ground so that the measurements are able to be adjusted. I would not get caught up all the time in the accuracy to decimal points of some of that stuff. In the main, we are dealing with human beings, and we do find statistical discrepancies. As I said, however, based on an overall trend in the Derry City and Strabane District Council area, the outcome will be that, if we do not change things, we will lose 13% of our population. That in itself —.
Ms McLaughlin: That is a really interesting fact about population decline, of which I am very well aware. Do you feel that population growth and decline should be one of the measurements in clause 7 of the Bill? It is a quite significant issue. On the Executive Office Committee, we are progressing the Age Discrimination (Goods, Facilities and Services) Bill. My colleague Claire Sugden talks about that frequently as it pertains to the Causeway Coast and Glens area. We should be looking at age-related data in Northern Ireland, because population decline will have a real impact on our economy into the future. We should include the age factor when we look to make good policy. Population decline is really significant for the economy.
Mr Gallagher: It happens for different reasons in different places. The core-periphery argument is that resources, including people, are pulled to the core. That is what happens to rurality. We have seen that in places such as France and Germany, which are struggling with their population. We need to stop that population decline, so it is about how we might do that. That is a wide-ranging challenge. It even comes down to something as simple as changing planning regulations for rural areas. If you are not assisting people to build houses in rural areas, you will lose your population and everything that goes with that.
For us in the city, net outward migration is the key issue. We are a victim of our own success. The schools are very good, and people are doing very well, but they are leaving. We do not have enough high-level jobs for them to come back to. It is a bizarre situation in which the better someone's level of qualification, the less likely it is that they are to get a job in somewhere such as Derry, because there are so few at that end. Seagate and others —.
Mr Gallagher: They are very well paid jobs, but the technological knowledge needed is critical. We do not have enough of them. We need more jobs but also better jobs. The gross disposal household income figure is a reflection of the quality of the jobs that we are getting at the minute. That needs to change.
Ms McLaughlin: That obviously has a knock-on effect on the high street, the town centre and everything else.
Mr Gallagher: Everywhere. Exactly.
Ms McLaughlin: This is about growing other places, not about taking away from anywhere else. The Bill will allow for opportunity in other places. Anna and Andrew, it is critical that there be a whole-of-government approach, because infrastructure and connectivity are fundamental for communities, housing, having access to sewerage and everything else. All those areas are fed by arm's-length bodies from all Departments. How important is it that arm's-length bodies have a regional balance remit built into the Bill, and should it be more explicit?
Ms Doherty: It is important that they do have such a remit. We have been campaigning for a long time for an intervention for Derry, particularly as it is the second city. It is a city of scale, with a population of 100,000. That number may be shrinking, but we hope that we can turn it around. In the north-west city region, however, there is a larger population of 300,000 to 400,000. We have the infrastructure assets of a port, an airport and a university, as well as a university just across the border. We made those arguments to the Place 10X consultation in 2023 and to the Invest NI consultation in 2024.
We have seen that most recently in the intervention of establishing the task force for the expansion of Magee. That is an excellent example of exactly that, because it is not just about DFE. It is not the only influence. DFE has had to lean on other Departments, and the task force has been relatively effective in being able to pull them together. Having legislative backup would strengthen that, however.
Mr Fleming: To see the Bill through is key. To have the legislation in place for different mandates under different Ministers will be key.
Mr Fleming: Will the task force be successful with the university? Yes, if it is given the time to do its job and compel the different Departments to work together to make things work. That would give us confidence. Take student accommodation, where the private sector is not yet quite confident enough that something is going to happen in Derry that it says should happen. It has that confidence in Belfast, which we have seen in the influx of student accommodation built there. We are not seeing that in Derry. Why not? It is because the private sector does not have the confidence to build in Derry, because it does not yet quite believe that the interventions are going to stick. There needs to be long-term commitment to a place, and that place can be Derry or anywhere else in Northern Ireland that needs it and has the headroom for growth.
Ms McLaughlin: Can I ask one quick question? In your response, you talked the possibility of strengthening the legislative language of "due regard". Do you mean that measures, targets and timescales have to be put against that?
Ms Doherty: There have to be measurable outcomes. You have to be able to put figures against them, and they have to be clear from the outset.
Ms McLaughlin: That is actually in the Bill. It is all about measures and baselines and making sure that we are measuring the right thing, with accountability built into the system thereafter in relation to the reporting and the reviews. I take your point that, if we recognise that something is not working or needs to changed within the five-year period, there should be a mechanism that can be adjustable. I am kind of looking at a way of ensuring that that is included in the clause.
Ms Doherty: That goes back to also having the right data at the right time and having transparency.
Mr Honeyford: Thank you all for coming in. It is fascinating to listen to what has been said about productivity. That was one of the lines that I was going to go down, but you have tackled the reasons for differences between areas, including numbers of retirees and students. This is all about people. Our focus should be on creating better conditions for people on the ground. I am worried that we are creating another layer without actually delivering for those people. I do not think that we can have regional balance if we look at Northern Ireland on its own — we have to look at the northern half of the island. The issue is more connected; it is not something that we can do ourselves. Is there a need to strengthen the Bill so that it has more cross-border working between the Executive and the Programme for Government here and the South so that we deliver for people right across the northern half of the island?
Mr Fleming: Yes. Business needs connections North/South, and we have seen a revolution in how the all-island economy works over the past 10 years since 2016 and the significant event that happened then. That has possibly been to the detriment of east-west connections, which are also massively important to the interconnectivity of the economy. As I mentioned before, some of our development agency and economic development work does not work as efficiently as it could across the border. That is a shame, but we should always be working towards unleashing those bottlenecks, whatever they may be. There are intrinsic things, whether those are exchange rates or taxation. Since 2016, we have seen a more difficult environment in which to work across the border, as opposed to the previous number of years in which the working environment across the border was easier. That does not sit well with the fact that more trade is happening across the border at the minute. It is quite difficult. We are being successful as an all-island economy despite ourselves. It shows that there is almost a handbrake to growth. Where could it be? Where is the opportunity cost at the moment with that trade?
Mr Honeyford: That is exactly the point that I am getting at. East-west trade is also growing, which is really positive. I am not saying that you take that and move it. I am not interested in the politics of it. That is why I started by saying that it is about people and how we make lives better for people and how we make opportunities for people wherever they live. In any other part of Europe, it is just normal that you get on and remove those bottlenecks. I am worried that that is not in the Bill and that we need a mandate so that, where there is a bottleneck, it is addressed on two sides. There is not only one part to this; there are two parts to it to make life better. You have kind of answered that.
The next bit for me is that you fascinated me when you said that the skills are there but that people have to leave. In every other area, the lack of skills are the barrier to getting inward investment and growth. It is a chicken-and-egg scenario.
Mr Gallagher: You need a critical mass of industry to attract people.
Mr Honeyford: You talked about the assets of Derry, such as the port, the airport and others. It is a fabulous place. My niece is at uni there. I love being in the city. If the assets are there and the skills are there, what are the barriers? I am just intrigued.
Mr Gallagher: The strategic growth plan has a lot of the evidence in it. The university is a key component and building block in all of that.
Mr Honeyford: What is the barrier to those high-end jobs coming, if you have the skills?
Mr Gallagher: It is historical. When deindustrialisation happened, we were still involved in the clothing and textile industry. We hung on to that in the north-west for far too long. We then suffered because, when the new industries came in, they went elsewhere. Once we got our act together, Seagate and others came in. DuPont has been there since 1950 and has invested, I think, $1 billion. Seagate has invested well over $1 billion at this stage. Vertiv, formerly Emerson Network Power, was set up by a local guy. It is worth a couple of billion dollars and is doing fantastically well. It is bringing people back.
The other issue — it is an issue throughout this island — is housing. If you went on to PropertyPal or one of those sites at the minute and looked at the actual physical number of houses available, you would see that there are not that many, even if you have the money. Water, sewerage, electricity and all the things that hold areas back are what are holding the city back. We are doing well: we have halved the claimant count in 10 years, which is a fantastic achievement.
Mr Honeyford: That is something to celebrate. It is noticeable. I am not in Derry that often, but the difference is noticeable. Alongside the issues that need to be addressed, we need to celebrate what is good.
Mr Gallagher: I cannot overemphasise the current impact of the university. Part of it is right beside our building. We see daily the people coming and going. That is bringing a whole new life to the city. We need to expand it.
Mr Fleming: To summarise, it is about releasing that handbrake and removing that glass ceiling, which is very low in the north-west. It is also about confidence, it is people, and it is perceptions. It is about people saying around the dinner table, "This place is really happening. Come home from Australia, come home from Canada, come home from London. This is the place to be". However, we need the jobs, the infrastructure and all the things that Michael talked about. It is about government allowing us to fulfil our potential. That is what we are asking of all you good people.
Mr Martin: Thanks very much for your presentation, folks. The infrastructural problems that you are highlighting are not unique to Derry/Londonderry. The problems that you have — I think that Andrew referenced them — with attracting the private sector are concurrent across all of Northern Ireland, because we have no water infrastructure capacity left, and the Infrastructure Minister has come up with no operative plan to address that. That is not something that is particular to the north-west, nor do I think that it will be dealt with by the Regional Balance Bill. It is a unique thing that will probably have to be dealt with by the Executive.
You also mentioned good jobs. I am aware that there is a GreenScale data centre going into the region. Is that something that you guys would welcome? Are those the sorts of jobs that you want? Everyone is looking blankly at me. Did I get that wrong? Is that not happening?
Mr Fleming: The data centre could form a piece of —. Some of the companies and clusters that we have talked about — Vertiv, Seagate — are all part of the supply chain for the new world that we are all working in. It is clearly an opportunity for the north-west, Northern Ireland and the island. It is a generational growth opportunity. The data centre forms a little part of that, but it is not the reason why economic growth will happen. The jobs that are created around the enabling technology have seismic potential.
Mr Martin: That is the sort of thing that you are talking about. I guess that you want more of those types of jobs. The evidence that you have given us is that there are not lots of jobs and the ones that do exist are not particularly well paid, whereas the GreenScale data centre is an example of a development that will provide reasonably well-paid fintech jobs.
Mr Gallagher: We want to see a spillover from the university. That has happened in other areas, with companies being setting up locally by its students. They are much more likely to stay, obviously.
Mr Martin: That is fine. I have one last question, Chair. You will appreciate my terseness today. This is directly for Michael. Early on, Michael, Mike asked you about financing, regional disparity and where you put the money. That is important, and we dealt with it in the previous session. The Executive have finite quantums of money for support, and we are currently a bit overspent. Let us park that for a second. You mentioned inefficiencies in your answer to Mike. Do you want to suggest where those are?
Mr Gallagher: The number of economically inactive people tells you where the inefficiencies are. They are labour market inefficiencies; people are not in the labour market, and they should be. People are far distant when they are economically inactive — they are not even on the claimant count. We need to look at the characteristics of those individuals and support them into employment. One of the ways is the community and voluntary sector, charities and things like that. We have had schemes such as that in the city that have worked relatively well, but you need employers who are adaptable and flexible, as well as employees who are adaptable and flexible, if you want those things to work. They can. We have people working in Seagate now who came in on schemes. The progress that they made was phenomenal. So it can be done, but it takes an awful lot of support.
The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Thank you all very much for coming. We talked about infrastructure, and you have had a journey down the road, so we really appreciate your coming in. I represent the south-east, so I did not have to come just as far as you guys. We really appreciate it. It has been really insightful. Thank you also for your written evidence, as I said, which really informed a lot of this for us. You mentioned a couple of things, I think, that you would forward to us. Alfie said something, so we will touch base with you again. Thank you very much for taking the time to help the Committee.