Official Report: Minutes of Evidence

Committee for the Economy, meeting on Wednesday, 11 November 2026


Members present for all or part of the proceedings:

Ms Diane Forsythe (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr Pádraig Delargy
Mr David Honeyford
Ms Sinéad McLaughlin
Mr Peter Martin
Mr Mike Nesbitt


Witnesses:

Ms Jill Cush, Fermanagh and Omagh District Council
Councillor Stephen McCann, Fermanagh and Omagh District Council
Ms Alison Allen, Northern Ireland Local Government Association
Alderman Hazel Legge, Northern Ireland Local Government Association



Regional Balance Bill: Fermanagh and Omagh District Council; Northern Ireland Local Government Association

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): I welcome Alderman Hazel Legge, president of the Northern Ireland Local Government Association (NILGA); Alison Allen, chief executive of NILGA; Councillor Stephen McCann, vice chair of Fermanagh and Omagh District Council; and Jill Cush, director of corporate services and governance at Fermanagh and Omagh District Council. Apologies if I pronounced anyone's name wrong; I am reading them for the first time. I thank you all and commend you for the high-quality evidence that has been submitted in advance of today's session. We have got a lot of detail on the Bill. We have that evidence if you want to speak to it or around it. We invite you to make some opening remarks, and then members will have questions. I will hand over to you guys.

Alderman Hazel Legge (Northern Ireland Local Government Association): Chair and members, first of all, on behalf of the Northern Ireland Local Government Association, thank you for the opportunity to give evidence today. NILGA represents the collective voice of local government across Northern Ireland, and our starting point is straightforward. NILGA strongly supports the objective of achieving better regional balance across Northern Ireland. Our evidence focuses on what is needed in practice to translate that objective into better outcomes for our places and communities. For us, the important issue is not simply how regional balance is expressed in legislation or strategy, but whether it influences the decisions that shape places, investment, infrastructure, public services and economic opportunity. If any statutory framework is pursued, the test should be whether it strengthens that connection and helps turn ambition into meaningful change on the ground.

Our first point is that regional balance has to be a whole-of-government objective. It cannot be delivered through economic policy alone. The prospects of a place are affected by transport and roads, waste water and other infrastructure, housing, skills, digital connectivity, access to public services, rural policy and wider public investment. Whatever mechanisms are ultimately taken forward, they need to connect regional balance to the Programme for Government, Executive budgets and investment decisions across government. Our second point is that regional balance is necessarily a long-term objective. Some disparities can and should be narrowed through better policy, infrastructure and investment, but some structural disadvantages will take many years to address, and some may never be entirely removed. Therefore, the objective cannot simply be equality of input. For us, the ultimate focus has to be on outcomes for people.

People and communities start from different places and circumstances. Achieving greater equity in those outcomes may require different levels and forms of intervention, investment or support. That does not mean trying to make every place the same, nor should regional balance become a zero-sum competition between different parts of Northern Ireland. Different places have different strengths, economic roles and opportunities. Pursuing greater equity in outcomes for people is not mutually exclusive with playing to those strengths. Investment in one place can generate benefits beyond its boundaries, while other places may require more targeted intervention to address particular structural disadvantages. The important thing is that those decisions are evidence-based and considered within a coherent regional picture. That matters now, not simply in the long term. Communities experiencing structural disadvantage cannot just be expected to live with its consequences while we wait for regional disparities to narrow. Alongside the long-term objective of better regional balance, there needs to be a coherent approach across government to equalisation, using policy, investment and, where necessary, financial support to mitigate the effects of structural disadvantage in the meantime.

The rates support grant is one practical local government example. Its purpose is explicitly equalising: to help address differences in councils' ability to raise sufficient finance to provide public service on a fair and equitable basis. That is also the position set out in NILGA's written evidence. However, it illustrates a wider tension. The grant has been significantly reduced from just over £20 million in 2008-09 to £4·9 million in 2023-24. That raises a broader question for government. Are individual funding decisions collectively reinforcing the strategic outcomes that we want to achieve?

There is a similar issue with evidence. Different parts of government can understand and measure disadvantage differently, using different indicators and thresholds to determine need and inform investment. There may be good reasons for Departments to use measures appropriate to their particular responsibilities; we are not suggesting that they all use exactly the same measure. However, there needs to be a more coherent understanding across government of regional and structural disadvantage, including differences between places and inequalities within them, and an understanding of their cumulative effect. Headline economic performance at regional or council level will not always tell us about the outcomes that are being experienced by people and communities in that place. Otherwise, decisions taken separately by different parts of government may not add up to a coherent approach to regional balance.

Finally, local government needs to be part of shaping that approach from the outset. Councils are democratically accountable place leaders. They understand their communities and already bring together public bodies, businesses and communities through community planning and other place-based partnerships. I am pleased that we are appearing alongside colleagues from Fermanagh and Omagh District Council, and I understand that the Committee also heard from our council colleagues earlier in today's evidence session. They can bring the direct experience of their places and what issues such as rurality, peripherality, cross-border geography and infrastructure constraints mean in practice. NILGA's role is complementary: to bring the collective strategic perspective of local government across Northern Ireland and consider what is needed across government to support all of our different places.

I will hand over now to NILGA's chief executive, Alison Allen, to focus on some of the practical tests for delivery.

Ms Alison Allen (Northern Ireland Local Government Association): Thank you, Hazel, and thank you to the Committee for giving us the opportunity to contribute. We have given this some consideration, given the importance of the conversation to how regional balance is delivered in practice. We will suggest some practical tests for your consideration in your onward scrutiny.

First, does it change decisions? Does evidence on regional disparity influence infrastructure priorities, budgets and investments? Does it influence the design of public services and decisions taken by Departments and their arm's-length bodies? We say that because, if we simply describe disparities after decisions have been made, we have not changed the outcomes that we feel are important. As the president has said, that has both a long-term effect and an immediate dimension, so the practical test for us is whether the evidence informs investment intervention and equalisation decisions on a whole-of-government approach.

Secondly, can government see the whole place? As we are a local government body, you would expect us to say that. The president has highlighted the differences in how Departments can assess need and disadvantage. We can give practical examples of those. The practical answer is not necessarily one universal measure. What is needed is a shared strategic evidence base across government, sitting across departmental approaches, so that, collectively, government understands how that disadvantage is expressed locally and, more importantly, the cumulative effect on a Department-by-Department basis. A community does not experience transport, employment, infrastructure, skills or access to services as separate departmental issues. It experiences their combined effect, and, ultimately, that evidence needs to tell us something about outcomes for people, not simply the relative performance of administrative areas.

Thirdly, does the concept work genuinely through place and measure what changes? Councils already bring public bodies, communities and businesses together through community planning and the wider convening role, so the starting question has to be not whether we need more structure but how we use the existing structures more effectively. The existing structures cover administrative and democratic leadership at regional and local level. That ensures that local intelligence is brought into the conversation at the appropriate point and allowed to shape how different policies interact in a particular place. Central government, of course, holds many of the powers, resources, major investments and levers required to respond, but councils and communities feel the impact of those decisions and are often required to deliver on them. Ultimately, regional balance requires both parts of government to work together, and we are very committed to that concept. We need to measure outcomes, not simply activity. You will have heard our president talk about the fact that this should not be considered in the context of inputs. We should be asking: are communities better connected; can people access better jobs, education and essential services; are infrastructure constraints being addressed; is investment responding to need and opportunity; and, over time, are disparities actually narrowing?

NILGA's central message to the Committee is that there is an opportunity to strengthen how regional balance is understood and reflected in decision-making across government. The Bill clearly has a role in reflecting that. If a statutory framework is pursued, it needs to connect ambition with investment, recognise the democratic and place-shaping role of local government and, ultimately, create wider coherence not just across central government but between central government and local government. That creates the accountability loop to the people whom we all serve. Many of the things that will ultimately determine regional balance sit beyond any single piece of legislation. That cross-cutting nature is probably one of the biggest challenges for you to consider. That is why we, as an organisation, see regional balance as being fundamentally a long-term, whole-of-government, whole-of-place challenge, although it is important to recognise that there is structural disadvantage that needs to be addressed now. The evidence that you will hear from Fermanagh and Omagh District Council and that you will have heard from colleagues from Belfast Chamber of Commerce and Derry City and Strabane District Council helps put that strategic context into the experience of real places and communities. Those places have different strengths, economic roles, opportunities and challenges, and that diversity is especially important in understanding that regional balance has to be about improving people's lives. Whilst recognising different forms of disadvantage and the contribution that different places make to Northern Ireland as a whole, it is important to understand that places should not be in competition with one another in the context of the Bill. It is not about one area losing out to another area with the goal of achieving regional balance. We have to play to all our councils' natural strengths and advantages. That is very important.

I will pass to colleagues from Fermanagh and Omagh District Council, who will bring some of that to life with their local experience.

Councillor Stephen McCann (Fermanagh and Omagh District Council): Thank you, Alison. Thank you, Deputy Chair and Committee members. On behalf of Fermanagh and Omagh District Council, I thank the Committee for having the council here today to provide evidence on the Regional Balance Bill. Fermanagh and Omagh District Council broadly supports the Bill, and we welcome its ambition to tackle long-standing regional disparities across the North. The Bill provides an important opportunity for a more systemic approach to address the very significant disparities that exist and that we see on a daily basis across our district. However, the Bill's effectiveness will depend on specific provisions of the regional balance framework. Those must reflect the needs of all council areas, including the distinct challenges facing our rural communities. Progress will require adequate funding, genuine partnership working and sustained delivery over the long term. Without those commitments, the Bill risks adding just another layer of reporting rather than delivering meaningful change. The council's key concern is that the Bill could primarily become a reporting exercise, unless it is strengthened through stronger statutory duties across all Departments; clear accountability mechanisms and binding targets; dedicated and transparent funding arrangements; greater recognition of rural and border challenges; and robust monitoring of investment and outcomes at a local level. Historically, we know that rural areas with a history of underinvestment, such as Fermanagh and Omagh, require targeted intervention rather than equal treatment to achieve genuine regional balance.

For context, Fermanagh and Omagh District Council is the largest council area by land mass, but it has the smallest population, with around 117,700 residents. It is the most rural district, with approximately 70% of its people living outside the main towns of Omagh and Enniskillen. It has no motorway, rail network or airport — there is City of Derry Airport and Belfast International Airport, but there is no connectivity to either — and there is less than 1 kilometre of dual carriageway across the entire district. The district has a substantial and very real infrastructure deficit.

Having a road network that is simply not fit for purpose results in longer, more complex and, when it comes to the A5, more dangerous journeys.

The district's rural characteristics create challenges beyond transport. Having a dispersed population increases the cost of public services, limits economies of scale and restricts business growth, investment and workforce mobility. Despite its strengths, moreover, the district experiences lower productivity and wages and comparatively low public investment. Between 2020 and 2025, it received £13 million in Invest NI support, which is about 3% of the region's total assistance, despite the fact that 11% of its businesses are in the district.

I will hand over to my colleague Jill Cush, who will pick up on some of the key issues that we identified in our consultation response.

Ms Jill Cush (Fermanagh and Omagh District Council): Deputy Chair and members, thank you for inviting us here. It is good to meet you all. As Councillor McCann said, we welcome the Bill. We will present additions that we believe would strengthen the Bill's effectiveness. I will cover three areas.

The first key issue is that the Bill must move beyond "due regard". In effect, it must have teeth. While the council welcomes the imposition of a statutory duty, a requirement to simply have due regard may not drive meaningful change. Our experience with the Rural Needs Act (Northern Ireland) 2016 illustrates the gap between process and outcomes. While the Act established important processes for considering how policy decisions affect rural communities, its application has not always translated into meaningful policy change and can, at times, be perceived as procedural rather than impactful. The Bill must therefore move from consideration to action. We suggest including a requirement for Departments to report tangible evidence on how their policies, spending and programmes will reduce regional disparities.

The council also supports stronger provisions and clear mechanisms to measure, monitor and challenge progress. In our submission to the Committee, we outlined our recommendation that a regional impact assessment akin to regulatory impact assessments and equality impact assessments be introduced to require public bodies to assess how major policies, programmes and investments affect regional balance.

The second action that we would like the Committee to consider is a call for funding to support the ambition of the Regional Balance Bill, with a linked requirement for binding targets. Simply put, the council is concerned that the proposed framework is not clearly linked to public expenditure. Reporting alone will not address regional imbalance, and sustained investment is required in infrastructure, economic development, public services and regeneration, particularly in historically underinvested-in areas.

The Bill should include clear funding commitments that align with departmental planning. Furthermore, the Department and arm's-length bodies (ALBs) must be accountable for delivery and be required to publish their expenditure by local government district. Investment falling below need or persistent underinvestment should trigger improvement plans informed and supported by transparent economic, social and demographic evidence.

The council is also concerned that the Bill does not sufficiently recognise the distinct challenges and, indeed, opportunities of rural and border regions. As the most rural council area, with over 200 kilometres — 43% — of the border with the Republic of Ireland, Fermanagh and Omagh can support cross-border collaboration in tourism, agriculture and the green economy. Every part of our district is more than 60 minutes from Belfast, and although progress on the A5 western transport corridor is very welcome and is necessary, critical challenges remain in transport and, in particular, waste water infrastructure and access to services. Regional balance requires support to be directed towards the regions facing the greatest barriers to growth, regeneration and development.

The council welcomes the fact that progress on regional balance will not be measured by a single indicator and states its preference for a basket of indicators. Importantly, the indicators and measures should reflect the lived experience of rural communities by including factors such as accessibility of education and healthcare services, road infrastructure development and journey times, public transport connectivity, digital connectivity and access to essential services. Those are important indicators in assessing rural measures. Members, that is a summary of the three key themes and aspects that we identified. I will hand back to Councillor McCann to sum up on the role of local government and partnership working, which we see as being important to realising the Bill's ambition.

Councillor McCann: Thank you, Jill. In conclusion, we believe that local government has a vital role in the delivery of the Bill. Councils are uniquely placed to understand the particular needs, opportunities and challenges in their communities and should be recognised as key delivery partners in the regional balance framework. Central government action alone will not achieve regional balance. A coordinated partnership across all levels of government must empower local areas to shape solutions for their own circumstances, perhaps through the now well-established community planning structures.

Once again, I thank you, Deputy Chair and members, for facilitating the evidence session and hearing our opening statement. We are content to engage further with you.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Thank you very much for that. I will bring Mike Nesbitt in first, because he might need to leave us soon.

Mr Nesbitt: Thank you all very much for the presentation. I have a comment and a question. The comment is that, sometimes, I feel that the public sector puts an emphasis on inputs and outputs and insufficient focus on outcomes. I particularly welcome what Alison said in that regard and about not needing more structures. When Bengoa looked at healthcare 10 years ago, he very cleverly headlined his report, "Systems, Not Structures". In my view, you are in the right area. His review talked about asymmetric measurement, and I wonder whether you could give me an example of that. Do you think that that impacts on how we determine objective need?

Alderman Legge: If you do not mind, Mike, I will refer you to Alison on that, because the research and report came through the NILGA offices.

Ms Allen: I am a former council officer, so I am used to administering those funds. I will give you some practical examples. For grants that councils receive from central government that have an intent around them to strike some kind of balance, Departments use a range of different measurements. Some use deprivation, some use economic outputs, and some will use population. Some may combine all those things with a base measure. To speak to some of the wider conversation, even from my engagement with economists, it is clear that, even at that level, there is not a shared understanding of what economic and social growth looks like. That leaves us in a very real strategic gap at a regional and local level when it comes to how we understand and address the concept of regional disparity. That goes to the core of our point about the need for a shared understanding of what that looks like across government. Different Departments may choose to place different emphases on how funding is delivered, but not understanding the challenge in a shared way and chasing the same goals that have the same measurements behind them is inherently problematic.

Mr Nesbitt: Do you think that clause 1, which places a duty on the Government to devise a framework, addresses that?

Ms Allen: The duty to devise a framework is adequate, as long as it is a cross-government framework that is owned by the Executive. There is a danger —. Clearly, the delivery of the Bill will be led by departmental action, at both political and individual level. The framework needs to be owned by the Executive, not an individual Minister or Department. That is probably our collective experience, because we see and experience so many Bills on a cross-government level. The risk is that, if the duty is not on the Executive rather than individual Departments, an opportunity could be missed.

Mr Nesbitt: Perfect. Thank you.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Thanks, Mike. A theme that has come through from you and from the earlier sessions today has very much been about, as Hazel said, not making every place the same. That is a key point of your message. I think that Stephen said something similar about having specific things in his local area. You are down there in Fermanagh, and I am from the Newry, Mourne and Down area. They may be similar areas, but their strengths and weaknesses could be different from those of other areas. Targeted interventions are really important. That key message has come through today.

You spoke about the importance of the intersection at every level of government. Local councils, which are very much the grassroots, pick up those things. You may correct me if I am wrong — the Bill sponsor is also here — but is it just the one place in the Bill that refers to consulting district councils before adopting the framework? Should local councils be more involved throughout the process? We are bringing the framework in, and it is important to consult with the district councils about the measures and the issues, but I do not see anything about when we will get annual reports, reviews and feedback from the Department. Should there be more involvement with councils in the reporting or the ongoing consultation partners at points throughout the process? I will go to Sinéad first.

Ms McLaughlin: Clause 1(4) states:

"Before adopting the Framework, the Executive must consult—

(a) Northern Ireland departments;
(b) district councils;
(c) such bodies as the Executive considers representative of business, workers, the community and voluntary sector; and
(d) such other persons as the Executive considers appropriate."

You will remember from our last evidence sessions that the Community Foundation mentioned a co-design process that would be place-based. There is a recognition that the development has to be from both the bottom up and the top down at the beginning of the process. The challenge around the table was about the bottom-up process, and they said, "No. Government and the Executive have to play their role".

Ms Forsythe: Thank you, Sinéad. Does local government have enough of a role in the development at the start? My thinking is that you have a lot of information, and should there be more of a role for the councils as the process goes on?

Councillor McCann: I mentioned that we believe that central government alone cannot make the Bill work. We believe there must be real partnership throughout the process, and there is nobody better placed than the councillors who know their areas like the back of their hand. In Fermanagh and Omagh, we know our real and unique challenges, and we feel strongly that there must be a partnership throughout the process to make a difference in the rural areas that the Bill is trying to have an impact on.

I commend Sinéad on her Bill because regional imbalance is a huge issue. The further west you go in our district, you see that more people are struggling with rural isolation, rural poverty and access to services. That has been a theme throughout your evidence gathering over the last couple of weeks. We have kept an eye on the sessions. For example, there have been issues with the closure of the GP surgery in Roslea, which is at the south end of Fermanagh. If you drive, it is well and good to access a GP practice in Enniskillen, but you are snookered if you do not drive because public transport is basically non-existent outside of the connectivity between the two main towns. I commend you on the Bill. However, we strongly contend that local councils should be a partner working alongside the Department and central government. The point has been well made over the last couple of weeks that there has to be cross-departmental working. If somebody thinks that somebody else is doing something, nobody will do it. Cross-departmental working would also be very important, but local councils will have a role.

Ms Cush: We welcome the involvement of local councils and local government at the start of the process because it is critical that the framework is as strong as it can be. It would be useful to have local council input into the annual reporting. Quite often, the data and statistics that are produced centrally chime with us, but often the data tells us something that we do not see on the ground or in the council chamber, and it does not reflect the real issues. Combining the central government, top-down approach with the local government, bottom-up approach will be very necessary for the Bill because it looks at regional balance, and it will be essential both at the start and through the process. It would be good to find a way to do that practically and sensibly.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): Often, the local government audit report simply compares the different councils to one another in order to serve a narrative. It does not get into the intricacies of regional imbalance, or what the measurements and outcomes are. That report input would definitely be useful. Did you want to come in there, Alison?

Ms Allen: I just wanted to draw some of that together. We would argue that seeing local government simply as a consultee does not fully reflect the position of the sector. There is a legitimate democratic mandate in councils, which is expressed through stand-alone public bodies that can make their own decisions. I would encourage a shift beyond consulting local government in making it part of the spheres of government that have responsibility for ensuring that the overall objectives are delivered. It is just a shift in emphasis. We believe that that is fundamental to the recasting of the central/local government relationship, primarily because for the majority of Departments and specifically the Department for the Economy, economic and social policies are expressed through councils in the majority of circumstances. That goes through the local democratic mandate in terms of how that is applied to local need and local context. NILGA feels a little bit uncomfortable with the idea that local government simply becomes a consultee. We want to be part of the spheres of government that will consider the Bill's objectives.

Ms McLaughlin: Thank you very much for your written and oral evidence, which was excellent. I agree that the success of the Bill depends on the ambition of the strategic framework. It is totally about outcomes, and I tried to reflect that in clause 1. It is not a tick-box exercise; it is about measurements, targets, timelines and delivery. This is, however, a private Member's Bill, which contains an instruction to government to do something with a statutory obligation behind it. It would be a failure of government if it were to become a tick-box exercise.

I totally agree with your view on the need for very strong measurements, targets and money. One of the indices is about capital spend and public finances. We need to know where the Government spend their money, particularly when their money is not flowing as well as it could or should. We need to know where that money is going and what the outcomes are. We need to know what an investment in one place can leverage for that place and the people there. This is an instruction, and the ambition will be what the Government do with that. It is important that the instruction is correct. If that needs to be done in partnership, I will take it on board completely that that may need to be stronger in the terms of reference and in the Bill itself.

The other area that I want to talk about is the phrase "due regard" in the Bill. The fear is that that expression is too weak an instruction in the Bill. "Due regard" may mean, "Well, we thought about that, but we are away on and just doing what we want anyway". What does "due regard" translate into? Does it translate into an action and an output, as you said? Can you talk to me about that? I have spent hours thinking and talking about "due regard". We have papers coming next week in relation to that. That language — the words "regard" and "must" and the phrase "due regard" — is normal in legislation, but those words have implications. "Due regard" has more strength than simply "regard". What other language do you think would have greater impact in the Bill? I am thinking about some of the legislation that we have had to date that contains the phrase "due regard". For example, the Northern Ireland Act 1998 is itself a "due regard" Act; the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 is a "due regard" Act; the Children (Northern Ireland) Order 1995 is "due regard" legislation; and the Environment Act 2021 is a "due regard" Act. I want the Bill to be as strong as possible, and so do other people. Do you have any thoughts on how to do that?

Ms Allen: NILGA is a political organisation, represented by political members. The strength of the provisions would ultimately be a political decision. We can, however, talk about our experience of how "due regard" is felt by councils in other ways. You have heard from colleagues. I will let Jill or Councillor McCann come in on those other aspects, but, for me, community planning is the most obvious example, and it uses the same language. You will know that community planning involves designated statutory partners. Departments are not designated statutory community planning partners, but the legislation includes provision for them to have "due regard", and I think that it is fair to say that all 11 councils feel the challenges presented by the weakness of that statement in Departments' participation in community planning. That legislation has been in place for more than 11 years now. It is weakened hugely by the fact that there are designated bodies that must participate — organisations that must be represented — whereas Departments, which are fundamental to how everything is delivered, only have to have "due regard". That is not felt well in community planning. You provided other examples, Jill, did you not?

Councillor McCann: If I may, I will jump in quickly. Thank you, Alison and Sinéad. My comment follows on from your comment about where the money is being spent, Sinéad. I might come from the view of where it is not being spent. It is also with Departments to have regard to where they spend their finances.

Recently, Fermanagh and Omagh District Council received just 2·25% of all Northern Ireland Water investment in new and upgraded assets, which equates to only £233 per capita, compared with the Northern Ireland average of £633 per capita. What does that mean for us? This is not unique to Fermanagh and Omagh District Council; it is across the board, but I will make the point as it relates to our council. For our council, it means that, in many areas, our waste water capacity is at its maximum, which has huge implications for our ability to build new houses and impacts on our local development plan. What does that mean for communities? It means that people cannot live where they want to live but have to move to other towns and even out of the area. That has a knock-on effect on our schools and local businesses. That shows the importance that we place on the term "due regard". What other language can we use to make the Bill as strong as possible? That is a very good question. It is to include in the Bill the accountability that is required to make a real difference. Mike and Alderman Legge made the point about outcomes. This is all about creating better outcomes for all. That is an example of where "due regard" does not have an impact, Sinéad, and it is only one example.

Ms McLaughlin: You talked about the peripherality of your council and how the Rural Needs Act could interact with the Regional Balance Bill. Do you see opportunities for those two pieces of legislation to work well together?

Ms Cush: Yes, I do. Going back to your point about the term "due regard", the Rural Needs Act, like community planning structures, is an example of where the requirement to have "due regard" is not at all strong enough. While we see rural impact assessments of legislation and programmes, there is no change on the ground and no tangible outcome or evidence that "due regard" has led to impacts and outcomes — it simply is not there. We see that repeatedly in the council chamber. While the intention and the spirit of "due regard" is there, there is not an understanding of what it means in practice. I know that the Committee is looking at that from a legislative point of view, and guidance and structure is needed around that to say what that will look like for the Regional Balance Bill. Looking again through the rural policy and the Rural Needs Act, which is under review, you can see that that is necessary. I see the Rural Needs Act and the Bill being interlinked because of regional balance being needed due to the rural areas of Northern Ireland being remote from the city areas. We need to look at those in the round, however, and much more work needs to be done, because they are not working.

We see that the rural needs impact assessment is quite often a procedural and paper exercise. We propose having more questions in the framework, such as, "OK, you've given due regard to regional balance. What has changed? What does that look like? What data or evidence is there to support the fact that due regard has been given?".

Ms McLaughlin: I looked at the Rural Needs Act and thought about how we could do it so much better, because that legislation did not bring the change that was needed. It does not have measurements; it does not have the baseline to measure against. How were we to know whether we were moving on when we were not benchmarking? There were no corrective measures to change it: evaluation, accountability and reporting were not built into it in a robust manner. It is a good example of how not to structure it. We tried to build something stronger and more robust to deliver for the people and places that have consistently been left behind.

The Committee wrote to all Departments, including DAERA, which we asked specifically about the Rural Needs Act. The Department's response was that its understanding is that the Regional Balance Bill is intended to operate alongside existing statutory duties rather than to duplicate, contradict or replace them. Duplication was one of your concerns. We are getting evidence back from Departments about the various interactions. Every piece of new legislation will, however, have interactions and consequences — otherwise, why bother bringing them? We are trying to create momentum and grow the economy through this targeted Bill. Thank you so much for all the work that you have done on it.

Mr Honeyford: Thank you for coming in. It is good to see Hazel again. Hazel was one of my daughter's favourite councillors when I was on council; she reminds me of that regularly.

You talked about two issues that I am concerned about. One is the risk of adding another layer and not getting delivery for people when, ultimately, this is about people on the ground. My second concern is the North/South piece. I will ask about the first issue first. You referred to being a consultee rather than a partner, and that is the bit that I want to tease out. Has local government got the powers and resources to deliver this on the ground? Ultimately, we want to see change for people in your constituencies.

Ms Allen: I am not sure that the detail of what this would look like on the ground is available yet. There is a fair bit of ground to be covered, and we would ask to be considered as a partner, along with Departments, as that is done. Resources are always a challenge for councils. We have just come from the Committee for Infrastructure, where we were giving evidence on the Tree Protection Bill, and it is not long since we were in on the Dilapidation Bill. I do not want your understanding of that to be that councils do not have ambition.

Mr Honeyford: No, no, that is not what I was suggesting.

Ms Allen: No, absolutely.

Mr Honeyford: What I am really getting at is whether more needs to be given to councils to enable delivery.

Ms Allen: Councils and local government are political organisations, so we are not blind to the financial challenges in Government. This is about reducing duplication and making sure that we all use our existing resources to best effect. There have been examples that are relevant to the Committee of interactions between local economic partnerships and local labour market partnerships. Sometimes, decisions are made by Departments that we feel lead to duplication, whereas, if there had been more engagement with local government, we could have found a more effective and streamlined delivery structure.

The proposal that I would put on the table is that regional balance is ultimately about place. Two councillors at this meeting are leaders of their place, with democratic mandates. I would not want practical challenges about how this is done, or, indeed, concerns about resourcing, to reduce anybody's ambition. We set the resourcing, and resourcing is something that we all have to be aware of. It is not a race to the bottom for councils. There are two councillors here who are ambitious for their areas. Of course, money is important, and that can be a challenge. Do you want to comment on that, as councillors? It is not a race to the bottom.

Councillor McCann: No, that is 100% right. I suppose that we are all about equity and fairness across the board. I understand that it is difficult, but those of us who live in Fermanagh and Omagh sometimes feel as though we are being left behind. It is about getting equity with others. What we can bring to the table is our real-life experiences. My experience in Fermanagh and Omagh may be different from Hazel's experience or the experience of somebody else in another part of the country. We can bring those collective experiences to hopefully bring value to what you are trying to do.

Alderman Legge: I agree totally. We have to realise that we do not have 11 equal councils with equal resources, but we want them to have equity in the work that they do such that, whatever services are provided in Lisburn and Castlereagh, the people of Fermanagh and Omagh can expect the same.

Mr Honeyford: I appreciate that.

The other issue is North/South. I think that all of us here were on local council at some time. The Belfast to Dublin economic corridor, which includes Lisburn and Castlereagh, was launched when I was on Lisburn and Castlereagh City Council. It is councils that have driven a lot of that North/South work: we can look at Derry and Letterkenny, across to Fermanagh, and at Lisburn for that. I am not interested in the constitutional politics of it but in making life better for people. This is the bit that I am worried about: as I said in the previous evidence session, we need to look at North/South and at the top half of the island, but, if we do that, I am not sure that the Bill is strong enough to give the Executive a mandate in order to ensure that councils are not trying to do it on their own. Do we need to go further with that piece to allow you to do the work that every council — every council along the border, anyway — is doing?

Councillor McCann: Yes, 100%. Local councils have been almost leading the way on that over the course of many years. Last year was 30 years since the formulation of the Irish Central Border Area Network (ICBAN), which I am sure you have heard of and with which you may have dealt. I am one of its directors, so I declare an interest. ICBAN has eight member councils. For 30 years, through ICBAN, we have been highlighting the issue of regional disparities to central Government here, to the Dublin Government and to Brussels. A delegation recently came back from Brussels, where it had been to discuss funding following Brexit, including uncertainty around PEACE PLUS and where funding will come from in the future. Of course, the impact of that in the border area in its entirety will be huge, North and South. ICBAN does great work. For many years, local councils have been leading the way on trying to direct and find solutions to regional imbalance.

Mr Honeyford: You are making my point exactly. Councils have been doing it naturally, if you like. That was the point that I was making about Lisburn and Castlereagh: we were part of the Belfast to Dublin economic corridor. I am worried that that will not push on. There is a blockage to allowing more to happen and making it easier for councils. There is a blockage to councils having the resources to actually do it, so that councils would get the resources, whatever the issue is and whatever Department leads on it. That is the bit that is missing. Clause 1 asks for "cross-border economic data", but we are not actually asking for the Executive Minister to engage with the Minister in the South to release the council to do that work.

Ms Cush: That would be helpful. There is no university in our district council, so economic development and research and innovation are driven by large companies in the region. A number of large, successful companies really underpin the economy of Fermanagh and Omagh in terms of employment. Those companies operate very much on a cross-border basis. Providing council support for those types of companies as well as other supports, such as skills support from the Department for the Economy, is challenging in a border region. There are things that we can do, and there are things that we cannot do. We then need to rely on interventions — very positive interventions — such as the Mid South West growth deal. In our region, the priority areas for that investment are infrastructure and business. That really tells the story: we have had to supplement central government intervention in areas where there is imbalance by using that growth deal. In a border area, with those constraints, it is necessary to do more to maximise opportunity. The key point is that it creates opportunity; it is about how that can be unlocked and brought forward.

Mr Honeyford: Thank you all very much.

Mr Delargy: Thank you very much for your time this morning. It was useful to hear your presentation. You have touched on a huge number of points; that is one of the downsides of being the last member to ask a question. I say that a lot at this Committee, but you really have covered a lot. A lot of my questions were on the metrics and the indices. The points that other members raised were key, particularly those that David raised on exactly how it would work in practice.

It will come as no surprise to you that my real interest is in how we work on an all-Ireland basis to drive regional balance. That is particularly pertinent in Fermanagh and Omagh as well as in my council area and others. I am keen to hear a bit more about that.

Early in your presentation, you touched on something important, which is that it is about the resource — it absolutely is — but also the input, knowledge, skills and on-the-ground experience of each council area. I thank Sinéad, again, for introducing the Bill. It is such a strong piece of legislation. When it comes to its review mechanisms, it is about how we make sure that there is co-design and shared knowledge and understanding with the councils at all interfaces and all points during the process.

Will you give me a wee bit more detail on the all-Ireland work, particularly in Fermanagh? I know that it is a bit more complex for you. At our end, in Derry, we work quite naturally with Donegal, but I appreciate that, at your end, you work with Donegal, Leitrim, Cavan and Monaghan, which is a much more complex picture. What forums do you have for doing that? How does that engagement work in practice?

Councillor McCann: Thank you, Pádraig. Given our geographical location, being in the country, we, by our very nature, work daily with colleagues across the border. In the council — Jill can touch on this, too — we have a number of formal working groups and alliances with councils in the South. We have worked with colleagues in Donegal, Cavan and Monaghan on the A5 stuff over a number of years through the A5/N2 working group that we established in-house. There are local groups, such as those in Clones and Ballybay, and, given our nature, we try to work with our colleagues in them to get the most for a particular area and on a particular theme.

I reinforce the point about the work that ICBAN does. It is really good and has filled a gap in identifying need, including even in broadband provision. The rural west struggled for many years — in fact, it still struggles — to get adequate broadband coverage. A lot has been done: for example, ICBAN led a delegation of councils from North and South to Scotland for a piece of fact-finding work on getting fibre to homes. In turn, with work here, that was made possible through Fibrus. That is one example. It has done a lot of work on Brexit, which councils fed into. The implications of Brexit for our part of the world have been massive.

Ms Cush: Pádraig, I will give a few more examples to follow on from what Councillor McCann said. There is a lot of cross-border collaboration in the tourism sector. We have the geopark in our region. We do not even see that as a cross-border project; it just covers that natural area. There are a lot of projects on economic development and skills development — green skills and manufacturing skills. More recently, a new initiative on cross-border emergency planning has been funded through PEACE PLUS, through which we are starting to see greater co-working so that, if an emergency happens, the resources will be there to support people. It will provide efficiency in resources, so it is a win-win all round.

There is a lot of collaboration. There is strategic collaboration through ICBAN, which tends to be on a needs basis. It works very well on the ground.

Ms Allen: That is a perfect example of how communities and economies are expressed. Fermanagh and Omagh are not unique; Derry City and Strabane council and other border counties and councils are the administrative geographies and are therefore the administrative departments. That is how government is structured. If there is an opportunity to reflect the local government experience in the Bill, that would be positive, because every council can give numerous examples of how they are working naturally from an economic, skills, tourism or social perspective. Things do not fit into the nice, neat boxes that government would like them to fit into; that is just real life.

Mr Delargy: Thanks for that. For me, it is about those points that you have raised, but I am also conscious that, in my council area, there is a lot of pepper-potting of funding, whereas things might be more —. I was going to say that things might be more straightforward in the Assembly, but I do not know how accurate that is. I am conscious that there is always an attempt, in councils, to pool resources from different pots and funding streams. That issue is probably more acute in border regions, where you are trying to get that crossover.

You mentioned the really strong local relationships, council to council, agency to agency and so on. One of the provisions in the Bill in which I am really interested, which David has mentioned, is around how we copper-fasten Executive and ministerial support. Obviously, we need there to be a collegiate, Executive-wide approach and agreement on that. If we do not have an onus on each Minister, we could end up in a situation where some Ministers who are committed to regional balance are doing that, and other Ministers who maybe do not share the same view on regional balance or do not prioritise it to the same degree put less emphasis on it. The Bill creates a good framework to put that into law and ensure that cooperation.

I am keen to get an understanding from both your councils on the rates support grant, which was raised during the previous evidence session. The cutting of that grant has had a hugely detrimental impact on my council area; disproportionately so. Will you explore for me the impact of that in your council areas and how you see that going forward?

Ms Cush: I certainly concur with your comments on the reduction to the rates support grant. The essence of the rates support grant was to provide balance and support to councils that are less well off. In principle, that is absolutely the right thing, aligning with regional balance. In practice, however, it has been whittled down over time and continues to reduce. We see the effects of that on the ground in the reductions to and constraining of service and, ultimately, the impact that it has on the ratepayer. I suppose it is a model to look at to see what can be learned. The intention was there, and it was good. In practice, however, it is not delivering what it needed to deliver. Why has that happened, and how do we change that? It is effectively a regional balance tool. It is a levelling-up tool — one of the first that came through. Historically, it has been a very important source of resourcing contribution in the area, and we see the effects of that now. It is a useful model to look to for learning.

Ms Allen: Chair, it may be interesting to understand how the Regional Balance Bill, had its provisions been in place, might have influenced some of the decisions that were made in recent years and led to the reduction.

Ms Cush: Yes.

Ms Allen: The grant is negligible for councils now, and that is significant. That may be a way of looking to the future at how the Bill may prevent similar situations from arising.

On your previous point on the Bill's emphasis potentially being more at place level, the Bill quite rightly recognises that Departments have huge resources and policymaking responsibilities. However, if the Bill's emphasis were on how place is experienced, that would, appropriately, bring in local government as place-based leaders. It would also give the space for places to be understood as they are, beyond their administrative geography. We would be happy to chat about what that might look like. We can bring colleagues to the table on that. It is about a shift in emphasis.

The Deputy Chairperson (Ms Forsythe): That is useful. Pádraig, is that you?

Mr Delargy: I totally agree with that point. Your comments on how to look at it, and on the retrospective look at how it could have informed other policy, has been thought-provoking. That is brilliant. Thank you for your presentations.

Mr Martin: Thank you for your evidence; it has been really interesting. I have a comment to make, and maybe one question. We have had evidence sessions with three sets of witnesses today. Two of those three, including you, have mentioned challenges, regionally, with waste water connections. I know a wee bit about waste water. There is a very good report by Turley on our waste water constraints. I do not know if this will be of any consolation to you, but seven councils are in an even worse position than Fermanagh and Omagh District Council with regard to opportunity costs. In relative terms, you are not in too bad a position, but, equally, 4,500-odd homes cannot be built because of the problems with getting connections to combined sewer overflows. I am cognisant of that: it currently lies with DFI and is something that I have raised with the Minister in previous positions that I have held. It is a real-life issue. Since you mentioned it, I will give you the chance to flag up any particular issues in that regard. I am not sure who mentioned it; I think that it might have been Stephen.

Councillor McCann: I sat on our council's planning committee. As you will know, you have to go out to statutory consultees for a planning response.

Mr Martin: I have been there.

Councillor McCann: You know the craic. In most of our towns and villages, the consultation response from NI Water is, "This should be refused because we cannot deal with the waste water". The impact of that on communities is huge. The more rural the area, the bigger the impact. I am from west Tyrone, where a number of schools have been proposed for closure in the past while. It is about trying to sustain rural communities and keep them alive. We have a rural way of life in our part of the world, and it is about trying to protect that and keep it alive, which is getting harder and harder to do. That is only one aspect of it; there are other challenges.

Ms Cush: We know that waste water infrastructure is a huge challenge across all areas. Its link to regional balance and economic development is critical. Stephen has cited one example of that. Representations come through to members of the chamber, weekly, on the fact that the lack of sustained investment in waste water infrastructure has led to very significant regional economic development challenges. That investment underpins it all. When the Executive are looking at the master Budget and considering regional balance, investment in waste water infrastructure is critical. There is a lot of data around it. There has been 2·25% investment in waste water infrastructure in the Fermanagh and Omagh region. That is 2·25% of the whole budget for Fermanagh and Omagh, and that has been sustained for a long time. It is a critical need. It is not an enabler; I am not sure what the negative of "enabler" is.

Mr Martin: Disenabler?

Ms Cush: It is a disenabler to regional —.

Mr Martin: I made that word up, Jill.

Ms Cush: That is the correct word.

Mr Martin: It is not the first time that I have made up a word in Committee.

You are absolutely right: it is an issue across all our constituencies and councils. Although the issue is possibly going to be kicked up to the Executive, it currently lies with DFI. It will not be solved by a fiscal injection. The Turley report reflects the fact that we have to consider, hard, how to deal with the issue and enable Northern Ireland Water to borrow in order to start to get a handle on this and get some of those homes and, as Stephen said, schools built. The situation is not sustainable: it is stopping not only housebuilding and economic development, which we know that it is doing, but FDI and other foreign investment. I have had lots of conversations about that in relation to cases where firms from outside the UK are looking to go to London, Edinburgh or Dublin to invest because they know that they cannot invest here in Northern Ireland because we cannot actually build anything. That is not something that any of us want.

Thank you for the interesting evidence. I appreciate it.

Ms Forsythe: Thank you all very much. We appreciate your evidence. It has been very informative. Thank you for the comprehensive written submissions and to both the council and NILGA for being so generous with your time and giving that overarching view. Thank you so much.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up