Official Report: Minutes of Evidence

Committee for Justice , meeting on Tuesday, 10 November 2026


Members present for all or part of the proceedings:

Mr Paul Frew (Chairperson)
Ms Emma Sheerin (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr Doug Beattie MC
Mr Maurice Bradley
Ms Connie Egan
Mrs Ciara Ferguson
Ms Aoife Finnegan
Mr Brian Kingston
Mr Patsy McGlone


Witnesses:

Chief Superintendent Gary McDonald, Police Service of Northern Ireland
Assistant Chief Constable Anthony McNally, Police Service of Northern Ireland
Superintendent Marty Reid, Police Service of Northern Ireland



Victims and Witnesses of Crime Bill: Police Service of Northern Ireland

The Chairperson (Mr Frew): Today, the Committee is commencing its oral evidence sessions with stakeholders on the Victims and Witnesses of Crime Bill with evidence from the PSNI. Those providing evidence today are Assistant Chief Constable (ACC) Anthony McNally, Chief Superintendent Gary McDonald and Superintendent Marty Reid. Gentlemen, you are all very welcome to the Committee. Thank you, as always, for your attendance and for sharing your expertise. Without further ado, Anthony, are you kicking off for us?

Assistant Chief Constable Anthony McNally (Police Service of Northern Ireland): Certainly. Thank you, Chair. Good morning, Chair and members, and thanks for the opportunity to provide the Police Service's views on the Victims and Witnesses of Crime Bill. As you said, I am joined today by Gary and Marty. Marty leads on victims' work in the PSNI's justice branch. It is good to have Marty and Gary here.

At the outset, it is important to say that the PSNI very much welcomes the Bill and its central purpose of strengthening the position of victims and witnesses in the criminal justice system. The PSNI firmly believes that victims and witnesses should be treated with dignity, kept properly informed and given confidence that their needs and rights are understood throughout the justice process. Indeed, that is reflected in outcome 1 of our policing plan, which states that the PSNI is victim-focused.

I will keep my comments on the constituent parts of the Bill reasonably brief to allow time for questions. First, the proposed establishment of a commissioner for victims and witnesses of crime for Northern Ireland is an important development for us. Over the past number of years, we have seen the benefits of the work of the current structure through the appointment of the commissioner designate, Geraldine Hanna. We have a very positive working relationship with Ms Hanna and her office, and we see the value of that role. It is important for us to work with the commissioner designate to ensure that we are supporting victims, and we very much hope that that relationship will continue through a formal statutory appointment.

We recognise that our responsibilities are set out clearly under the Victim Charter. This role should also help to identify recurring problems, encourage improvement and provide a stronger voice than those who experience the justice system as a victim or witness sometimes find.

We recognise that we have a significant role to play in the process and that we are often the first point of contact for victims and witnesses. The quality of that first contact and of the support, communication and updates that follow can shape victims and witnesses' journeys through the entire justice system. The Bill therefore provides an opportunity to strengthen that service and to ensure that feedback from victims and witnesses via the commissioner's office will be used constructively to improve our policing response.

I turn to the hate crime provisions in the Bill. We welcome the measures relating to offences aggravated by hostility. Making victims and witnesses in such cases eligible for special measures recognises the particular impact that hate-motivated offending can have on not only an individual victim but their family and the wider community. The protection afforded by clause 25, titled "Protection from cross-examination in cases involving aggravation by hostility", that prevents the accused person from personally cross-examining a complainant is also a positive and proportionate safeguard that we welcome.

For policing, the key point is that allegations involving hostility must be identified early, recorded accurately and investigated thoroughly. That includes gathering evidence of aggravation from the outset and ensuring that the impact on the victim is properly reflected in the case file. In order to meet the requirements of the Bill, we will require clear operational guidance, appropriate training and, through that, effective supervision so that the protections intended to be provided by the Bill work in practice. The PSNI is already working on how best to ensure that those issues are progressed so that it can comply with the Bill should it pass and become an Act.

The provisions affecting serious sexual offence cases are also significant and welcome. As we read it, the Bill recognises complainants and gives them greater opportunity to participate in court applications concerning private material and sexual history evidence. The direct procedural duties in those areas will primarily rest with the court and the Public Prosecution Service (PPS). However, where the PSNI holds relevant material or is providing victim care and support to individuals, police processes may be affected.

We have always recognised the importance of proportionate lines of enquiry in those investigations. The careful handling of private material and clear communication with complainants in such cases is essential. Any changes arising from the Bill will therefore need to be implemented in close partnership with the Public Prosecution Service, the Northern Ireland Courts and Tribunals Service, victim support organisations and others across the justice system.

I turn to transparency and accountability. The Bill will also create new expectations around information, reporting and accountability. As a listed Victim Charter service provider, the PSNI may be required to provide the commissioner with information necessary to monitor compliance with the Victim Charter: I welcome that. We may also be required to provide statistics, to maintain records of complaints that allege a breach of charter obligations and to report annually on those complaints and their outcomes. One of the things that we must do — we have not yet done so — is raise with the Department and highlight to the Committee the role of the Office of the Police Ombudsman for Northern Ireland in the process. The Committee may wish to consider that in the context of the Bill. Again, we are actively progressing work to ensure that we are in a position to comply with any request from the commissioner.

We recognise that, where the commissioner makes a recommendation relating to the PSNI, we will be required to publish comments within 56 days that set out the action taken or explain why we do not intend to take action. We absolutely understand the importance of that transparency and accountability measure. It will be important, however, for the PSNI to have clear internal arrangements to respond consistently, lawfully and within the required timescale, so we ask the Committee to recognise that much of the detail of the operational impact of that, on cost and demand but also on practicalities, and of how it will work is not yet known. We look forward to working with the Department of Justice through its data working group to make those points clear.

Finally, I turn to clause 27, titled "Limitation of power to dismiss charges involving death or serious physical harm of a vulnerable person". We recognise the amendments that the clause makes to the Justice Act (Northern Ireland) 2015, and we support the protections that they provide for children and vulnerable people in particular — all the more so in cases in which the high-end offences of murder and manslaughter are in play.

That concludes my opening remarks. We recognise the benefits that the Bill is designed to deliver, the expectations around data reporting and information sharing and all the aspects of the Bill that relate to the commissioner. We will continue to engage constructively with the Department of Justice, the Justice Committee and our justice partners as the Bill progresses. We are very happy to take any questions that you, Chair, or members may have.

The Chairperson (Mr Frew): Thank you very much for your presentation, Anthony, and for being concise. We really appreciate that when we are struggling for time.

I think that we all support the Bill's principle about bringing in a commissioner's office. You will not get any contested space there. There is then the Victim Charter and what comes out of that, and I think that we all support that concept as well. For me and for the Committee, it is important that we interrogate the nuts and bolts of that and how it will work alongside the tried and tested practices and the operational duties that you guys and others in the justice system have. The PSNI is already heavily scrutinised by the Police Ombudsman. How do you see that scrutiny playing out alongside the Victim Charter and the PSNI being answerable to the commissioner for victims? Will there be overlap or duplication? If so, is there a danger that one investigation could interfere with the other, when information is disclosed to one party and then the other?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: I understand the rationale behind the question. A comparator is domestic homicide reviews. There might be a complaint by, for example, a family member of someone who died as a result of a domestic homicide. A criminal investigation would then be running at the same time as a domestic homicide review, and a complaint may be made to the Police Ombudsman's office. Indeed, I would go further and say that there may be a serious case review if children were involved. Work has been done on how all those things work alongside one another and do not impact on each other. There are tried and tested processes in place as to how it would work.

I see it as being less about whether a complaint was made against an individual and, primarily, about organisational learning. I could see real benefit in the commissioner highlighting thematic issues on how we were dealing with particular victim or witness groups and us working with the commissioner to take them forward. I see comparators to other areas of policing, and I welcome that.

I accept your point, and I will not miss the opportunity to say that, as an organisation, we have highlighted our financial challenges and our numbers of officers and staff. We will continue to take that forward separately, but it would be remiss of me not to say that there is an opportunity here in that regard. As I said, outcome number 1 of our policing plan is to be victim focused. If the commissioner can help us to do that, we would very much welcome that.

The Chairperson (Mr Frew): Thank you. An onus would be placed on all the organisations that are signed up to the charter, including the PSNI, to supply the commission with statistics. There may be a question mark around compliance with article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights on respect for family and private life. Do you see the PSNI's having to hand over information that pertains to victims, witnesses and people who made complaints to the police, and information that pertains to defendants and perpetrators, being an issue for your organisation?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: We already have processes for how we supply information to, for example, Victim Support and our advocacy services on matters such as domestic abuse. However, I understand the broader sentiment regarding the providing of information. You will know — you may well come on to it — that there are safeguards in the Bill where there would be impacts in respect of data protection, the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 and so on. Where there is a requirement to share information — we would look to the Department to lead on this — we would seek to supplement that through data protection, data protection impact assessments (DPIAs), memorandums of understanding and other mechanisms to make sure that we have the appropriate safeguards. Ultimately, we have to comply with the law, and any sharing of information must be necessary, proportionate and within the legislative framework under which that information is being asked for.

The Chairperson (Mr Frew): This is a wider question on the commissioner for victims. If the commissioner were to get information from a victim or witness, and a formal complaint had not been made to the Police Ombudsman, should the commissioner have the right, the power or the remit to go to the Police Ombudsman themselves? Do you think that there should be a formal link between the commissioner for victims and the Police Ombudsman that could commence a Police Ombudsman investigation into a police officer's conduct?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: The list of service providers includes the PSNI. There needs to be a conversation about whether the Police Ombudsman, too, should be listed as one of the service providers. The ombudsman always has the right to call itself in on an investigation that relates to the police.

Chief Superintendent Gary McDonald (Police Service of Northern Ireland): Even today, if the Commissioner Designate for Victims of Crime were to come up against a particular case where she felt that there was a police failing, the option would be open to her to go ahead and make that complaint to the ombudsman, with the consent of the victim. To add to the ACC's comments, as well as the Police Ombudsman, we have the Criminal Justice Inspection (CJINI) and His Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire and Rescue Services (HMICFRS), which probably look at the issues more thematically. There could be some sort of service-level agreement (SLA) or MOU between all those organisations to make sure that we are not getting duplicate recommendations, because repeat recommendations would add bureaucracy. There may be something to look at in that space.

The Chairperson (Mr Frew): OK. This question relates to the guidance and training that your officers would have to go through in respect of the commissioner for victims, the Victim Charter and everything else that comes with it. I am looking at Part 2 of the Bill. A lot of the stuff that we have been looking at in the Criminal Justice (Sentencing) Bill regarding hostility has been about the process in court, but it all starts with somebody being charged with the hostility aggravator. How do you see training, awareness and guidance for your officers rolling out, and how much will it cost?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: These are great questions that we welcome. I have repeatedly made this point about legislation. The explanatory and financial memorandum for the Bill states that it will be cost neutral. What I read from that is that we would have to accept the outworking into our daily lives as an addition, but that there would be no financial support to deliver it. That is not uncommon with new legislation — certainly not with the legislation that has been introduced during my tenure in policing and in this role. I do not, however, see the training requirements being particularly substantive, because it is not really a significant change. It would be more about awareness-raising and information-sharing than having specific training. As you rightly said, there are other areas, in the Sentencing Bill, that will impact on this. Other legislation, such as the Domestic Abuse and Civil Proceedings Act and the Protection from Stalking Act, have been significantly more seismic. Those were fundamental changes. This Bill would probably have less of an impact than those. You are right, however, to highlight that everything has a cost, and, as I mentioned, we would have to absorb those costs into an already limited budget.

The Chairperson (Mr Frew): Thank you very much. I will hand over to members.

Mr Kingston: Thank you for your attendance, Anthony, Gary and Marty. Along similar lines to the Chair, I will start on the subject of how the role of the commissioner for victims and witnesses of crime will link with the role of the Police Ombudsman. We have had the benefit of having a commissioner designate for four and half years, and you have already said that you see value in the role, but I always naturally question increasing the number of commissioners and public bodies, because we have to ensure that there is value in adding to that number. We have, however, had the benefit of having the commissioner designate over the past four and a half years.

Geraldine Hanna attended the Committee some weeks ago along with a representative from Victim Support NI. In your experience, is there potential for confusion, from victims' point of view, between the roles of the commissioner for victims and witnesses of crime and the Police Ombudsman? I should know the answer to this, but can the commissioner designate for victims get involved in individual cases? If so, to what extent, or is it more like an overview role?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: I will go back to my opening points. First, it has been a really helpful relationship. It has been a privilege to work with Geraldine Hanna. In her time in that role, there have been significant benefits to policing. There have been good thematic matters raised that challenge us around the victim journey and that make us think about how we can provide our services better. I have always welcomed that challenge and scrutiny, because we want to provide the best journey that we can.

We have to accept that, at times, people will not come forward to us or the Police Ombudsman, but there might be a place for the commissioner to understand those concerns. They may not be complaints; they may be about how that journey works. I do not see a conflict. There has not been a conflict in that time between the role of the Police Ombudsman and the commissioner. If there were any doubt in a serious case, we would self-refer to the ombudsman. That would remain an option to us. As I said, the ombudsman can self-appoint. I would be comfortable with those relationships, and, as you said, we have had the benefit of that role. I see it as positive and as something that supports us.

Gary rightly highlighted that we have those other inspectorate regimes. When the commissioner is placed on a statutory footing, we need to make sure that those regimes are all aligned and that we do not get duplicate requests from three different places. We can work through that.

Mr Kingston: Would it provide another layer for people who have concerns about their individual case if they could go to the commissioner rather than the ombudsman in the first place? I am trying to think about how it all connects. People might want lessons to be learned, or they might have concerns about their individual case. Do you think that that would sometimes happen, rather than people thinking that the only option is to go to the ombudsman?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: That is probably a question for the commissioner. There is no doubt that individuals will go to the commissioner's office, and I would encourage that. People should use whatever avenues are open to them to highlight concerns. It might not be a complaint. It might not be about the police; it might be about another part of the process. It is important not to forget that. It is helpful that we have a statutory oversight body, but, if the complaint is about the process of how things moved from the police to the Public Prosecution Service or to the courts, that is where there is a real strength in having a commissioner whose role is to look across the entire justice system and hold us all to account, frankly, as opposed to just policing.

Mr Kingston: This question might be beyond your remit, but, when considering the Criminal Justice (Sentencing etc) Bill, we have had a discussion, which is relevant to this topic, about communication with victims at the end of trials. That is about ensuring that life sentence cases are understood by the perpetrator who is found guilty and that victims are best informed. Those tend to be higher-profile cases involving life sentences, but there is a question around how victims are kept informed in other cases that go through the court. Victims might not be in court for sentencing by the judge. There is a concern about whether victims are properly informed of the outcome and where responsibility for that lies, whether it is with the Courts and Tribunals Service or Victim Support NI. Do you have any view on that or any experience of victims feeling that they have not been kept informed?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: Yes. We get that feedback. Marty is leading on a piece of work on the Victim Charter. He is probably the best person to talk you through that journey. Victims are kept updated, but Marty can explain the process.

Superintendent Marty Reid (Police Service of Northern Ireland): When we refer the matter to the Public Prosecution Service, the victim and witness care unit picks up primary contact with the victims and witnesses and takes them on the journey from that point.

Mr Kingston: What is it called again?

Superintendent Reid: The victim and witness crime unit.

Mr Kingston: In PPS?

Superintendent Reid: In PPS. It is jointly staffed by PPS and PSNI staff. PPS takes the management of the unit, and we provide one third of the staff. At the point of referral to the PPS, the victim and witness care unit takes on the further contact. In some of the cases where there is a conviction, the police may not necessarily know, as we may not necessarily have been in court. The correct process is that the victim and witness crime unit — care unit; apologies — would pick up the contact at the end of the process. However, I have no doubt that the new commissioner will want to make sure that the issue of the contact through the entire journey often being disjointed is properly resolved and that victims get the information at the end of their case.

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: I will add to that. The Criminal Justice Board, which is chaired by the Justice Minister, has discussed the victim's journey as part of the broader piece. The commissioner designate previously raised the information flow from each agency.

From a policing perspective, we recently launched our online portal. For cases that are within the police's remit, rather than contacting an individual on a 10-day basis, as we did previously, we have introduced an online portal. A victim of crime will receive a text message from us that gives them their crime reference number. They can go on to our victim portal and create an account. From there, they can ask for automatic updates from their investigating officer. That is a very welcome development, in that it is victim-led. Victims can request those updates, and officers will respond. From our perspective, the portal has been really helpful in making sure that the way that we keep victims who are at the policing part of their journey through the justice system updated is as effective as we can make it.

Mr Kingston: Which website is that on?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: It is called the victims' portal, and it is accessed through the PSNI website.

Mr Kingston: OK. My final question is about Part 2, "Criminal evidence and procedure", which introduces special measures. As you said, the term is "hate crime", and people understand that to be when there is aggravation by hostility. My understanding is that those special measures do not apply in cases of aggravation by reason of vulnerability under clause 36 of the Criminal Justice (Sentencing etc) Bill.

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: Will you say that bit again for me?

Mr Kingston: The Sentencing Bill introduces sentencing aggravators for offences that are aggravated by hostility on the grounds of race, religion, disability and sexual orientation. Clause 36 is about vulnerability and recognises that a victim may be considered vulnerable. We have had various debates about which categories fall under hostility or vulnerability. My reading of this Bill is that the extra measures in it do not apply where the aggravation is based on vulnerability.

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: That is my interpretation as well.

Mr Kingston: Do you have a view on that? Some people have argued that they want to be included under the hostility provision because that is seen as stronger, but the evidential threshold is higher. Vulnerability, however, recognises where someone is vulnerable because of their physical or mental condition and so on.

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: I will pass that to Gary, who has been doing some work in that area. My starting position on the definition of vulnerability is that, in a policing context, there are 13 different characteristics, some of which lean into this. It therefore becomes quite complex. I am not saying that that should not be the case, but I want to highlight that point.

Chief Superintendent McDonald: My understanding is that it is simply an extension of the current legislation that deals with special measures. The existing legislation refers to witnesses who are vulnerable or intimidated, and there are subsections about what that looks like. The Bill adds to that offences that are motivated by hostility. The existing legislation already covers vulnerability, including in relation to, for example, those under 18 and those with a physical or mental disability, as well as other characteristics that the ACC has referenced. My understanding is that the Bill extends the existing legislation that already touches on vulnerability.

Mr Kingston: Is vulnerability already covered in the existing legislation?

Chief Superintendent McDonald: Yes, in the provision of special measures. That application is made in conjunction with the Public Prosecution Service, and the judiciary ultimately makes a determination on that.

Mr Kingston: OK. That is helpful. Thank you.

Ms Ferguson: I have two questions. The first is on clause 11, "Statistics relating to the Victim Charter". Obviously, the Department has not yet published any regulations for you. Have you had any engagement with the Department about what those may look like? Will there be a difference in how you currently report to Criminal Justice Inspection Northern Ireland (CJINI) and the Probation Board so that duplication is avoided but there is still an overall picture, given that it is about complementing the work rather than duplicating it?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: Marty can give more detail, but there have been some conversations with the Department and one meeting of the data group, which sits under Marty.

Superintendent Reid: We have engaged with the Department, and we recognise that we and other parts of the system collect huge amounts of material. The initial meeting was to agree on who collects what and when so that we can ensure that we collect what is needed. If we are not collecting certain material, we need to make sure that processes are put in place to do that. Part of the issue that we will face is that parts of the system collect similar material: for instance, a victim's personal statement may be recorded by the PSNI, Victim Support NI or the victims themselves. We are trying to figure out what material may be required by the commissioner and how to record it in such a way that we can provide it to the commissioner in a timely manner when they ask for it. The short answer is yes: we have actively engaged with the Department, and we will continue to engage to make sure that we have those statistics available when asked for them.

Ms Ferguson: At this stage, you do not have concerns. Is that right? I assume that, over time, the information exchange process between the bodies that you need to report to will probably become more streamlined. It may be difficult at the start.

Superintendent Reid: I am confident that we probably hold the sort of material that we will be asked for, and we likely report it in certain ways to different people. We are completely in favour of streamlining the information to make it more readily available and accessible.

Chief Superintendent McDonald: When we look at what the Victim Charter asks of the Police Service, we see that it is about the provision of victim information at the initial stages, such as the initial victim needs assessment, any interpretation or translation services for those for whom English is not their first language, case updates, the prompt return of property and referrals to support agencies, and all of that is covered. Through existing practice, we can probably capture some of that, but, as Marty said, there may be some gaps around the victim personal statement, which is a key aspect of the Victim Charter. We might not always have that as an easy way to collect the information, and we will need to work through those issues.

Ms Ferguson: I assume that the information is all held electronically rather than on paper, or is there a mix? Do you want it all to be electronic?

Superintendent Reid: We want to move towards the electronic capture of that material. The vast majority of the material is captured electronically, and there are some additional workarounds or steps in the process that are paper-based. We are keen to see those aligned and made electronic to make data capture much easier.

Ms Ferguson: Thank you. Secondly, the Police Service has requested a defined protocol with the commissioner to negate the risk of duplication. Have there been current operational challenges with the existing commissioner? Will there be a smooth transition?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: I have welcomed the relationship with the commissioner, which has been very positive and supportive. Anything that has been raised with us has been to help us to do better. We meet the commissioner frequently in many different forums, and we very much welcome that support. The Criminal Justice Board is the most senior forum, and the commissioner sits on that. The relationship has been nothing but positive and supportive, and, so far, it has not caused us any problems in the sharing of data or information. I do not envisage that changing in the future, subject, of course, to what we work through with the Department.

Ms Ferguson: Thank you.

Mr Bradley: Thank you for the presentation. How will you ensure that vulnerable witnesses, including children, are identified early enough to receive the support that they need, as proposed in clauses 24 and 25? How will you identify who is vulnerable, especially children and victims of sexual assault, early enough to make sure that they get the support that they need?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: We identify them early enough through the processes that are currently in place. In the PSNI's public protection branch, which Gary and I used to lead, specific child abuse units look at those arrangements and at how we gather information and get reports of crime. They have strong relationships with social services whereby, if a social worker comes across a crime that we do not, it is referred to us. We have relationships with schools through the likes of Operation Encompass, via which we share information about domestic abuse incidents. We are also a member of the Safeguarding Board for Northern Ireland, which has oversight of how arrangements support the welfare and safeguarding of children. There are many structures in place for that. I am content, and the feedback that we hear is that those arrangements work well and that our child abuse units carry out investigations where there is a need for that protection of and support for a vulnerable child.

Superintendent Reid: I can add to that, Mr Bradley, because it is truly helpful. We recognise that we are often the first point of contact, so we have a real responsibility to collect information. In our Niche system, which, I am sure, you have heard about — it is our main records management system — there is a module called the "victim and witness contact management module". We have not traditionally utilised that in the PSNI, because it is slightly more robust and requires a bit more time. We are going to try that as a pilot in Causeway Coast and Glens Borough Council area to see whether it is the best methodology for us to capture all the material that we might want in order to be in a position to feed it on through the system. Our next step will be to run that pilot and see how the victim and witness contact management module works. We hope that it will be a really good opportunity to gather information at the point of first contact with victims and witnesses.

Chief Superintendent McDonald: Vulnerability is assessed from that first point of contact. Even if someone rings 101 or 999, an assessment is made at that initial stage by the call handler to look at and identify vulnerability. There is also the initial victim needs assessment that is conducted by the attending officer who first responds to a crime incident. Right from the outset, there is an assessment of need. Aggravation by hostility will depend on what evidence is available through the investigation. If that is apparent, all the necessary protections will come into play.

Mr Bradley: Thanks for that, Gary. I am pleased that you are piloting that in my area of Causeway Coast and Glens. There is a good team in the Coleraine station — until you guys start to promote them all out of it, but that is a different matter.

I accept what you said about having trained officers, but will further and future training be mandatory, or is it the case that we are where we are and will see where it takes us?

Chief Superintendent McDonald: Future training for what?

Mr Bradley: To identify vulnerability, especially with regard to child abuse and sexual offences.

Chief Superintendent McDonald: Do you mean in relation to the special measures aspect? There will be training, which we touched on — the boss touched on it as well in respect of the Sentencing Bill — to identify the aggravators at early stages, once the Sentencing Bill is enacted. That will be the natural next step. If the vulnerability aspect or the hostility aspect comes into play for special measures, we already have all of that in place. It is about broadening the remit to include the new aspect.

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: You asked whether that will be it. To reassure you, I highlight again the point that we have specialist child abuse investigators. We also have specialist investigators for vulnerability, including for adults through our public protection branch or through adult safeguarding teams. Those structures and processes are in place. Those officers receive specific training for those roles. Where there is a requirement to amend that training because of the introduction of new legislation such as this, that is what we do. Anybody coming into the organisation or into those roles after that will, of course, get the most up-to-date training. It is not a case of our training somebody and that is it; new requirements will be embedded in our training going forward.

It is also important to highlight the point about capturing that vulnerability. As I mentioned, Victim Support is a key partner for us. We make referrals to it where there are victims of crime. Part of its process in support of the police role and of those victims, particularly vulnerable people and children, is that its assessment specifically includes vulnerability and looks at the processes that will be put in place to provide support beyond what policing provides.

Mr Bradley: Thank you very much. I have one wee quick question. You said that there was a victims' portal: is that accessible only by a reference number?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: Yes. You have to be a victim of crime.

Mr Bradley: Any Tom, Dick and Harry cannot access it.

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: No.

Mr Bradley: That is good.

My other question is this: are you not frightened of collecting all that data in case, somewhere along the line, there is a data breach?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: No, I am not frightened of that. I am aware that, with data anywhere in the organisation, and in any organisation anywhere in the world, there is always a risk. Subsequent to our data breach, however, we put structures in place. An independently commissioned report gave us a significant number of recommendations on better securing our data, most of which have been progressed; work on the rest will, hopefully, be concluded soon. We have a strategic data board and data delivery group, chaired by the Deputy Chief Constable, that oversees our approach to data security. It is something that we are very thoughtful and considered about. You can never rule out human error, attacks and so on, but I am reasonably content that, as an organisation, we do all that we can through our data structures to manage our data effectively.

Mr Bradley: We have learnt the lesson from the past.

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: I hope so.

Mr Bradley: Thank you very much.

Mr Beattie: Thank you for the evidence, guys. I am sorry that I am not there; I have another appointment.

I will come back to the information and support that victims get, which I have been pushing for a while. Will you clarify whether all victims of crime get support from you regardless of who they are? As that support continues, if someone no longer wants it, what do you do?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: Anyone who is a victim of crime receives updates from the PSNI. We have processes and policies under which the first natural point for a victim to receive an update is at 10 days, and they will then be updated at other points. I talked about how that is officer-led — we make the contact — but, through the victims' portal that I referred to, if the victim registers on the portal, they now have the option to contact their investigating officer at any time to ask for an update on their case. Our putting that in place is a welcome step towards ensuring that the process is victim-led. The structure is now in place, and we are embedding it. It has been live for about six months. We hope that it will continue to become embedded, and we will continue to highlight it to victims.

Have I missed a second part to your question?

Mr Beattie: Yes. I have seen the Victim Charter and everything that you provide. You provide a really good service, and this question is not a reflection on that. My point is this: months after someone becomes a victim, what happens to them when they no longer want to get more information from you? Do they opt out, saying, "I don't want any more information from you"? That is the point that I am trying to get at.

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: Marty will cover that, but I will add to it. One of the things that we will do through the victim needs assessment is look at how a victim's needs might change — this leans into your point a little — including their no longer wanting support. Needs are largely assessed at the point at which the crime is committed, but that may not be the most appropriate time, given that the victim may still be suffering trauma and might not provide us with information. As we progress through the journey, we are looking to build that needs assessment into processes so that it becomes ongoing rather than something that is done only once. That is important, and we are looking to take it forward. Marty, do you want to cover disengagement?

Superintendent Reid: That is a really good question, Mr Beattie: thank you. This is where the role of Victim Support becomes fundamental. There may be cases in which there is a victim of a crime but the PSNI has no suspect. We may feel that, without there being someone whom we are looking at as a suspect, we will never solve the crime, but, of course, their victimhood remains. Our referral mechanism to Victim Support NI has become increasingly robust in recent weeks and months. We have tried really hard to make sure that the referrals that need to go to Victim Support do so. Our default position is, in effect, that all victims will be referred unless they formally opt out. To do that, a victim would need to say, "I do not wish to be referred to Victim Support NI". That is not happening, however, and the vast majority of victims are referred to Victim Support, which picks up the provision of short-, medium- and longer-term support for them. If any victim takes the view that they do not need additional support or referrals, that is within their gift, but, from the PSNI's perspective, the short-, medium- and longer-term support of victims is delivered via Victim Support, which is the primary provider in that space.

Mr Beattie: That is absolutely clear. You will realise that I might be leading up to something. The process is exactly the same for the victim and witness care unit, which you share with the PPS, in that somebody can opt out. However, when it comes to the victim information scheme, which is post trial, you have to opt in. My argument is that you use an opt-out system, and the victim and witness care unit, which involves the PSNI and the PPS, is an opt-out system, so how does it make sense for the victim information scheme, which is run by the Probation Board after trial, to be an opt-in system? Do you see a bit of duplication between the three that I have just mentioned?

Superintendent Reid: I will start off. There is not duplication. Victim Support provides support to victims regardless of whether there is a suspect or a future defendant, whereas the victim and witness care unit becomes involved when we refer a file to the PPS, at which stage there will be a suspect or a future defendant. In those circumstances, the case will have progressed further, and we have submitted a file to the PPS. Those are slightly different parts of the system.

I have no issue with the personal preference that those services should be opt-out rather than opt-in. In my opinion, any sort of support should be opt-out rather than opt-in.

Mr Beattie: OK. That is all that I had. You are not the only ones to get that line of questioning from me. It is important for my evidence building. Thank you very much.

The Chairperson (Mr Frew): That is all the members who wished to ask a question.

We have talked today about clause 33 of the Sentencing Bill, which is about aggravation by hostility. Clause 36 of that Bill is about aggravation by reason of vulnerability, which, as Brian rightly said, is not included in clause 24 of this Bill, which amends the Criminal Evidence Order 1999. In addition, section 33(1) of the Criminal Justice (Sentencing etc) Act 2027 is specified. Clause 36(1) of the Criminal Justice (Sentencing etc) Bill states:

"It may be specified as an allegation alongside a charge of an offence against a person ('A')".

Clauses 24 and 25 of the Victims and Witnesses of Crime Bill would give a person who is the victim of hostility the same special measures as victims of sexual offences, domestic abuse and stalking. However, they do not include vulnerability. What is really important in those two clauses of the Sentencing Bill is that age appears only in the vulnerability provision; it is not a protected characteristic in the hostility provision. Therefore, it could be the case that, as you go through those special measures, you see that age is, in effect, left out, by virtue of the fact that it is not included in clause 33(1) of the Sentencing Bill.

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: I see your point, Chair. The vulnerable and intimidated witnesses process, which is the gateway to special measures, covers the points that you raise. That is my understanding, although I would need to go back and read the legislation. I suggest that that is something for the Committee to consider. I think that, when you apply the gateway to special measures, those aspects would be covered. This provision is about adding specifics where an offence is aggravated by hostility, which would not be covered in that gateway. I see it as complementing that, not creating duplication.

The Chairperson (Mr Frew): The Committee will probably have to study article 27A of the Criminal Evidence (Northern Ireland) Order 1999 in detail. The special measures section is pretty meaty. In fact, we may need to look at article 27 in its entirety, including all of its subsections. There could be an issue there that we need to examine. It might even impact on the Sentencing Bill.

You talked about a list of vulnerabilities that you take into account. Do you have a defined list of vulnerabilities that your officers use, and could you share that with us?

Assistant Chief Constable McNally: Yes. The National Police Chiefs' Council has a portfolio called VKPP. I cannot remember what the mnemonic stands for, but there is a designated list, and it is contained in our service policy. I can share with you our service policy on vulnerability.

The Chairperson (Mr Frew): That goes back to the point that Maurice raised about vulnerabilities and how we protect people and ensure that we identify vulnerabilities as early as possible.

You already have standard operating procedures in place for criminal offences such as sexual offences, domestic abuse and stalking. It will be really interesting to see how the aggravation-by-hostility piece is added to that, given that the vulnerability piece does not seem to have been included. To me, it would be common sense to include vulnerability. We might be able to amend the Victims and Witnesses of Crime Bill to include hostility and vulnerability, but that might have unintended consequences. We would need to tease that out. I have thrown a lot of detail at you and gone into the minutiae of the two Bills. It would be useful for us if you could have a wee look at that to see how it would impact on your operational procedures.

No other members have indicated that they want to ask a question. Thank you for your presence and for your information. It has been very useful.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up