Official Report: Minutes of Evidence
Committee for Justice , meeting on Thursday, 12 November 2026
Members present for all or part of the proceedings:
Mr Paul Frew (Chairperson)
Ms Emma Sheerin (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr Doug Beattie MC
Mr Maurice Bradley
Ms Connie Egan
Mrs Ciara Ferguson
Ms Aoife Finnegan
Mr Brian Kingston
Mr Patsy McGlone
Witnesses:
Ms Geraldine Hanna, Commissioner Designate for Victims of Crime
Victims and Witnesses of Crime Bill: Commissioner Designate for Victims of Crime
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): Geraldine Hanna, the commissioner designate for victims of crime, is with us. Geraldine, you are, as always, very welcome. Thank you for your presence here. Without further ado, I ask you to commence. Thank you.
Ms Geraldine Hanna (Commissioner Designate for Victims of Crime): Thank you, Chair. Almost four years and eight months ago, the office of the Commissioner for Victims of Crime was created with a real single guiding principle: that those who have been victims of crime should have a stronger voice at the highest levels of the criminal justice system. Since then, the team and I have been engaged in that important task, working closely with criminal justice organisations, community and voluntary sector colleagues, civil servants and elected representatives like yourselves.
As I sit here speaking to you, it is 11 years to the day since the Victim Charter was placed on a statutory footing. When that happened, I was about nine months into my role as chief executive of Victim Support, and I thought that it would mark a diametric shift in and a fundamental rebalancing of how victims were treated. Some things have improved for some victims over that time, but not for all and not enough. We are now discussing putting on a statutory footing an office that can monitor criminal justice organisations' compliance with that charter and how to make that charter tangible. It has taken too long, but I am so glad that we are here.
For anyone who works with victims and witnesses, it is abundantly clear that issues affecting them spread beyond the remit of the criminal justice system, and it is crucial that the office considers all aspects of society. I have been aware of that, and I have raised it consistently across my term, while also trying very hard not to stray beyond the remit of the role. Since my first day in office, I have been cognisant of the fact that, as the first-ever commissioner designate in Northern Ireland, I have had an important part to play in scoping out how the office would work when on a statutory footing. Perhaps less obviously, I have had an important role in setting a precedent that shows not only that the office is effective but that it adds value. That work on how the office should work is important, and you will have received our submission to the consultation and our scoping paper on the functioning of the office. However, in my opening remarks, I want to speak first about the why.
One of the things that the Bill does is to put the office of the commissioner for victims and witnesses of crime on a statutory footing. It is really important that we step back and ask why that is a good thing. Do not get me wrong: I definitely think that it is a good thing, but understanding the why makes the how that much simpler. I want to explain to you why I think that it is important, using the story of one of the first victims I met after taking up my role. I will call her "Cathy", but that is obviously not her real name. Some of you may have heard me speak about her before. If you have, you will know that one of the biggest issues that she faced was the production of her private information, particularly her counselling records, during the disclosure process in the trial of the man who was accused, and later convicted, of sexually assaulting her. We routinely refer to that issue as "disclosure".
Cathy told me that the system had failed her. In truth, many systems had failed Cathy throughout her life, but the criminal justice system exacerbated her trauma. One of the individuals who I spoke to about the same issue described that as a second assault and as being worse than the sexual crime that she had suffered. Those are not small words. 'A "Second Assault"' was the title of the first major piece of research that I published, back in 2023. It found that, as was the case with Cathy, many of those people were holding back from going to counselling for fear that the counselling records would be requested by the defence and seen by the judge, or choosing not to seek justice because they wanted to go to counselling without fear of their innermost thoughts being displayed to a court — information that they had an absolute right to expect would remain private. Essentially, they were being forced to choose between healthcare and justice. That is not just an issue that we are facing here. Canada and Australia are already doing things differently, and the Law Commission for England and Wales has considered the issue.
I could not change the outcome for Cathy as an individual, and she did not come to me to make things better for herself. Cathy came to me because she wanted to make things better for those who came after her. I have been struck by the fact that almost every single victim whom I have spoken to said something along the lines of, "I don't want this to happen to anybody else". These people are not coming to me for individual redress or just to rage against a faceless machine. They are carrying out selfless acts of civic virtue. We have a responsibility to honour that, to match their courage with our own determination and to wield the two together to make real and meaningful change.
Let me tell you something: the fact that I cannot help individuals is probably the worst thing about this job. I am used to just mucking in and getting my hands dirty. But this role is important. If you had asked me 25 years ago, when I started as an administrator in Victim Support in England and Wales, if there should be a Commissioner for Victims of Crime for Northern Ireland, I would probably not have understood what you meant. If you had asked me a few years later, I might have told you that the money would be better spent on witness services. However, the longer I work I this field, the more I am convinced that victims and witnesses need someone to amplify their voices at the strategic, policy and legislative level. It is here at Stormont, at meetings of the criminal justice board and inside the senior teams of the criminal justice organisations that the Cathys of this world are not being heard. When Cathy came to talk to me about disclosure, she was not alone. A raft of other victims came forward and support services shared their experiences. The issue was so pressing that I identified it as one of my strategic priorities for my term.
Here I am today, sitting in this august Building with you, the people endowed with the mandate of the electorate, considering legislation on changing how production of that information works. That is fantastic, because it means that I can tell you what victims have told me, which is that the Bill does not go far enough. We need a Canada-plus model, and I am more than happy to get into the detail of that during questions. It is fantastic because, just a few weeks ago, I told the Justice Minister the same thing. I said, "I did this report. You consulted on it, and, respectfully, what you've included in the legislation doesn't go far enough". She listened and kindly agreed to have her officials work with my team to work on amendments to make the Bill better. That is the commissioner's office working as it should, amplifying victims' voices, working at the strategic level and working constructively to make positive change.
Obviously, I think that this office is important and that it does important work. However, if this Bill passes, and even if the commissioner's office is placed on a statutory footing with all the powers that it should have — again, something that I am happy to expand on — that is not going to make things perfect for victims and witnesses overnight. Let me put it this way: this office is not about picking fruit, it is about planting seeds. The work that we are all engaged in here today is trying to plant the seeds of something that will make a difference for all those who come after us. That will require the right support, care and attention, as all seeds do. The trick is getting it right at the start. Making sure that conditions are as good as they can possibly be right at the beginning will give us the greatest chance of success. My office and I are entirely at your service to help in any way that we can so that the office gets off to the best start and the seed grows into a mighty tree. Every victim who has come to me has wanted to plant a seed and see it grow into something that could shelter people in the future. We owe it to them to make that happen, because we all know how the old saying goes: societies grow great when people plant the seeds of trees under the shade of which they know they will never sit. The best time to plant that seed may have been 20 years ago, but the second-best time is right now. Thank you for your time. I am more than happy to take any questions.
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): Thank you very much, Geraldine, for your concise presentation. We really appreciate it, as we are struggling for time. I will open things up to members straight away. First on the list is Connie.
Ms Egan: Thank you so much for coming in today. I really appreciate it. First, I want to ask you to expand on something. When we look at an overview of the Bill, we see that it puts the commissioner's office on a statutory footing, but it does not immediately do a lot of the things that people may initially associate with improving the criminal justice system for victims. Will you expand a bit on the provisions of the Bill that will help with that and on any possible amendments that you would like to see?
Ms Hanna: I am broadly supportive of what is in the Bill in respect of the powers for and duties of the office. It is broadly there. I think that the Bill can be strengthened with regard to the commissioner's office. As you will see from my consultation response, some clauses that say "may" should really say "must". The powers to compel organisations to respond to recommendations in the annual report could go broader than that. The reality is that the office will make recommendations based on research and reviews throughout the year. Where we can place in statute time frames and obligations, it is important to do so, because there is a little bit of a gap in the Bill at the moment around the disclosure piece.
To make that issue real, I give the tangible example of the disclosure of victims' personal information. Victims come to me and identify an issue. My role is about listening to lots of victims and, if the Bill passes, witnesses, identifying commonalities and using that evidence base to build a case for change. I will be able to do that, as I did in the 'A "Second Assault"' report, by interviewing lots of different people, bringing forward proposals and, hopefully, influencing Departments to consult on issues and then change legislation.
If we bring forward the changes with the addition revisions — that is the bit of the Bill that we really need to strengthen — and put in the Bill greater stipulations on what judges must consider before granting the production of records, akin to the Canada model, details of which are in the submission, that will make a more tangible change. In many ways, victims struggle to find redress, but, when it comes to what the Bill will deliver for them, this role will provide an element of redress, not so much for victims' own cases but for those who come after them. That is the most powerful thing that will come out of the Bill, if it passes.
Ms Egan: I agree. Some of your reports have been amazing, especially the one on family courts. It is pretty much the only piece of evidence that we had for the Committee's work on that. We really appreciate it.
I also appreciate that, as part of your written evidence, you sent through amendments to the Bill that you would like the Committee to table. You engaged with the Minister on those. You were quite open about saying that some of it does not go far enough. It is positive, from our perspective, to hear that the Minister is open to working with you around that. I am really interested in the Canada-plus model. Will you explain that a bit more and what you would like to see the Committee bring forward?
Ms Hanna: The amendments are probably the key bit. I am sure that you were thankful when you noticed that I do not have as many suggested amendments for this Bill as I had for the Criminal Justice (Sentencing etc.) Bill, but I have some amendments, nonetheless. The biggest one is around the disclosure piece, which is in there. The Minister's commitment to strengthen the Bill in that regard is really welcome, but, until I see what we land on, I will not know whether I totally support it.
The Canada model is really helpful because of what it states in legislation. I truly appreciate the need for court rules and practice directions — they all have a part to play — but we are talking about something as significant as the rights of victims of crime. This really touches on the article 8 privacy right. It also touches on article 3 rights and the positive obligations that states have to protect victims of gender-based violence. We know that, whilst disclosure is applicable to all crime types, it is in sexual violence cases that we see the greatest number of requests for access to third-party material and things such as counselling records and medical notes.
In the Canadian model, the legislation clearly stipulates what counts as insufficient grounds. It talks about some aspects of a request not being sufficient in and of themselves. The fact that a record exists does not mean that you should be able to see it just in case there is something in it. Just because the complainant has received counselling does not mean that you should see it. The legislation talks about the fact that there may have been a prior inconsistent statement by a witness, but that does not mean automatically that you should get to see it. There is a lot of detail in there that I will refer you to. For example, section 3 talks about factors that judges should consider beyond looking at the interests of justice. It is about looking at wider society's interest in encouraging people to report crime and the need to remove from the fact-finding process any discriminatory beliefs or bias. That is also part of the challenge. We do not want prejudicial and subjective bias influencing our justice system. If we seek access to someone's information, the court must be satisfied that it is beyond mere speculation and that there is genuine probative value.
By stipulating that in legislation, we ensure that a consistent approach will be taken to this by all judges. That does not mean that there will be no further production of victims' information. I started this with counselling records being my hope, but the legal advice was that article 6 rights would work against that. Therefore, respecting that, it is about how we secure a better balance between the article 6 rights of the accused, which must be protected, of course, and the article 8 rights of victims in particular. It cannot be just a blanket, "This trumps that". We need to look at that. Where there is a genuine expectation of privacy of records, our courts should consistently ensure that anybody who requests access to such records — on a lot of occasions, it is the defence — follows a process and that that is clearly applicable in every case. Some judges will say, "We already do that"; I am saying, "Put it in law", in the same way that they have in Canada and Australia.
Mr McGlone: Thanks very much. It is good to see you today again.
Will you talk me through the process? At the start, you emphasised, and I read in your paper, the need for additional powers for the commissioner's office. We will take a simple example. We will start from a victim and the role of your office and how it relates to that victim. Because the other aspect is that you are looking for more staff and more resources, we will take it through to how the staff in your office relate to other statutory agencies, such as the police, the Police Ombudsman, social services and all that, including with the correct flow of information, if required, from those respective agencies. Ultimately, we will take it to the courts, because there is — how shall we put it? — an import in what you say is the ability for there to be what some might see as interference in the court process. Will you talk me through the role of your office right through to the court process, to establish what your ask is to enable your office to be empowered to do those things and ultimately to be there for that individual victim who may have approached your office?
Ms Hanna: This role is distinct from that of the Police Ombudsman; his role is to investigate complaints. It is distinct from Criminal Justice Inspection NI (CJINI), whose role is to inspect the performance of the criminal justice system in a range of areas, from victims to how prisoners are treated, efficiencies, delay and all that. The role of this office is to advocate for and champion the needs and rights of victims of crime. Where the Bill talks about powers to compel information or about responses to recommendations, that is around thematic issues and areas of improvement to the system. Rather than it being about how an organisation has responded to an individual victim, it is about how it will improve its policy and procedure for victims in general. Does that make sense?
Mr McGlone: That brings me back to my point. How can you be best informed, if, in fact, the individual victim is not best able to inform you on a one-to-one basis and the agencies with which the person may have liaised cannot provide you with broader information or decide to withhold from your office information that it regards to be sensitive or private? In other words, Geraldine, how do you get the accurate picture to enable your office to champion and advocate on behalf of victims when what an organisation sees may or may not be the actuality for the victim, if you cannot get that flow of information correctly or if an organisation says, "Sorry, we're not compelled to give you that"? Leading on from that, how would the extra staff that you would have be best able to fulfil their role without potentially being frustrated by other statutory agencies?
Ms Hanna: Assuming that I am following you correctly, in terms of the power to compel information, the information that we would want would be about policies, procedures, how those work and the numbers of people coming to them with certain issues and how they address certain challenges. The evidence base that we would build before making any recommendation or report would have to come from a range of sources. I have met hundreds of victims in my current role. There are similar things that cut across all their cases, but some things are bespoke. Bespoke things could include a failing of an individual officer or prosecutor. If it relates to just one individual case, it will not give me that evidence base. I try to identify the things that I hear repeatedly that will give me the impetus to say, "Right, there is something more here". It is then that we go to agencies to ask for further information on an issue, which could be things like, "What is your policy in relation to that?"
A classic example of that is probably the 'A "Second Assault"' report, which was my first report. Victims told me that they were choosing between healthcare and justice. They said that they were not told that the information was being sought, so they never had an opportunity to refuse it. Support services told me that they were getting requests from the court for access to absolutely every piece of information on a person. If that service is a GP, as you can imagine, that involves the person's GP records from throughout their life. After that, I went to the Public Prosecution Service (PPS), which told me that it was not always made aware that these requests were being made by the court, even though the practice direction says that the victim should be notified. Only the PPS could notify the victim that the information was being sought, but the PPS was not aware that the information was being sought. That gave me evidence that the current practice was not being followed, which lead to us creating a task and finish group —.
Ms Hanna: Exactly. That is one of the best ways, in terms of what might be in rules, for us to ensure that everybody does things appropriately.
Mr McGlone: That brings me back to the question of whether the compulsion is for them to share the information with you. Is your argument that you would require additional powers to do that because, as it is, they may or may not share the information with you?
Ms Hanna: In terms of this office and the current powers, bar the recommendations that we have in our submission around time frames and organisations giving a reason if they are not responding to something, it is broadly there.
I will not be investigating individual cases. I will be asking the organisations, "What is your response to this? What is your policy on this?". If they say what their policy is, and I say, "That sounds fine, but I have evidence that this is not being addressed", I will recommend improvement.
Mr McGlone: I want to get this clear in my mind. You are happy enough that those agencies will share with you whatever information you require.
Ms Hanna: To date, I have not encountered any issue with the criminal justice organisations not giving me information, and I hope that that will continue. In many respects —.
Ms Hanna: Four and a half years. My office has not been on a statutory footing thus far, and we should never have to rely on statutory powers. If the criminal justice system is willing to learn and improve and to commit to what it says that it wants to achieve for victims and witnesses, it will readily engage. It is a matter of belt and braces when it comes to the legislation on the powers of the office. Compelling people to respond is enough. If they do not respond, obviously, it will be about the form of redress. In my consultation response, I recommended enabling my office to intervene in judicial reviews. I do not think that the Bill prohibits that, but I want to ensure that my reading of it is accurate. I do not think that that would happen regularly, but determining when to intervene would have a resource implication for any commissioner. If there were a thematic issue on which we were not making headway, however, that might open an avenue to do so. It needs to be made clearer that that is an option.
The work of my office is thematic, systemic improvement, so I will not say to the police or the prosecution service, "You must give me information about what happened to Patsy McGlone in this case and share all of it with me". That is not my role. I will be referring people to relevant organisations and signposting victims where there are complaints about that. We have not really got into that since I took up my role, largely because the information is not there — that is not on a statutory footing yet either — but that is why the collection of data on compliance with the Victim Charter is so important. You cannot expect my office to monitor compliance with the Victim Charter if you do not create the infrastructure to enable it to do so. If the organisations do not collect data on their compliance, no commissioner will be able to make determinations on the basis of anything other than anecdotal evidence.
Mr McGlone: In conclusion, you are happy that, if the infrastructure that you propose were to be put in place, it would be effective enough to do what needs to be done.
Ms Hanna: The current remit of the role is broadly reflective of that of the commissioner in other jurisdictions. My consultation response makes stipulations about strengthening some of the wording of the Bill and therefore the expectations on agencies, but the Bill will ensure that the remit of that broader role that does not involve the investigation of individual cases is appropriate.
Ms Sheerin: Thanks, Geraldine, for coming in. You will know — we have spoken about this — that, as a party, we are concerned about a cohort whose cases are not captured: victims of domestic violence who are deemed to have died by suicide, when it was clearly not suicide. In your submission, you:
"query whether it may be prudent to include an enabling provision ... that could be activated in future to allow the Commissioner to act as a monitoring mechanism for Domestic Homicide Reviews."
How is the number of people affected by that captured at the minute?
Ms Hanna: There is no accurate figure for domestic abuse-related suicide. There are two things about that in our submission, one of which is about suicide following domestic abuse. We need to consider whether we need a new law on that. I appreciate that the time left in the mandate may not facilitate that, but there may be an opportunity to create a condition where the police and the Coroners Service are required to keep a record of any case involving a death with any allegation or suspicion that domestic abuse has been involved. The data will give us the information that we need to have evidence-based policymaking because we are unable to determine the numbers that we are talking about. It would be helpful if the relevant criminal justice organisations, such as the Coroners Service, kept records because the domestic homicide reviews do not currently include suicide. It is not that the Department is averse to that; it has just not had the resources to do that yet. When considering expanding it, it would be helpful to know the numbers that we are potentially talking about.
Northern Ireland was late to the table when compared with other jurisdictions, but I am very conscious that we are already starting to see repeat recommendations as domestic homicide reviews are produced. If we are going to invest the time and energy necessary to undertake a domestic homicide review, it is incumbent on us to learn from the loss suffered by the families who have contributed to the review and make those changes. Whether it is this office or another office, it is inappropriate that there is no independent body overseeing the implementation of those recommendations. There is joint Department of Health and Department of Justice oversight, but the reality is that the majority of the recommendations are attributed to the Department of Health, the Department of Justice and the Police Service, and it all falls into that realm. An independent oversight body would assist with that. England and Wales have travelled the journey and are ahead of us on the issue. If we want to learn lessons from elsewhere, England and Wales now have a Domestic Abuse Commissioner who looks at that as part of their role. In the future, if there is an enabling provision in this legislation, an independent body might appropriately sit there.
Ms Sheerin: Basically, you have said that it would allow our domestic homicide review to capture suicide, and as a result of that, we might be in a place to gather the data to enable us to legislate for domestic-abuse-induced suicide?
Ms Hanna: I would sequence it by capturing the data, which is the lower-hanging fruit, so that we know the numbers. If we can do something in this mandate to require organisations to capture the numbers, they will be there to inform any business case for the additional resources that will be needed to expand domestic homicide reviews to look at all domestic abuse-related deaths, as is the case in England and Wales. At the minute, we can say, "We think that it is going to be a lot, but we are not really sure". That is just sticking a finger in the air to see which way the wind is blowing, which is not good enough for a business case. The data will go into the domestic abuse-related deaths and, we hope, improve the domestic homicide reviews. Running alongside that is the consideration of whether we need a specific law to act as a deterrent. There is an argument about whether we need another law or whether we are covered by our current manslaughter laws, but that will take a bit more consideration, which could run alongside the review and support it.
Mr Bradley: Thank you very much for your presentation. You alluded to Patsy that the commissioner's office would need more powers. Can you expand on that? Your submission says that England, Scotland and Wales are ahead of the game. What would you import into your office from England, Scotland and Wales? Can you give us a flavour of the statutory powers that should be added to the office?
Ms Hanna: The broad infrastructure is there, and it reflects the office in England and Wales and that of the Victims and Witnesses Commissioner for Scotland. England and Wales have a Victims’ Commissioner, which also covers witnesses to some degree, but Scotland is bringing forward a Victims and Witnesses Commissioner. The learning from England and Wales is on the duty to respond within 56 days to every recommendation. There is a need for agencies to cooperate with the commissioner's office. There is an obligation on criminal justice organisations to provide data to help the commissioner's office to monitor compliance with the charter. If there is a refusal to provide that data, an explanation must be given.
The other thing that really interests me about Scotland's commissioner is that, if an organisation refuses to provide information, there is provision in the legislation that allows them to refer the matter to the Scottish civil courts to determine whether that refusal is warranted. Again, that underlines and recognises the importance of the office and the duty to cooperate. You would like to think that that would never be needed. I talk about planting the seed and making sure that we start off on the right footing. It is about ensuring that, if we are going to invest in the office, we give it the right powers and duties to ensure that it effectively achieves what we hope it will, which is to advance the interests and needs of victims and witnesses of crime.
Mr Bradley: How do you see your role when it comes to this Committee? Will you report back to us at regular intervals and give us updates? Your presentation was very informative, and your passion for your job comes across clearly. How do you intend to interact with the Committee, and how regularly do you envisage doing so?
Ms Hanna: I will come up every week if you want me to. [Laughter.]
Ms Hanna: Have you nothing else to think about?
Ms Hanna: Paul would have us here all the time.
It is a really important vehicle. As I said in my opening remarks, the power of this role is not to speak on behalf of victims but to amplify their voices. It gives victims a voice at the table of key decision-makers, and you do not get more senior than our legislators; you are making decisions that will impact on the environment that victims and witnesses encounter when they come forward to report crime. That is really important. Reports will be produced by the office, whoever the commissioner is, and I would expect any commissioner to submit reports to all the relevant bodies, including the Committee. Depending on your interest, you will probably want the commissioner to come and speak to you about those reports, any recommendations and what they mean.
It is also a temperature check and another way for you, as a Committee, to gain evidence about how the system is operating from an independent voice. The Department, the police, the prosecution service and the courts all give you evidence on what they are doing and how they are improving. For the police, having a victim focus is a strategic priority, and they will, of course, highlight all the things that they are doing to improve, but what you will get from this office is how that comes across. Is that actually being felt by individuals on the ground? I think that that is a key part of the evidence base that informs your thinking and decision-making.
Mr Bradley: Thank you very much. Any invitations will come from the Chair, not me.
Mr Kingston: Thank you, Geraldine, for attending. You talked about victims being concerned about the disclosure of personal information in trials. I want to weigh that up against the need for the justice system to approach cases with an open mind and find the truth when an allegation has been made and a trial is then going to take place. Sometimes, what seems to have happened can change during a trial when all information is disclosed. The justice system has to have that open mind. We are all aware of cases in which it has been decided to keep some information from the court about something that happened previously and, if that had been known to the jury, it might have influenced it. It is about the need for the justice system to have access to as much information as possible to determine the truth. How do you weigh that up, recognising that some of the people who are involved may not want personal information to be disclosed?
Ms Hanna: That is the challenge that we grapple with. To be fair, it is a challenge that our judges and our court system grapple with every day. They are constantly weighing up the competing rights involved. I am concerned that our current practice does not give enough weight to not looking for the information. I am not saying that there should be a blanket ban on saying anything personal. If, for example, I have alleged that a crime has been committed against me, I cannot say that you should never say anything about me, because there may be something relevant there. However, to go looking for that, it cannot be on the basis of, "just because it exists, I should look at it". There needs to be a stronger evidential base to go looking for that information. It needs to have significant probative value. From my perspective, the threshold is better outlined in the legislation in Canada and Australia, where that need is stipulated.
The additions that I think should be made to the Bill do not tie the hands of the judiciary from seeking any information. It will ultimately always require judicial decision-making. However, it will place in legislation a strong threshold that needs to be examined and criteria — a framework — that they must look at and satisfy themselves with as to the need for that information before seeking it.
We found in our 'A "Second Assault"' report, as did the then Information Commissioner's Office in its examination, that particularly when it comes to victims of sexual violence — and more specifically, women — reporting facts, a bit of a fishing expedition was going on. We have made some improvements, but, as we introduce this legislation, there is an opportunity to strengthen the threshold and ensure that there is a consistent approach. Really, there is also an opportunity to emphasise the fact that just because a record exists does not mean that it should be sought and the court must satisfy itself that it has suitably assessed an application before the information is produced. I will give credit: the Lady Chief Justice has updated the practice direction in that regard. However, in our legislation, I would like to see a greater framework on what the judges are considering, similar to that introduced in other jurisdictions, such as Canada and Australia, which have the same issues around common law jurisdiction and wanting to ensure that we get the right balance in that area.
Mr Kingston: OK. You were here in September on the Criminal Justice (Sentencing etc) Bill, but, at the Chair's discretion, I will ask about and briefly touch on some of the extra matters that we have been considering.
Mr Kingston: On the issue of victims being notified when the offender is discharged or given temporary release — that it should be an opt-out system rather than an opt-in system — have you had experience of victims not being notified? Has that been brought to you?
Ms Hanna: No. On the victim information scheme and the need to register to opt in, I unfortunately —. I have not had many recently — in the past two years — in this job. However, I did experience that while in Victim Support, and there have been a few cases since I have been in this job in which victims did not know soon enough that they needed to opt in. In those cases, it was only when there was something in the press about the release — for example, a release on compassionate leave — that the victim knew about it and said, "Oh, but I did not know". Sometimes people cannot quite remember.
I will always go back to my experience in Victim Support. In relation to the criminal injuries compensation scheme with its two-year time limit, I remember sitting in front of a victim, who, when I told them to apply, told me, "I did not know about the criminal injuries compensation". Their son had been murdered, and they had ended up getting into quite a bit of debt with the funeral expenses, but they said that they had not known about that scheme.
I came out of the meeting, and I had another member of staff with me, who said, "I was in that person's house, and I did tell them about it", but the level of trauma that the individual was experiencing at that time was such that they just could not remember. My fear is that, when we have an opt-in scheme, we are putting the onus on victims to be, first, aware and, secondly, in the right place to be thinking about that, whereas, with opt-out, you have an opportunity to let the person know that they are opted in, and they can opt out if they choose to and maybe opt in again later. They are in the scheme until they choose to leave it. When it comes to the quantum of harm, that is the better option. I would much rather explain to a victim, "Well, we sent you that letter to tell you that a key thing is coming up. Do you want to find out about it?", and deal with the harm that that causes than have a victim come to me distressed having found out that someone had been released via the media, press or, worse still, by running into them on the street.
Ms Hanna: I fully support that. I know that the Department has been trying to improve its system in that regard, particularly with life-sentence prisoners and the families who are affected by that. However, a cleaner way in which to do it is just to flip that and have an automatic opt-out.
Mr Kingston: Another issue that we talked about was victims' personal statements at sentencing hearings. What is your knowledge of the current arrangements for that — when they are permitted and when they are not?
Ms Hanna: That is another area into which we have undertaken some research. We discovered several issues with the victim personal statement scheme as it was then operating. You have an entitlement under our current Victim Charter to make a written statement. That was not always being offered to everybody, particularly in the Magistrates' Court, which moves very quickly from adjudication to sentence. There was a need to improve the process so that we were able to secure those statements earlier in the day. That change needed to be made to current procedure.
The other thing was that people were not being given the opportunity to read their statements out to the court. When we produced our report on that, I was being told by the Department of Justice that it was OK: there was provision, and it was down to judicial discretion. I was told by some in the judiciary that, no, because the legislation talks about written application, it may be preventing that. Therefore, I made a recommendation that, either way, we should figure that out and that it would be better if we said that legislatively. The Lady Chief Justice then clarified that it is down to judicial discretion. I welcome that, but my proposal, and what I think would be much better for consistency, is that it is enshrined as a right in our legislation that, if a victim chooses to read their statement — not everybody will want to — they will have the opportunity to do that.
You can see the power that those statements have. One victim described it as the beginning of their healing journey when they were able to tell the offender — not the court, but the offender, who is obviously going to be there — the harm that the offence had caused. That was the first part of their healing journey. You will have seen in some recent cases — the Brand case in particular — the power that those statements have, not just for the public's understanding but more so for the victims and survivors of those cases. I strongly believe that our legislation should enshrine that as a right for victims.
Mr Kingston: I used my discretion. Some might not want to make a statement, but it is useful to determine what the situation is.
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): It is very useful, yes.
Thank you. All the members on the list have asked questions. While you are here, Geraldine, I will ask a couple of important questions that relate to certain clauses. You have talked about your frustration at not being able to get involved in individual cases. The Bill is explicit about restrictions on the exercise of functions. You ask for the right and the power to make complaints on behalf of victims to relevant ombudsmen and commissions. Is that not interfering in individual cases?
Ms Hanna: When it comes to my frustration about individual cases, I would love to be able to intervene in everybody's case, but the system would be overwhelmed. Absolutely everybody comes to me when they have a complaint. Also, I would be duplicating. We do not want the role to duplicate the complaints mechanisms.
When I talk about wanting to make a complaint to an individual body, I mean that the office should be able to refer a case to the Police Ombudsman's office. At the moment, I have two issues with the legislation that governs the Police Ombudsman's office. It can take a complaint from a member of the public only if that individual has been directly involved, so, because I have not been directly involved, I cannot make a complaint.
Another issue is that serving police officers cannot make a complaint either. That needs to be changed. Also, certain bodies can refer a case to the Police Ombudsman. The bodies named are the Department of Justice, the Policing Board and the Public Prosecution Service. I would not intervene in their cases. When I meet victims and hear about their experience of the system, I will often ask them whether they have made a complaint to the Police Ombudsman's office or the PPS. If they have not, I will signpost them to those agencies.
About a year or two after I came into the office, we created a leaflet to try to make that process clearer, because it can be quite complicated. People might have complaints about several bodies along the way, so we will signpost them. However, if someone shares something with me during an interview that gives me sufficient concern that the police have acted gravely and that individual does not feel strong enough or does not want to make a referral to the Police Ombudsman and go through the process of making that complaint, with that person's knowledge, our office should be able to refer that case and let the Police Ombudsman look at it.
I do not expect that to happen in every case. It is more in cases where the commissioner hears about something that is an abuse of power for sexual purposes by a police officer, for example, and that person has not felt willing or able to report that to the Police Ombudsman.
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): In that case, if you were given the vires and referred a case to the Police Ombudsman, how would they conduct a thorough investigation if the victim was not up to being interviewed, given that they were not up to taking action in the first place? Would the Police Ombudsman interview you?
Ms Hanna: I would want to engage with that individual to seek permission to make that referral on their behalf, on the understanding that the information that they had given me may form the basis of it but that they may need to have that further interview. If they then decide that they cannot and will not engage with the Police Ombudsman, there may be, if the allegation is sufficiently serious, enough information for the Police Ombudsman to act on their own powers. It would apply to cases where you think that what has been said is really significant. That is one of the challenges for me in my office. I do not ask people to talk to me in detail about the crime itself. I am interested in their experience of the justice system. Some people will share elements of the crime, but I can foresee an occasion when someone may share something that rings an alarm bell for me and that a relevant body needs to investigate.
Ms Hanna: Yes, it could be. If somebody disclosed a crime, I would be duty-bound to report that. However, if they alleged that the individual who perpetrated that harm was a police officer, it would be the Police Ombudsman to whom I would refer.
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): What about the people who would complain to the Police Ombudsman or to you about the PSNI but who were not necessarily victims?
Ms Hanna: People who complain to me as a victim?
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): Yes. There might be an occasion when someone might stick in a complaint to the Police Ombudsman, but they are not necessarily a victim or witness of a crime; they just happen to have had an interaction with the police in some way. I suspect that those people would not interface with you, but, if they thought that you had the vires to refer something to the Police Ombudsman, they might come to you. You would, I suspect, have to determine that they were a genuine victim.
Ms Hanna: You mean that rather than going straight to the Police Ombudsman, a person would come to us to report the police for committing a crime against them.
Ms Hanna: We would need to be clear about our remit and what the power —.
Ms Hanna: We would need to ensure that that was appropriately handled, either in legislation or the rules around that. I am not sure whether you are touching on this, but complaints monitoring is one of the areas that needs to be considered. Part of the commissioner's role is to monitor complaints that are made in relation to failures of the Victim Charter. In order to monitor complaints across the criminal justice system, I would need to know from the Police Ombudsman how many complaints from victims of crime are about the police. If that office is not included as a charter service provider, it is not required to capture the information as to how many victims of crime complained about the police. In that instance, I would not be able to monitor complaints against what is a key body in the criminal justice system.
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): That brings me on to clause 9. Is the Police Ombudsman the only body that has been left out of that list?
Ms Hanna: The Police Ombudsman jumps out as being a key one. It should be possible to hold to account any organisation that provides a statutory public service to victims of crime. It is my understanding that those bodies are included so that this office can appropriately monitor compliance with the Victim Charter. The criminal justice organisations that are charter providers are included, but the Police Ombudsman's office has never been part of that.
Ms Hanna: That is one of the things that I have suggested be changed. The Bill refers to complaints made about the charter. I believe that this office should have the responsibility to monitor complaints about treatment across the system. Just because something is not in the charter does not mean that —. Were this office to get the relevant data from the respective organisations, we would be looking at complaints in order to establish thematic issues — what are the most common issues that people are complaining about, and, significantly, what are the most common outcomes? If every outcome is, "Nothing to see here", I would be asking whether we needed to do a little bit more digging into the issue. Why is it that everybody complains, but the Police Ombudsman or the PPS say that there is nothing to see?
Ms Hanna: CJINI does not monitor complaints. It will look at the thematic issues that have an impact on performance across the system. It will not look at the complaints monitoring process. That is my understanding, but it might be worth checking that with CJINI. I do not believe that that is a duplication.
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): Clause 10 is "Compliance with the Victim Charter". In your written submission, you mention that time frames need to be imposed on the bodies that are charter service providers. What sort of timescales are you talking about?
Ms Hanna: For me, up to three months, perhaps, seems reasonable. In the absence of any time frame, it is a bit loose.
"A charter service provider must, so far as is appropriate and reasonably practicable, comply with a request made to it under subsection (2)."
What is appropriate and what is reasonable?
Ms Hanna: That is where people could argue about differences in definition. The Scottish clause helps in that instance, in that it focuses the mind. You cannot just say, "Oh no, we do not think that that is reasonably practicable" and not do it. If we thought that there was the potential that a court might then make a determination on that, that would help to keep us all honest.
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): I will come back to the list at clause 9. The Department is included in that in respect of the functions exercised by the Prison Service and the Youth Justice Agency. The Probation Board is on the list, but the Minister keeps reminding us that it is not part of the Department. What about the Department itself? Why would it not be included in the list?
Ms Hanna: As I understand it, the clause is about the ability to monitor compliance with the Victim Charter and subsequently, we hope, the Witness Charter. The Department is not a direct service provider under those charters. The role of my office is to make recommendations on anything that relates to understanding the rights and needs of victims. We can, where the commissioner thinks it appropriate, advise a Department on the interests of victims and witnesses. In clause 3, titled "General duties", under subsection 3(b), the commissioner must advise the Department:
"on such other occasions as the Commissioner thinks appropriate."
If the office had evidence to suggest that the Department should do more or do something different in relation to victims and witnesses, the commissioner would have a duty to advise the Department under that clause.
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): OK.
Are you happy with the schedules as they relate to the nitty-gritty of your office, including the provision that you can serve only two terms?
Ms Hanna: The "Tenure of office" provision is important to the independence of the role. The time frames are broadly right. We want there to be enough time for the commissioner to make a difference, but, equally, we do not want someone to be in the job for the rest of their life, perhaps becoming too comfortable — much as I would be happy to stay on for ever.
The main provisions in schedule 1 are about the independence of the role and the staffing of the office. Currently, the staff of my office are seconded from the Civil Service, but, given that we were established on a statutory footing, we should be able to bring in external staff as well. Given the nature of the commissioner's role, with its specialism in victims' rights and interests, it may be appropriate for the office to bring in external staff. The requirement in the Bill for staff appointments to be approved by the Department of Justice and the Department of Finance concerns me somewhat. If the office is given a budget, it should surely be for the commissioner to determine how the staffing of the office works. If the commissioner were to decide that the office needed some great role, as long as that fitted with the remit, powers and functions of the office, the commissioner should be able to determine the appointment, provided that that would not mean going beyond the budget envelope. I have a bit of concern about the requirement for externally recruited appointments to be approved by the Justice Department and the Finance Department.
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): We talked about time frames for compliance with the Victim Charter and for responding to requests for information from service providers. You talked about a period of three months, but it is stipulated under clause 19, titled "Duty to response to annual reports", that a service provider must publish comments on a commissioner's report:
"before the end of the period of 56 days beginning with the day on which the report is published."
How did the Department arrive at the period of 56 days?
Ms Hanna: A 56-day period seems to be standard in the other jurisdictions. The Domestic Abuse Commissioner for England and Wales and the Victims' Commissioner for England and Wales have that period. I cannot recall whether Scotland also has it. It seems to be a reasonable time frame. There should be a longer time frame for the other requirement, for service providers to provide a report, because, on being asked for a huge amount of information, they may need time to turn it around, whereas 56 days seems appropriate for responding to a recommendation by indicating, "Yes, we will do this. We accept this and will do whatever". It might take a further year to deliver that, but it is about responding rather than saying nothing. If, in reviewing a certain area, we were to need a lot of information on a specific issue, a 56-day response period may or may not be appropriate: that is why, I think, it seems appropriate for a three-month period to apply to a response.
The Chairperson (Mr Frew): OK. I am happy enough. I have no further questions. Thank you very much for your attendance; it has been very useful.
Ms Hanna: Thank you very much.