Official Report: Minutes of Evidence

Committee for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, meeting on Tuesday, 17 November 2026


Members present for all or part of the proceedings:

Ms Diana Armstrong (Chairperson)
Mr Declan McAleer (Deputy Chairperson)
Mr John Blair
Mr Tom Buchanan
Miss Michelle McIlveen
Miss Áine Murphy
Mr Gareth Wilson


Witnesses:

Mr Colin Armstrong, Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs
Mr Tommy McCormick, Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs
Ms Kelly Mills, Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs
Mr Phil Stewart, Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs



Fisheries, Aquaculture and Water Environment Bill: Committee Deliberations

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): I welcome to the meeting Colin Armstrong, director of water and marine policy and legislation; Kelly Mills, deputy director of marine and fisheries operations; Phil Stewart, aquaculture policy branch; and Tommy McCormick, Bill lead. You are very welcome this morning. Please provide us with your briefing on clauses 10 to 18. Thank you.

Mr Tommy McCormick (Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs): Thank you, Chair. I will open on fixed penalties. Part 4 of the Bill provides the Department with the power to bring forward subordinate legislation to provide for fixed penalty notices (FPNs) in relation to certain offences under the Fisheries Act (Northern Ireland) 1966 and for any offence under the Water (NI) Order 1999. The intention is to use fixed penalty notices —.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Could you speak a little more loudly? It is quite hard to hear from down here. Thank you.

Mr McCormick: Sorry. Yes.

The intention is to use fixed penalty notices as an alternative to prosecution for low-level offences where prosecution through the courts may not be the most proportionate enforcement response. That will widen the enforcement methods open to enforcement officers and provide a fuller range of options in dealing with offences from minor cases to the fixed penalty provisions and through to the most serious cases in a Crown Court. While that will remove the need to take court proceedings to deal with low-level offences, the decision to issue a fixed penalty notice will be taken on a case-by-case basis, and, where a decision is not to issue a fixed penalty notice in relation to an offence, the matter will be taken through the courts. In taking forward the fixed penalty scheme, the Department will develop the policies and subsequent legislation in conjunction with stakeholders, public consultation and the views of the Committee. Any proposed legislation will be subject to the draft affirmative procedure.

I will go through the clauses, Chair. Clause 10 defines a "fixed penalty notice" as:

"a notice that offers a person the opportunity to discharge any liability to be convicted of an offence"

rather than proceeding through the criminal courts. In practical terms, it offers a proportionate and efficient enforcement option for less serious offences.

Clause 11 gives the Department the power to introduce fixed penalty notices for a specified offence under the Fisheries Act (Northern Ireland) 1966 and regulations made under that Act.

Clause 12 provides an equivalent power in relation to offences under the Water (Northern Ireland) Order 1999 and any subsequent legislation made under that Order.

Clause 13 sets out the matters that regulation may cover when establishing a fixed penalty notice scheme.

Clause 14 provides that no prosecution may be brought against a person in receipt of a fixed penalty notice prior to the time limit for payment of a fine.

As mentioned, the detail of how fixed penalty notices will operate will be developed in conjunction with stakeholders and consulted on and will be set out in regulations and subject to Assembly approval. Thank you, Chair.

Mr Phil Stewart (Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs): I will cover clauses 15 to 18, which are on aquaculture licensing. The overarching policy intent set out in the consultation document was to ensure a comprehensive and transparent licensing system that supports the sustainable development of all aquaculture subsectors. The subsectors that we commonly refer to are marine shellfish, which comprise mussels and oysters; marine salmon; and marine seaweed. There is also the inland fin fish sector, which primarily produces Atlantic salmon, brown trout and rainbow trout.

In the public consultation, we set out our intention to introduce two separate licensing processes: one for inland and one for marine. During post-consultation stakeholder engagement with inland licence holders, they voiced strong opposition to the proposal to remove their fish culture licence, stating that they wished to retain their existing licences. There were also complex issues with the marine proposals for the consolidation of licences, which identified property rights concerns for existing licence holders. As a result of those issues and the views expressed by stakeholders, it was decided that separate processes for inland and marine farms would not be taken forward and that the Bill would instead focus on key amendments and additions to the existing provisions in the 1966 Act to address some of the long-standing legislative gaps while still contributing to the original policy intent.

Additionally, a commitment was given in the Department's consultation response to produce a dedicated aquaculture policy through a co-design process with stakeholders. That aquaculture policy will set out how the Department intends to support the sustainable growth of each marine subsector in accordance with the position that is set out in the UK joint fisheries statement (JFS). Likewise, it will provide an opportunity to set out how the Department will support the sustainable growth of the inland aquaculture sector in accordance with the inland fisheries objectives and inland fisheries policy statement. The Committee was briefed on those previously, and they are detailed in clauses 1 and 2.

Work on the aquaculture policy has commenced in tandem with the progression of the Bill through the Assembly. The first co-design stakeholder workshop was held on 3 November. Further workshops are planned for January 2027. The intention is to have draft policy prepared for ministerial consideration prior to the pre-election period in March 202 and to consult on the draft policy in the new Assembly mandate. It is therefore intended that that work will already be at an advanced stage in the event that the Bill gets Royal Assent.

I will now give an overview of each of the clauses. Clause 15 substitutes the existing section 11 of the Fisheries Act 1966 on "Fish culture licences" with a new section 11, "Aquaculture licences". The new section introduces new definitions of "aquaculture", "aquaculture activities" and "aquaculture farm", aligning with terminology used in the Fisheries Act 2020. The new definitions broaden the scope of the licensing provisions to include all forms of aquaculture, not just fish and shellfish production. That addresses a long-standing gap in the legislation and supports the development of emerging subsectors such as seaweed cultivation. It sets out offences for operating an aquaculture farm without a licence and for a licence holder to fail to comply with their licence conditions. It also provides a power for the Department to make regulations, subject to the draft affirmative resolution procedure, to include or exclude certain businesses from the licensing requirement.

Clause 16 sets out a series of amendments that are consequential to clause 15. They update the 1966 Act, changing "fish farm" to "aquaculture farm" and "fish culture licence" to "aquaculture licence", which gives effect to clause 15.

Clause 17 describes the transitional arrangements for existing fish culture licences. It sets out that existing licences will automatically become aquaculture licences upon commencement and will continue to operate under the same conditions as were attached to the licence immediately before commencement. That is to minimise the impact on existing licence holders while retaining the Department's powers to amend, suspend or revoke licences where required.

Clause 18 introduces a specific provision to enable licence transfers. That is currently absent from the 1966 Act and is currently managed through the granting of licence amendments. Including it in the Bill will align aquaculture licensing provisions with other similar licensing regimes, such as marine licensing and discharge consents, both of which have licence transfer provisions. The clause also includes the right of appeal for the applicant should the Department refuse an application and the ability for the Department to set fees for licence transfers.

The provisions in Part 5 will take effect by commencement rather than on Royal Assent, with the exception of the new clause 11(7), which gives the Department regulation-making powers to exclude certain businesses from the licensing requirement; a power that the Department intends to exercise. The businesses that we wish to exclude from the licensing requirement include pet shops, recreational fisheries and hobby ponds. Those businesses do not currently require a fish culture licence, and we wish that to remain the case for aquaculture licences.

That was the detail of clauses15 to 18. We are happy to take any questions that you might have.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Thank you, Tommy and Phil.

Members, do you have any questions to put at this point? No. I think that that is it for now.

We will go into closed session. Members, do I have your agreement that we move into closed session?

Members indicated assent.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Thank you, panel. We may request that you return after the closed session.

The Committee went into closed session from 10.44 am until 11.29 am.

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): I thank the officials for coming back. We have just gone through clauses 10 to 14. The Committee Clerk will summarise the Committee's deliberations.

The Committee Clerk: As I go through the summary, if there are any issues or points that the officials feel that they can clarify quickly, please stop me and jump in.

During the closed session, the Chair went through clauses 10 to 14 and highlighted key points of the evidence that we have received for the Committee to be aware of and discuss. The Committee is, essentially, content with clause 10 at this stage. No particular queries were raised.

I have a fair few notes written down about clause 11. Not all of those may be issues; it was just to summarise the discussions. There seems to be some confusion in the evidence that we have received regarding fines related to prosecution and fixed penalty notice fines and whether the receipts from those could be redirected to particular aspects of work: for example, environmental work or work related to the issues for which individuals were fined. The Bill official —.

Mr McCormick: Sorry to stop you there. Fines taken through fixed penalty notices would go into the Consolidated Fund, so they would not come back to the Department. It is only where a person is prosecuted under the 1966 Act that that money comes into the Department.

The Committee Clerk: OK.

The Bill official gave us an example of a fixed penalty receipt in local government in the UK where the local authority can use fixed penalty receipts for certain purposes. We were given an example of legislation, should the Committee be minded to consider that. The Committee understands that it would be a relatively small pot compared with fines through prosecutions.

The Committee also discussed its understanding that fixed penalty notices can discharge liability. However, it is not an either/or situation, as clause 13(1)(j) would allow the Department to commence proceedings for an offence even if there has been a payment of an FPN. Is that understanding correct?

Mr McCormick: That is correct. The correspondence that was sent to you recently covers that and explains the situation. When we were drafting the powers, we looked at what was in the Marine and Coastal Access Act. We looked at the similar power in that Act and felt that it was more appropriate that we take it than not take it, in order to account for anything that might arise during the policy consultation stage and the development of the legislation.

The Committee Clerk: OK. Thank you.

There was also discussion about whether the Department will consider on a case-by-case basis what is proportionate in each case when deciding whether it would be an appropriate use of court time. That ties in with some of the evidence that we have received, which called for stronger measures than fixed penalty notices. Will the Department consider on a case-by-case basis whether a matter is suitable for a fixed penalty notice, prosecution or, in some case, both?

Mr McCormick: That will be taken forward in the policy development. It will become clearer as we move through that process.

The Committee Clerk: OK.

The Committee understands from its discussions that the Bill would not specifically tie the Department to the use of fixed penalty notices only for matters listed in that clause and that regulations will cover that in more detail. Is that understanding correct?

Mr McCormick: Yes.

The Committee Clerk: Thank you.

We had another brief discussion about the landing obligation. The Chair highlighted the Department's response that we received this week, which stated that nothing in the Bill would change the existing landing obligation. The Committee discussed the potential — we will write to you about this — of adding that clarification to the Bill as a belt-and-braces measure.

Mr McCormick: We will consider that when it comes to us.

The Committee Clerk: OK. Thank you.

The Committee received a proposed amendment from the British Hydropower Association to new clause 11. The Committee considered that but took the view that the matters were already covered in clause 13. The Committee has also received queries about further clarity, such as whether there is an appeal mechanism for FPNs. Again, we can write to you about that.

Mr McCormick: The basis for a fixed penalty notice is that you give the person the opportunity not to go through a criminal prosecution. If they do not accept the FPN, that is their way of appealing to have their day in court.

The Committee Clerk: We will probably write to you to get written clarification for the report.

There were some other proposals on stipulating offences in regulations rather than in the Bill, but the Committee felt that that would make the Bill less robust.

On clause 12, there was some discussion about why some offences in the previous clause under the 1966 Act are not listed in clause 12. Offences are specified in clause 11 for the 1966 Act but not in clause 12 for the Water Order. Will the Department comment on that?

Mr McCormick: As you can see, there are some offences in the 1966 Act for which it would not be suitable to give a fixed penalty notice. Take the likes of assault of a person: you cannot really give someone a fixed penalty notice if they have assaulted a person. We therefore took a more bespoke approach to the 1966 Act by specifying the offences.

The Committee Clerk: So, they are all covered.

Mr McCormick: In the 1966 Act? Yes.

The Committee Clerk: And the 1999 Act?

Mr McCormick: It covers all offences in the 1999 Act. Again, when we go through the development of the supporting legislation, it will become clear which ones we are looking at.

The Committee Clerk: On clause 13, the Committee discussed some matters that the Examiner of Statutory Rules highlighted, including the issue of clause 13(1)(j). We will probably put those in a letter because they relate to her legal advice.

Clause 13 refers only to the regulations provided for in clauses 11 and 12. We therefore received evidence that a £50,000 statutory ceiling for serious offending is not relevant to clause 13, because it refers only to the offences in clauses 11 and 12. Am I making sense? The regulations in clause 13 refer only to the regulations provided for in clauses 11 and 12. There was a query about an increased statutory ceiling of £50,000, but that is not relevant to that clause.

Mr McCormick: I do not think that, as we said, that is relevant to this.

The Committee Clerk: The Committee discussed the fact that some amendments that it received seemed excessive for a fixed penalty notice. Again, we will provide those amendments in a letter, and you can come back and comment on them. The Committee thought that they were more suitable for prosecutions and fines.

We then moved on to clause 14. We discussed the fact that the clause is fairly routine for fixed penalty notices and provides protection for persons to pay their fines within a 28-day period. Again, we discussed the fact that it is not an either/or in the Bill. It is not a fixed penalty notice or prosecution. There is scope to move from a fixed penalty notice to prosecution or to start at prosecution. The Department therefore has a good degree of flexibility. Is that understanding correct?

Mr McCormick: Yes.

The Committee Clerk: Thank you.

The Committee wanted to ask whether you had any idea at this stage of the values of fixed penalty notices. Will it depend on the offence? Will they be staggered? Will there be a table of offences?

Mr McCormick: That is yet to be developed. We will take the views of stakeholders and the Committee when we come to the policy development.

The Committee Clerk: OK. That is all that I have. Do any members want to delve into anything further?

The Chairperson (Ms D Armstrong): Thank you, Janice. Do members wish to ask any questions? No. OK. Thank you for being here, for briefing us and for answering the questions. Thank you very much indeed.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up