Official Report: Tuesday 17 November 2026
The Assembly met at 10:30 am (Mr Speaker in the Chair).
Members observed two minutes' silence.
Mrs Mason: As political unionism continues to tear itself apart, I ask a simple question today: who loses in all of this? Who pays the price for the DUP's political tantrums? I will tell you who it is: our children. Children are being used as political pawns by a party that simply cannot accept the democratic reality of a nationalist and republican First Minister. We have 90,000 children living in poverty who will benefit from measures to tackle holiday hunger, yet the DUP was content to stand in the way of that. Look at its priorities when it comes to funding. On the one hand, support is being cut for children going to their youth orchestra practice and, on the other, hundreds of thousands of pounds are being awarded to loyalist marching bands, many of which are linked to paramilitaries. What a shameful set of priorities.
Then we have the children who learn through the medium of Irish — children whose only crime, it would seem, is being educated through their own language. The DUP, aided and abetted by its lapdog Jon Burrows and little drummer boy Timmy, was prepared to weaponise a petition of concern to block legislation designed to support the education of those children and address the shortage of teachers in Irish-medium schools. What for? It was not because the legislation was wrong or because those children did not need that support; it was because, by its own admission, it wanted to punish Sinn Féin. Imagine being so consumed by political bitterness that you are prepared to punish schoolchildren in order to get at your political opponents.
That brings us to the heart of all this. Drumcree was never the real issue; it was the excuse. The real issue is that the DUP cannot stomach the fact that Michelle O'Neill — a nationalist, a republican and a woman — is our First Minister. It cannot accept that the days of unionist supremacy are over. Rather than accept democracy and equality, it would sooner frustrate government, block progress and make ordinary people suffer. I say this directly to those on the Benches opposite who are laughing: you are not punishing Sinn Féin; you are punishing children. You are punishing children who are living in poverty, children with musical talent and children who are learning through Irish. Those children are from all backgrounds.
That is not leadership. It is pathetic. That is not unionism standing up for its community; it is political failure, and children are paying the price. We will not stand by and allow the DUP to sacrifice our children's future on the altar of its political bitterness. Those days are gone, and there is no going back.
Mr Martin: Yesterday, chapter three of the Omagh bombing inquiry hearings came to a conclusion. On 15 August 1998, that bomb killed 29 people, including a woman who was pregnant with twins, and the Real IRA claimed responsibility. On that day, Protestants and Catholics were murdered together by terrorist action. Norman Baxter, a retired RUC chief superintendent, gave evidence to the inquiry yesterday. I will read into the record what was said:
"Q. And before the second of the ceasefires, so we think about 1994 being the first, and then we have the second, but prior to that was there, as far as you were aware, a high degree of cooperation between different republican terrorist groups?".
"A. ... at a senior level of Sinn Féin there was a degree of contact with Michael McKevitt"
— the Real IRA leader, who was responsible for the Omagh bomb —
"in terms of the bombing campaign. ... I think ... that the Sinn Féin leadership were content that there were bombs happening so that they could say to the British Government 'you can't push us too far' ... certainly the bombing campaign of ... 1998, was beneficial in the political negotiations Sinn Féin had with the British Government".
Yesterday, the Sinn Féin First Minister said that the Omagh bombing was "horrific" and that "That remains our position", although that clearly was not the Sinn Féin position in 1998. I would call on Sinn Féin members, elected or otherwise, to reveal to the police what they knew about the Omagh bomb, but we know that that will never happen. All comrades in arms.
I quote Michelle O'Neill directly on the IRA campaign:
"I think at the time there was no alternative".
Yesterday, the families' solicitor said:
"Children from Donegal died in Omagh. If this had happened in Kerry, Offaly or Kildare there would be public outrage and an immediate search for the truth. [The Republic of] Ireland has rightly demanded the truth from Britain for its own dead. It cannot demand in London what it refuses in Dublin."
He went on to say that the families:
"have been patient and reasonable. They gave the Irish Government the benefit of the doubt. They are done waiting. Silence is no longer available to the Taoiseach. This inquiry is coming. He can open it, or he can be brought to it."
I completely concur with those sentiments.
The families have now written formally to Taoiseach Micheál Martin demanding a statutory public inquiry in the Republic of Ireland. I intend to write to the Taoiseach to support the families' calls for that inquiry. I say this to those families: my party, the DUP, and I are so sorry for your loss, and we will do all that we can to ensure that the truth is brought into the open.
Ms Mulholland: Tomorrow is Fuel Poverty Awareness Day. I recognise the work that National Energy Action (NEA) has done to highlight the impact of cold homes on children's health and well-being. NEA's September 2026 polling found that 43% of households were spending more than a tenth of their income on energy. The figures for families with children were particularly troubling: more than 58,000 households with children under the age of 16 live in fuel poverty in Northern Ireland. Once housing costs are taken into account, almost half — 46% — of all households with children in that age group are affected. As a mother, I find those figures troubling. Children need somewhere warm to sleep, play and do their homework, and parents should be able to provide that without stressing about whether they will have to go without other essentials to provide it.
We all know that cold homes affect children's physical and mental health at a crucial stage of their development. In my constituency office, sadly, I hear all too often from constituents whose children have asthma, which is made so much worse by cold and damp homes, and from people with chronic illnesses who cannot recover because they live in substandard conditions. Repeated illnesses mean that children miss school and fall behind in their learning, leaving them struggling to catch up long after winter has passed.
In North Antrim, many families depend on heating oil. Finding the money up front for a delivery can be a serious obstacle when income is already stretched.
I welcome last week's announcement of stronger protections for heating oil consumers and want to see those proposals delivered promptly, but there is also the question of how people can afford to improve their homes. On Saturday, a constituent in Ballymoney was looking to install a heat pump. He had done his research but felt so penalised simply because he lived in Northern Ireland. Eligible households in England and Wales can receive £7,500 towards a heat pump through the boiler upgrade scheme: that scheme does not cover Northern Ireland. Our planned domestic energy efficiency and heat programme is not expected to launch until late 2027. People who want warmer homes and lower bills need affordable support to make those improvements. The cost of taking that first step must not put it beyond their reach.
For families in rural communities, living beyond the gas network should not mean being left behind as we move towards cleaner and more affordable energy. The warm healthy homes strategy needs to be properly resourced, with a warm healthy homes fund to invest in insulation. Families struggling with costs this winter need help now, and they need accessible emergency support, benefits advice and enough income to meet those essential costs. I thank the advice workers and community organisations who help people every day. Our ambition must be that every child should grow up in a warm, safe and healthy home.
Mr McGrath: This Thursday, 19 November, marks Carers' Rights Day, which is an important opportunity to shine a light on around a quarter of a million unpaid family carers in Northern Ireland who look after someone with an illness, a disability, an addiction or a frailty. They contribute £5·8 billion in equivalent health and social services here every year. Caring for somebody can boost our sense of well-being and mental health, but, when caring becomes more intense and round-the-clock, it often comes at a significant cost to the carer's own life, including their job, their education, their health and mental health, their free time and their social life. Nearly 70,000 people here provide over 50 hours of care each week.
Unpaid carers are not getting the support that they need in their caring roles. Carers NI says that 42% of carers do not receive social services support for themselves or their cared-for person. Nearly 60% have not received any kind of support from their GP, and over half feel that they have not been given sufficient information and advice from the healthcare system to care safely and well. Those are shocking statistics that show how carers have been left to pick up the pieces of a fragmented health service and have been left alone to just get on with it.
The theme of this year's Carers' Rights Day is identifying carers. Let that be the rallying call for us as politicians, for policymakers and for all of the health and social care profession to address the dire situation. Let us commit to proactively identifying unpaid carers in our society and ensuring that we work to provide the appropriate services, support and help that they so richly deserve.
Mr Boggs: Before I make my statement, I declare an interest as a school governor.
Last week, some 300 schools across the North again received emails directly to their inboxes that threatened the school building. That again sent a real sense of fear and panic throughout the school community. Again, school principals and staff were impacted on and left in the unenviable position of having to decide what to do with their cohort of children, their staff and the wider school community. Parents were left wondering about the safety of their children. Some were anxious, and those who contacted my constituency office certainly felt that they were being left in the dark and did not really know what was going on. They could see that schools across the area were doing different things, through no fault of the principals or the staff. Since then, there have been children who clearly have been left wondering what is happening because, in one small classroom, some children were being picked up by parents and some were not. Children were then asking teachers and classroom assistants why they were not being picked up, why the child who sits beside them was leaving to go home and why so many people were doing so many different things. That left staff in a difficult position, again having to explain those circumstances.
School principals, fellow governors, staff and parents whom I have spoken to are asking what has changed in the approach from the Education Authority (EA) and the Department since the previous threatening email that was sent to schools. It seems clear that absolutely nothing has changed. No clear guidance has been provided to schools. Schools have not been given more concrete direction on what to do. As I said, that has resulted in a situation in which the school at the top of the road is doing one thing while the school at the bottom of the road is doing another. That is an untenable position.
School staff are expected to wear many different hats, but principals, teachers and governors should not be expected to be security experts as well. I call on the EA, the Minister of Education and the Department to produce clear, unequivocal guidance for school leaders about what they should do, because the Minister himself has recognised that it could happen again.
Mrs Dodds: November is Lung Cancer Awareness Month. Northern Ireland does not have a lung cancer screening programme, so I am highlighting the urgent need to introduce targeted lung cancer screening. Lung cancer remains the biggest cancer killer in our society. Far too many people are diagnosed when the disease has already reached an advanced stage, when treatment options are more limited and outcomes significantly worse. Cancer Research UK has revealed that 71% of lung cancers in Northern Ireland are diagnosed at a late stage. That statistic should concern every Member. We know that, when lung cancer is diagnosed at stage 1, more than half of those people survive for five years or more. By stage 4, however, the survival rate falls dramatically to just 2%. That is a really stark statistic for all of us to consider. Behind every statistic is a person: a husband, a wife, a parent, a grandparent, a colleague or a friend. Every lung cancer death is a loved one lost, and we must never underestimate the human cost.
There is also an economic cost. Cancer Research UK has estimated that each lung cancer death results in an average productivity loss of around £32,000 a year. With hundreds of families affected by lung cancer, those losses accumulate rapidly.
In England, screening is helping to detect cancers earlier, when treatment is more likely to be successful. Importantly, it is also reaching people in communities that have historically experienced poorer health outcomes and higher smoking rates. In doing so, lung screening is helping to tackle some of the deepest health inequalities in our society.
Cancer Research UK also estimates that a lung cancer screening programme could save around 70 lives a year in Northern Ireland. That is a significant number that we must all consider. The evidence for screening is now substantial. It can save lives, reduce inequalities, support our health service and deliver meaningful economic benefits. This is the only part of the United Kingdom not to have a lung cancer screening programme, so I urge the Minister of Health to consider introducing one to be his most urgent responsibility.
Miss McAllister: Advancements in medical technology give us an opportunity to shorten recovery times and tackle waiting lists. It is magnificent that such changes are happening across the world, but, unfortunately, they are not happening in good time. Northern Ireland has seen a rise in the use of advanced medical technology, but its use has not always been equal when it comes to gender healthcare.
I first spoke in the Chamber almost two and a half years ago about the Belfast Trust's da Vinci robot and about how more than 240 patients were receiving healthcare using that new state-of-the-art technology.
The gender breakdown of those patients, however, was just 40 women and the rest male. That was no surprise, of course, because it was commissioned for the urology department. On asking questions of the Department of Health and the Belfast Trust, we were told that that was because it was only the urology team that specialised and was trained in that advanced medical technology and that could use it to offer the care needed. That is simply untrue. We were previously approached by senior clinicians from the gynaecological department of the Belfast Trust who had also specifically requested, and wanted a business case approved for, the same robot.
I am not suggesting that medical misogyny in Northern Ireland is intentional, but it has been happening for years. That is why, working with senior clinicians over the past two and a half years, we have written to the Department of Health, the Minister, the Belfast Trust and the Western, Northern, South Eastern and South trusts asking when the teams in their gynaecological departments would receive such a robot to ensure that there was equal access to care. I am delighted that, in the past six months, a robot has been commissioned at the Belfast Trust and two other trusts, and that robots will soon be rolled out to every trust in Northern Ireland specifically for women's healthcare — not exclusively but specifically. It is important that we ensure that that robot is used to drive down waiting lists and shorten recovery times.
It is unfortunate, however, that it took a Member to bring the issue to the Department of Health and the trusts to ensure that medical misogyny was examined in detail. Whilst that is a massive achievement for women across Northern Ireland, we are yet to see a specific women's health action plan, despite being promised that in one of the first motions brought to the Chamber when we returned in 2024.
Mr Gildernew: No one should spend the last months of their life worrying about whether they can afford to keep their home warm or run the medical equipment that they rely on. In its recent report, 'Dying in Poverty 2026', Marie Curie estimates that 2,800 people in the North experience income poverty in the final year of life, which is a desperately sad statistic that should stir us all to action. In the report, it is stated that around 5,000 people experience fuel poverty in their final year of life; that is almost 1:3 people across the North. In my Mid Ulster District Council area, 25% of working age people in their final year of life were estimated to be in fuel poverty. Behind those figures are real people facing some of the hardest news and darkest days of their lives. They should never have to face financial hardship on top of that.
A terminal diagnosis can mean having to give up work just as the bills begin to rise. The heating may need to stay on day and night. There are more journeys to appointments and more washing, and, sometimes, medical equipment needs to run round the clock. For someone on a fixed income or pension, there may be very little room to absorb those costs, and the last thing that families caring for someone they love should be doing is worrying about and wondering how they will pay the next bill. The Executive's warm healthy homes strategy 2026-2036 recognises that people at the end of life have particular energy needs. The Minister for Communities needs to say now how he will turn that commitment into practical help, what support will be available this winter and how people will get it quickly.
Sinn Féin believes that people with a terminal illness should be prioritised for emergency help and that benefits should be fast-tracked for them and their carers. We believe that the winter fuel payment should be extended to people with a terminal illness regardless of age. Such people should also be targeted for help with energy bills that reaches households that rely on home heating oil. A person of working age who has to give up their job because they are dying should not be left without enough income to meet their basic needs.
I thank Marie Curie for the work that it does day and daily throughout our community, for listening to families and for asking me to bring its experience into the Chamber today. People should be able to spend the time that they have left in warmth and dignity with the people they love. That is the least that they deserve.
Mr Dunne: I warmly congratulate Donaghadee Community Development Association (DCDA) on receiving the prestigious King's Award for Voluntary Service at the weekend. It is a tremendous achievement, a fitting tribute and a proud moment for the Donaghadee community and, indeed, the wider north Down area. The award is the highest form of recognition that His Majesty can give to a local voluntary group in our United Kingdom and is equivalent to an MBE. It recognises the truly outstanding contribution made by the dedicated volunteers who give their time, energy, commitment and passion to making a positive difference in Donaghadee all year round.
Since becoming an MLA, I have had the privilege of seeing first-hand the dedication and enthusiasm of those involved with the association. Donaghadee is a town with a strong community spirit and passion, and the association has played a key role in nurturing that over the years. The association has been the heartbeat behind so much positivity in community life in the town. From its annual summer festivals to keeping the town in award-winning bloom, Christmas festivals and championing the campaign to end violence against women and girls — an issue that has, sadly, impacted on Donaghadee even in recent years — the DCDA has been front and centre in all of that for many years.
The association's work also benefits the many visitors who enjoy coming to the town from around the world, many of whom have been encouraged by the success of 'Hope Street' going out across the globe.
I recognise and thank the wider network of volunteers, local businesses, community organisations and supporters who work alongside the association all year round. The award reflects the collective effort of so many people who care deeply about Donaghadee. It would be remiss of me not to mention the sterling work of Mr John Caldwell BEM, the association's honorary secretary, in leading the association in so many ways over many years.
The award is thoroughly deserved and is testament to the hard work, dedication and community spirit of everyone involved. Congratulations once again to Donaghadee Community Development Association.
Mr Gaston: At the weekend, the leader of the "O'Neill Must Stay" campaign warned unionism that, under Westminster control, Northern Ireland would have a "radical woke agenda" foisted on it. If Gavin Robinson wishes to argue for the need for devolution on that point, he would do well to look at the part that his party plays in enabling Stormont's radical woke policies.
Let us consider the toilet policy in this very Building. It is a policy based on self-identification that allows men to use the female bathrooms, approved by the Assembly Commission after consultation with the disgraced Stonewall. I have only to look at the 'Civil Service Inclusive Language Guide' to see how captured Stormont really is. That guide was introduced under this Executive. It advises people to use "partner" instead of terms such as "wife" and "girlfriend". It says that using "Christian name" can be "disrespectful" and should be avoided. It recommends using "humankind" instead of "mankind" and suggests using the title "Mx" for:
"people who do not identify with a binary gender."
Where was the attempt to stop that guide, which applies across the Civil Service? Where was the attempt to stop it around the hallowed Executive table? Let us consider the home of wokery in Stormont: the Executive Office. That Department, jointly headed by the DUP and Sinn Féin, has no agreed position on what a woman is. It issues surveys with response options including "male", "female" and "other". It funds the Equality Commission, which is seeking to prevent the For Women Scotland judgement from being applied in Northern Ireland.
What is the Equality Commission's argument on that point? It states that the situation in Northern Ireland is different because of the protocol, as though the meaning of "male" and "female" changes on a boat somewhere between Cairnryan and Belfast, in the middle of the Irish Sea. Far from protecting us from the "radical woke agenda", Stormont has presided over its enforcement and, indeed, advancement on the people of Northern Ireland.
For far too long, the liberal elite sitting in this Chamber has been captured by the noisy minority. It is time for less wokery. It is time to reinstall some Christian conservative principles into our decision-making.
Mr Speaker: As Chairman of the Assembly Commission, I wish to correct you, Mr Gaston: the decision in relation to the toilets was taken when the Assembly was down by the senior management team, not by the Assembly Commission.
Mr Buckley: St Mark's Church in Portadown has literally been a centrepiece in the modern history of my local town. It is a familiar landmark and has been a key part of the town's identity. At the weekend, it celebrated a special anniversary: its bicentenary. It has existed for 200 years since its official opening in 1826. The church was a church plant that spawned from the ancient church of Drumcree. It has been, literally, a physical presence for those of a Christian perspective and, indeed, those who look to the town for its landmark for all those years. It has been a spiritual, social and community hub for the people of Portadown. It has been a place of worship, fellowship, comfort and support for so many local families; indeed, few institutions can claim to have witnessed so much of our modern local history. It has seen wars — the Boer War, the First World War and the Second World War — and many anniversaries since. Its town clock centrepiece stands as a memorial to those who made the supreme sacrifice in the First World War. Portadown has suffered grievously at the hands of terrorism over the years. The church stood as a community focal point when an IRA bomb exploded in the town.
Such is the resilience of the Portadown community and such is the welcoming home at St Mark's that, alongside colleagues, I was proud to attend its bicentenary service at the weekend. I pay particular tribute to Rev William Orr, the current rector, and those who have served in that position over the 200-year period. Their dedication and leadership have helped sustain the important continuity of Christian worship in our town throughout the generations. I also welcome and recognise the contributions of those who sometimes receive less attention but serve in equally important roles, without whom the church would not function: the select vestry, parishioners, volunteers, sextons, musical directors, administrators and everyone else who gives of their time voluntarily to ensure that St Mark's stays at the centre of our community. I congratulate all those associated with it and wish them well for the next 200 years.
That Mrs Julie Middleton replace Mr Peter Martin as a member of the Committee for the Economy and that Mr Peter Martin replace Mrs Julie Middleton as a member of the Committee for Education. — [Mr Clarke.]
Mr Speaker: I have received notice from the Minister of Finance that he wishes to make a statement. I encourage Members to be concise in asking their questions.
Mr O'Dowd (The Minister of Finance): I welcome the opportunity to update the Assembly on the ongoing engagement with the British Government about the Executive's Budget and to set out the latest position on the Executive's level of relative funding following the autumn Budget 2026. I have been working consistently not only to get to the point where the Executive can agree a Budget but to ensure that it is done on a multiyear basis. We are all agreed on the benefits of that for long-term planning and the delivery of stable public services. I remain determined to get to that point.
Let me set out the reality, however. The reality is that, following the autumn Budget, we were expected to be underfunded below 124% in every year of this spending review period. The reality is that around one third of the financial package on offer will be required just to bring us back to the level of funding agreed by the Westminster Government. That would mean the Executive continuing to be trapped in a cycle of drifting from one short-term cash injection to the next and continuing to be underfunded relative to other devolved regions. That is not a platform for fiscal stability; it is a continuation of the very instability that must be addressed.
The Executive have a plan for the reform and transformation of public services. It is a plan that means better public service delivery, better outcomes for the public and more efficient delivery of services. We have seen the improvements that are possible in the health service, for instance, through focused investment in reform and transformation. There are plans in place for continued reform across the public sector. However, the Executive will continue to be constrained in their ability to deliver those reforms for as long as the current pattern of underfunding persists.
The funding on offer does not provide equitable treatment when compared with other devolved regions. Members will have heard me repeatedly make the case for fairer funding and highlight the fact that we are not funded on a basis comparable to Scotland and Wales. As part of the autumn Budget, Treasury provided its assessment of our relative funding per head position across the spending review. Treasury’s own assessment shows that we are underfunded relative to our current estimate of need for 2027-28 and 2028-29. My officials' analysis indicates that we are also underfunded this year and, therefore, in each year of the spending review. Updated calculations show that, if the North were funded on a basis comparable to Scotland, it would have, on average, around £3·2 billion in additional funding per annum and, if funded on a basis comparable to Wales, would receive around £1·5 billion more per annum over the spending review period.
Not only are the Executive unfairly funded compared with Wales and Scotland but they have been denied the other fiscal tools that those Administrations have at their disposal, which help them to achieve a balanced Budget. I ask this question: why will the British Government not allow the Housing Executive borrowing powers similar to the arrangements for councils in England and Wales? Those powers would allow the Housing Executive to carry out much-needed investment in its 80,000 homes. They have never adequately answered that question. What is clear, therefore, is that the Executive do not have a Budget problem as much as a problem with the persistent failure of Westminster Governments to fund this place properly or on a fair basis. That problem has been compounded by the mismanagement of the economy by successive Westminster Administrations through policies that do economic harm, chief among which are Brexit and austerity.
There has been extensive engagement with London since February of this year, when the open-book exercise commenced. In July, Departments provided detailed evidence on financial pressures, savings, efficiencies, priorities and transformation. Further evidence was provided in September and October, including direct discussions with accounting officers on financial pressures, actions taken and transformation timescales. Most recently — in November — there were talks at Hillsborough. I am not sure how much more information the Treasury needs to verify the reality of the pressures that we face; indeed, it is its own analysis that verifies that we are being underfunded. Further, the British Secretary of State, Chris Bryant, has yet to explain privately or publicly why we are not being afforded the same treatment as our colleagues in Scotland and Wales. That is despite being asked the question directly by me, other Ministers, political parties and the media. At every turn, more information is requested, further discussions are proposed and more obstacles are placed in the way of the Executive agreeing a Budget that meets the needs of people here. The Executive are committed to playing their part, but London must play its part too. Additional funding or appropriate funding flexibility is needed to bridge the gap while those plans take effect.
The challenge that we face is not unique to the North. Delivering public services is a challenge across Europe, as evidenced by the strikes in the South of Ireland and unrest in Europe, reflecting the realities of delivering public services in today's world. The difference is that our delivery is made harder by the choices of the British Government to underfund us in respect of our 124% assessment of need, which they signed up to provide, and in respect of Professor Holtham's independent report, which demonstrates a need level of 128%. Despite agreeing to engage on Professor Holtham's report with the Executive in June last year, the British Government have yet to honour that pledge.
Suggestions that we could address those pressures simply by raising more revenue or delivering further efficiencies, oversimplify the challenges that we face. Indeed, if you were to listen to the Secretary of State, Chris Bryant, you would think that the Executive do not raise any revenue. As Members will be aware, as it stands, the regional rate is the main available lever to the Executive to raise income. For context, if we wanted to raise an additional £100 million, that would require raising the regional rate by 11%. Closing the shortfall would, therefore, require an increase of several times that size. It is neither realistic nor fair to expect households or businesses to face rates rises of that scale while the Executive remain underfunded. The Secretary of State may well believe that the answer is to put further pressure on families and businesses that are already struggling, but I do not. People here pay their taxes and rightly want and deserve access to good-quality public services.
The Executive's desire is to grow the economy locally and improve the standard of living of all our citizens, but household incomes and business profitability are generally lower than in most parts of England, meaning that the scope to generate additional revenue locally is more constrained and the impact on citizens and businesses is proportionately greater. Any expectation that locally generated revenue can be a substitute for a fair and sustainable funding settlement is, therefore, unrealistic and unfair.
As I have said repeatedly, fair funding is at the heart of the matter. Around one third of the currently proposed financial package is required on its own to merely bring the Executive to the 124% level of need. That does not begin to consider the application of Professor Holtham's central assessment of our need at 128%, including agriculture. Previous one-off packages have left us facing a cliff edge and have led us to the current situation because the fundamental point of fair funding has never been addressed. Throughout the engagements with the Westminster Government, I have repeatedly made the comparison between the Executive's level of funding and that afforded to our devolved colleagues in Scotland and Wales.
The situation has now deteriorated further. There is a significant funding gap. The amount of money that the Executive now require from the Government to maintain and sustain our public services, pay our public-sector workers and grow our economy is insignificant when you compare it with the amounts available to the British Government. We are talking about a sovereign Government and hundreds of millions of pounds, but they continually underfund this place, both against our level of need and in comparison with other jurisdictions. The financial package in its totality provides only the additional funding that the Executive will receive in one year, if funded on a comparable basis to Wales. That demonstrates how the proposed financial package fails to meet the test of fairness and equal treatment for families, workers and businesses here when compared with Wales and Scotland. If we had the same treatment as Scotland and Wales, we would have the fiscal headroom to make the investment needed to drive transformational change, leading to longer-term fiscal sustainability.
People here want to see public services funded properly; they want to see nurses, healthcare workers and other public-sector workers get their pay award uplift; they want families to be able to access the support that they need; and they want the investment that will help to grow our economy. I have written to the Chief Secretary to the Treasury and the Secretary of State setting out my concerns on the widening disparity. We need to move beyond the cycle of short-term financial interventions that have constrained long-term planning and investment in the transformation of public services.
As Finance Minister, I will continue to stand up for public services, workers, families and businesses. I have made it clear, publicly and privately, that securing a pay uplift for public-sector workers has been my priority. My focus remains on delivering a pay uplift for our health workers, teachers, police, civil servants and all other public-sector workers.
Mr O'Toole: Minister, this is a shambles and a disgrace. You talk about reality, but the reality is that you — not anybody else — published a draft Budget in January this year and told the Executive parties to sign up to it. The reality is that you say that you support workers, but they cannot get a pay rise because the Executive will not set a Budget in time for Christmas. You say that you want the economy to grow; the reality is that the Executive are cutting the funding for further education colleges and universities and for skills because you cannot agree a Budget. We have always supported the Executive's calls for more money, and we still do, but if the Executive refuse to set a Budget, one of two things will happen. Either the UK Government will set a punishment Budget or the Executive will run out of money. I suspect, Minister, that you want them to set a punishment Budget so that you can shift blame. Which is it?
Mr O'Dowd: Are you a spokesperson for the people of South Belfast and the people of the North —
Mr O'Dowd: — or are you a spokesperson for Chris Bryant?
Mr O'Dowd: You are defending the indefensible. I set out clearly in my statement that the British Government, who you are standing up for, are underfunding this place not only compared with Scotland and Wales but contrary to the agreement that they signed up to. The British Government agree with me that, at a bare minimum, the level of funding for this place should be 124%. Current funding is somewhere around 123%, yet you say, "That's OK. Go ahead and set a Budget".
Everybody in the Chamber and around the Executive table should be united in one call, which is that the British Government have a responsibility to fund this place properly. They are failing to do so, and you are a disgrace.
Ms Forsythe (The Deputy Chairperson of the Committee for Finance): The DUP has long campaigned for fair funding for Northern Ireland. All Ministers have been united in that call in recent negotiations. Minister, I agree with your statement. The time for cliff edges and sticking plasters is over. Do you agree that, in addition to the quantum of funding required for here, we need to see urgent progress made on Northern Ireland Housing Executive borrowing and on access to the National Wealth Fund?
Mr O'Dowd: I agree. The people of the North, be they public-sector workers or those who rely on our public services, should not have had to go through the past 10 months, during which we have engaged with successive Secretaries of State and successive Chief Secretaries to the Treasury about achieving a fair and sustainable settlement for this place.
A year ago, the British Government signed up to the Holtham report, which states that this place should be funded at a minimum of 124%. Today, we are being funded below that. The Holtham report states that, ideally, we should be funded up to 128%, including agriculture, but we are not being funded to that level. Scotland and Wales are being funded to above their level of need, and, by the way, I do not begrudge them that money. They are entitled to receive proper funding for their public services, but we are fighting to get the bare minimum. Well, some of us are fighting, while others are trying to make party politics out of it.
The Deputy Chair makes a very good point. It is not just about fiscal funding. We are not given equal access to the National Wealth Fund. As part of the Budget, a number of weeks ago, the British Government pumped billions of pounds into the National Wealth Fund. The Executive, our businesses and our councils do not have equal access to that fund.
Councils in England and Wales can access borrowing at a much lower rate for housing and improvements to housing than the Housing Executive or the Executive here can. The British Government are denying us access. It is therefore a fairness issue. It is about getting fair and equal treatment for the people whom we represent.
[Translation: I thank the Minister]
for his statement and for making it very clear that the North is not fairly funded compared with Scotland and Wales or to our level of need, be that 124% or Professor Holtham's 128%. Can the Minister provide an update on the engagement that has taken place on a fiscal framework?
Mr O'Dowd: Again, that is a commitment that the British Government made over a year ago and have not lived up to. Rightly, many of the discussions have been about the amount of funding that we receive to allow us to invest in day-to-day public services and to grow our economy. As I have said repeatedly in the Chamber, we are significantly underfunded for that.
The fiscal framework is about creating financial stability for this place and allowing us to maintain, grow and transform our public services and grow our economy. What should a fiscal framework look like? From my point of view, it should include fiscal devolution, as recommended by the Fiscal Commission, which set out a number of tax-varying powers that should be devolved to the Executive. I accept that others do not agree with that, but it is a discussion that should be taking place with the Treasury and the British Government and among ourselves, because we continually lag behind.
As part of the Westminster Budget, the British Government announced that they will give councils tax-varying powers. They will give councils tax-varying powers, yet the Executive cannot get tax-varying powers to create fairness and equality across the board. That would also allow us to set out a pathway to financial stability.
The British Government and successive Secretaries of State have lectured the Executive about taxing people more. They have said, "Introduce water charges. Increase your rates. Do this. Do that. Introduce prescription charges", etc. All those things are decisions for the Executive to make, and the Executive have decided not to do a number of them. That does not, however, alleviate the British Government's responsibility to properly fund this place.
Mr Burrows: I support the case for fair funding, but also for responsible spending and accountability. Just today, the Audit Office has released a report that states that £5·1 million was wasted on a botched MOT procurement contract — procurement that your Department oversees. What steps are you taking to radically reform procurement in this country so that we get value for money and have more credibility when we speak to the Treasury and ask for more money?
Mr O'Dowd: It is not a case of either/or. Of course, there should be efficient and effective service delivery across our public sector. I make that case regularly around the Executive table and here in the Chamber. All Ministers and their arm's-length bodies have a responsibility to run an efficient, effective service. The Member refers to the report on the Driver and Vehicle Agency (DVA). That report also mentions that lessons are being learned by Construction and Procurement Delivery (CPD). Further lessons from that case need not only to be learned but to be implemented. We have to ensure that every penny that we spend is used wisely and effectively.
Mr Boggs: I thank the Minister for the statement. Minister, I welcome your restatement that lumping further pressure on already hard-pressed workers and families is not your answer — people here pay their taxes and deserve proper public services — and also that revenue raising, on its own, is not a substitute for a fair funding model. Some people seem to think that it is. What do the Executive seek from the ongoing negotiations with the British Government?
Mr O'Dowd: We seek a fair, sustainable funding package that brings us up to the very minimum — the level of need — and allows us to maintain and sustain our public services. We seek engagement and delivery on the commitment that was made a year ago on the fiscal framework to include access to the National Wealth Fund, Housing Executive borrowing and, in my opinion, fiscal devolution through tax-varying powers for the Executive.
We are looking at a broad package. We are also looking at baselining of funding, because, as I said in my statement, we have come to this cliff edge far too often. The British Government come to the point where they accept that there is a shortage of funding from them to the Executive, they provide short-term funding and the Executive do their best to move forward with that. We always reach that cliff edge. As I say, it is absolutely unforgivable that the Government and others have allowed that drama to develop over the past nine to 10 months. They are breaching their own agreement on the 124% level of need here. It is not the first time, and I suspect that it will not be the last, that the British Government breach an agreement. They are breaching their own agreement.
Mrs Dodds: Thank you for the update, Minister. You will not find any argument on this side of the House against the need for fair funding for Northern Ireland, particularly from us when it comes to the need to fund public-sector pay settlements.
However, there is a two-way process, and accountability is also very important. Three weeks ago, the Health Committee got a paper that talked about four projects that are run by the Belfast Trust, all of which are late, millions or tens of millions of pounds over budget, and delaying work on capital projects in constituencies like ours — at Craigavon Area Hospital, for example — because of overspends. Where is the accountability, Minister, particularly in Health, where the Executive ring-fenced £80 million for health waiting lists? Last week, we learned that just over half of that will be spent on health waiting lists. The rest will be spent on the thrombectomy service, more training places for dentists and a cancer charity's grant funding, but not on waiting lists, which people expect to be shorter.
Mr O'Dowd: The accountability comes from various directions. The Audit Office has been mentioned. However, I regularly listen to and see the Health Committee holding the Health Department to account. Members around the Chamber are members of Committees. They know only too well the good work that goes on in those Committees. I will also engage, and have been engaging, with the Health Minister. My officials engage regularly with Health officials, for example — and with officials from all Departments — on the proper and effective use of funding. We cannot afford to waste a single penny of public funding.
Across the board, we have seen failings in the delivery of major capital projects. We have to improve those across the board and ensure that delivery is time-bound and within the financial envelope that is forecast, so that we can use funding elsewhere. The Member mentioned Craigavon Area Hospital and other projects. However, it is not a question of either/or. There is a duty on the Government to deliver the amount of money that we require to sustain and deliver our public services, and there is a duty on us, as elected representatives, to hold all our spending bodies to account and ensure that we are getting efficiency and effectiveness for every pound that we spend.
Mrs Erskine: Minister, the MOT, as you know, is my 'Mastermind' subject now, and today's Northern Ireland Audit Office report points to the fact that the Driver and Vehicle Agency is looking at lessons learned, but how do we implement that? The report says that at the time of its review and publication, the lessons learned had not been put on the legal lessons learned register. That concerns me, because, today, we are talking about the transformation of public services. That was a public service transformation project in the DVA. We have had successive Audit Office reports now. When will Departments speed up in learning the lessons and implementing what the Northern Ireland Audit Office actually says?
Mr O'Dowd: I will not go into the detail of the Audit Office report because, first, it may end up in the PAC, and secondly, I have no doubt that the Infrastructure Committee will also want to look at it. There will be opportunities for the Infrastructure Minister and others to respond in due course to that. However, we can all agree on the basic principle. If there are lessons to be learned — there are lessons to be learned from that report, and some have been learned — they have to be implemented, and we have to ensure that that implementation goes right across our public sector and that people learn the lessons to ensure that we save and use our public finances effectively and efficiently. However, do not divert attention from where it needs to be at this moment. Your constituents are being funded significantly less than Chris Bryant's constituents are being funded in Wales.
Mr O'Dowd: I am not suggesting that the Member is diverting attention, but the constituents of Chris Bryant, the Secretary of State for this place, are receiving £1·5 billion more, today, than your constituents are. [Interruption.]
Over the past three weeks, that gap has grown by over half a billion pounds, and the Secretary of State is tweeting and challenging the Executive and me, as Finance Minister, to go away and tax citizens here more. He needs to give his head a shake.
Mrs Dillon: I thank the Minister for his answers so far. I remind the leader of the Opposition that, 19 years ago, in 2007, the SDLP spoke to a motion — your party may have been one of the sponsors of it — that sought to devolve fiscal powers to the Assembly. Your colleagues were in the Executive at the time but did not trust themselves with fiscal powers, and, given your statement this morning, they were right not to do so.
Minister, you have, I will say, questioned the British Secretary of State's integrity, rather than outline his dishonesty. He has stated that we will remain funded above 126% in all the years of the spending review. Do you think that that is factual? If so, would we be able to do all the things that we have talked about here this morning?
Mr O'Dowd: In the absence of the financial package, we are funded below 124%, so Chris Bryant's tweet is inaccurate.
With the financial package, we are still funded well below Professor Holtham's recommendation, which was 128% including agriculture, and we are significantly underfunded compared with Chris Bryant's constituents.
Why is it fair that Chris Bryant's constituents are funded significantly above the level of need but your constituents in Mid Ulster are funded below the level of need? I know that the leader of the Opposition has been standing up for Chris Bryant and others around this, but that is a huge mistake. We need unity of purpose in this place. We need to stand up for our constituents. Chris Bryant can stand up for himself. We need to stand up for our constituents.
Mr Chambers: Thank you, Minister, for your statement. I welcome your comments on how your focus is on delivering a pay uplift for health workers, teachers, the police, civil servants and other public-sector workers. What is the doomsday outcome for that aspiration if no further funding becomes available? We have all talked about and agreed on the impact on public services that is coming down the line. As an example, I fear for policing, as the PSNI claims to have a current deficit of £80 million. What will policing look like as we come towards the end of this financial year? Minister, would it be helpful if your party's MPs were in the House of Commons now, making our case?
Mr O'Dowd: I am sure that your party's MP is making the case, but is anybody listening to him at Westminster? I suggest not. That is a political argument that you and I can have another time.
A lot of figures and facts are floating about today, and I am sure that the general public are wondering how we keep track of all that. However, the general principle that we need to keep an eye on is that this is about fairness and equality. If Chris Bryant's constituents can receive £1·5 billion above their level of need, why can your constituents not receive that? Why are my constituents, your constituents and other Members' constituents being funded below their level of need, which means that the Executive, as the responsible authority, are trying to do more with less?
You mentioned pay uplifts for public-sector workers and health workers. Those need to be delivered. I see nobody around the Executive table who is opposed to delivering them, but we need a mechanism and the quantity of funding that allow us to do it. Were I the Finance Minister in Wales, I could do that, because Wales is funded £1·5 billion above its level of need. However, I am Finance Minister for here, and our Secretary of State, who is a Welshman, refuses to listen to the justifiable case that we have.
Mr McGrath: Minister, you have set Budgets in the past few years when we were equally underfunded. Setting a Budget is your responsibility, and not doing so will either prevent Departments from being able to spend or cause the British to set a punishment Budget. One wonders whether your "tough Minister" approach is because an election is coming up. Is the statement, which tells us little, saying to healthcare workers, who are on the ground working daily, that no pay uplift will be coming for them any time soon?
Mr O'Dowd: I heard not one word of challenge to the British Government or to the Secretary of State from the SDLP spokesperson in regard to the British Government's responsibilities. Who is on an election footing: me or you? I suspect that it is you, because, if you were not on an election footing, you would join the united response of the Executive and other parties in the Chamber. You stand alone. The SDLP stands alone on the issue as a spokesperson for Chris Bryant. As I said to others, Chris Bryant can speak for himself. He has a Twitter account and does all sorts of magical things through social media. You do not need to speak for him. Speak for yourselves, and stand up for your constituents.
Mr Speaker: That concludes questions on the ministerial statement.
Mr O'Toole: On a point of order, Mr Speaker. Will you confirm that the job of the official Opposition is to question Ministers of the Northern Ireland Executive in this place? I chair the Finance Committee, and, for the record, given that the Finance Minister made a lot of this, it is seeking to get Chris Bryant before the Committee so that we can ask him precisely the tough questions that the Minister talked about. It is, however, our job in the Chamber to ask Ministers questions. Is that correct?
Mr Speaker: The Member has made a point of order clarifying what, he believes, his role is. That is fair enough.
Mr Speaker: I call the Minister for Infrastructure, Liz Kimmins, to move the Further Consideration Stage of the Water, Sustainable Drainage and Flood Management Bill.
Moved. — [Ms Kimmins (The Minister for Infrastructure).]
Mr Speaker: As no amendments have been tabled, there is no opportunity to discuss the Water, Sustainable Drainage and Flood Management Bill today. Members will, of course, be able to have a full debate at Final Stage.
The Further Consideration Stage of the Water, Sustainable Drainage and Flood Management Bill is therefore concluded. The Bill stands referred to the Speaker.
Mr Speaker: I call the Minister for the Economy, Dr Caoimhe Archibald, to move the Further Consideration Stage of the Petroleum Exploration and Licensing (Repeal) Bill.
Moved. — [Dr Archibald (The Minister for the Economy).]
Mr Speaker: As no amendments have been tabled, there is no opportunity to discuss the Petroleum Exploration and Licensing (Repeal) Bill today. Members will, of course, be able to have a full debate at Final Stage.
The Further Consideration Stage of the Petroleum Exploration and Licensing (Repeal) Bill is therefore concluded. The Bill stands referred to the Speaker.
That the Pension Schemes Bill proceed under the accelerated passage procedure.
Mr Speaker: The Business Committee has agreed that there should be no time limit on the debate.
Mr Lyons: I welcome the opportunity to address the Assembly on the motion. I do not ask lightly for the use of accelerated passage and do so only in exceptional circumstances. Such circumstances exist for this Bill. When taking forward legislation, my preference is to have a full Committee Stage to enable clause-by-clause scrutiny and informed discussion on matters arising. However, for this Bill, there are compelling grounds for a departure from the normal procedure and for the use of accelerated passage.
(Mr Deputy Speaker [Mr Blair] in the Chair)
The Bill is vital legislation and will ensure that Northern Ireland pension savers benefit from the same improvements to the pension system as people elsewhere in the United Kingdom. As required by Standing Order 42(4), I will explain my reasons for seeking accelerated passage and the consequences if it is not granted.
While the regulation of pensions is a devolved matter, in general, Northern Ireland's pensions policy and legislation operate in line with corresponding pension provision in GB, as provided for in section 87 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998. In effect, there is a single pension system and regulatory regime across the UK; indeed, many private pension schemes operating in Northern Ireland are UK-wide schemes. The Westminster Pension Schemes Act 2026 received Royal Assent on 29 April, and the UK Government have already begun to develop the necessary subordinate legislation to give effect to many of the measures in the Act, with the first set of regulations due to become operational in April next year. That, in essence, sets a deadline for the enactment of a corresponding Northern Ireland Bill. All Assembly stages need to be completed at the beginning of 2027 to allow Royal Assent to be attained before April. That is essential to ensure that any operational divergence and adverse impacts on Northern Ireland retirement savers can be avoided. The timescales are extremely challenging. That is why I seek Assembly agreement to the use of accelerated passage.
I had hoped to be in a position to bring forward the legislative proposals much earlier in the mandate, but, unfortunately, several issues impacted significantly on the progression of the work. In March of this year, the Executive had agreed to admit the Bill into the legislative programme and to engage the Office of the Legislative Counsel (OLC) to draft it. However, delays during the passage of the Westminster Act significantly reduced the time available to progress the corresponding Northern Ireland Bill. The compressed timetable has been further impacted on by the need to consider the interaction between devolved pensions policy and reserved financial matters that fall within the Treasury's remit and to ensure that the legislation remains aligned with the policy intent of the corresponding GB provisions. Resolving those issues has required extensive engagement by my officials with legal advisers, the Northern Ireland Office and the Treasury, which was necessary to ensure the legislative competence of the Bill.
While the timelines for the Bill's passage have become increasingly compressed, the use of accelerated passage will enable my Department to plan with a degree of certainty that the legislation will be in place on time. That will allow officials to start preparing the secondary legislation required to maintain parity with GB. I emphasise that the request for accelerated passage reflects the specific timing and circumstances of the Bill. I remain committed to ensuring that future legislation is brought forward at the earliest practicable opportunity, therefore reducing the need to seek recourse to exceptional procedures.
If we cannot proceed by accelerated passage, the consequence will be a real risk that legislative passage will not be completed during the current mandate, which would mean that the Bill will fall. That would inevitably result in a significant delay in the introduction of these important reforms: modernising the pensions system by improving retirement outcomes for savers; promoting better value and governance in pension schemes; supporting consolidation and investment reform; and enabling pension assets to contribute more effectively to long-term economic growth. That is what would be at risk if there were any delay.
Members will, of course, have the opportunity to discuss the general principles of the Bill at Second Stage, and I look forward to that engagement, because I believe that we have a collective responsibility to deliver this important legislative reform during this mandate. I therefore invite Members to support accelerated passage for the Pension Schemes Bill.
Mr Gildernew (The Chairperson of the Committee for Communities): I rise as Chairperson of the Committee for Communities to speak on the motion that the Pension Schemes Bill proceed under the accelerated passage procedure.
At the outset, it is important to be clear about what the Assembly is being asked to agree today. Under Standing Order 42, accelerated passage for a Bill such as this is an exceptional procedure, and, if agreed, there will be no Committee Stage. I therefore want to set out for the House the Committee's engagement with the legislation and its position as we come to today's debate.
The Committee first received a detailed briefing from departmental officials on the proposed Bill on 16 April this year. At that stage, officials anticipated a substantial Bill of around 90 clauses and told the Committee that it was expected to follow the normal legislative process. The intention at that time was that the Bill would be introduced before the summer recess and that the Committee Stage would begin as soon as possible thereafter. Officials indicated that approximately three months had been built into the legislative timetable for Committee scrutiny. Even then, members expressed concern about whether that would be time enough for detailed scrutiny of such a large and technical Bill.
In anticipation of the legislation arriving, the Committee and the Department agreed that members and officials would meet during the summer recess for four information sessions. Those sessions took place on 9 July, 16 July, 13 August and 27 August. I acknowledge the time given to that work by Committee members, departmental officials and the Committee team during recess. Members received briefings on the main policy areas covered by the Bill, including value for money, the consolidation of small pension pots, guided retirement, superfunds, pension scheme surpluses and a range of other measures. Many of those areas were identified by members for further scrutiny. Therefore, it is important to distinguish those useful sessions from a Committee Stage. The Bill for the North had not, at that point, completed the drafting process, so the information sessions covered policy themes and rationale. The Committee was not examining the clauses of the Bill that is now before the Assembly and was not taking evidence from stakeholders.
On 13 October, the Minister wrote to advise the Committee that he intended to seek accelerated passage, subject to Executive agreement. The Minister explained, as he has done today, that delays to the corresponding legislation at Westminster, together with legal complexities arising from the interaction between devolved pensions matters and reserved financial matters, had left a compressed timetable. He also outlined the Department's concern that failure to legislate within this mandate could create divergence from Britain and could mean that pension savers here would not receive the same reforms and protections. Members of our Committee take that point seriously. The Committee would not want pension savers in the North to find themselves with fewer rights or protections than savers elsewhere.
Last Thursday, 12 November, the Minister attended the Committee for his quarterly briefing. I asked him directly to set out clearly why there was a need for accelerated passage. He again referred to the delays and changes in the Department for Work and Pensions process and the risk of savers here being left behind. He confirmed that the sooner the Bill could be passed, the better. The Minister also offered to make officials available to assist members with further information.
Following that evidence, the Committee discussed the matter. Members did not reach a collective position either in support of or in opposition to accelerated passage. As a Committee, we simply do not have sufficient information to make a fully informed recommendation, so, today, it is a matter for the whole Assembly.
The Committee's concern is a straightforward one. We recognise the importance of maintaining access to pension reforms, but we have had no opportunity to scrutinise the Bill as introduced. The Committee therefore wrote to the Department seeking further information. In particular, we asked for the commencement timetable for the corresponding provisions in Britain and for clarity on the practical consequences for pension savers here if the Bill were to proceed through a normal Committee Stage. We also asked whether there might still be time for some focused evidence gathering on provisions that are not due to commence immediately. The response to that correspondence was circulated to all members yesterday afternoon, but the Committee has not yet had an opportunity to review and discuss its contents in detail. There has, of course, been extensive scrutiny of the corresponding legislation at Westminster. Scrutiny elsewhere cannot, however, be a substitute for the Assembly and the relevant Statutory Committee considering the legislation that will apply here, given the many unique situations that exist for our pensioners and savers. A Committee Stage would ordinarily allow us to invite evidence from pension providers, trustees, employers, trade unions, consumer representatives and others; to examine the clauses in detail; and, where appropriate, to propose amendments.
On behalf of the Committee, I want to be clear that I am not making a recommendation to the House on how Members should vote on the motion; rather, I am placing on record both positions facing us: concerns about delay and divergence and, equally, the concern that a significant and highly technical Bill with 97 clauses will proceed without the scrutiny that is normally undertaken at Committee Stage. If the House grants the Bill accelerated passage, the Committee will continue to engage with the Department and to take seriously its scrutiny of the considerable amount of secondary legislation that is expected to flow from the Bill. I also welcome the Minister's undertaking to make his officials available to assist members as the Bill progresses.
Mr Allen: The Ulster Unionist Party will support accelerated passage for the Pension Schemes Bill, albeit reluctantly. As a member of the Committee for Communities, I share the concern about the lack of opportunity to scrutinise properly a substantial and complex Bill.
As the Minister pointed out, accelerated passage should be the exception rather than the norm. There is good reason why legislation goes through a Committee Stage, as it allows members to examine the detail, take evidence and, where necessary, challenge what is being proposed. Indeed, the Committee explored whether even a short evidence session could be accommodated, but the Department advised that the timetable would not allow for it. That is disappointing.
We recognise the explanation that the Department and, indeed, the Minister today have provided about the challenges arising from the legislative timetable at Westminster, as we do the importance of maintaining parity in pension provisions across the United Kingdom. We also recognise the potential consequences of failing to progress the necessary legislation before the end of the mandate, including the risk of pension savers in Northern Ireland being disadvantaged. While the provisions largely mirror those in GB, that should not be taken as a substitute for proper scrutiny by the House and the Committee. I recognise that much of the detail underpinning the reforms will be determined through secondary legislation. That makes it all the more important that the Communities Committee have a meaningful opportunity to scrutinise the regulations as they are developed.
On balance, given the circumstances and the potential consequences of any delay, the Ulster Unionist Party will reluctantly support accelerated passage.
Mr Lyons: I appreciate the contributions that Members have made to the debate. As I have said, accelerated passage is not something that I would ordinarily seek. I hope that the House understands that this is largely outside the control of people in Northern Ireland, but it is important that we maintain parity so that, compared with savers elsewhere in the UK, people here are not disadvantaged.
On Mr Allen's final point, I can confirm that, should the Bill be granted accelerated passage, sufficient time will be available for the Committee to scrutinise properly the secondary legislation. I hope that that offers Members some reassurance. I am grateful for the support that has been pledged.
Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): Thank you, Minister. Before we proceed to the Question, I remind Members that the motion requires cross-community support.
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved (with cross-community support):
That the Pension Schemes Bill proceed under the accelerated passage procedure.
That the Second Stage of the Pension Schemes Bill [NIA Bill 48/22-27] be agreed.
Mr Lyons: This is an important Bill that will help to ensure that Northern Ireland's pensions framework remains modern, effective and aligned with developments across the UK. While pensions are a devolved matter, as provided for in section 87 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998, Northern Ireland has long maintained parity with GB on pension policy and legislation, reflecting the fact that many pension schemes operate on a UK-wide basis and that members, employers, trustees and regulators benefit from a consistent legislative and regulatory framework. The Bill therefore makes provision in Northern Ireland to correspond with key elements of the Pension Schemes Act 2026. It will help to maintain a coherent pensions system across the UK.
The pensions landscape has evolved significantly over recent decades: people live longer, working patterns have changed and pension savers increasingly move between employers several times throughout their career. As a result, the pensions market has become more fragmented, with many individuals accumulating multiple small pension pots. At the same time, there is growing recognition that pension schemes must deliver better value for savers and that scale can play an important role in securing better outcomes and improving efficiency. The Bill responds to those challenges. Its overarching objectives are to support better retirement outcomes for pension savers; to strengthen value in workplace pension schemes; to encourage consolidation, where appropriate; and to support long-term investment while maintaining robust protections for pension scheme members. The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) estimates that, over a full working life, the combined effect of the reforms could leave an average defined contribution saver up to £29,000 better off at retirement through higher net investment returns, lower costs and improved value for money across the pensions market.
Automatic enrolment has transformed pension saving in Northern Ireland. Today, more than 75% of Northern Ireland employees are members of a workplace pension scheme, with participation in the private sector having risen by 43 percentage points since 2012. That success means that our focus must shift from participation to outcomes, ensuring that every pound saved delivers the greatest possible value. While more people than ever are saving for retirement, significant numbers are still projected to retire with incomes that are insufficient to maintain their expected standard of living. Therefore, a key theme running through the Bill is ensuring that pension saving works harder for scheme members.
The Bill introduces a new value-for-money framework that will increase transparency and comparability across defined contribution pension schemes. Rather than focusing solely on costs, schemes will be assessed on the value that they deliver to their members, including investment in performance and services. That will help to drive improvements across the market and protect savers from remaining in persistently underperforming arrangements.
The Bill addresses the long-standing issue of small, dormant pension pots. Millions of pension pots across the UK are small, deferred and at risk of being overlooked by savers. The proposed consolidator model will allow those pots to be brought together more effectively, reducing inefficiency, lowering the risk of pots becoming lost and making it easier for people to keep track of their retirement savings.
The legislation will further support the development of pension schemes that have the scale and governance needed to deliver good outcomes while introducing measures to support members as they move into retirement. Through the guided retirement provision, schemes will be required to consider how best to help members access their savings and secure an income throughout retirement, addressing what is often one of the most complex stages of the pension journey.
The Bill also includes important reforms for defined benefit pension schemes. Funding levels in many defined benefit schemes have improved significantly in recent years, with many schemes now holding surpluses. The Bill will permit trustees, subject to stringent safeguards and their existing fiduciary duties to members, to modify scheme rules to allow surplus funds to be shared with sponsoring employers where appropriate. That will create greater flexibility while maintaining protections for scheme beneficiaries.
In addition, the Bill establishes a statutory framework for pension superfunds. Those arrangements can provide an alternative route for certain defined benefit schemes that may not be available to secure an insurance buyout but, nevertheless, wish to improve security for members and achieve greater long-term sustainability. The Bill introduces a comprehensive authorisation and supervisory regime for such arrangements, overseen by the Pensions Regulator.
The reforms will deliver benefits for a range of stakeholders. For pension savers, the Bill aims to improve outcomes, better protect pension rights, reduce fragmentation, improve transparency and ensure greater support in retirement. For employers, it creates a more efficient and sustainable pensions environment and provides additional flexibility for those sponsoring well-funded, defined benefit schemes. For government and regulators, it supports a pension system that is more coherent, more resilient and better placed to respond to future challenges. The Bill also contains practical measures to improve the operation of the pensions system. They include provisions relating to Pension Protection Fund levies, pensions dashboards and the provision of better member information by employers, ensuring that schemes have access to accurate and up-to-date data.
The policies before the Assembly have been developed following extensive consultation and engagement across the pensions industry. Stakeholders, including employers, trustees, providers, regulators and member representatives, have contributed to the development of the reforms. The Bill largely establishes enabling powers, with detailed implementation to follow through secondary legislation and further consultation.
It is also important to recognise the consequences of failing to legislate during the current Assembly mandate. Without the Bill, Northern Ireland will diverge from Great Britain in important areas of pension policy and regulation, and pension savers here could miss out on key reforms. Those include the new value-for-money framework, the automatic consolidation of small dormant pension pots and enhanced support on accessing pension savings at retirement. Such divergence could result in less favourable outcomes for savers; greater complexity and compliance costs for employers, trustees and pension providers; and additional administrative burdens for regulators and government. There is also a risk that delays in maintaining parity could adversely affect access to UK-wide initiatives, including pensions dashboards, potentially limiting access to pension information for a significant number of scheme members. For those reasons, it is important that the Assembly takes the opportunity presented by the Bill to maintain an effective, coherent and modern pensions framework for Northern Ireland.
In summary, the Bill is about ensuring that pension saving delivers the best possible outcomes for current and future generations. It seeks to create a pensions system that is more efficient, more transparent, better focused on member outcomes and better equipped to meet the challenges of the future while providing consistency across the UK. I hope that Members are content with the broad thrust of the Bill, and I am happy to deal with any points of concern during what, I hope, will be an exciting, lively and spirited debate. I commend the Bill to the Assembly.
Mr Gildernew (The Chairperson of the Committee for Communities): Given the debate that has just taken place on accelerated passage, I want to be clear about the basis on which I am speaking in this debate. The Committee for Communities received a pre-legislative briefing from Department for Communities officials on the policy intent but has not undertaken a Committee Stage. My comments therefore reflect what the Committee has been told by the Department and the issues that members have raised to date. I cannot report to the House the views of stakeholders on the Bill or a concluded Committee position.
The background to the legislation is the long-standing approach to pensions policy under section 87 of the NI Act 1998. While pensions are devolved, the policy and legislative framework here generally operate in line with Britain. The Department has stressed to the Committee that divergence can create practical and regulatory differences. The Bill makes provisions that correspond to measures contained in the Pension Schemes Act 2026. The Department has described the package, containing over 97 clauses, as the most significant reform of the pensions landscape in more than a decade.
I now turn briefly to the main areas of the Bill. Part 1 deals with defined benefit pensions and, in particular, the circumstances in which pension scheme trustees may modify scheme rules in order to allow surplus funds to be paid to a sponsoring employer. When the Committee first heard from officials about the proposal in April, members raised questions about how the interests of scheme members would be protected and why surplus funds might be returned to employers rather than used directly for the benefit of scheme members. The officials responded that those provisions relate to defined benefit schemes where the pension that is payable to scheme members is fixed, according to the rules of the scheme. They also advised that trustees will remain under duties to act in beneficiaries' interests and that payments will be subject to funding safeguards and actuarial certification. That is clearly an area where the details of the safeguards will be important.
Part 2 contains a number of major reforms that will affect defined contribution pensions. The value-for-money provisions are intended to move the focus beyond charges alone towards the overall performance of the scheme. The Bill provides for schemes to be assessed using information on matters such as investment performance, costs and quality of service, and for schemes to receive ratings. Poorly performing schemes may be required to improve or, ultimately, transfer members elsewhere. The Committee received a briefing on that framework during the summer recess and identified several areas for scrutiny at Committee Stage.
The Bill also provides for the consolidation of small dormant pension pots. Changing employment patterns and automatic enrolment have resulted in many people accumulating a number of relatively small pension pots over their working lives. The proposed system is intended to allow those pots to be consolidated into authorised schemes while retaining safeguards and, importantly, an ability for scheme members to opt out. Another significant area is scale and asset allocation. The Bill provides for large-scale pension arrangements in the auto-enrolment market and includes powers that relate to how assets may be allocated. The Department has told the Committee that larger schemes may offer economies of scale, stronger governance and access to a wider range of investments. Members have, nevertheless, recognised that powers capable of influencing pension scheme investment are significant. A Committee letter to the Department last week specifically highlighted that area as one that on the face of it, merits careful scrutiny.
The Bill goes further than simply encouraging greater diversification. It provides powers for regulations to set binding requirements around the allocation of assets in certain defined contribution default funds, including the ability to set percentage targets for investment in specified asset classes. The Department for Communities has described that as a "backstop" power, intended to be available if voluntary commitments by the pensions industry do not deliver the desired change. Committee members recognised that as a potentially significant power that could, in certain circumstances, influence where pension schemes invest members' savings. In its letter to the Department last week, the Committee therefore specifically highlighted provisions concerning the direction of scheme investment as an area that also requires careful scrutiny. In the course of a normal Committee Stage, Committee members would expect to be able to examine the circumstances in which such a power could be used, the safeguards for scheme members, how trustees' duties to act would interact with any investment requirements and the level of Assembly scrutiny that would apply to those regulations.
The Bill also deals with default pension arrangements more generally and with guided retirement. Guided retirement is intended to address the difficult decisions that are faced by people with defined contribution pensions when they reach retirement. Schemes will be expected to provide a suitable default solution for members who do not wish to make complex decisions themselves, while retaining individual choice.
Part 3 establishes a statutory regime for pension superfunds. Those are intended principally for defined benefit pension schemes that may not be able to afford an insurance buyout but could improve the security of members' benefits by transferring into a larger regulated arrangement supported by additional capital. The Department stated that transfers would be voluntary, that trustees must consider them to be in members' interests and that the regime will be overseen by the Pensions Regulator.
Part 4 contains a number of other measures, including changes relating to Pension Protection Fund levies, pension dashboards and information that employers may be required to provide to pension schemes. The pension dashboard provisions are particularly relevant, given that the Committee considered dashboard legislation previously. The underlying objective of dashboards is to allow people eventually to see all information about their different pension entitlements in one place, thereby having a clearer picture of their retirement income. Across all those areas, a recurring feature of the Bill is that much of the operational detail will follow in regulations. The Committee had a dedicated powers memorandum (DPM) circulated to it yesterday evening but will have no opportunity to seek assurances from the Examiner on its contents. The DPM was circulated to all Members.
The explanatory and financial memorandum (EFM) describes many of the provisions as technical and enabling in nature. Therefore, further consultation is expected as secondary legislation is developed. That will place considerable importance on the quality of future consultations and on the scrutiny of the regulations that follow. The Committee was informed that the policy behind the equivalent Westminster legislation was subject to a series of consultations in which stakeholders here were able to participate. The explanatory and financial memorandum confirms, however, that there was no separate consultation specific to the North. That is relevant in the context of there being no Committee Stage and therefore no separate call for evidence by the Committee.
The Westminster legislation underwent a lengthy parliamentary process between June 2025 and April this year, including the taking of evidence, detailed examination in both Houses and several rounds of consideration of amendments. That provides a useful background to scrutiny. However, Committee members originally anticipated that the Assembly Bill would receive its own Committee Stage. When officials appeared before the Committee on 16 April, they told us that the normal legislative process was anticipated and that they were factoring in three months for Committee scrutiny.
As I said in the debate on accelerated passage, in an effort to prepare, members and officials devoted time during the summer recess to four sessions on specific policy areas. Again, I place on record the Committee's appreciation of the officials who facilitated those sessions and the members who participated. The sessions undoubtedly gave the Committee a better understanding of what the Department is seeking to achieve. However, such sessions cannot not provide the Committee with evidence that it has not heard: for example, we do not have evidence from pension scheme members, pension providers, employers, trustees, trade unions, consumer bodies or professional advisers setting out their views on the final Bill. Therefore, the Committee cannot tell the House that those sectors support, oppose or would seek changes to any particular clause. That is an important limitation on the contribution that I can make today as Chairperson.
What I can say is that members recognise the objectives of ensuring that pension savers here are not disadvantaged by unnecessary divergence and that they can benefit from reforms intended to improve value, governance and retirement outcomes. At the same time, members consistently emphasised the importance of appropriate safeguards for pension scheme members, transparency in decision-making and proper scrutiny of powers that may have significant effects. If the Bill proceeds without Committee Stage, the scrutiny role does not disappear entirely. A considerable body of secondary legislation will be required to implement the reforms, and the Committee will expect the Department to engage early and fully as that detail is developed. There will also be a need for effective post-legislative monitoring to establish whether the reforms deliver the intended outcomes for pension savers in the North. Today, however, I place before the House the information that is available to the Committee, the work that members undertook to understand the proposals and the limits imposed by the absence of a formal Committee Stage.
Mr O'Toole: I am opening a document that was sent to me. I am speaking on behalf of the official Opposition as my colleague Mark Durkan is not able to be here for the debate.
We support the proceeding of the Bill. We understand and acknowledge the reasons for accelerated passage, albeit, as the Chair of the Committee said, it is not ideal. Although the Bill is extremely technical, Members, as legislators, should obviously have every opportunity in Committee and in plenary meetings to scrutinise primary legislation.
The Bill is primarily about people's financial security and dignity in retirement. The reforms in the Bill have the potential to make a meaningful difference, and, as has been said, the aim is to improve governance and value for money, including by consolidating small, dormant pension pots and providing better support for people as they approach retirement. In correspondence with the Committee — I am told; I am not on the Committee — the Minister highlighted the potential consequences of failing to maintain parity, including people in Northern Ireland missing out on protections and improvements that would be available elsewhere in the UK.
As I said, we acknowledge the reasons for accelerated passage being sought — it has already been agreed by the Assembly — but I put it on record that we have concerns about it. Accelerated passage should always be the exception rather than the rule, so our preference is for things such as this not to happen, but we acknowledge the reasons for it in this instance.
The Minister points to the delays in the corresponding Westminster legislation as well as to the technical complexities arising from the interaction between devolved and reserved responsibilities, which is a challenge. We acknowledge that challenge, but, again, for the record, that underlines the importance of early planning, with the Committee being notified and MLAs being able to scrutinise the legislation. Although there were, no doubt, good reasons in this instance, the earlier that notice can be given to the relevant Statutory Committee, the better.
We agree that the Bill provides for sensible reforms. In the context of Northern Ireland maintaining parity with changes in Britain but having devolved responsibility, it makes sense for the Bill to proceed. We ask the Department to provide the Committee and, indeed, MLAs more broadly with maximum information about the changes. We welcome the fact that the Bill has been introduced: better late than never. The impact of not implementing the Bill could have lasting consequences, including presenting a risk to about 140,000 deferred members of the Pension Protection Fund and the financial assistance scheme who might be unable to access information about their compensation if there were to be any jurisdictional divergence between here and Britain.
As I said, despite our reservations about the process, my colleague looks forward to engaging with the Committee, insofar as that is possible, in the period ahead. The Bill is ultimately about protecting pension savers, improving retirement outcomes and ensuring that people in Northern Ireland receive the same protections and opportunities as those across the water. The official Opposition supports the Bill.
Ms Mulholland: The Pension Schemes Bill contains measures aimed at strengthening the regulation and administration of pension schemes. Whilst it may seem rather a dull topic to talk about, it is important, particularly to those who are planning their retirement. It is about ensuring that Northern Ireland's legislative framework keeps pace with wider developments in pensions policy.
Among the Bill's provisions are those that seek to improve the powers available to regulators and to support the operation of collective defined contribution schemes. One of the most welcome aspects of the Bill is its role in the progress towards pensions dashboards. The world of work has changed so dramatically in recent decades, and gone are the days when people such as my parents spent their entire career with one employer and retired as a member of one pension scheme. Many workers now change jobs multiple times during their career and move between sectors, work part-time, take career breaks or combine employment with self-employment. As a result, it is increasingly common for individuals to accumulate several pension pots from different providers and, in some cases, to lose track of what they have built up. Pensions dashboards have the potential to be genuinely transformative in addressing that challenge by allowing individuals to view all their pension entitlements in one place. Dashboards can give people a much clearer picture of their retirement savings, help them to reconnect with lost pension pots and support them in more informed planning or the amalgamation of some of those pots.
Greater transparency can encourage engagement with pensions at an earlier age. The Committee heard about the proposed reduction in the age of auto-enrolment. Allowing people to make better decisions from a younger age about their contributions, retirement age and long-term financial security can only be a positive thing.
At a time when responsibility for retirement planning increasingly rests with the individual, having clear and accessible information in words that people can understand is essential. That will be key going forward. While dashboards are not a solution to pension adequacy or pension confusion, they are an important tool to help people understand what they have saved, identify gaps in provision and take action where necessary. For those reasons, the move towards dashboards is, as I said, a particularly positive element of the Bill and has the potential to deliver real benefits for savers across Northern Ireland.
Alongside improving transparency and engagement, it is essential that the Bill's reforms be accompanied by appropriate safeguards for savers as they approach retirement. Pension decisions are often really complex and confusing and fall outside the normal scope of people's understanding. They involve choices about when to retire, how to draw down savings and how to make a pension pot last throughout retirement. For many people, those are decisions that they will make only once, yet the consequences can affect their financial security for decades. That is why measures on things such as guided retirement are so important. With greater flexibility, individuals can be offered more choice, but that has to be matched by clear information, effective guidance and protections against poor decision-making, scams and undue financial risk. The guided retirement approach recognises that, while many people do not require full financial advice, they would benefit from structured support in understanding their options and the implications of different choices. By helping savers navigate decisions on drawdown, annuities and income planning, guided retirement services can improve confidence and outcomes while reducing the risk of people exhausting their savings far too early or making choices that do not reflect their needs. As pension freedoms continue to evolve, ensuring that people have access to trusted guidance and really robust consumer protections will be just as important as ensuring that they can access the information about their pension savings in the first place.
Many of the Bill's objectives are sensible and welcome. Giving people greater visibility of their pension entitlements, improving governance standards and ensuring that regulators have the tools necessary to protect scheme members are really important goals. As I said, as pension arrangements become increasingly complex and individuals bear greater responsibility for their retirement planning, particularly if they have not stayed with just one employer, the reforms to improve transparency and consumer protection are really welcome.
While the Bill's policy direction may not be particularly contentious, as Members mentioned in the previous debate, it is slightly frustrating that accelerated passage has been required. Legislative alignment is important, particularly in areas such as pensions, where consistency across jurisdictions can benefit providers and members, as the Minister outlined in his opening speech. Nevertheless, parity should not become a substitute for scrutiny. The Assembly's role is not simply to replicate legislation but to satisfy itself that the proposals are for the good of people in Northern Ireland. I therefore welcome the Minister's comments that his request for accelerated passage will not be repeated lightly.
We find ourselves in broad agreement with the Bill's aims. The measures to improve pension governance, strengthen member protections and increase transparency through pensions dashboards are all really worthy objectives. Good pensions legislation is really important. It may not be the most exciting thing that we will discuss in the Chamber, but it affects the long-term financial security of thousands of people. While the Committee may not have the opportunity to scrutinise the Bill properly, we hope that its objectives have the outcome of protecting people and ensuring their financial security in the time to come.
Ms K Armstrong: I thank the Minister for introducing the Bill, because, as my colleague has just said, having a pensions dashboard will at long last deal with the fragmented pension pot that many of us have. Anyone who has worked in as many places as I have will know how difficult it is to find all those pensions, never mind work out the benefit from them. The Minister will be pleased to learn that, in 125 days, when I take my pension and leave this place, he will no longer have to put up with me standing up and speaking in the House.
Ms K Armstrong: I have not mentioned it. For anybody who is standing again, that is 18 weeks away.
The Pension Schemes Bill is a substantial reform of pensions legislation in Northern Ireland. Maybe it is more pertinent to me because I am closer to my pension. Someone once said to me, "Save when you're young. It will pay dividends for you when you get older": how true that is. If I had known when I started out at work that I should save every penny that I could into a pension so that I could retire early on a good pension, I would have listened to that. As it stands, my pension will not be wonderful, but at least I will be able to find it, once the dashboard comes into play.
The Bill has received accelerated passage, so the Committee will not have the ability to look through the details. When I looked at what Westminster had said about the Bill, I saw that there was support for larger pension schemes and consolidations. The Northern Ireland Pensions Schemes Bill replicates what went through Westminster. It is difficult for me to accept accelerated passage, which, I know, the House has agreed today with a cross-community vote. However, Minister, that does not land as a problem at your door; it lands with Westminster's inability to understand that the devolved nations should be given time and place to look at Bills.
One of the things that were raised as a concern at Westminster relates to government directing pension investments. I do not know about other Members, but there are some pension investments that I do not want to see. I would rather that I, as the person buying into the pension, had a say on not investing in armaments and oil. Concerns were raised in Westminster on a contested issue about whether the reserved power in the Bill allowed Ministers to require schemes to invest in particular asset clauses, including productive finance and, potentially, UK infrastructure assets. Torsten Bell, the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, defended the power, arguing that pension providers identify market barriers that discourage long-term productive investment, despite potential benefits for savers. However, some MPs and peers expressed concern that pension investments should be driven by members' interests rather than the Government's industrial policy. Ministers could end up influencing where pension money is invested, and the fiduciary — I am not sure whether I have pronounced that right — duties of trustees could become blurred. That is highly relevant because the Northern Ireland Bill contains equivalent powers allowing future investment allocation requirements.
There was also debate in Westminster about the £25 billion scale requirement. We will not have a Committee Stage, so I do not know the answer to this question: how many of our Northern Ireland pension providers have £25 billion in assets? We may well see more and more of our local pension providers becoming part of a national grouping together of pensions in order to meet that limit. Critics in Westminster said that the threshold was arbitrary, that competition would be reduced by the gathering together of pension providers and, of course, that smaller providers could be forced out of the market. Supporters argued that larger schemes had better governance and stronger investment capability and can assess assets unavailable to smaller funds. However, in the back of my mind, I remember the bank crashes. What happens if one of the superfunds in a pension crashes? That is a risk to its members.
The House of Lords, in particular, repeatedly scrutinised the extent to which policy details were being left to secondary legislation rather than appearing in the Bill. Many of the operational details surrounding value-for-money frameworks, small pot consolidation, asset allocation, guided retirement and superfund regulation were left to later regulations rather than being in the Bill. That echoes one of the major points apparent in the delegated powers memorandum that was provided to the Committee yesterday: substantial discretion is being given to the Department for Communities, and a lot of pressure will be put on that Department. I am sure that, when the secondary legislation comes through, the future Committee will look at that.
While there was general support in Parliament across the water for creating a permanent statutory framework for pension superfunds as an alternative to insurance buyouts for defined pension schemes, concerns were raised about the protection of member benefits, investor profit extraction — that is important because, if employers are able to extract from pension funds, that might be risky for the people who have paid into it — and the adequacy of regulatory oversight by the Pensions Regulator. Those concerns are reflected in the dedicated superfund provisions that are replicated in the Northern Ireland Bill.
I would have liked to ask whether pension assets could effectively be steered towards UK investment priorities rather than solely member returns and what the impact of the £25 billion scale requirement would be on small pension providers, particularly what it means for our local providers in the Northern Ireland market. Although many of the providers will be UK-wide, smaller providers exist. The automatic transfer of small dormant pension pots that will happen without active consent is a concern for me, and I would have liked to ask about that. The large number of delegated and Henry VIII powers have been a concern at Westminster in the House of Lords, as has the adequacy of protections when surplus funds are released to employers. How will we protect members to make sure that the arrangement is fair? I understand that a determined amount of pension is set out, but is it fair that the surplus goes to your employer and cannot be kicked back to the people who have paid into the scheme? I would love to have asked whether superfunds prioritised members' security over investor returns.
The Bill is welcome. We need an overhaul of pensions, but there are still concerns. The Northern Ireland Assembly will not be able to scrutinise the Bill through the Committee system. However, Westminster has scrutinised it, and that is why I looked at their questions: at least they were able to ask those questions. I expect that the secondary legislation will bring some clarity, and I am sure the Minister will be ready with the delegated powers that will be given to the Communities Department to answer those questions.
For now, we have a Pension Schemes Bill. It has reached Second Stage and will proceed quickly because of accelerated passage. We need to watch how this progresses through Westminster, because it will be able to ask questions and this House less so. We have to ensure that our pensioners and our assets are protected — I suppose that I should declare an interest as a future pension taker — and we do not want to see super-pensions collapsing and leaving pensioners without an adequate income.
Mr Allen: First, Mr Deputy Speaker, I apologise for the late notification. My app was not working for some reason.
As I outlined during the earlier debate on accelerated passage, the Ulster Unionist Party recognises the importance of the legislation and the need to maintain parity in the provisions across the United Kingdom. I do not intend to revisit the arguments around accelerated passage, as I have no doubt, Mr Deputy Speaker, that you would bring me swiftly back to the Bill before us.
In that vein, I turn to the legislation. As other Members have mentioned, there are several measures that are welcome, such as the proposed value-for-money framework. When people pay into a pension, often over several decades, they should reasonably expect that their savings are being managed properly and that they are receiving good value for the charges that they pay. The framework seeks to look beyond the charges alone and will take account of investment performance and the quality of the service provided, which we see as a sensible change. Greater transparency should help identify underperforming arrangements and encourage improvements. However, it will be important that the framework genuinely improves outcomes for pension savers rather than simply creating additional reporting requirements for pension providers.
We also welcome the proposals to address the growing number of small dormant pension pots. People change jobs, sometimes several times throughout their working life, and can end up with relatively small amounts of pension savings scattered across schemes. That can make it difficult to keep track of what they have saved and can result in unnecessary administration costs. The proposed arrangement for consolidating eligible small pots is therefore sensible in principle.
The Bill provides for certain transfers to take place without the member's express consent, provided the necessary notice has been given and that members have not objected. I understand why that approach is being taken, but it places considerable importance on how people are notified. We need to ensure that members understand what is happening to their savings and have a genuine opportunity to object, should they wish to do so. That is particularly important for people who may struggle with complex financial correspondence or who cannot easily access information online. I welcome the reassurance that accessibility will be properly considered when the detailed arrangements are developed.
There are other aspects of the Bill on which we believe that we need to exercise some caution. One is the provision relating to the payment of surplus funds from defined pension schemes to employers. We recognise the argument that, where a scheme is sufficiently well funded, there may be benefits in allowing surplus funds to be released and reinvested in businesses. For example, that could support jobs and economic activity. However, we must remember that these schemes exist to provide pensions to their members. A scheme may be in a strong financial position today, but circumstances can change. Investment markets fluctuate, liabilities change, and pension commitments can extend many years into the future. The Bill retains trustee oversight and provides for funding safeguards, with important details to be set in regulations.
I will also touch on the provisions relating to pension investment. The Bill introduces a reserved power that could, subject to specified conditions and safeguards, require certain pension arrangements to hold a minimum proportion of their assets in particular types of investments. We understand the desire to encourage pension funds to invest more in the wider economy. There are potential benefits from greater investment in infrastructure, business and other productive assets. However, we believe that there is an important distinction between encouraging investment and requiring pension schemes to direct members' savings towards particular assets. The interests of pension savers must remain central to those decisions, and I have no doubt that that will be the case. We recognise that safeguards have been included, particularly the savers' interest test and restrictions on when the power can be used. Nevertheless, we would welcome clarification from the Minister on how those protections will operate in practice, particularly where a scheme believes that meeting an investment requirement would not be in its members' interests.
Another significant element of the Bill is the move towards larger workplace pension arrangements. The legislation introduces scale requirements for certain defined contribution pension arrangements, including a £25 billion threshold. The argument is that larger arrangements may be better placed to reduce costs, improve governance and access investment opportunities that might not be available to smaller schemes. There may well be merit in that. However, size alone is no guarantee of good performance. What matters is whether the changes actually deliver better outcomes for the people whose money is being invested. I would be interested to hear how the Department intends to assess whether the expected benefits are being achieved, either directly or through its counterparts in Westminster.
We also welcome the provisions relating to guided retirement. For many people, deciding how to use their pension savings when they retire can be a difficult and daunting decision. They need to consider how long their savings might have to last, what income they will need and what options are available to them. Requiring schemes to offer appropriate retirement solutions while preserving members' freedom to make their own choices is a reasonable and practical approach. However, those arrangements will need to be clearly explained so that people understand what they are being offered and are not simply directed towards a default option without understanding the alternatives.
I will also address the delegated powers memorandum that was circulated to Members on 16 November. I have considered the memorandum, and it is clear that a considerable amount of the detail underpinning the reforms will be determined through secondary legislation. The memorandum identifies several Henry VIII powers that allow specified provisions of primary legislation to be amended through regulation. I recognise that those powers vary in scope and that many relate to technical aspects of what is a complex area of legislation. I am not suggesting that every technical matter needs to be included in the Bill. However, some of the regulations will deal with significant matters, including the conditions governing pension surpluses, surplus payments, the transfer of members' savings and the operation of new regulatory frameworks.
The memorandum also sets out different levels of Assembly scrutiny, with some regulations subject to confirmatory procedure and others to negative resolution. Given that the Bill will proceed without the normal Committee Stage, there is particular responsibility on the Department to ensure that the Communities Committee is properly engaged as the regulations are developed. I welcome the Minister's commitment in that regard.
We broadly welcome the Bill's provisions. Pensions is a complex and detailed area of legislation. We echo the concerns raised by other Members, but we recognise the need to maintain parity, primarily for pension savers and employers. We have a number of concerns, particularly about the fact that the Committee will not get the opportunity to invite key stakeholders in and have that engagement. We note that Westminster has gone through its process, but we encourage the Department and, indeed, the Minister, for the remainder of his term in office, to ensure that we do not just follow Westminster's process. That is not the approach that the Minister normally adopts. It is important that we keep a close eye on that and feed in our concerns where required.
Mr Lyons: I appreciate the contributions that have been made. We touched a little on accelerated passage in the previous debate. I understand the concerns that have been expressed about the need for proper scrutiny. One reason why I wanted to ensure that we had accelerated passage was so that the Committee would have the opportunity to look at some of the secondary legislation. I hope that that will give members the opportunity to ask questions on the issues that they have raised.
A number of issues were raised, particularly around the potential for surpluses in pension schemes to be removed by employers. I understand the concern that has been expressed around that. On the face of it, I understand why people are asking why, when employees are putting money in, employers should be able to take it out. Hopefully, I can reassure people by saying that there will still be a number of safeguards in place. We need to ensure that we are in a position where pensions are secure for the future and employees are never put at risk. Of course, any decision to release a surplus must take account of the long-term security of members' benefits and the overall funding position of the scheme. I assure Members that there will, of course, be those appropriate safeguards and protections for scheme members. I hope that Members will have the opportunity to ask further questions when the secondary regulations are in place.
Concerns were also raised about the figure of £25 billion. Evidence gathered during the Westminster Bill's formulation shows that a greater number of benefits can arise from assets of the scale of around £25 billion to £50 billion that are under management. That is also supported by industry analysis of schemes of that size. Providers find it easier to invest in that way. International evidence shows that funds in the region of £25 billion make nearly double the level of private market investment of a £1 billion fund. A pragmatic approach was taken, and the lower level of that scale was selected. There is, however, further evidence that demonstrates that the greater the scale, the greater the benefits to members.
I understand some concerns about the reserve powers. I do not think that Kellie Armstrong's concern will necessarily materialise. The Bill is not about making certain types of investments with which people could take issue . Rather, it is about ensuring that we have that investment across private markets and that savers can then benefit from that diversification and the potential for longer-term returns while also supporting economic growth. In view of the progress that has already made, my Department does not expect to need to use those powers.
A number of other issues and questions were raised, as were changes that we might like to make. I simply make the point that we are caught by the need to maintain parity, not just for the sake of it and so that things are the same across the United Kingdom but because of the way in which the system operates. It is important to ensure that our overall welfare system maintains parity, but, when it comes to pensions, when we deal with the regulators in particular and the guidance that is in place, having the same system across the UK is better for savers here. That is why it is important that, despite our constrained timescale, we get the Bill passed and are not left in a position of uncertainty, which would be the worst of all worlds for us.
A couple of other points that were raised. To the Chair of the Committee, Mr Gildernew, I say again that I understand the need for engagement on the secondary legislation. That is one of the reasons why we wanted to make sure that we got accelerated passage. I confirm again that my officials will be made available not just for that process but for any other questions that Members have. We will be more than happy to ensure that that support is provided.
Sian Mulholland said that this was a rather dull topic and not the most exciting issue. How dare you? It is very exciting stuff, indeed. To be fair, she saved herself afterwards by saying that, although, on the face of it, it may not be the most exciting legislation that we are putting through the House, it is an exceptionally important issue. She was right to say that as it has significant implications for the people whom we represent. I welcome any opportunity to debate those issues and, hopefully, in some way, to raise the issue in the minds of people here in Northern Ireland, because the changes that we can make when we are younger can have a much bigger impact later on.
I note Kellie Armstrong's comments in that regard as well. I make no comment on her leaving this place. I certainly make no comment on ages of retirement or anything like that, other than to say that I am sure that we wish her well and that we will miss her expertise in this place. She often tells us that she has great levels of expertise on so many different issues. How on earth will the House survive without her? However, we appreciate the genuine passion that she has brought to the issue and the respect that she has for the House and for the place that the House should have in the scrutiny of legislation.
As I said at the start, this is not ideal; however, it is the best course of action for us to take so that we can ensure the best possible outcomes for people in Northern Ireland. Therefore, I beg to move that the Second Stage of the Pension Schemes Bill be agreed.
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved:
That the Second Stage of the Pension Schemes Bill [NIA Bill 48/22-27] be agreed.
Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): That concludes the Second Stage of the Pension Schemes Bill. As the Bill is proceeding by accelerated passage, there will be no Committee Stage. The Bill stands referred to the Speaker.
I ask Members to take their ease before we move to the next item in the Order Paper.
(Madam Principal Deputy Speaker in the Chair)
That this Assembly notes the report of the Committee for Education on the 'Strategic Review of Current SEN Provision and Transformation Agenda'; recognises that, despite sustained efforts to implement reform, significant systemic challenges remain; further notes the particular special educational needs (SEN) workforce challenges, including specialist staffing shortages, in the Irish-medium education sector; identifies the need for greater investment and inclusion in SEN provision; and calls on the Minister of Education to prioritise early intervention and stronger support for schools before any reduction in support ratios is considered.
Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: Thank you, Nick. The Business Committee has agreed to allow up to one hour and 30 minutes for the debate. The proposer of the motion will have 10 minutes to propose and 10 minutes to make a winding-up speech. All other Members who are called to speak will have five minutes.
Nick, please open the debate on behalf of the Committee.
I am grateful to all stakeholders in the education system for engaging so candidly with the Committee and for very much bringing the best interests of children to the fore during the Committee's deliberations. I thank all Committee members for engaging in such detail with our inquiry, as well as the Clerk and the Committee team for all the support that they provided.
I note that the Minister is not here to respond to the debate, which is disappointing. I am not sure what his reasons for that are, but, given the number of parents, teachers and pupils whom the issue affects and the number of people who took the time to provide such detailed evidence to the Committee's inquiry, it is disappointing that he will not be here to respond to any of the points that will be raised.
Mr Allen: It is not for me to defend the Minister, but, as the Chair may acknowledge, business has been dispensed with quite quickly today. Will he confirm whether he received prior notice that the Minister will not be here to respond or whether it is a case of business moving faster than was expected?
Mr Mathison: I thank the Member for his intervention. Based on the briefing that I received from the Committee Clerk, my understanding is that we were notified in advance that the Minister would not be in attendance.
The Committee began its strategic review of special educational needs in September 2025. It considered 51 written submissions, held an event to hear the views of stakeholders and took oral evidence from the Department, the Education Authority (EA) and a number of other stakeholders. I will not name every witness, but I sincerely thank them all for their evidence, expertise and candour.
The Committee review had three distinct phases. The first phase looked at governance issues. We commissioned research on several significant and relatively recent reviews of SEN provision in the jurisdiction. We looked at what actions had been taken to address the recommendations from those reviews' reports. We then moved into the second phase of the inquiry, in which we looked at the evidence that was provided to us by stakeholders that attended the Committee or submitted written briefings in order that we might identify the challenges and strengths of current provision. I emphasise that the evidence was weighted much more heavily towards the challenges of current provision. That was the experience of stakeholders, particularly school leaders and practitioners on the ground. We then moved into the third phase, which was the consideration and reporting stage, in which we brought together and assessed the evidence that had been gathered and came to a position on whether the Department's SEN reform agenda is in fact addressing the key challenges that the system faces.
The report's headline conclusions can be summarised as follows: the SEN system requires a stronger focus on early intervention and workforce capacity building, and we need to see a reduction in bureaucracy, an improvement in planning for placements and a move towards much closer integration between Department of Education and Department of Health services that operate in that space.
The Committee made a number of specific recommendations that it hopes that the Department and the EA will take forward. The Committee's asks of and recommendations for the Department were as follows: the SEN reform agenda should be simplified to focus on a smaller number of clear, measurable priorities with published timelines; an action plan should be published to address the placement crisis and ensure that placements are delivered on a planned and, where possible, local basis in a non-discriminatory manner; the Department should develop and publish an inclusive education policy to define clearly the roles of mainstream schools, specialist provision in mainstream schools (SPiMS) and provision in special schools; there should be investment in workforce development, particularly for neuro-affirming practice, for all education staff; the special educational needs coordinator (SENCO) role should be supported, with a full, comprehensive review of the workload and time provided to make the role sustainable; early intervention services should be made universally available across settings; equal access to early years SEN support should be provided, regardless of whether that is in a statutory or non-statutory preschool setting; there should be improvements made to the bespoke SEN support that is provided in Irish-medium settings; urgent action needs to be taken on the issuing of guidance on restraint, seclusion and restrictive practices in schools, including a review of existing legislation on the use of force in schools; joint Health and Education working should be maximised; and focused work needs to be taken forward across Health, Education and the Department for the Economy on strengthening transitions for post-19 young people.
I note that the two DUP Committee members recorded their position as being that they did not support the Committee's call for the repeal of article 4(1)(c) of the Education (Northern Ireland) Order 1998 on the use of physical force in schools.
The Committee also called for the Education Authority to reduce bureaucracy by streamlining local impact teams (LITs) and their referral processes and to prioritise investment in local impact teams as an early action, with a particular focus on services providing behavioural support. There needs to be improved access to the EA's educational psychology service, and clarification should be provided on the role of educational psychologists in the system as it stands. There were also calls for a focus to be placed on professionalisation and clarification of the role of classroom assistants to ensure that their pay and career progression are invested in; and for one-to-one support for pupils to continue to be specified in statements where it is assessed as meeting those children's needs.
The motion does not set out all those recommendations, but it is important to put them on the record, as they are clear, specific and practical. The motion does make a specific call for a couple of the items, namely investment in early intervention and support services at school level, to be the priority that is taken forward. It also notes the concern around there being any reduction in support being provided to children who have a statement of special educational needs before we have a reformed system with all the wrap-around services in place.
The Committee report represents a great deal of time, evidence-taking and consideration, and I commend the Committee's position and recommendations to the House.
I will now make a few remarks in my capacity as Alliance spokesperson for education. I make it clear that I and my party support SEN reform. We recognise clearly that the current support systems are not good enough and that we have all known that for many years. In many respects, the inquiry tells us nothing new about the issues that are in the system. I am ready to support reform of SEN services, but it must be done in the right way, with the right interventions and with the needs of children at its heart.
Years of failings mean that we operate in a system, and have done for a long time, where parents feel that they must secure a statement of special educational needs if they are to get support. I am happy to see us move to a model that ensures that the right support is put in place as soon as needs are identified, not just when it becomes somebody's statutory duty to do so. I understand that many in the Department and in the EA share that vision, but we have to be clear: if we are to start withdrawing access to services that parents have fought hard for before there is clarity about what the wrap-around services that will come in to support schools will look like, we will need to proceed with caution. Future provision for SEN support must be legally compliant, meet the needs of the child and, most importantly, be appropriately resourced if it is to be effective.
I referred to local impact teams. They are a welcome development in our system. If we really are looking for the key intervention that is being carried out at school level, that is it. However, the resourcing issues mean that the teams are not able to deliver effectively. That is no comment on the professionalism of the staff who work in that system; it is simply that demand massively outstrips supply.
Mr Sheehan: First, I commend the Chair for his chairing of the Committee during the review. He mentioned resources, but is it not also the case that children with SEN in the Irish-medium sector are being particularly disadvantaged by the lack of a workforce plan? It is an absolute disgrace that the Minister was happy to sign a petition of concern to block the workforce plan for the Irish-medium sector.
Mr Mathison: I thank the Deputy Chair for that intervention. I am short on time, but, yes, the Irish-medium sector has a specific set of challenges around SEN. The workforce challenges in the LITs are massive anyway, and the fact that a petition of concern was utilised to block workforce planning in that space — I am on record as saying this in that debate — is, to my mind, a disgrace.
When it comes to LITs, resourcing is critical. If the EA is going to focus its resource anywhere, that is where it needs to be. I also highlighted the issue of early intervention. I have no doubt that the EA is concerned with that, but I am concerned that early intervention, particularly at preschool and early years stages, seems to have dropped off the agenda of the conversation that we are having in that space. If we do not get early intervention right and get support into our preschool and early years settings, all the changes that we will make further downstream in the system may be rendered utterly ineffective.
I referenced the issues around joint Health and Education working. The issues have been rehearsed over many years and need to be addressed. That requires leadership from the Education Minister and the Health Minister. I would have loved to have the Education Minister here today to advise us about what he is doing in that space, but we will not get that opportunity.
There is much work to be done, but the Committee report gives us an opportunity to make a positive contribution through this debate. I hope that we can play a supportive role in seeing the SEN reform agenda rolled out with children's needs and children's rights at its heart.
Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: The Business Committee has arranged to meet at 1.00 pm today. I propose therefore, by leave of the Assembly, to suspend the sitting until 2.00 pm. The debate will continue after Question Time, when the next Member to be called will be Cathy Mason.
The debate stood suspended.
The sitting was suspended at 12.55 pm.
On resuming (Mr Speaker in the Chair) —
Mr Muir (The Minister of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs): To date, 65 fishers have received initial payments totalling £209,987 under the Lough Neagh eel fishery transition scheme for the 2026 closed season. Of the 70 fishers with a record of eel fishing since 2022 who were invited to apply, 65 accepted the offer. I introduced the scheme to support livelihoods affected by the brown eel fishing moratorium, recognising eel fishing's importance to Lough Neagh's communities and cultural heritage. Support has also been offered to three private haulier businesses that have transported brown eels each season since 2022, with payments to date totalling £4,399. Support payments for the 2027 closed season will commence in April 2027 at the start of the next financial year.
Mr McGlone: Gabhaim buíochas leis an Aire as ucht an eolais sin.
[Translation: I thank the Minister for that information.]
Minister, to qualify what you have said, how many eligible eel fishermen who applied have yet to receive an additional payment? What is the average processing time for applications? When is it likely that any outstanding payments will be completed and got out the door?
Mr Muir: Thank you, Patsy. As I said, 65 fishers have received initial payments. The Member asked a number of questions about statistics, and I will check with officials and write to him. I recognise the importance of the scheme, and I thank those who applied. I give people an assurance that we will seek to process those applications speedily.
Mr K Buchanan: Minister, I understand that it is a three-year scheme. European research has indicated that there has been a 90% to 95% reduction in eels, so, after three years, what will be the benefits to Lough Neagh in respect of numbers? What are the numbers today, and what do you think they will be in three years' time? What would you like the numbers to be?
Mr Muir: Thank you very much. As the Member acknowledged, this is a wider issue beyond Lough Neagh, but I do not underestimate the ecological challenges in Lough Neagh and how they affect the eel fishing industry. We will monitor the progress of the interventions that we have made and evaluate that at the end of the three-year period. At the heart of this, it is about supporting the industry and the livelihoods that have been affected.
Ms Mulholland: Minister, could you give us an update on the actions that you have taken to date to address the blue-green algae crisis in Lough Neagh?
Mr Muir: Thank you, Sian, for the question. The crisis at Lough Neagh is one of the greatest environmental challenges that we have seen in Northern Ireland and has arisen as a result of decades of neglect, indecision and, on occasions, the wrong decisions. The challenges are significant, but I am focused on taking action and giving people the hope that they need that things can be turned around. We must lay the foundations for the long-term recovery of the lough, and, as Minister, I am doing just that.
The £49 million secured through the Shared Island Fund for the Lough Neagh catchment water quality programme will promote nature-based solutions and offer on-farm advice to address agricultural pollution. That is on top of the sustainable agriculture programme, which we are rolling out, and schemes such as Farming with Nature and the recently announced landscape scheme will bring farmers, land managers and environmental groups together to deliver nature recovery on the ground. In addition, we have the sustainable farming investment scheme, which allows farm businesses to invest in technologies that improve water quality. I am also proud of the work that farmers and environmental organisations have done to agree a way forward on the nutrients action programme (NAP), which will make a huge difference to addressing pollution from agricultural sources.
In addition, I am clear that I want stronger regulation and enforcement on sewage discharges. I await Executive approval so that we can end the bye ball that was wrongly afforded to Northern Ireland Water under the statement of regulatory principles and intent (SORPI). Furthermore, I am progressing legislation to increase fines and penalties for water pollution and hold polluters to account.
Mr Muir: Before April 2026 and following the introduction of hybrid working, my Department had already taken significant steps to maximise the utilisation of Jubilee House. We reduced our office accommodation to reflect operational needs. That created space for the Department for Communities to occupy the second floor of the building and for the Department of Finance to operate a Connect2 hub on part of the ground floor. The hub is available for staff from across the Northern Ireland Civil Service to use.
Since the end of March this year, the number of my Department's staff in post at Jubilee House has increased by 18 to 471. We have been able to accommodate those additional staff in DAERA's existing space, facilitated by hybrid working arrangements. However, our accommodation requirements will continue to be monitored and kept under review to ensure the most effective and efficient use of Jubilee House.
Mr Robinson: I thank the Minister for that response. A lot of money was invested in Jubilee House, and I want to see the economic and employment benefits from that investment. What discussions have you had with Ministers about bringing additional Civil Service jobs to Ballykelly?
Mr Muir: We have already taken significant action in that respect, as I said, through the use of the second floor by the Department for Communities. We will continue to engage with Departments as necessary when they are looking for office accommodation. Jubilee House is a building which we should be proud of. My predecessor opened the building, and it provides good accommodation for staff. I recognise that hybrid working arrangements have changed how we need office accommodation, and we have reflected that in accommodating the Department for Communities. If other Departments want to consider using the building, we already have the ground floor available for a hot-desking arrangement, and we are open to other discussions if necessary.
Ms D Armstrong: Minister, your Department has stated that hybrid working has enabled a 52% reduction in DAERA's benchmark office estate, generating approximately £950,000 of income from leasing part of Jubilee House to another Department and delivering substantial savings in heating, electricity and running costs. Given those savings, what assessment has been made of whether further efficiencies could be achieved through the additional rationalisation of the Department's office estate?
Mr Muir: We always keep our office estate under review. However, I have also received correspondence about the value that our DAERA Direct offices provide to our farming community, particularly in giving access to face-to-face services. We will continue to strike a balance and to review our estate. The arrangements that we have in place work well, hopefully, for our staff, whom we want to keep motivated, and for public service delivery, which, we want to ensure, remains the focus of all that we do.
Mr Muir: While the UK-EU sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement is a reserved matter, I have met UK Ministers regularly to press for a comprehensive SPS agreement that serves Northern Ireland's interests, particularly those of our agri-food sector. I have used those discussions to highlight the needs of Northern Ireland. Engagement includes regular four-nation ministerial meetings chaired by Baroness Hayman, covering negotiation progress and arrangements following any agreement. She has also chaired regular and frequent quadrilateral ministerial meetings to ensure that all regions of the UK are appropriately briefed on negotiation developments and consulted on ways of working post any agreement.
Since the EU-UK common understanding was announced in May 2025, my officials have also met DEFRA weekly to discuss the details of the negotiations. I remain confident that a positive outcome will be announced at the summit on Friday that will be good for our consumers, good for our businesses and good for our farmers.
Mr Dickson: Thank you, Minister, for your answer. In those conversations with officials and Ministers, do you encourage the United Kingdom Government to go further in strengthening our ties with the European Union ahead of this week's summit?
Mr Muir: I am proud that Alliance was the first party to call for an SPS agri-food and drink agreement. While others were promising sunny uplands and then complaining about the self-inflicted consequences of Brexit, we were getting on with the job of ameliorating some of its worst consequences.
The honesty from the new British Prime Minister about what we have lost is welcome. It is clear that the Brexit experiment has been an utter failure. Take, for example, the extra admin for our businesses; the skills shortages faced by many sectors across our economy; the loss of opportunities for our young people; the constant worry about regulatory divergence; and the hoops that British citizens have to jump through when going on holiday. The fact is that Brexit has made us all poorer. At a time when we can least afford it, the UK economy is 6% smaller, and our public finances suffer as a result.
The Brexiteers on the Benches to my right are guilty of one of the greatest acts of economic sabotage. I urge the Prime Minister to go further and embrace a closer relationship with Europe. Rejoining the European Union should be the ultimate destination. In the short term, however, we should consider rejoining the single market and the customs union. Alliance will continue to promote stronger ties with the European Union, because that would be good for Northern Ireland and good for our neighbours across these islands.
Mr T Buchanan: Minister, regardless of our differing positions on Brexit, which, by the way, was democratic, do you agree that farm businesses, garden centres and retailers should never have been subjected to additional bureaucracy and costs caused by divergence in the first place? Do you now regret calling for the rigorous implementation of a food border within the UK?
Mr Muir: The Member probably forgets this, but Northern Ireland voted to remain. I hear Members from the DUP bemoaning the consequences of Brexit, but it is a Brexit that they championed and sold, and they need to own it. I am trying to deal with the consequences of Brexit. You pushed for a hard Brexit —.
Mr Muir: You pushed for a hard Brexit, and we are dealing with the consequences of that. I am focused on solutions and on delivering for Northern Ireland, and that is what I am doing.
Mr O'Toole: We could all have long conversations about the DUP's mania over a hard Brexit, which is an obsession that it still has not got over, despite the damage that it has done to it.
Minister, you talked about an SPS agreement: the SDLP has long championed an SPS agreement. Have you and your Department specifically made formal representations to the UK Government about the benefits of an SPS agreement to Northern Ireland and our agri-food sector? Have you put that in writing to the UK Government and, indeed, the EU?
Mr Muir: I have not just sent letters; I have been engaging regularly on the details, which is important. The SPS agreement will not solve everything, because Brexit has caused so many problems, but it will address a lot of the concerns that have been raised with us all in recent years. The details will be announced on Friday. It will include areas such as the emissions trading scheme (ETS) and the carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM). I will not go into the technical detail associated with those —
Mr Muir: — but you will recognise the importance associated with them. It is very detailed, and maybe you and I could have a chat about it afterwards.
It is an important deal, but we need to go further. We need to have a closer relationship with the European Union. That would be good for Northern Ireland, good for the UK and good for the European Union. I consider myself a European citizen, and it is in our interests to rejoin the European Union. My aspiration is to be back in the European Union, because that would deliver real benefits for Northern Ireland. In the short term, however, we are looking to get the deal over the line and have it legislated for.
Ms Murphy: On possible cost savings for your Department, Minister — [Interruption.]
Ms Murphy: Minister, have you done a cost impact assessment looking at possible savings for your Department, the agri-food sector and, most important, our economy?
Mr Muir: The UK Government have done assessments of the wider impact associated with our leaving the European Union and not having an SPS agreement. As the Member will probably appreciate, that does not sit primarily under my direction and control: it is a reserved matter that the UK Government are negotiating with the European Union. I am focused on getting the full detail published on Friday, and then, at the beginning of December, I will proceed to Brussels to engage with member states and MEPs. We need to send a strong ,positive message from Northern Ireland that we can be trusted to abide by international trade deals — that is important because trade is based on trust — and to sell Northern Ireland as a place in which to invest, live and visit. We should be proud of what we have delivered in Northern Ireland and of the relationship that we can have with the European Union, which would be good for Northern Ireland.
Mr Muir: In line with the Windsor Framework (Implementation) Regulations 2024, Regulation (EU) 2023/1115, which is the EU deforestation regulation, and any discussions associated with its implementation fall under the direction and control of the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.
Mrs Dillon: Thank you, Minister. Can you confirm whether you or your Department have had any conversations or interaction with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) to ensure that implementation of the EU deforestation regulation is aligned across this island, as this is the island that matters to me?
Mr Muir: I go back to my original response because that does not sit under my direction and control. It sits under DEFRA, and the engagement will be via DEFRA to DAFM. Whilst people see this as something that DAERA implements, it occurs under the direction and control of the DEFRA Minister. However, one of the issues here is with the agreement on Friday. We want to have alignment, as much as is possible, with the EU because that is good for our businesses in Northern Ireland and those in the South of Ireland, the rest of the UK and the European Union. We are better together. I will not prejudge what comes out on Friday, but the more that we can be aligned on EUDR and other issues, the more it will be good for all of us.
Ms Bradshaw: Minister, can you please outline why the EU deforestation regulations are important?
Mr Muir: Thank you, Paula. The EUDR will help to ensure that products placed in or exported from Northern Ireland to the EU market do not contribute to deforestation, which is one of the top drivers of biodiversity loss and climate change globally. Protecting and restoring nature is not just a nice thing to do. I set that out earlier at the RSPB event upstairs. It is our legal and moral obligation to future generations to protect and enhance the natural environment. I therefore welcome the regulation.
Miss McIlveen: Regardless of whether it is a DEFRA regulation or not, there will be an impact on Northern Ireland. Therefore, what engagement has the Minister had with local industry, including the new chief executive of the Northern Ireland Grain Trade Association, on the prospective harm of that regulation as it comes in from 1 January 2027?
Mr Muir: As I set out, this does not sit under my direction and control, as a result of legislation that your party requested. I engaged with stakeholders around it, but the primary responsibility for engagement with stakeholders is with DEFRA.
Mr Muir: Northern Ireland’s first climate action plan is overdue. It has been with Executive colleagues since August and now needs to be published urgently. The priority must be to agree it without further delay so that we can accelerate delivery. We must also turn our attention to the second plan, which will set out a programme of sustained action across government and will give businesses, communities and investors the clarity and confidence that they need. I have set out my vision for bold action. It is lower emissions, thriving nature and a stronger economy. That means accelerating clean, renewable energy; improving the energy efficiency of homes and buildings; supporting sustainable transport and agriculture; and restoring peatland, expanding woodland and reducing waste. Delivering that vision demands a shared commitment across government.
The opportunities are clear: investment, skilled jobs, healthier communities and a more resilient economy. The costs of doing nothing are equally stark: damaged infrastructure, disrupted businesses and pressure on households and public finances. Climate change is not a distant threat; it is here in Northern Ireland. Record-breaking warm summers, frequent storms and flooding are already causing costly disruption. As COP31 enters its final days, world leaders, experts and civil society representatives have recognised this as a turning point for climate action. Northern Ireland must play its part. The immediate priority is Executive agreement. The plan is ready, and we must now move to agreement, publication and delivery.
Mr Tennyson: Thank you, Minister, for that answer. Do you agree that it is indefensible that the DUP is blocking a plan that would result in cleaner, greener and cheaper energy, warmer homes and better jobs for people in Northern Ireland?
Mr Muir: I could not agree more. Whilst the DUP is stuck in the mode of dither, delay and deny, quoting outdated and irrelevant figures — a bit like the party, to be honest — I am getting on with the job. Climate action is an investment, and, all the time, it is getting cheaper whilst the costs of staying on the fossil fuel roller coaster will again be felt by households across Northern Ireland this winter. Countries such as Denmark, Spain and even China are turning to renewable energy, and people are making savings as a result. Northern Ireland is predicted to make a net saving by our fourth carbon budget, which I soon be laying in the House.
Let me outline, for the slow learners, what that investment looks like: investing in home-grown renewable energy to promote energy security, reduce bills and have cleaner air; making our homes more energy efficient and warmer; developing a green economy with clean growth; supporting innovation; and creating good green jobs. It is about supporting our agriculture sector to become more sustainable; investing in active travel and public transport; and planting trees, restoring peatland and enabling nature recovery. All that work is already being done, and the money for the CAP period has already been invested. The young people to whom I spoke at the COP31 climate simulation event for schools on Friday made clear their desire for action. Those who are stuck in the mode of dither, delay and deny will not be judged well by history.
Mr Wilson: Minister, figures provided by your Department show an increase of 182% in climate-related spending, including £140 million over three years. My question is asked against a backdrop of the apparent availability of money. I welcome the additional spend that was secured for the rural business development grant scheme, which meant that 286 businesses in my council area received letters of offer confirming support. From your previous answers to me, however, I know that the scheme was heavily oversubscribed across the Province, with projects totalling £16 million approved but only half that amount of funding available. Minister, will you commit to the House that you will ensure that, in the next roll-out of the rural business development grant scheme, which is to be next spring, you will significantly increase the amount of funding, in order —
Mr Wilson: — to put our rural businesses on the best footing for the future —
Mr Wilson: — and divert an element of climate spend towards that clearly oversubscribed but important grant scheme?
Mr Muir: The substantive question was about the importance of investing in tackling climate change and of taking action to deliver good green jobs, renewable energy, lower bills and healthier communities. That is what my Department and other Departments are doing, and I am proud of that, because it will bring real benefits. I have set out how the Department has worked hard to secure additional funding for that grant scheme, but the Member will be aware of the acute budgetary situation in which we are operating. I have moved twice to allocate additional funding to the grant scheme, because I recognise the level of interest in it, and that is what I have sought to match. I also have to watch the overall budgetary situation, however, in order to see what we have available to spend, which is very tight.
Mr Gaston: The Environment Minister is more focused on advancing his climate ideology than he is on protecting our country's food security. Will he tell the House how much his Department is spending on net zero initiatives and other radical woke policies instead of supporting the family farms that feed our great nation?
Mr Muir: The Member says that it is ideology. As I have set out previously, it is science and evidence, but he does not respect that science and evidence. His question goes off on all sorts of tangents, so it is very difficult to reply to him. My Department is investing in the future of Northern Ireland. We owe it to future generations to tackle what is the defining issue of our generation. The Member's Trumpian perspective on life does nothing to serve farmers in Northern Ireland, where climate change is the biggest threat to them. We owe it to the people of Northern Ireland to face the issue, grasp the opportunity and address the challenge, not to deny the science and evidence and go off on spurious tangents, for which the Member is very well known.
Mr Muir: Plastic pollution has a significant negative impact on our environment, human health and marine life. I am committed to delivering ambitious action to reduce unnecessary plastic waste and to support sustainable alternatives. In doing so, I am mindful of the potential implications for the competitiveness of Northern Ireland businesses. My departmental officials continue to engage with their counterparts in the other UK nations in order to align circular economy ambitions, reduce unnecessary plastic UK-wide and ensure, where possible, a consistent approach.
Packaging extended producer responsibility was jointly developed and implemented from April 2025 as a UK-wide scheme. Policy decisions continue to be agreed collaboratively in order to maintain a consistent framework across all UK nations. There are currently no areas of policy divergence, with the agreed framework ensuring uniform obligations, implementation and enforcement throughout the UK. The UK Government introduced the plastic packaging tax in April 2022 to encourage the use of recycled plastic in plastic packaging. The tax is an excepted matter, administered by HMRC, and all UK businesses that meet the relevant criteria are required to register.
Restrictions on certain single-use plastic items already apply elsewhere on these islands but have not yet been implemented in Northern Ireland. DAERA officials are working to transpose elements of the EU single-use plastics directive. That legislation is under the direction and control of the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, and it is anticipated that it will come into force on 1 April 2027, thus aligning Northern Ireland with restrictions that are already in effect across the EU and in GB.
Mrs Cameron: I am surprised that the Minister does not understand that the Brexit vote was a UK-wide vote and that whatever way Northern Ireland voted, be it in or out, made no difference to the overall result.
Does he accept that locally based Northern Ireland businesses such as those in my South Antrim constituency are being disadvantaged? Those companies are having to bear significant compliance costs, while competing suppliers that operate over the Irish border may not face equivalent obligations or enforcement. What assurances can the Minister give that Northern Ireland businesses will not continue to be disadvantaged against competitors elsewhere in the UK and Ireland as a consequence of these arrangements?
Mr Muir: Regardless of any referendum outcome, the consequences of it are entirely clear, and, frankly, you can own that. Ten years ago, there was a big red bus, and you were thrown under it, and we have felt the consequences of all that. Fair play to the UK Government for trying to address some of the issues arising from Brexit. I want them to go further. There is real benefit for us in being closer to the European Union. If I was the DUP, I would keep my head low on Brexit, to be honest. If the Member gives me specific examples of the issues that she set out, I can consider them. However, there is a clear benefit to us being aligned with the EU, which is a very large trading bloc.
Ms Egan: Minister, will you please outline the benefits of extended producer responsibilities in protecting the environment and boosting our council recycling rates?
Mr Muir: The extended producer responsibility for packaging collects £1·4 billion per annum from producers across the UK to address the costs associated with packaging faced by local authorities. Essentially, it is the principle that the polluter pays, which is a pretty sound principle. In the first year of the scheme, £51 million was allocated to Northern Ireland councils to address those costs and improve recycling efficiency and effectiveness. As Ministers across the UK, we continue to engage on those issues. We recognise some of the challenges that have arisen, particularly in the glass sector, and are looking at a coordinated package of supportive measures. The scheme is about reducing the level of waste by preventing it but also by ensuring that the polluter pays, which we should all support.
Mr Muir: Over the past two decades, Northern Ireland's household recycling rate has doubled to 50%. The proportion sent to landfill fell from over 50% to around 14%, and recent provisional figures show that it is now lower still. However, recycling rates have plateaued. Analysis indicates that at least 50% of waste in residual bins could be recycled. Increasing the capture of recyclable materials provides an opportunity to improve recycling performance and further reduce reliance on landfill.
My officials are finalising a new resources and waste strategy, bringing together policies on waste prevention, reuse, repair and recycling to help to set the strategic direction for managing resources and waste. DAERA already supports repair and reuse initiatives through delivery partners such as the Northern Ireland Resources Network, and works closely with councils to improve recycling services, increase food waste collections and improve the quality of recyclable materials collected from households. The household waste recycling collaborative change programme has made £23 million available to councils to improve recycling and collection systems. There is considerable scope to increase recycling from the non-household municipal sector through greater waste separation. The challenge now is not simply to reduce landfill but to keep valuable resources in productive use for as long as possible, supporting a more circular economy.
Mr Allen: I thank the Minister for his answer. Minister, does your Department have a role in monitoring the quantity of products sent for recycling that are actually recycled?
Mr Muir: There is obviously a role for district councils in waste and recycling, and we report regularly on all waste that is collected and recycled. If the Member has specific concerns, I am happy to follow those up with the council concerned.
Mr Honeyford: Will the Minister outline how separate recycling streams can help to develop the circular economy, provide jobs and grow the economy in Northern Ireland?
Mr Muir: Thank you, David. The quality of recycling is just as important as the quantity. Source-separated collections can reduce contamination and improve the quality of recyclable materials. Higher quality materials are more likely to be reprocessed locally, and many places do that. That supports local investment, jobs and circular economy opportunities.
Mr Speaker: Dr Aiken is not in his place, Colin McGrath is not in his place, Sinéad McLaughlin is not in her place, and John Stewart is not in his place. Shame on them.
Mr Muir: Thank you, Connie. The nature recovery strategy sets out how we will halt and reverse biodiversity decline, protect more important sites, restore degraded habitats, reduce pressures on wildlife and help threatened species to recover. Central to that is the international 30by30 target to ensure that at least 30% of our land and sea is effectively protected and managed for nature by 2030. Bigger and better connected habitats will give wildlife the conditions needed to recover. The strategy includes a detailed species recovery programme, action to improve protected sites and stronger consideration of biodiversity in government decision-making.
Farmers are essential to delivery, and the Farming with Nature package is a core part of that.
I commend the RSPB for today's event in the Long Gallery and for the work that it does. I hope that all MLAs get an opportunity to pop along.
Ms Egan: Minister, what is your assessment of the proposal by Ards and North Down Borough Council to utilise mechanical beach-cleaning equipment despite clear warnings about its impact on biodiversity?
Mr Muir: Thank you, Connie. I watched that council debate: I do not know what planet those councillors are on, but it is not this one. We have to care for the planet and respect science and evidence. If councillors cannot do that, we will send them a letter as a reminder.
Mr Muir: NIEA assesses each proposal on its merits. Where the proposed infilling does not qualify as "relevant work" for the purposes of paragraph 19, it falls outside the scope of the exemption and would not be registered as being in line with the requirements of the Waste Management Licensing Regulations. In that case, applicants are instead directed to the appropriate authorisation route. Depending on the activity's nature and scale, that may require a pollution prevention and control permit, a waste management licence or other relevant environmental authorisation. That ensures that waste recovery and disposal activities are properly regulated to protect human health and the environment.
Mr Speaker: We must move to topical questions. I call Daniel McCrossan, or is it the man from Del Monte? [Laughter.]
Mr McCrossan: You have just ruined my rhythm, Mr Speaker. I had a serious question, and you took the steam right out of it.
T1. Mr McCrossan asked the Minister of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, having noted that, as of this morning, he, like many MLAs, had received 1,100 emails from people across Northern Ireland about the Minister's carbon tax proposals, about which small family farms are deeply worried, to tell farmers what, in pounds and pence, his proposals will cost a typical small family farm and what specific protections he will put in place to stop those costs forcing family farms out of business. (AQT 2821/22-27)
Mr Muir: Thank you, Daniel. On this issue, I hope that it will be a case of, "The man from Del Monte says yes".
The benefits of climate action are really clear. Farmers can sign up to the carbon footprinting project at no charge. Having signed up, they will get a full understanding of their business, which will help them make decisions to increase efficiency and profitability and to reduce their carbon footprint. That is really positive and beneficial and is something that many processors, banks and retailers are looking for when it comes to additional scope emissions reporting categories, so we should all support it.
Mr McCrossan: Minister, I get that some are in favour of it, particularly larger operations, but farmers are worried that, if they do not comply with the regulations, their single farm payment will be cut, not because they will not comply but because they are not capable of doing so. If a small family farm struggles to afford the changes, how would cutting its income help it to comply? Will you provide such farmers with upfront financial incentives to ensure that they can afford to make such transitions?
Mr Muir: The Member slightly misunderstands the carbon footprinting project. Farmers can sign up to it online. We gather some information that we already hold in line with the privacy notice to ensure that privacy is protected. Farmers provide additional information and are given information that they can act on as they require.
We will not require people to do something as a result of a carbon footprinting report. We are giving farmers the tools to reduce their carbon emissions and to increase their efficiency and profitability as an enterprise. As the Member knows, processors, banks and retailers look for that information, and we seek to give farmers the tools to provide it consistently. Rather than having different calculators in use across Northern Ireland, the project uses a unified calculator. It is proposed to make it a condition of the farm sustainability payment, because we see the benefits associated with the project. As the Chair of the Public Accounts Committee, the Member will be aware that we rightly deliver significant funding to support our agricultural community. We also need to demonstrate value for money, however, and that is one way of doing so.
T2. Mr Bradley asked the Minister of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, to enable Members to look at the science, what percentage of the world's carbon emissions comes from Northern Ireland. (AQT 2822/22-27)
Mr Muir: I know where the Member is going with the comparison with the rest of the world: down the same avenue as Phillip Brett, saying, "What's the point? China is creating loads of emissions, sure, so let's give up". That is the attitude, but, in reality, there are many other countries, small nations and devolved Administrations that are similar to us. I want the Member to step back and look at the ambition of the other nations in the UK.
Scotland is aiming for net zero by 2045. If you look at it from the perspective of businesses, you see that their commitment to it is very clear. The House passed legislation. The first climate action plan is aligned to an 82% reduction, which is what the Member is seeking to support. That is what the first climate action plan is aligned to, so why not agree to it? It is beyond me why that has sat at the Executive since August.
Mr Bradley: I thank the Minister for answering Phillip Brett, but I asked the question, not Phillip. If you had the manners to answer me rather than somebody who is not here, I would appreciate it. I do not give you bad manners, and I will not take any back. Thank you. I think that I have said enough.
Mr Muir: I could not answer Phillip Brett, because he is not here.
T5. Mr Nesbitt asked the Minister of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs what is being done to support rural communities. (AQT 2825/22-27)
Mr Muir: The Department is delivering significant interventions to support rural communities. The key policy that we are delivering is Rural NI, which is a new policy being supported across government to ensure that we all champion the needs of rural communities and deliver for them. In addition, we have a range of popular funding schemes, including the rural micro capital grant scheme and TRPSI — tackling rural poverty and social isolation framework — which is another acronym that we have in the Department. It is really important that we agree the new Rural NI intervention, which will give confidence to rural communities that Departments are stepping forward and delivering for them across the whole of Northern Ireland.
Mr Nesbitt: I thank the Minister for that. I note that he mentioned a number of funding streams. Will he articulate the quanta?
Mr Muir: Thank you, Mike. The tackling rural poverty and social isolation framework continues to deliver practical support across Northern Ireland. In 2025-26, its initiatives were estimated to benefit around 165,000 rural dwellers, helping to tackle poverty and social isolation and improve health and well-being. We are also working with our counterpart down South and the Special EU Programmes Body to deliver £80 million of PEACE PLUS investment, supporting rural communities through regeneration, social inclusion, innovation and smart towns and villages. Alongside that, we are also developing the Rural NI approach, which is with the Executive for approval. In addition, I have secured Executive agreement to add an additional 54 public authorities to the schedule to the Rural Needs Act (Northern Ireland) 2016 to make sure that they properly account for how they are delivering for rural communities.
T7. Mr Dickson asked the Minister of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs what role councils have in supporting the roll-out of his programme of animal welfare reforms. (AQT 2827/22-27)
Mr Muir: Councils, and their animal welfare officers and dog wardens, play a vital role in protecting companion animal welfare and often deal with difficult and complex cases. My Department recognises and values that contribution. Councils have a statutory responsibility for companion animal welfare enforcement. We want to work closely with them to deliver clear, proportionate and practical requirements that improve animal welfare and can be enforced effectively. For example, councils will enforce the new requirements under Lucy's law. I will shortly announce my next steps following the recent consultation on companion animal welfare reforms, including banning specific aversive training devices and improving microchipping arrangements. Councils' operational experience is essential to getting the implementation of those reforms right. We want their input as the guidance is developed, including on how compliance can be checked, evidence can be gathered and offences can be enforced. The Department's role is to develop a clear and workable legislative framework in partnership with those responsible for putting it into practice.
Mr Dickson: Thank you, Minister, for your answer. Councils have an important role in supporting animal welfare protections. What additional work should and could they do?
Mr Muir: Thank you, Stewart. Councils retain responsibility for their operational enforcement decisions. That includes ensuring that animal welfare enforcement is appropriately prioritised and resourced locally, including consideration of staffing, officer training, operational capacity and arrangements for responding to welfare concerns. They have valuable operational experience and local knowledge, and I want them to bring that expertise to the table, helping to identify practical challenges and working with us to develop solutions. Our shared objective is better outcomes for animals across Northern Ireland through effective legislation, practical implementation and close cooperation between central and local government. We are progressing key legislation — Lucy's law — to introduce a ban on the third-party sale of pups and kittens. I am disappointed that local government has decided not to attend or participate in working groups around the design and implementation of that legislation. I urge local government to rethink how it approaches that issue with us.
Mr Speaker: Eóin Tennyson is not in his place. I call Paula Bradshaw.
T9. Ms Bradshaw asked the Minister of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs to update the House on efforts to designate inner Belfast lough as a protected area for shellfish. (AQT 2829/22-27)
Mr Muir: I am seeking, as a matter of urgency, the Executive's agreement for the identification of the inner Belfast lough shellfish water protected area as a sensitive area. That is DAERA's statutory responsibility under the Urban Waste Water Treatment Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2007, and it is a key element of my Department's wider plan to improve water quality not only in Belfast lough but across all of our waterbodies. Whilst I recognise the implications associated with that, it is a legal obligation, and identification will enable DAERA to meet its statutory obligations, support the long-term environmental and economic recovery of Belfast lough and provide regulatory clarity for infrastructure planning whilst making sure that we meet our legal obligations. It is important that there is Executive agreement on that because, yet again, we are acting unlawfully because the Executive are sitting on one of my papers.
Ms Bradshaw: Thank you, Minister. What impact is the failure to upgrade our creaking waste water infrastructure having on the health of our waterbodies, housebuilding and the economy?
Mr Muir: Improving water quality in Northern Ireland remains one of my highest priorities. Insufficient treatment capacity and pressure on waste water systems can harm water quality. Waste water discharges are a frequent and significant pressure in some catchments. Much of our sewerage network is aging and, in some locations, already at or close to capacity. During periods of heavy rainfall, overloaded systems can result in untreated waste water entering watercourses, with consequential risks to water quality and the wider environment.
Whilst I recognise the constraints in Northern Ireland's waste water infrastructure, we have legal obligations to improve water quality and not have raw sewage being pumped into our rivers, lakes and loughs. It is important that the Executive step up to that and agree the papers in front of them so that we can properly tackle sewage pollution in Northern Ireland.
Mr Speaker: Topical question 10 has been withdrawn, Minister, so you can take your leave. Thank you. Members may take their ease. I am not permitted to start questions to the Executive Office until 2.45 pm, so you may chat amongst yourselves for two and a half minutes.
Mrs Little-Pengelly (The deputy First Minister): Mr Speaker, with your indulgence, I take the opportunity, at the outset of Question Time, to extend my deepest condolences to my colleague and former Member of the House Lord Morrow of Clogher Valley on the deeply sad deaths of his daughter, Rachel, and his wife, Lady Morrow. I am sure that I speak for all Members when I say that we are thinking of Maurice, of Victoria for the loss of her sister and mother on the same day, and of Rachel's husband, John, and her children, Jack and Isla.
I am pleased to say that the competition is at an advanced stage and is currently under ministerial consideration.
Mr McAleer: I thank the Minister for her response. I associate myself with the thoughts and prayers for the Morrow family at this desperately sad time.
Minister, there were four successful candidates from a merit-based public appointments competition, but, for two years, you have refused to make the appointments. Do you accept that that undermines confidence in the process?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: As I indicated, I am pleased to say that the competition is at an advanced stage, and it is under ministerial consideration.
Mrs Cameron: I also wish to place on record my condolences to Lord Morrow on such a terrible tragedy. Our thoughts and prayers are with him and the family at this time.
Can the deputy First Minister outline the steps that have been taken to secure additional funding for victims and survivors organisations? Does she agree that those who have dedicated their lives to supporting victims and survivors should not be left struggling to deliver essential services because of the uncertainty about the funding?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: Yes, I absolutely agree with the Member. Right across Northern Ireland, people are working day in, day out in organisations and individually to support victims and survivors of the Troubles. Many victims and survivors still live with the physical and mental scars of what happened. Undoubtedly, a significant need is still there.
One of the key things that we have witnessed over the course of the application process for the pension for the severely injured is how retraumatising the process can be. That is inevitable because people are not just thinking about what happened; they have to put it down on an application form and are speaking to people about it. That has increased demand for and necessitated the supply of mental health supports right across our groups. I was pleased to listen to a number of my colleagues, including Keith Buchanan in Mid Ulster, who made representations on behalf of local victims' groups to get additional funds to ensure that those mental health supports can be there for people. I thank all the people in those organisations who work to support our victims and survivors. They must never be forgotten, and we must continue to support them and roll out the services that are so deeply required.
Mr Dickson: Like other Members, I add my words of sympathy to Lord Morrow and his family at this very difficult time. I remember my first meeting of the Justice Committee when I first came to the Assembly; he was the Chair of the Committee, and he was a very generous Chair. My sympathy is with him and his family.
Deputy First Minister, there is recognition in your answer that it is important to fill the vacancies on the board of the Victims and Survivors Service, but two years is a very long time. Can you tell us not only about those vacancies but whether any other appointments are being held up by your office as a result of the current impasse between yourself and the First Minister?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I assure the Member that we endeavour to move as swiftly as possible on public appointments. We have previously spoken to the commissioner about the issue. We have talked to the head of the Civil Service and, indeed, the Department, because the process for reappointments or appointments takes much too long. That becomes particularly challenging if somebody leaves unexpectedly, because we have been advised that you need at least a six- to 12-month process and run-in time before you can get somebody to be deemed appointable and before Ministers.
We have looked at all those issues. We have a number of vacancies at the moment, but I assure the Member that we are moving as swiftly as possible. Of course, we need to get the right people for those posts, and we are very aware of that. It takes time to get that right, but the process could be made much shorter and more fit for purpose, and we are looking at that at the moment.
Mrs Little-Pengelly: Communities in Transition currently operates in eight areas identified through independent research that the Executive programme on paramilitarism and organised crime (EPPOC) commissioned in late 2016. The areas are as follows: Carrickfergus and Larne; Derry/Londonderry; north Down; Lurgan; west Belfast; north Belfast; Shankill; and east Belfast.
In 2024, the Executive Office commissioned Queen's University Belfast to refresh the evidence base underpinning the identification of the CIT areas. Its research confirmed that the current eight CIT areas remain the most relevant for the programme. Although there are no plans to extend CIT to East Londonderry, we continue to keep the programme under review.
Ms Sugden: I thank the Minister for her answer, which I appreciate. I am sure, however, that Members across the House will recognise that pockets of paramilitary activity exist and that we are not getting a grip on the situation in the way in which we need to. Do we need another programme or plan to stop that type of behaviour, which is a scourge on Northern Ireland?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I thank the Member for her important question. It is 28 years since the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement and 20 years since the St Andrews Agreement. It is a complicated issue to take on. I have spoken to community organisations, the PSNI and policy experts, and I probably speak for most people across Northern Ireland when I say that we want to send a very clear message that no paramilitaries are wanted. There was never any justification for their existence, and they are absolutely not wanted now. They should simply get off the stage.
We also recognise the challenges in communities, however. They need help and support. They need programmes to support them with resilience. They need CIT programmes to help them with addiction issues, money-lending problems and a whole range of other social challenges. CIT is therefore deemed still to have relevance.
Moving forward, the Member may be aware that the Executive Office Committee has agreed to hold a consultation on what a refreshed programme should look like, but I am absolutely clear that we do not want any paramilitary activity to remain anywhere in Northern Ireland, so we must do everything that we can to help every community that continues to suffer the scourge of it.
Mrs Mason: The 40th anniversary of the formation of Ulster Resistance earlier this month has once again highlighted the involvement of senior DUP figures in its establishment and their support for it. Will the deputy First Minister call on those in her party who were involved in Ulster Resistance to provide to the PSNI all information that they hold about its arms importation and use their influence to ensure that all remaining paramilitary weapons are decommissioned without delay?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: The DUP has made clear that anyone with any information should come forward to the PSNI. We have taken a very clear line on paramilitary activity. Most of the people who are watching, when they hear what you just said, will, however, simply say, "What a hypocrite". You sit where you are sitting and say what you have said, but just have to look to your left and to your right. Right beside you is Carál Ní Chuilín. She was arrested in 1989 and sentenced to eight years for possession of firearms, possession of explosives and attempted murder. Look to your right, and you have Pat Sheehan, who is the cash-and-carry bomber. He was sentenced to 15 years. [Interruption.]
He was not at Drumcree the last time because he was in prison. He was convicted of attempting to booby-trap a Belfast security checkpoint with a bomb. It is sheer hypocrisy. Get your own house in order.
There are people sitting around you on those Benches who have information about crimes and about the disappeared. [Interruption.]
Tell them to come forward to the PSNI. Just this week, we heard the revelation that the Omagh bombing inquiry was told that senior people in Sinn Féin — senior people in the IRA were involved in discussions with people who were still carrying out terrorism. Utter hypocrisy. [Interruption.]
Mr Bradley: Minister, can you outline how CIT funding is helping communities that have experienced particular challenges and how it will ensure that communities in working-class areas can benefit fully from its programmes?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I thank the Member for his relevant question. Northern Ireland is trying to move on. We need to move on by addressing some of those issues and the terrible legacy of paramilitary organisations right across the piece, be they loyalist or republican, such as the legacy that has been left by the IRA. They were an absolute scourge on our communities. They have scarred individuals physically and mentally. It is left to the rest of us to attempt to do everything that we can to help those communities to move forward with their lives, including their community lives.
The CIT projects go across four key areas, as identified: mental health and addictions; exploitation, be that child, criminal, sexual or monetary; youth and encouraging aspiration within communities; and the impact of paramilitarism on the physical landscape, such as through murals and graffiti. A number of important projects are happening, which include restorative practices. I have had the opportunity to get out and speak to people who are involved in some of those projects. It is really inspiring to see the work that they do. Often, they work with some of the most challenging young people across our communities to give them the resilience to be able to resist the scourge and approaches of paramilitaries, and to give them some hope and opportunity in their lives.
Ms Egan: Deputy First Minister, have you considered expanding the parameters of the Communities in Transition programme in my constituency of North Down, because, unfortunately, it is not just individuals in the two estates that have been identified who have to suffer the scourge of paramilitary intimidation and coercion in their communities?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I thank the Member for her question. An aspect of the programme that we are actively looking at is a move to a more thematic approach, which would give flexibility outside very specific geographical boundaries. As with neighbourhood renewal or any of our programmes, if it is defined by geographical boundaries, there will be people who are objectively in a similar situation but who just do not get that help or support and cannot go to those programmes because they fall outside the particular area. There is an issue of fairness in that. We are actively looking at it. As I said, the consultation process is due to kick off, I think, in January 2027 and run to March 2027. That will inform the future overall programme, including what CIT will look like.
It is also really important that we avoid duplication. If some of those themes can be more mainstreamed within some of our many other programmes, such as Together: Building a United Community, our race relations programme, neighbourhood renewal or our programmes that go through Justice, that would also be a very good way in which to offer that help and support.
Mr O'Toole: Notwithstanding the whataboutery in the Chamber, which does no good for either reconciliation or, indeed, victims, I want to ask about Communities in Transition funding and loyalist paramilitaries who exist and continue to exert coercive control. There have been repeated statements from the police and others that loyalist paramilitaries were instrumental in fermenting and organising racist violence in this city over the past three summers. Deputy First Minister, have you sought to ask whether any recipients of Communities in Transition funding had any hand or part in fermenting racist violence over the past three years, and, if not, why not?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I have no interest in whataboutery, but I will not stand here and listen to unbelievable hypocrisy either, so it needs to be called out.
I advise the Member that I have absolutely no interest in funding people who are associated with paramilitary organisations — none whatsoever. I met the Chief Constable some months ago. On that occasion and the number of times that I have met him since, we discussed some of that disorder on the streets over the past number of years and I always asked him those questions. I said to him very clearly that, where there is paramilitary activity, there needs to be a robust criminal justice response. Where communities are subject to some of those approaches, be it coercive control or intimidation, we need to step up and help them with programmes around resilience and support.
I also said very clearly to the Chief Constable that, if the police have any intelligence whatsoever that any of those people sit in or are employed by community organisations, we need to know that. I am not a police officer or intelligence officer. I do not have the ability to get that information, but they do. I am always more than happy to work closely with the Chief Constable and the PSNI for that two-way flow of information. Again, the absolutely key message is this: paramilitaries are not wanted; they need to go away.
Mr Beattie: Minister, one of the CIT areas is in my own constituency of Lurgan: Drumgask and Kilwilkie. It is absolutely clear that it is not working. Does the deputy First Minister agree that the clear, hold and build strategy of CIT works only if it is built like an ink spot because it will expand out of initial areas into surrounding areas to transition them too.
Mrs Little-Pengelly: The CIT fund does not necessarily work specifically or directly with paramilitaries. It works with the local community to build local community resilience. Therefore, the planning for where it should be targeted is based on a range of different sources, including PSNI intelligence. I have robustly questioned some of that intelligence to find out where it is actually coming from and how robust the evidence is. An awful lot of that is gained from talking to the local community as well.
You are absolutely right. A lot of the lessons that we are using to form those programmes are based on best practice, be it restorative justice or other initiatives that have worked elsewhere. As I said, it is about building community resilience and, indeed, resistance to the coercive control or influence of paramilitary organisations. Very much at the heart of that are our young people. We do not want young people being dragged into that type of thing, and, regardless of the difficulties that we have seen over the past months, I welcome the fact that there has been a peaceful approach and that we have not seen a reaction that might have led to disorder on our streets. I do not want our young people being criminalised any more than anybody else in the Chamber does, but we need to work with them to protect them, to give them the best possible chance in life and to get them away from that type of influence.
Mrs Little-Pengelly: Mr Speaker, with your permission, junior Minister Bunting will answer this question.
Ms Bunting (Junior Minister, The Executive Office): The public consultation seeks views on the proposed inquiry rules, which will set out the procedures for conducting the inquiry and help ensure that it operates in a fair, transparent and consistent manner. The consultation opened on 23 September and closes today. Obviously, we were keen to hear from everybody with an interest in the proposals, particularly victims and survivors. We distributed the consultation documents to our victims and survivors mailing list and to more than 400 stakeholders. We also hosted online information events and engaged directly with the Victims and Survivors Consultation Forum to encourage participation and gather views. The responses will now be considered and a report published. Any necessary changes will then be made before the proposals are brought forward for Committee and Assembly scrutiny. The aim is to have the secondary legislation in place in early 2027, subject to the completion of the scrutiny processes.
Ms Murphy: I appreciate the work undertaken by TEO officials throughout that consultation process. Junior Minister, you will know that many birth mothers and their children are getting older. Their health is also declining, and they have waited decades for recognition. In that vein, can you set out when the redress scheme is expected to open and the timeline for its implementation?
Ms Bunting: I thank the Member for her question. We are acutely conscious of the age profile of some of the victims and survivors. A comprehensive package of support has been developed in partnership with the Victims and Survivors Service, WAVE Trauma Centre and Adopt NI. That includes practical help with completing applications, counselling and family tracing services to ensure that victims and survivors have support throughout the process.
I want to factor in a couple of other things. All of the services, particularly redress, must take account of terminal illness, and can take account of the age and health profile of applicants. All of that has been taken into account. The Member will be aware that we have been having difficulties with access to records. Victims and survivors raised that issue with us repeatedly. I assure Members that work is under way on that. Junior Minister Reilly and I have met with the Minister of Health and his officials, and there has been engagement on the matter at official level too. A lot of work is under way. A lot of support packages are in place. We are aware that there is still more to do, but we are eager that the redress scheme, subject to the consultation processes and Assembly scrutiny processes, will open as quickly as we can get it open in early 2027.
Mr Martin: Does the junior Minister agree that it is vital that the voices of victims and survivors remain at the heart of the process and that the inquiry must also have the necessary independence and powers to establish the truth and provide the very important answers that are required?
Ms Bunting: Yes, of course. There is no question that that is the case. Victims have been at the heart of the process the whole way through, and they have been provided with support throughout it. That was important too, given the traumatic events through which they suffered. They have been consulted on everything. Thus far, the Department has convened over 60 consultative forum meetings. There is regular engagement to make sure that we bring victims and survivors along with us. For us, it is imperative that victims and survivors have confidence in the processes, because what they have endured is horrendous, heartbreaking and, in some cases, frankly disgraceful.
The inquiry chair, Rachel Langdale KC, is extremely experienced in inquiries. She has been involved in several high-profile inquiries, and victims and survivors appear to be very happy with her appointment. She is moving at pace. She is not one to dither or protract processes, and she is very engaged in the entire process. Certainly, I can assure the House and any victims and survivors who may be watching that she will follow the evidence where it leads.
Ms Bradshaw: Thank you, junior Minister, for the information on the consultation. I assure you and your colleagues that the Committee will do everything that it can to expedite its scrutiny in respect of that process.
It is great to see that Rachel Langdale KC, as she now is, has been appointed as chair. Can you provide information on the other support and secretariat services that have been appointed to facilitate her in setting up the inquiry?
Ms Bunting: The work of the inquiry has already started, as the Member knows, because, as soon as the Bill received Royal Assent on 7 October, that essentially allowed for the formal commencement of the public inquiry. Rachel Langdale was announced as chair of the inquiry on 30 September. So far, she has engaged with victims and survivors — she did that in October — to gather their views on the inquiry's terms of reference. Those terms of reference will be finalised in the coming months. She has already submitted some views on them, and work is being undertaken in that regard. We expect further information on that from officials.
Oral hearings are expected to take place in late 2027. However, the Member will know that much work in relation to evidence, statements and records needs to be completed in advance of that. In the interim, Rachel is highly engaged. She has engaged with victims, although it is important for the independence of the inquiry that she retains a professional distance. She is, however, acutely aware of the issues at hand, and she is highly experienced. Support mechanisms will be put in place to ensure that every victim and survivor who chooses to come forward has access to everything that they need, including the supports that they require, so that we get as much evidence as possible and ensure that the inquiry produces everything necessary to satisfy victims and survivors.
Mr McNulty: The public consultation on the inquiry rules regarding mother-and-baby institutions, Magdalene laundries and workhouses closes today. "Well done" to everyone who has engaged with that consultation, however challenging it may have been. What immediate steps will the First Minister and deputy First Minister take to ensure that survivor and victim groups are directly consulted on the analysis thereof?
Ms Bunting: I assure the Member that victims and survivors have been part of the process of the consultation on the regulations and the inquiry rules. They have been engaged with at every stage. They were consulted via in-person and hybrid forum meetings, and they have been through the process. The intricacies of the consultation process were explained.
All of the analysis will be published. They will get the chance to see what comes out of it. They have had a chance to feed into it. There may be some changes once the analysis is complete, but all of those will be brought to the Assembly and the Committee for scrutiny. The Committee may wish to hear from victims and survivors again, but, for our part, we have ensured that they have been brought along with us throughout the consultation process. They have fed into it, and we will take on board the things that they have raised with us.
Mrs Little-Pengelly: We recognise the importance of supporting young people with special educational needs as they move from school to adulthood and the need for coordinated action across training, employment and health pathways. The delivery unit is overseeing a portfolio of transformation activity, within which are a number of projects that aim to strengthen pathways and outcomes for young people with special educational needs. As part of that, the unit is supporting a proposed transitions and pathways project that the transformation board has recommended for funding once more transformation funding is available. Our officials have been engaging with Departments that have direct policy responsibility, including the Department for the Economy, the Department of Education and the Department of Health, with discussions focusing on sharing information, updating progress and developing a collective understanding of the challenges involved.
Mrs Guy: I thank the deputy First Minister for the response. I want to be clear: is she talking specifically about post-19 reform or generally about support for kids with special educational needs who are moving into adulthood? I want to be clear on that point, because time is running out in the mandate to deliver for those kids. We know that we need cooperation between Departments. I want to be clear on whether the delivery unit is leading on that work. If it is not, will the deputy First Minister point us in the direction of the Minister who will lead on it?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: The delivery unit is not leading on the work. The delivery unit oversees the transformation projects; it is not really its role to take on that type of project. However, I am acutely aware of the needs. The Member, like me, has had a lot of engagement with, for example, Alma from Caleb's Cause and with other organisations. Across the Lagan Valley constituency, we see such valuable work in that post-19 age group, not least — it is always a worry to reference them in case some are left out — Live Life Well-Being Centre, Stepping Stones, Orchardville and other organisations such as Sensability that very much try to raise awareness of the needs of those with special educational needs.
The transformation project is being taken forward by the Department of Education, so that Department will have more detail of what it hopes to do. The project is at an early stage. It has been passed through the transformation board, so it has been cleared as a successful project, but it is in tranche 3, which is awaiting funding. My understanding is that it will look at a range of issues, including general provision for post-19 and the related transitions.
I strongly believe that we need to get on with cross-departmental work regardless. There is some provision, but it is not fit for purpose. We need greater coordination. That is not to say that individual aspects of it are not good; they are — I have witnessed that at first hand — but we need more of it to support parents, particularly when their child reaches the age to come out of full-time education. Transitions can be exceptionally difficult. We want all our people across Northern Ireland, including those with special educational needs, to have valuable continued development and an environment that is stimulating for them as they go into and through their adulthood.
Mr Baker: Will the deputy First Minister outline what practical impact the delivery unit has had to date in addressing the concerns of parents and carers about the availability of appropriate post-19 provision? What tangible improvements have been delivered for young people and their families?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I thank the Member. As I indicated, the delivery unit is not taking the lead on that work. It has a role in overseeing all the transformation projects, so it works with those projects across the piece, including in Health. Part of that role is about identifying some of the challenges and barriers that, unfortunately, continue to exist in cross-departmental and cross-agency working. That has been a particular frustration of mine for a long time. The reality is that many of the big, important issues do not fall simply within the silo of a particular agency or Department. We know that and have known it for a long time. We therefore need a better and more accountable way of working cross-departmentally. I have put that challenge to the head of the Civil Service and the permanent secretary in the Executive Office. We must work better in policy development and in implementation and delivery. If there is one thing that I would really like to see significant change in, it is that piece. Hopefully, the delivery unit is able to look across a range of working and will pull forward best practice so that we can establish it system-wide.
Mrs Erskine: Does the deputy First Minister agree that the delivery unit has a key role in overseeing transformation projects across government to drive greater efficiencies, reduce the cost of delivering public services and ensure that we have sustainable public finances? Does she also agree that that is particularly important in light of today's Northern Ireland Audit Office report on the Driver and Vehicle Agency's procurement of test centre equipment, which details that £5·1 million was paid out for a contract that provided nothing and that we have lost £11 million in MOT fees because Hydebank and Mallusk test centres are not open as a result of procurement failures in that transformation project?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: Thank you. The Member is absolutely correct. We simply cannot continue to do that. It is unacceptable, particularly at a time when we are under massive fiscal constraint. We simply do not have enough money to do the things that we need to do. At the moment, we do not have enough money for, for example, public-sector pay settlements. That is why we are fighting so hard. From a party perspective, the DUP has been determined to keep pushing the case, because we want our teachers, doctors and nurses to get the same pay increase as others have got across the UK.
The issue that the Member highlighted is one of deep frustration to me. We must drive inefficiency and waste from every part of every Department, and people who stand over that must absolutely be held accountable for it, because we do not have the money to waste. However, even if we did, it would be completely unacceptable, because we should be utilising that money in a way that best serves the purposes that we want it for: to improve public services for the people of Northern Ireland. It is unacceptable. We need to get this right, and, moving forward, we have to scrutinise all such decisions to make sure that public money is being spent in a way that maximises value for the public whom we serve.
Mr O'Toole: Deputy First Minister, the SDLP believes in building a better Northern Ireland on a journey to building a new Ireland — an inclusive, anti-sectarian new Ireland — for everyone. We will go anywhere and talk to anyone about that vision, and, to that end, we planned to have a town hall public event on the Lower Newtownards Road here in east Belfast last night. We have had to move it because of intimidation. It is still going ahead, but we have had to move it. I respect unionism's not wanting to talk about a new Ireland, but I also respect your ability and right to go anywhere and to talk to anybody about your preference for the Union.
Mr O'Toole: asked the First Minister and deputy First Minister whether the deputy First Minister will unequivocally condemn the intimidation that obliged his party members to move their meeting to talk about their vision for an inclusive new Ireland and whether she respects their right to go into any community in Northern Ireland to talk about that vision.
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I have said before and am more than happy to say again very clearly that I absolutely condemn any intimidation. There is no space for it whatsoever anywhere in Northern Ireland, regardless of the circumstances. We need to move to a position of respect. The issue that the Member raises is an important one, because, over the past number of months, we have not seen that respect. We have heard some appalling things said, including about my cultural identity and heritage, and that has caused a significant amount of hurt, dismay and anger across Northern Ireland.
When I stepped into the role of deputy First Minister, I did so on a very clear platform: to give respect and to show respect. However, I also demand that respect back, and I know that the Member will agree with me on that. We have seen a number of months of appalling behaviour by some. There has been disregard, demeaning and dismissing, and, frankly, many of us in the Chamber need to step back and take a hard look at ourselves and where we are going. I will always push for a better, brighter future in Northern Ireland for all of us. I stand over all the events and activities that I have attended to send a very clear message about the type of future for Northern Ireland that we are trying to build. However, that future cannot be built on defying the law, hatred of somebody else's cultural identity or intimidation.
Mr O'Toole: I appreciate the fact that the deputy First Minister has condemned intimidation, and intimidation it was. We will not be deterred from bringing our vision of a better Northern Ireland and a hopeful new Ireland to people from all backgrounds here. I respect not just the tradition that you come from, deputy First Minister; I respect your and your party's right to sell your vision of the Union to anybody anywhere.
Deputy First Minister, given that this place is clearly, as you have effectively said, mired in division and dysfunction, will you open your and your party's minds to reform of these institutions, because the public out there simply do not think that this place is working? If you say that you believe in mutual respect, surely you also believe that no one party should be able to collapse the Government here.
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I believe in a bright future for Northern Ireland, safely and strongly within the United Kingdom. I will not engage in conversations that would bring about the end of Northern Ireland's place in the United Kingdom. I believe strongly in our future — 100-plus years and still going strong. There are Members who, I believe, do not want Northern Ireland to succeed, thrive or even survive. I will always do everything in my power to make this place work. That does not mean putting up with hypocrisy, bad behaviour or people thumbing their nose at the rule of law, but somebody in the Executive Office needs to take responsibility for trying to push forward for everyone in Northern Ireland. I will face recklessness with responsibility. I will face those who break the law by not becoming a lawbreaker. I will face the future with the values that I want Northern Ireland to continue to build on so that everyone can have a successful and thriving future here, regardless of their background.
Ms Bradshaw: asked the First Minister and deputy First Minister, given that the all-party group (APG) on ethnic minority community met yesterday in Parliament Buildings and heard some really insightful presentations, one of the recurring themes of which was the involvement of paramilitary organisations in racially motivated violence and intimidation, to outline any discussions or work that has taken place between Departments to rid us of paramilitary control.
Mrs Little-Pengelly: There need to be further conversations with the Chief Constable and the PSNI. I specifically asked the Chief Constable at the time of the race-related disorder about whether any paramilitary activity was involved, and he said that the assessment was that there was not, although he added that the police could not discount the possibility that individuals who may have been involved in paramilitarism in the past had been involved in some of the disorder. We therefore need to get clarity on that, because I hear that assertion repeatedly now, and I do not believe that what is being put across is accurate. If it is accurate, however, we need to receive a clear assessment from the PSNI.
On the Member's wider question, we need to work with the local community to make sure that we move into a future that is free from paramilitarism, intimidation and that type of activity. I am more than happy to work with every community to try to achieve that and also to ensure that that work is mainstreamed in our strategies.
I have already answered a number of questions about CIT and the wider anti-paramilitarism programme, but I will repeat my view that there was never any justification for paramilitary activity. There are some in this place who not only continue to attempt to justify it but continue to glorify it and those who partook in it. That sends the worst possible message to the wider community, including our young people. We need political leadership, and that political leadership needs to say clearly that all paramilitarism is wrong, that it was wrong in the past and in the present, that there is no place for it in the Northern Ireland of today and that there is certainly no place for it in the Northern Ireland of the future.
Ms Bradshaw: Deputy First Minister, you will recall that the Committee for the Executive Office proposed a motion calling for an investigation of what led to the riots in my constituency in the summer three years ago. I do not believe that any such investigation was ever undertaken. It would have provided a good evidence base not just of what happened over those couple of days but of what happened in the months beforehand, but it remains outstanding.
The other issue that came up yesterday at the APG meeting was the need for early warning and tension monitoring systems so that organisations in the community and voluntary sector might be in a better position to support those families and communities that could be attacked. In their view, we will probably see a fourth or fifth —
Mr Speaker: Is there a "who", "what", "where" or "why" coming?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: It is incredibly important that we learn from what happened. For example, I went out very shortly after some of that disorder to speak to residents in Ballymena to get a sense of where they were coming from and how they viewed the issue. I met people from many different places, including some, of course, who were born and bred in Ballymena. The common thread that ran through those conversations was that people did not feel that their concerns were being listened to, whether those concerns were about immigration, access to public services or access to housing. Another common thread is that people feel that what politicians, including those in this place, and others talk about has no connection to their lived experience in the communities that are most impacted on by some of the changes that have happened.
We need to listen to the communities that we serve. If we do not, the anger there bubbles, and we have seen the result of some of that anger. My commitment to people and communities across Northern Ireland is that I will always be the person who listens to them. I may not always agree with their analysis or their views, but I can respect the fact that they are very often genuinely held views. People want to articulate those views. Most of all, however, people want their communities to improve. They want better access to public services, and they need housing that is fit for purpose. Those are all things that we should focus on.
Mr Mathison: asked the First Minister and deputy First Minister what reassurance they can give to victims and survivors who are concerned that the current political instability will hold back from them vital support and services.
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I thank the Member for his question. I am not sure whether he clarified whether it is victims and survivors of the Troubles that he is referring to. Yes, it is.
I have worked with victims and survivors of the Troubles for many decades. There is no doubt that we need to ensure that support is in place. I can reassure victims and survivors that the funding settlement for the Victims and Survivors Service is there. Those funds are going out through payments to support groups to continue those vital services. In addition, the independent severely injured pension application process continues. There is a commitment to ring-fence those funds and to hold the profile of what is required year-on-year.
Mr Mathison: I thank the deputy First Minister for giving that reassurance. It appears that we are witnessing, including in the Chamber today, a complete relationship breakdown between her and the First Minister. In that context, deputy First Minister, will you reassure us that victims and survivors will not be penalised in any way and that they will not miss out on any services or support?
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I assure the Member that victims and survivors funding support is an absolute priority for me, and I will continue to do all that I can to ensure that the support is there.
The Member is absolutely right that relationships are incredibly difficult, not just in the Executive Office but across the Executive and, indeed, in the Assembly. I feel deeply let down by the behaviour of the First Minister. I believe that she has acted in a way that has shown utter recklessness and disregard to relationships in the Executive Office, relationships in the Executive and relationships here. It is not just that; it has done damage in the community. I can advise the First Minister and others in this place that many people out there are genuinely angry and dismayed at the divisive action of the First Minister. It is not only about that action; it is about the First Minister's refusal to acknowledge that what she has done has caused a deep fracture in the Executive Office, the Executive and amongst the people across Northern Ireland.
I have said clearly that I am determined to face recklessness with responsibility, no matter how difficult it is to do that. I am deeply disappointed and feel deeply let down. More than that, however, the people of Northern Ireland have been let down. We have very important issues to try to resolve, including the Budget, public-sector pay and trying to make sure the citizens we serve can continue to get the public services that they need. The people out there do not deserve dysfunction. It is those who did wrong who deserve to be punished, not the people of Northern Ireland. I will always work to try to ensure that Northern Ireland works, thrives and continues to do what it can to give us all a better and brighter future.
Ms Sugden: asked the First Minister and deputy First Minister to outline how the Executive are able to continue to function, given the breakdown in relationships that the deputy First Minister described and the fact that the First Minister and deputy First Minister seem to have difficulties even speaking to each other, let alone agreeing policy initiatives.
Mrs Little-Pengelly: I thank the Member for her question. I believe that the responsibilities that we have in leadership and the roles that we play as MLAs, Ministers or deputy First Minister, should always trump personal disappointment or dismay. That does not mean, however, that there will not be consequences for actions, because there are always consequences for actions.
Of course, the understandable consequence when somebody has treated the relationships in the Executive Office and in the Executive with utter contempt is that there cannot continue to be activity as if nothing has happened.
There is a fundamental problem, and that problem lies with the lack of respect that continues to be shown. The First Minister is sitting here, chatting away during Question Time, and I think that that represents a lack of regard for the current situation that we are in. As I have said, I am deeply disappointed. I have been deeply let down, but the people who I put first are the people of Northern Ireland. No matter how difficult it is, I will continue to do everything that I can to make this place work, to make Northern Ireland work and to provide public services, no matter how difficult that is. The people of Northern Ireland deserve a Budget, and our public-sector workers deserve pay settlements, and they deserve the transformation that is required to improve our public services. I will continue to do that and to fight for that every single day.
Mr Speaker: Time has elapsed for questions to the Executive Office.
Ms McLaughlin: On a point of order, Mr Speaker. I apologise for not being in my seat during AERA Question Time to ask a listed question. I apologise to you and to the House, and I will write to the Minister.
Mr Stewart: On a point of order, Mr Speaker. I also apologise. I was at a Committee at the time of my question and mistimed my multitasking attempts. I apologise to you and to the House.
Debate resumed on motion:
That this Assembly notes the report of the Committee for Education on the 'Strategic Review of Current SEN Provision and Transformation Agenda'; recognises that, despite sustained efforts to implement reform, significant systemic challenges remain; further notes the particular special educational needs (SEN) workforce challenges, including specialist staffing shortages, in the Irish-medium education sector; identifies the need for greater investment and inclusion in SEN provision; and calls on the Minister of Education to prioritise early intervention and stronger support for schools before any reduction in support ratios is considered. — [Mr Mathison (The Chairperson of the Committee for Education).]
Mr Givan: On a point of order, Mr Speaker. I apologise to Mr Mathison. I was not here for the commencement of the debate and the Chairman's contribution. It is no excuse, but I got caught out by the business moving at pace. I put on record my apologies, and I certainly intended no discourtesy to Mr Mathison.
Mr Speaker: We are certainly doing well for apologies today. It is no bad thing to apologise, folks.
Mrs Mason: I will not begin my contribution by apologising, but I welcome the fact that the Minister has now joined us. I think that this is a really important debate, and I am glad that he is here to hear it and respond to it. I welcome the opportunity to speak on this important report from the Education Committee. As the Chairman did, I record my thanks to all the witnesses who came in and gave us huge amounts of detail and information and to the officials and the Committee staff, who spent an awful lot of time pulling the information together.
(Madam Principal Deputy Speaker in the Chair)
It is only right that I begin my remarks by acknowledging the children, the parents and the dedicated education workforce who are at the very heart of this discussion and every discussion that we have around special educational needs. When we talk about SEN reform, workforce planning, one-to-one support and transformation agendas, we must never lose sight of what all that actually means for our children and our families. At the end of this, it is about the child who needs support. Behind every delayed assessment or inappropriate placement is a family trying desperately to secure the education that their child deserves, and behind every classroom that is struggling to meet increasingly complex needs is a teacher, a classroom assistant or a school leader doing everything that they possibly can with the resources that are available to them.
I speak regularly to parents across South Down who are absolutely exhausted — parents who have fought for years to secure assessments, statements, appropriate placements and vital classroom support. They are parents who have become experts in a system that they should never have had to navigate alone and parents who are absolutely terrified that the support that they have fought so hard to secure for their child could now be reduced or taken away. They are not unreasonable parents making unreasonable demands; they are mothers and fathers who are asking for their children to have the same opportunities as every other child.
I want to be equally clear about our education workforce. Our teachers, our classroom assistants, our SEN coordinators and our school leaders are working under extraordinary pressure. They are supporting children with increasingly complex needs without the resources that they need. Classroom assistants in particular play an absolutely invaluable role without the very basic pay and job security that they so rightly deserve. For many children, that trusted adult is the difference between being able to access education and being able to cope in a classroom environment. That relationship is not simply about a staffing ratio on a spreadsheet. It is built on trust, consistency, understanding and care, and any proposal that takes that away will have a real impact on those children and their families.
We cannot take support away from children today based on the promise that a better system might exist tomorrow. That is why the central call in this motion and this report is so important. Early intervention and stronger support for schools must come first, not after cuts have been made, nor when savings have been delivered. It must come first. We also need to recognise the particular challenges facing Irish-medium education. Children with special educational needs who learn through Irish must have access to appropriate specialist support, assessments and a workforce that is equipped to meet their needs. The shortages in specialist staffing cannot be allowed to create further barriers for those children and their families. The complete irony here is that, rather than having a Minister who recognises that, we unfortunately have a Minister who uses a veto to block support for Irish-medium education, further exposing the anti-Irish, sectarian and bigoted agenda that has marred his ministerial tenure.
Any reform must be measured by what actually changes for the child in the classroom; that came through loud and clear. Does that child get the help that they need? Does their teacher have the support to meet their needs? Can parents finally stop having to fight and start having confidence in the education system? Those are the measures that matter. I ask the Minister to listen carefully to the people who came and gave us evidence. It is outlined in the report. I ask him to listen to the people who are living with the consequences of his decisions on how to prioritise his budget, which is the second-highest budget in the Executive, in excess of £3 billion. He prioritised TransformED conferences, highly paid English consultants and soccer-pitch pet projects. Instead, Minister, please listen to parents, classroom assistants, teachers and school leaders and, above all else, listen to the children themselves.
Mr Martin: On behalf of my party, I welcome the opportunity to speak on the Education Committee's report on the strategic review of special educational needs provision and the transformation agenda. At the outset — I have written these two points down — I will say that I was going to be positive today, because this is a very important issue. I was also going to say that it is too important to be a political football but, unfortunately, it is too late for that. I will certainly not be scoring any political points here. This issue is very sensitive and needs to be respected. To be honest, if this sort of stuff is not above politics, I am confused as to what is in this Assembly.
This is an important and timely report that considers one of the most significant challenges facing our education system. Supporting children and young people with special educational needs is a responsibility that we all share. It is essential that our approach delivers the right support at the right time and in the right setting. The Committee Chair covered that in his speech. I acknowledge the work that the Committee undertook in producing the report, and especially the wide sectoral engagement that it carried out during that work.
One of the key messages emerging from the report is that, whilst considerable work has been undertaken on SEN reform, the challenges remain. I concur with the Committee Chair on that. The Education Minister, the Department of Education and the Education Authority (EA) have made significant efforts to improve provision, and it is important to recognise that such a level of transformation will take time. Progress must be measured, however, by the difference that it makes to children, families and schools. We also have to be cognisant of the fact — the Minister may reflect on this — that budgets are incredibly constrained. Every penny that we spend on something else cannot be spent on this.
I welcome the emphasis on early intervention, which is a topic very close to my heart. Providing support where it is needed as early as possible can make a significant difference to a child's educational journey. Every member of the Committee will understand that. It can help prevent difficulties and escalating diagnoses, and it can also help to ensure that children have the ability to develop to their full potential. Early intervention must be a core focus.
We also have to recognise the pressures that are experienced by those who are delivering support every day. Teachers, special educational needs coordinators (SENCOs) and classroom assistants play a vital role, but they are working under considerable pressure, and we all understand that. The report highlights the need for appropriate training, manageable workloads, improved access to special advice and better recognition of the classroom assistant role. Those are issues that the Minister has already taken on board and is working on.
We must continue to get the message out on one-to-one support: although it remains in place, it is not deemed the most effective support intervention for every child, and nearly every country in Europe has moved away from automatically providing that as an exclusive model. The Finnish model is often cited. The transformation in Northern Ireland's approach will take us much closer to how SEN provision is managed in Finland, and that work is ongoing.
On that note, I was a little confused about paragraph 115 of the report. I will quote it:
"Where 1:1 support from a classroom assistant is assessed as the best way to meet a child's needs, this should be detailed and quantified on their statement and EA must be clear that new models of support."
That is where the sentence finishes. I am not sure that that is a recommendation; I do not believe that it is a sentence either. Perhaps, in closing, the Committee Chair could pick up on that point, which is an important one. The sentence is not a sentence, but it is about an important area, and perhaps he can cover that off.
A crucial area is the relationship between education and health services. Again, the Chair covered that. Children with additional needs often require support from a wide range of professionals, and a disconnected system does not help. Therefore, better cooperation, information sharing and collaboration between the Department of Health and the Department of Education would be a really positive step forward.
The report provides a useful assessment of where SEN provision currently stands and identifies areas where further progress is needed. It recognises the work that is already taking place at pace while making clear that there is more to do. Ultimately, every child deserves to have the opportunity to learn, develop and fulfil their potential, and that should be the guiding principle behind any reform of SEN provision.
Mr Burrows: There is much to give credit to in the report on SEN. There is no greater challenge facing us — there are a number of challenges — than supporting children who have special additional needs, their families, and, of course, their teachers and teaching assistants, who do a valuable job. Classroom assistants do not get the support that they deserve when it comes to the remuneration in their pay packets. Their eligibility to go up pay grades and develop professionally is lacking.
Early intervention is key, and getting young people diagnosed with additional needs is too slow. That is a significant challenge. It is why Health and Education must work in tandem, which is one of the recommendations, from the outset to beyond the post-19 support that children who have additional needs must get. There is a role for an inclusive education system in which those with additional needs are in mainstream education. Specialist provision in mainstream schools (SPIMS) has a role, but it cannot be a substitute for specialist provision when that is required.
One thing that we consistently hear from schools, whether in evidence to the Committee or when going around the country, is that some people feel that a child is not in the right placement. One of the challenges for the education system — I have heard this directly from teachers and classroom assistants — is that the parent often wants their child to be in a mainstream school, and the child would be better off in a specialist school. We need to reconcile parental autonomy with where the needs of a child can best be met in the wider range of classrooms. There are tough things that we should have looked at in the inquiry but did not: in particular, the underlying causes of the rise in the number of children with additional needs. The phrases "additional needs" and "special educational needs" cover such a spectrum that they have come to encompass a range of things, including delayed development, some of which is linked to parenting skills and having to give parents more support in developing those skills.
It is about dealing with the challenges of the digital era and the fact that, for a lot of children, there are issues with diet and lack of exercise.
I see Mr Baker screwing his face up, but we have to be candid about the range of factors behind the rise in special educational needs and additional needs, some of which —.
Mr Baker: Autism is not created by bad diet or lack of exercise.
Mr Burrows: I did not think that, in this place, Members chuntered from their seated position.
Mr Baker: You pointed at me across [Inaudible.]
Mr Burrows: Am I able to continue, Madam Principal Deputy Speaker?
Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: Yes, but, if you refer to a Member, you should at least give way to them. I will not tolerate shouting back and forward. That applies to everybody.
Mr Burrows: I will respect your position, Madam Principal Deputy Speaker, but he never asked me to give way — not once. [Interruption.] [Inaudible.]
Mr Burrows: Thank you very much for your permission. I will speak when I am standing; I will not chunter like Mr Baker.
We need to support the workforce. SENCOs, again, are in a — [Inaudible.]
Mr Burrows: — specialist role.
You are behaving like a child, Danny.
Too many SENCOs are juggling too many jobs. For the sake of those who need them, it should be a full-time job.
Much has been said recently about Irish-medium education. I support Irish-medium education, but the bottom line is that every sector deserves a Department that works for it, not against it, and every sector deserves a level playing field. Our responsibility is to ensure that every child, regardless of the sector that they are in, has the appropriate support.
We also need to increase the capacity of the Education Authority and to improve its engagement with school principals. Too often, principals are left too long to await decisions and support at a time when pressure on schools is growing. At a school in Bangor, I heard moving testimony from teachers who felt that there was a crisis in the school around a pupil. All they needed was quicker support: someone to come in and help them solve that crisis, which was connected to a child with additional needs.
We need to talk about the things that are uncomfortable to hear, including the injuries and the experiences that teachers and teaching assistants —.
Mr Baker: The Committee does a really good job of scrutinising officials' work. That was evident from the Committee's scrutiny of the recent SEN regulations. The Minister wanted to push those through quickly, but, by taking our time and listening to children's rights advocates, we seem to have got to a far better place. The regulations may be able to go forward after all, with significant changes proposed by the children's rights advocates, who work every day to support the children and their families.
Families have to fight so hard. What they do not need is to be pitted against one another or to be blamed, which seems to happen to parents a lot.
Mrs Mason: I know that Peter Martin has not been on the Education Committee for a while, so he might be out of the loop, but he began his remarks by talking about positivity in the debate. Does the Member agree that there is nothing positive about parents sitting in my office, not two weeks ago, in tears because their child is in an inappropriate place and they feel guilty that their child is not getting the education that they deserve? Does he agree that Irish-medium teachers contacting me following the DUP's blocking of the Irish-medium Education (Workforce Plan) Bill, which those teachers saw as a lifeline, is not positive?
Mr Baker: Absolutely: I completely agree. I know that some Members will find that uncomfortable to hear, because they signed a petition of concern to punish children with additional needs: those children need that extra support, but you could not see through your bigotry.
The intervention was timely, because, right now, parents of children at Oakwood School and Assessment Centre, who are well known in the system, are once again facing a long wait because there is no place for their child in P5. It has happened not just to one or two families but to 30 families. It happened last year and is continuing to happen. Children are not placed in the right setting, and they end up on reduced timetables. The evidence that we heard through the inquiry is that nobody is keeping track of the children on reduced timetables and of the support that they get. At times, it comes across as though those children are being treated as a name on a spreadsheet. It appears as though it is about ticking a box to say that everyone has now been placed. That is just firefighting. I know that reform is needed. People are trying their best — we are not blaming SEN link officers, who are under immense pressure — but the resources are simply not there for them.
The elephant in the room when it comes to reform is that the Department of Health is not at the table. We heard that as recently as last week when discussing the SEN regulations. The EA needs to slow down transformation. Otherwise, the situation will get a lot worse for families. If Health is not involved, we will not get early interventions right. We are better off doing things right now so that, in the next mandate, we do not have to undo the bad work that may have been done.
I hope that the Minister is listening. I hope that he has read the Committee's report. I hope that he can influence the EA on operational matters in order to get it to slow down transformation, listen to children's rights advocates and work with the Children's Law Centre (CLC). They are up for transformation as well. Everyone wants to get SEN provision right. No one wants children to be in the wrong place. We therefore need to continue to work together. The Committee needs to scrutinise, which it has been doing. I am glad that officials have been allowed to come back to the Committee, because their presence will be very important in the months ahead.
I will make a final point, which is that we need to stop trying to look for reasons to blame the families and children concerned. I have heard such comments too often in the Committee, and they keep being repeated. Yes, I may pull a face when I hear them, but I am pulling a face because, like Cathy, I have so many families coming to my office. They are crying, because they have nowhere else to turn. They have been fighting for years, but they are being failed. We even see that with the changes to the statementing process. There is a lot of worry out there. The removal of one-to-one support is a huge worry for families.
Some of the commentary has been that one-to-one support for all statemented children was not happening. Yes, it was. Changes are happening, but the EA needs to slow down the process and bring parents along with it, because trust is so important, and that trust goes to the very top. Leaders have to lead. Those families deserve leadership, and they have not seen it in recent weeks, given that a petition of concern was used to disadvantage children with additional needs who learn through the medium of Irish. That was callous, and it cannot continue to happen. Seriously, you need to take a long look in the mirror and think about all children and not just your selfish interests.
Ms Brownlee: I no longer have the pleasure of being on the Education Committee, but when I saw the motion in the Order Paper, I was delighted to put my name down to speak to it. I pay tribute to the Committee, the Clerk and the Committee team for their hard work on the report and to the witnesses who attended the evidence sessions.
We know that special education is an extremely challenging area, not just financially but across the board, and that was mentioned in the report. We all genuinely care about the issue. It places significant demand on our schools and services and has a direct impact on children and their families. It is therefore important that we get SEN provision right. Every child deserves the opportunity to learn in an environment that meets their needs and puts the right support around them.
The report makes a number of recommendations. It will now be about how those recommendations are put into practice and how we will see practical improvements for children, parents and schools. It is great to hear that the Minister supports that. In my constituency, the Minister has put significant investment into special educational needs provision. I am truly witness to that, and I know that he will take forward the work in good faith.
I will pull a few recommendations out of the report, the first of which is on data sharing and communication, particularly with the Department of Health. That is one of the strongest themes running through the report, particularly the communication element. We know that the Department of Education and the Department of Health cannot continue to operate in silos when supporting children with special educational needs. Doing that just does not work. Schools need up-to-date, relevant information about the children in their care to ensure that they have a full and complex profile of each child.
We need to make sure that that information follows the child from early intervention through to when they leave school. We understand that parents become frustrated and overwhelmed when they have to repeat the needs of their child to every education or health professional. Having that holistic picture will help them in their journey. One issue that I have been looking at relates to data-sharing between Encompass — in Health — and Education. Hopefully, that will be moving forward. Education and Health are trying to formalise it in a way that will make a significant difference.
I was pleased to see SEN and the PGCE mentioned in the report. During my time on the Committee, I was passionate about that. It is important that that proposal continues to be expanded and explored. We know how important it is to support our teachers who are entering the profession, but those who are already working in the classroom deal with a wide range of complex educational and medical needs, and any support that they can get, particularly at the early stage of their career, will be invaluable for the children in their care and for their own confidence and that of the staff around them.
I recognise the incredible work of SENCOs. I have spoken to a number of them over the years. There is growing pressure on that role. It is demanding and complex, and there are a number of layers to it, as they are obviously trying to do their daily job as well. It is, therefore, important that that has been recognised, that the Minister has taken that on board and that we can look to support our SENCOs.
I move now to the staff, including classroom assistants. We use the word "invaluable": they really are. They become part of the family: they look after the child; they know the details that are integral to the child; and they know how the child ticks and needs to be supported. That is key; they are key to the whole journey. It is key that they feel valued and supported throughout their careers, be that through education or training support or, of course, financial support.
Mr Martin: I thank my colleague for taking an intervention. I was criticised for using the word "positive" in my speech. There is a need to be solution-focused. Given the Member's experience, does she agree that debates in the Chamber around special educational needs should be positive, solution-focused and have kids at their middle, and not be some sort of sectarian battleground? The only Members who have raised that, so far, have been the Members opposite in Sinn Féin. I am disappointed in them. We should be able to have a debate in the Chamber about SEN without making it party political.
Mr Martin: Apologies, Madam Principal Deputy Speaker.
Ms Brownlee: I totally agree with the Member. Nobody cares what background a child comes from, particularly in relation to special educational needs. It is all about making sure that that child has the right support at the right time in the right place. We can recognise that significant investment has been made and that significant change has made a positive difference, but we can also acknowledge that there may be gaps and things that need to be adapted and changed once we progress and get feedback from lived experience and the stakeholders. That is normal.
School statements and getting the right setting are incredibly important. What might appear, on paper, to be the right setting for a child may not be the most practical and right solution. Of course, we need to reflect on that. There is a need to ensure that the school has the right support and interventions in place. That needs to be reviewed. If a child is unhappy and the placement is not suitable, there is nothing wrong with exploring other options. That comes down to communication. A running theme is the need for communication between the EA, parents, families and the Department to make sure that everybody is aware of the process and the support that is available.
Identifying suitable placements and collaboration between the local schools is also important. Some schools might have the like of soft play, sensory rooms, better outdoor space —.
Mrs Guy: I thank the Committee team, my colleagues on the Committee for their work on the inquiry and everybody who gave evidence. Having heard that evidence, I pay tribute to our school leaders, teachers, SENCOs and families who are putting the needs of children with SEN first, day and daily.
The inquiry has shown us that there are inspirational individuals who go in to bat for the children they are responsible for, but I also want to highlight the parents who made time to write to us or gave evidence to the Committee — parents who have precious little time but campaign for the rights of others, such as Alma from Caleb's Cause, Karen from Sensability and the parents from SEN Reform NI.
The objective of the inquiry was not to produce yet another report on SEN; we have countless reports. We wanted to hear how reforms were being delivered on the ground and what difference they were making. It was particularly important because our experience on the Committee through various evidence sessions was that there was a disconnect between how officials thought things ought to operate and how they were being experienced by schools and families. I do not say that to chastise; I say that because getting it right matters. It matters to me; it matters to the Committee; and I know that it matters to the Minister and the officials. We all have our respective roles to play. I acknowledge the progress made in partnership working between the Department and the EA. There appears to be much more alignment and collaboration, helped by a more focused approach, which is something that the Committee asked for.
The overload of pilots and the thin distribution of resources across a number of areas have now largely been focused on local impact teams (LITs), nursing provision in special schools and the enhanced support model. I acknowledge the dedication of those in charge of SEND reform in the EA and the Department because they are genuinely trying to make things better in an ongoing crisis, but ultimately, we are not in a good place. The move to local impact teams makes sense on paper, and there is broad agreement that it is the right model, but it can work only if it is properly resourced. The risk now is that there is a postcode lottery for support based on how well specific LITs are resourced. Right now, data generated from LITs show the level of demand but also that they simply cannot meet it.
I have spoken to many schools about SEN provision, and the lack of behaviour support comes up in almost every school. They are not calling for more reviews on the issue; they are calling for appropriate placements and experts on the ground to support them. On the enhanced support model, I have spoken to school leaders who like the idea of choosing what support is available to children in their school. The EA is still gathering ideas from over 100 schools that have been doing things differently. Therefore, we have no idea about what the final model will look like, whether there will be enough staff to sustain it or what the employment terms will be.
Ema Cubitt, the Autism Reviewer, rightly points out that greater flexibility in how support is delivered does not automatically lead to improved outcomes. We need to track and measure outcomes for children. I am prepared to be open-minded about change, but it must be driven by the needs of children and young people. It was a fundamental error by the Department to launch the model in the context of a cost-saving exercise, and I hope that the EA and the Department learn from their mistakes in the approach to TransformED. We need to listen to schools and parents and respond to what they say, communicate repeatedly and build trust, rather than trying to force through change. Parents fight hard to get support for their children, and they need clear evidence on how changes will be better for them.
Education and Health working together is imperative for success, and that is not happening well enough. It is another example of the disconnect between the institutional perception of working together and the real-world experience. The other frustration is the expanding bureaucracy facing school staff. Children need face-to-face time with teachers and staff, yet the level of paperwork that schools have to complete for a range of issues and reasons appears to be expanding, and that is not sustainable. Finally, there continues to be huge frustration that, despite endless reports evidencing the need for early intervention, it is not happening with sufficient focus. Shifting interventions to younger ages will make a huge difference. I met a principal on Friday who was eager to make that point.
When we invest in children with SEN and target support to meet their needs, the impact is transformative. A focus on getting the system right is worth our time and investment, and I am clear that success must be oriented to the needs of the child.
Mr McGrath: I am pleased to speak about the report, and I thank the Committee for its work. I speak on behalf of Cara Hunter, who is unable to be here today.
I want to start by making two points. I am a former member of the Education Committee, and that was over 10 years ago. Maybe by the end of my contribution, we can measure where we have got to in those 10 years. First, I think of all the young people, their teachers and their families, amounting literally to hundreds over the years, who have contacted me about the difficulties that they have had in trying to access and complete their education. Reports such as this are absolutely invaluable because, if nothing else, they validate the issues that people have had to face. They know that people here and people working in education policy recognise the issues and concerns that people face. As we talk about the issues, we need to remember that we are talking about children, their education and their future. I hope that that can continue to be done as constructively as possible.
At the heart of the report is this uncomfortable question: after years of reviews, consultations, strategies and promises, why are so many children with special educational needs still being failed? The statementing process is perhaps the clearest example of a system that has stopped working for too many families. I understand that the Committee heard about parents being forced into disputes with the very system that is supposed to help them. Families are battling for assessments, challenging decisions and then waiting for months or years for support that should have been available all along. As was referenced earlier, I am on the Health Committee, and we can see the connections between the two Committees in trying to get the diagnosis and the necessary help and support.
Every delay matters, because childhood does not pause for a bureaucratic process. A year lost for a child with additional needs can have profound consequences that will, regrettably, follow that young person throughout their life. The Department and the Minister continue to speak of transformation, while statutory targets are routinely missed. Some 44% of statements completed in August 2025 were issued outside the 26-week statutory time frame. Twenty-six weeks is half a year, but, when you break that down into the time that a child is at school, that is the best part of a school year. Almost half the statements were completed outside that time, and no amount of spin can disguise what that means for those young people. It means that the system is failing to meet its legal obligation to children and their families.
The appeals figures are even more damning. I understand that the Committee found that there were 751 appeals against SEN decisions between July 2024 and June 2025. Of those, the Education Authority conceded 460 before they even reached a hearing. That is over half of them where the EA said, "OK. We got that wrong". How can so many of the processes be wrong? Again, as has been referenced, given the time and energy that families, schools and teachers put into that process only to find that the case is conceded because it should not even have started in the first place, that must be utterly disheartening for those who are involved in that process.
As I said, I wanted to take one of two approaches at the beginning. I said that, 10 and a half years ago, I was on the Education Committee. I was on it for only six or seven months before this place collapsed and went into abeyance for a number of years. However, at that stage, we were firmly talking about special educational needs and the difficulties in the system. We were talking about how long it was taking for people to get their diagnosis and the support that was needed to help them to have their education and get the best possible beginning to their lives. We are still getting it wrong. Come on: we have to do better. I welcome the fact that reports such as this are good staging posts along the way to encourage that decision and change to happen more quickly.
Mr Gaston: The Committee's report on special educational needs provision is welcome, but it reaches a stark conclusion that, sadly, is not unexpected. Despite the years of hearing all the right buzzwords — "reviews", "reforms" and "strategies" — many of the same systemic challenges remain. Most important, the report makes it clear that early intervention, workforce capacity, placements and effective support services must be prioritised before any reduction in support ratios is contemplated. The Committee identified a placements crisis, workforce shortages, inadequate coordination between Health and Education and a lack of strategic planning as some of the most pressing issues that face our SEN system. Those conclusions will come as no surprise to the families, teachers and support staff living with those working pressures every day.
In my constituency of North Antrim, we are blessed with Castle Tower School. It demonstrates both the success of specialist education and the growing pressures placed on it. Now operating over two sites, the school educates 407 pupils, despite originally opening in 2017 with capacity for just 275. To accommodate demand, an extension of four modular classrooms has been added, yet the pressure continues to grow year-on-year. Supporting those pupils requires around 250 members of staff, whose dedication deserves recognition and high praise. The Committee rightly highlights workforce capability as being central to successful reform. We can publish all the strategies and delivery plans we like, but, without enough teachers, classroom assistants, therapists and specialist professionals, meaningful change will remain out of reach.
Castle Tower also illustrates the need for better strategic planning. Its Ballee campus accommodates all its post-16 pupils. It meets the current need but little more. There are no food preparation facilities on-site, meaning that meals have to be prepared at the main campus and transported across daily. Significant public money continues to be spent on adapting and maintaining facilities, but where is the long-term plan and vision? The Committee specifically highlighted the lack of strategic planning across the SEN system: looking at Castle Tower, that criticism feels justified. How much money is being spent annually to modify buildings just to cope with the demand of that year's intake? Why is the Education Authority still occupying space on a site where educational needs continue to grow? Why is the sports hall packed with unused IT equipment and being used for document storage rather than being used by the young people with additional needs on the Ballee site?
The Committee also concluded that, wherever possible, children should be educated in their local communities and that area planning must play a much stronger role. That is particularly relevant given the eye-watering transport costs incurred every year moving children around a system that often lacks suitable local provision. We must look beyond post-19 transitions and examine what happens after post-11 transfer. One issue raised with me repeatedly is the bottleneck in provision between primary and secondary education. Pupils who benefit from specialist provision in mainstream units at primary level frequently discover that the equivalent provision is much harder to access at secondary level. Continuity of support must not disappear at the point of transfer.
The Committee's most important conclusion is that support services must be strengthened before support ratios are reduced. When will we start to plan effectively for the future of SEN pupils? Here, in 2026, that appears to be a long way off.
Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: No other Members have indicated that they wish to speak, so it is over to you, Nick Mathison, as Chair of the Education Committee, to conclude the debate and make the winding-up speech on the motion. You have 10 minutes.
Mr Mathison (The Chairperson of the Committee for Education): Thank you, Madam Principal Deputy Speaker. I thought that we might hear from the Minister. Perhaps he will come in during my comments. He mentioned earlier that he was unable to attend the start of the debate. We understand that business moved quickly this morning.
I will first speak as Chair and make some initial remarks, and then I will move on to make comments in my role as an Alliance MLA.
There is a huge amount of agreement in the room. There has been a bit of back and forth about whether the tone of the debate was right and whether everybody was on the same page. However, there are consistent themes coming through here that, regardless of the politics, everybody can agree on. It is pretty clear that everybody has agreed that we cannot just let this be another review. I was particularly struck by Colin McGrath's remarks referencing back to 10 years ago and how many children have been through a system and, potentially, failed by that system in that time. None of us wants to be here in 10 years' time having the same discussion. There is a sense that we definitely all need to unite around some agreed aims and approaches that we can all support politically. Parents, children and schools need us to do that. They really need to hear a degree of a united message coming through, though every political party here will have different levels of emphasis. There is, of course, a clear role for the Committee to hold the Minister and the Education Authority to account, but we also need to remind ourselves of the need, when the good things are happening, to support that work and to be clear on that.
Everybody — almost without exception — referenced early intervention. We all know the huge challenges around budget. Resourcing SEN services is becoming more and more expensive. Much of the spend that accumulates in SEN is driven by statutory duties that kick in when a child's needs have not been met and they end up with a statement, and there is so much catching up to be done. If we can invest early, it gets the money in at the right stage. Every bit of evidence that the Committee heard about intervening early was that it was the right thing to do.
Mr Martin: I thank the Chair for taking the intervention. I agree completely with what he has said so far. On that financial piece, does he agree that it is challenging, with the Budget that we face, but that, often, early intervention is done by pump-priming? You use some of that additional funding to put into invest-to-save measures, but the current financial circumstances make it challenging to see where it is coming from.
Mr Mathison: I absolutely agree. It is a sort of burning-platform scenario. You have a set of statutory duties that you have to meet, and you are desperately trying to reform a system alongside that. It is about how to get the balance right. I really appreciate that those are challenges.
We have to move beyond lip service on early intervention. It has become almost a throwaway phrase; a bit of a cliché in policymaking. We have to get serious about it.
There are things that are relatively inexpensive too. Everybody has referenced collaboration with Health. That is about an approach and getting the right people around a table, not just to meet and talk — the Committee report uses the phrase "jointly ... commissions ... services". It is about getting around the table together to ensure that that can be done properly in the most collegial way; sharing data at the right time; sharing data so that, when a child moves into a preschool setting, there are no surprises; sharing the information that healthcare professionals may be aware of in a child's life so that the preschool leaders and teachers in nursery schools are aware of those issues and the support can be ready for the child coming in. Surely, it cannot be beyond the ability of those two Departments to get some of that right.
A lot of reference has been made to local impact teams and the challenges around resourcing. Of course, there are huge challenges there, but to streamline the bureaucracy, to reduce the workload impacts around those, to ensure that it is the most effective and streamlined approach to get requests for involvement into the system and support coming out on the other side, again, surely, does not need to be a hugely expensive exercise.
There is lots of agreement, and there are lots of things that, hopefully, we can unite around. I hope that the Committee, in what is left of the mandate, as well as whichever Committee emerges on the other side of an election, will continue to keep the issue of special educational needs as a firm and fixed priority.
Mr Baker: I thank the Member for giving way. Does the Member share my concerns about the approach of the Department around the SEN regulations and welcome where we are at now, because of the work that was done in the Committee? Does he also agree with the message that we heard last week that children's rights advocates also need to be at the table on the reform and transformation coming from the Education Authority, because things are moving fast?
Mr Mathison: Yes, I share the Member's concern. That was always a balance to be struck in the inquiry, because, although everybody is on the same page about the need for reform, we know that, if reform is rushed and got wrong, unintended consequences can be created that last for years to come. Colin referred to the Education Committee of 10 years ago, but, in 10 years' time, nobody wants to be analysing and debating mistakes that were made during this mandate. I therefore agree that a balance has to be struck. I may come on to the SEN regulations when I make remarks in my capacity as an MLA.
Focusing on a review of SEN provision and the transformation agenda was the right thing for the Committee to do. I again thank all Committee members and everyone who gave evidence to the inquiry. Let us find the common ground. I hope that, on the back of the report, the Department and the EA will come forward with actions that align with the report's recommendations.
I will now speak briefly as an Alliance Party Member. There was some discussion in the Chamber about the need to be positive about SEN provision. Cathy Mason said that it does not always feel as though there is much to be positive about. Any of us who speaks to parents of children with additional needs can relate to that. Parents who feel that they are involved in the fight in the middle of the system will probably struggle to hear the positivity, but it is about changing the language. Rather than be positive for the sake of it, we can be collegial. Surely we, as MLAs, can all get behind the issue of meeting the needs of children with SEN and agree to collaborate and build consensus at the Education Committee across all parties. Absolutely, it is all political. We are all here with our different mandates, but if children's needs and rights are at the heart of what we are prioritising, surely we can find areas in which we can reach a consensus and get around the table to do what is right for children.
I finish with a brief remark on where there is scope to see some positivity. Even in the evidence that we received during the inquiry, the EA and the Department took an approach that we had not seen from them before. They came to present to us jointly and made a joint proposition. The EA was not saying, "The Department isn't doing what it needs to do. It doesn't give us enough money". The Department was not blaming the EA for messing up operationally. Rather, it was a collegial response. Through the SEN regulations, which Danny referenced, we have seen the Department step up and agree to work collegially with the Children's Law Centre. If we can see more of that sort of approach, which will reassure parents that it is about doing the right thing for them and their child, we potentially have a pathway through this.
There are concerns about the enhanced support model, and parents worry about the potential withdrawal of support, but we all agree that reform is needed. We cannot keep doing what we are doing, because it is the worst of both worlds: a huge financial expenditure that does not adequately meet children's needs. That cannot be a good place to be in. If we could agree that, yes, we can look at reform but that we must do it collaboratively, bring educators and parents with us and keep checking in with them, that would be positive.
It was possibly the Northern Ireland Commissioner for Children and Young People (NICCY) who highlighted in his evidence to the Committee that reform is needed but that it must be continually sense-checked and benchmarked with practitioners on the ground by asking, "Is this working? Is this delivering for you at a school level?". I would add parents to that process. Reforms need to be continually benchmarked and sense-checked with parents by asking, "How are the reforms that we are making affecting your child at a school level?". To me, that is how we must do it. Reform has to involve a collegial approach. It cannot be something that is done to the system. We have heard that in debates on TransformED. Parents expect us to be collegial on that issue and not to sling mud around the Chamber. One thing that I would like to see happen in this mandate is that we take the debate and move on from here to saying that we will get behind reform that is done right. We will not unpick it just because we may not like everything else that the Minister is doing, but we also will not just sit back and say, "Yes, carry on with that" without challenging it or holding those responsible to account if we do not think that it is right for the system. That is where I am at with that.
Parents deserve better from their elected representatives on the issue, and I hope that we can all agree that we can do that. Even if nothing else is to come out of the debate, if we can reach that sort of agreement, progress will have been made.
Question put and agreed to.
That this Assembly notes the report of the Committee for Education on the 'Strategic Review of Current SEN Provision and Transformation Agenda'; recognises that, despite sustained efforts to implement reform, significant systemic challenges remain; further notes the particular special educational needs (SEN) workforce challenges, including specialist staffing shortages, in the Irish-medium education sector; identifies the need for greater investment and inclusion in SEN provision; and calls on the Minister of Education to prioritise early intervention and stronger support for schools before any reduction in support ratios is considered.
(Mr Deputy Speaker [Mr Blair] in the Chair)
Motion made:
That the Assembly do now adjourn. — [Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair).]
Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): In conjunction with the Business Committee, the Speaker has given leave to Paul Boggs to raise the matter of Youth Service provision in Strabane. I call Paul Boggs: you will have up to 15 minutes.
Mr Boggs: Go raibh maith agat, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle.
[Translation: Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker.]
Members will be glad to hear that I do not intend to take the full 15 minutes. I thank the Minister for being present in the Chamber this evening for the debate.
As a former teacher and now a community and political representative, I know how important youth provision is for our young people. Proper youth provision, as Members will know, helps young people build their confidence, develop long-lasting friendships, improve social skills and become the best version of themselves, particularly in an area such as Strabane, which continues to face significant challenges, with some of the highest levels of social and economic deprivation across this island. We do not wear that proudly.
The work of the Youth Service and the community and voluntary sector is invaluable in supporting our young people. In this evening's debate, first and foremost, I praise the good work that is being done on the ground to support the children and young people of Strabane. Whether it is the youth club at Melvin Sports Complex, the youth drop-in at the Education Authority (EA) Strabane Youth Resource Centre on the Urney Road or our first-class community groups in the community and voluntary sector, young people have many opportunities to avail themselves of. The hard-working commitment of EA staff, staff and volunteers in the community and dedicated school staff who provide extracurricular activities ensures that there is a good level of support for children and young people. As more and more young people become interested in the issues that matter to their communities, forums such as the North West Ministry of Youth provide a voice for young people to have their say on what they want to see and the type of Strabane and, indeed, west Tyrone that they want to be a part of.
In the 2026-27 year's membership census, 269 young people registered with the EA's directly delivered youth provision in Strabane town centre. That is great to see, and I again commend all involved in delivering that provision. To all those who play a part in supporting our children and young people and who may be listening this evening, I say a huge "Thank you" for the job that you do: we are having this evening's debate, in part, to recognise the fantastic work that you do, but also to continue the fight to ensure that you are supported in doing what you do in a new, fit-for-purpose, modern facility.
The issue is not so much that Strabane has no youth provision in place; it is more about delivering on long-term promises to ensure that children and young people have access to the facilities that are needed in our community. For example, I mentioned the provision at Melvin Sports Complex. Strabane Youth Association, or "the youth club" as it is better known locally, has been going in Melvin for years. In fact, I went there when I was younger. It is somewhere that youth workers support the emotional, personal and social development of children and young people outside of a school setting. While staff make every effort to make the best of the current facility, Melvin is a council-owned building and is often well over capacity, with sports clubs and other people making use of every inch of space. While the provision is great, the facility is not built to cope with the demand.
Elsewhere, in the EA resource centre, staff and volunteers ensure that young people have a safe space to meet, to get involved in activities, to enjoy trips away and to have the opportunity to train in youth work practice themselves. Similarly, our community and voluntary groups are playing their part to ensure that young people have opportunities in their communities, and many of those opportunities have a positive impact on the wider community, not just on the young people. I know that the EA has plans to extend the provision to other community centres to create opportunities for local young people to build their skills and take on leadership roles. As I have said, as a former teacher, I know the brilliant work that the EA Youth Service does in reaching into our schools. Locally, at Holy Cross College and Strabane Academy, pupils benefit from that outreach work. Again, the debate is not to pick holes in the good provision that we have but, rather, to look at ways that we can best support that provision in future.
As the Minister will know, Strabane has long been promised a purpose-built youth centre facility that would bring together the great work that is being done in a space that meets the needs of our young people. In 2021, my colleagues Órfhlaith Begley MP and the then MLA Maolíosa McHugh, along with Councillor Michaela Boyle, held meetings with representatives from the EA and youth workers. They were told that a proposal for a £3 million youth facility in Strabane had been finalised by the EA and had proceeded to the Department of Education and to the then Minister, Minister Weir, for approval. Fast-forward to 2022, when Minister McIlveen said that it could be possible for a new youth facility to be opened by the end of 2023. In the period since, I too have met youth workers and the EA to explore options. From Minister Weir to Minister McIlveen, I now bring the issue to the current Minister, Minister Givan.
I understand that finances are a struggle, but when everything is a priority, nothing is a priority. While there have been challenges, including in securing a site, the youth of Strabane have waited long enough. In 2024, Minister, you told my colleagues that, due to constrained capital budgets, the EA was unable to give a timeline for completing the project. However, what seems to be the difference between where we once were, as far back as 2021 and 2022, and where we are now is that, at that time, sites were identified and work was happening in the background to have a shovel-ready project, so to speak, for when capital funding was available. The main reason for me bringing the debate is to get clarity about the situation — where we are and what we need to do to ensure that we are ready when capital funds become available. In response to a Derry City and Strabane District Council motion that I brought on behalf of Sinn Féin, the Minister told us that work would continue to look for a suitable site. If that is the case, that is all well and good, but, for some, it feels like it is falling off the edge.
I would be doing all the children and young people in Strabane a disservice by not raising these issues. I would be falling at the first hurdle in upholding the commitment that I made when I signed the Youth Work Alliance charter some time ago. I know and fully understand that we cannot build a youth centre overnight, but we can work together; make sure that a new building is kept at the top of the agenda; keep chipping away in the background on the work that needs to be done before any new facility comes to fruition; and, ultimately, see a new, modern, fit-for-purpose and accessible facility at the heart of Strabane town at the earliest opportunity. That is my goal, and I ask the Minister, the Department and the EA to make it theirs as well. Such a service will be of much benefit to the youth of the town and the surrounding areas and will allow our young people to flourish. It is long past the time for action.
Mr T Buchanan: Provision and facilities for youth services form an essential part of our towns, villages and, indeed, rural communities throughout Northern Ireland and are vital for the future development of our young people. It has to be acknowledged that, while there are gaps in some areas, there is, nevertheless, much good work being done on a voluntary basis through community groups, youth workers and organisations, as well as through the EA provision, for today's youth right across Northern Ireland.
I will come to West Tyrone and the Adjournment debate that focuses on Strabane. At the outset, I commend the invaluable work that many community groups, youth workers and youth leaders are doing in Strabane to give that much-needed support to our children and young people, not forgetting the services provided by the Education Authority. When that need continues to increase year-on-year, it becomes inevitable that available facilities that have been in use for many years will become too small and will outlive their purpose, hence the need for a new purpose-built facility in the area. Current facilities at the Strabane Youth Resource Centre on the Urney Road, the Strabane Youth Association at the Melvin Sports Complex and in Sion Mills Youth Centre are heavily utilised, and there is a growing need for a purpose-built children's and youth facility in the Strabane area. We can never overestimate how important such purpose-built facilities are for our young people and our youth. They provide safe spaces where young people can meet their friends, learn new skills, develop confidence and stay active. That helps to reduce isolation, improve their mental health and keep them engaged in positive activities, which takes our children and young people off the street and ensures that they do not get involved with the wrong company, which can lead to devastating consequences in future years.
Investing in children's and youth services is not a luxury but a necessity. I am aware that work was done back in 2021, as Mr Boggs said. A business case was submitted for that project, and it was branded a priority, but it has fallen by the wayside. In a discussion with council officials in Derry City and Strabane District Council, the Strabane canal basin was again mooted as being an ideal location for such facilities, being central and in close proximity to other neutral spaces and service provision for our youth. Perhaps the Minister can give us an update on what happened to that proposal and what is currently in the offing for Strabane.
While tremendous work is being done in limited facilities in Strabane, I have some concern at the focus for the provision of such a new youth sports facility being solely on Education. It is much wider than that and should involve a number of Departments. Limiting this to Education could stymie other funding sources and continue to delay such a vital project in Strabane. Other sources of funding can be sourced by working with the community, councils and other Departments, given that it is a cross-cutting issue that needs to be given priority due to the increasing youth sector. Like many other towns, Strabane has many talented, ambitious and creative young people, and they are being denied the resources and opportunity to reach their full potential. The importance of a children's and youth facility and services will create a stronger, safer, more vibrant community, not only for them but for the whole community and for society as a whole.
I thank the Minister for being in his place to hear the debate and the concerns that need to be addressed for our youth in Strabane. I look forward to hearing his response.
Mr McCrossan: I thank my constituency colleague Paul Boggs for bringing this to the House, and I wish him well. He is the new MLA on the block and has settled quite quickly. It is good to have another Strabane man on the blue Benches. It is important that we work together across the House, particularly among the representatives of the West Tyrone constituency, to do all that we can to maximise the benefits and opportunities for the people we represent.
The fact that we are debating this again in late 2026 tells its own story. As other Members have said, young people in Strabane have been promised a new youth centre for countless years. As Mr Boggs pointed out, in July 2020, I and other elected representatives for the constituency were told by the Education Authority that the project was a top priority for the area. Six years later, young people are still waiting. An entire generation is losing out on what was promised to them. In 2021, the then Education Minister, Michelle McIlveen, indicated that the centre could be open by December 2023. It is now almost December 2026, and not a sod has been turned.
It is not just disappointing but deeply frustrating. Young people, parents and youth workers have heard promises but have not seen delivery. The people of Strabane are entitled to ask why, if this was a top priority in 2020, it still has not been delivered in 2026. I appreciate that there has been quite significant movement in the main Strabane town centre area, with investment in the public realm, general facility upgrades, the new leisure centre, the new North West Regional Campus that is, we hope, coming soon, and new health facilities. Of course, there are the wider plans for the Riverine and, hopefully, the A5 upgrade will happen very soon. However, when it comes to the youth of the town, Strabane is found wanting. It lacks places where they can meet and facilities that they can engage with and, of course, enjoy. We find that a vacuum has been left and that young people are simply congregating in town centres and other places that are not entirely appropriate. In fact, I heard that some were congregating in local graveyards at the weekends, which is not appropriate either. When I raised that concern, one parent wrote to me asking, "Where else are they supposed to go?". That points to a fundamental issue. They have been left completely without those important facilities and without the support that they need.
It is not about bricks and mortar alone. We have the benefit of having youth workers in the area, but it is about opportunity. It is about providing safe spaces for young people, supporting their well-being, helping them to develop the skills and confidence that they need and giving them somewhere to belong. Youth services should not be taken for granted. They play a vital role in our communities every day. They are an investment in our young people and in the future of our communities. That is why I have consistently opposed cuts to youth services and welcomed decisions that protected important youth and early years programmes. We know the difference that those services make, particularly for vulnerable young people and families. Many young people may have a very difficult situation at home and just want to be out of the house but have nowhere to go. Again, those youth services play a hugely diverse and widespread role, and none of us can pretend to understand the unique circumstances that so many of our young people face, particularly in the current climate.
Minister, the case has been made for Strabane. The need has been established and the promises have been given, yet the delivery has not come. I said previously that those delays were simply a kick in the teeth for young people in the area that I represent, and I stand over those remarks today, because I can see the huge benefit of the youth services in the Omagh area. I have engaged with those services not just to protect them but to see further investment in the important role that they play. The youth of today deserve investment, and they need and absolutely deserve modern facilities. They deserve the same opportunities afforded to young people elsewhere across the North. I hope, Minister, that this debate brings to your attention the importance of facilities. I have no doubt that you will understand that. The fact is that it was promised and the case was made. The money, we were told, was there and sites were being identified, yet here we are, heading for 2027 and almost seven years on from what was initially promised. It is time to move beyond those promises and provide certainty. It is time to deliver these services. Minister, I hope that you will consider what has been said today and recognise that this is a significant void that needs to be filled urgently.
Mr Givan (The Minister of Education): Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker. I thank the Member for securing the Adjournment debate, and I wish him well in his role as a Member of the Assembly for West Tyrone.
The debate provides an opportunity to provide Members with an update on the EA's plan for a dedicated youth facility in Strabane town centre. Such a facility is needed for the delivery of universal youth services to support children and young people in the Strabane area. A business case was approved in 2022, with the preferred option being the construction of a purpose-built youth facility on Railway Street, which is adjacent to the Alley Theatre. However, Derry City and Strabane District Council, as part of the city deal Strabane canal basin regeneration project, requested that the Education Authority not procure that building but examine other options that it had deemed appropriate.
No alternative sites were considered suitable due to concerns around neutrality or cost. Following the announcement of the new city deal, there was increased demand on land purchases, which affected the EA's ability to purchase the original site.
As I have highlighted before, we are at a critical juncture. Our special schools are full, our facilities are outdated, and the demand for specialist provision is growing year-on-year. Without decisive action, we risk failing the children who need our support the most.
I turn now to the broad areas around the budget. The draft budget includes capital allocations of £1·3 billion to my Department against what are actual capital requirements of £2·4 billion of need over the period from 2026 to 2030. That will, obviously, result in a funding gap of £1·1 billion, with only 53% of identified requirements being funded. The level of capital funding that is allocated is clearly insufficient to address the longer-term strategic investment requirements. That will require my Department to reconsider, defer or reprofile capital investment proposals throughout the Budget period. Due to those demands, there has been no capital funding available to progress any youth schemes since 2023.
Mr Boggs said — I agree — that, if everything is a priority, nothing is a priority. He is right in that respect. When we prioritise all things, what is the actual priority? I have outlined a £1·1 billion funding gap that necessitates decisions to be taken. Special educational needs has the first call on the funding that is available to my Department and continues to get the funding that is needed to provide additional placements and flex the school estate for our special schools.
I recognise the pressures for youth provision, which I regard as being very important. I benefited from being involved in youth organisations, and we have many that provide support to young people, whether they be faith-based or community-based. There is the Girls' Brigade, the Boys' Brigade, the Scouts and the Guides and so on. I benefited from being a member of Every Boys Rally (EBR). For those who do not know what EBR is — there is a test for everyone here — I say that it is the brethren version of the Boys' Brigade. There will be those who are familiar with gospel halls. I am not brethren, but my next-door neighbour was, and my parents were delighted to get rid of me and my two brothers on a Friday to go to their youth work. We headed to Finaghy, where we benefited from EBR in the church hall. It instilled a lot of good discipline in the young people who came through it. I am hugely appreciative of so many people who volunteer across so many different youth organisations and community groups. There are many different community groups in my constituency that are engaged in the important work of helping our young people to become more empowered and to make progress. They are often a lifeline for many young people, giving them something to do, not just for the sake of it, but to give them skills to help them develop.
Youth work is hugely important. I have been taken round a number of youth centres by Assembly Members and MPs. In North Belfast, Mr Finucane MP and MLAs brought me to Ardoyne Youth Club, where I could see first-hand the pressures that the club faces. The situation is not unique to Strabane but has an impact on young people in different localities.
I wrote to the Finance Minister in May 2025 to request a dedicated, ring-fenced youth capital fund and to protect it as an Executive ring-fenced funding stream that would go to youth organisations to give them capital requirements. Unfortunately, that was not supported by the Finance Minister, and it was not brought to the Executive for us to have a dedicated youth capital funding allocation. If Members can apply pressure on their colleague the Finance Minister as we look to agree a Budget and capital allocations, I would be supportive of a dedicated youth capital funding stream, so that it gets protection. When it sits in my Department alongside special educational needs and schools, I can understand why officials come to me with a list of expenditure that is deemed to be critical. Youth are not getting the right kind of prioritisation, but, when faced with having to take decisions as Minister, I am having to give the first call to other things. I would therefore support a dedicated capital funding stream for youth at the Executive, and I would revisit that if the Finance Minister were amenable to considering it again.
Young people are the future, and youth organisations continue to make a real difference to the lives of our young people. Youth facilities improve their outlook on education, so it is vital that we continue to provide young people with a safe and friendly environment in which to meet similar young people and develop their individual skills, as doing that will allow them to enhance their abilities in their community outside the school environment. The situation is not good enough, and that is why I am unapologetic about continuing to make a strong case for increased and sustained investment in the education system, including in the youth sector. I assure the Member that the Department will continue to work with the EA and other Departments to support the youth sector.
By way of an update, I can confirm that my Department has completed its review of its Priorities for Youth, which is the strategic policy framework that has underpinned youth work provision since 2013. The review was undertaken to ensure that youth work policy remains responsive to the needs of children and young people and that it reflects the significant changes that have taken place across society, education and public services in the intervening period. Following completion of the review, my Department published 'Stronger Futures – A Northern Ireland Youth Work Policy Statement' for public consultation on 10 June this year. I extended the consultation until 30 October in response to requests to do so from stakeholders, including representatives of the Irish-medium youth sector and other community and voluntary providers. We have now received over 160 responses. Feedback has been largely supportive and constructive. Key matters raised include but are not limited to a definition of "youth work", the level of detail and inclusion across the diverse youth sector, including the Irish-medium sector. Following closure of the consultation, officials are undertaking a detailed analysis of the responses, the findings of which will inform the final policy. It is hoped that that final policy will be published in early 2027.
I thank Members for their contributions, not just those about Strabane, although I appreciate that it is the focus of the Adjournment debate, but those that expressed positive support for youth work. Mr Buchanan brought me to see an example of youth work in his constituency only last week when I was up in Donemana. We saw some excellent work taking place with young people who meet every Monday night. That is happening in a small rural community. Those young people are doing superb work, so I want to support them by making youth services more responsive to the needs of our community and voluntary sector, as well as where they are directly involved themselves, because there are huge benefits for young people.
Mr McCrossan said that he opposed cuts to youth services. That is not something that I ever want. He said that there was huge benefit to be had from youth services, with which I agree, and that investment in them is required.
I will conclude on this point: just last week, the House voted through £25 million in welfare payments out of the education budget. I fear that the Baker cuts are going to land on youth services and other EA provision. We cannot vote for things without recognising their consequences. Although I appreciate the support for youth services, Members have left the EA in the invidious position of now having to find £25 million, and I suspect that youth services will be one area that it will have to look at. I would not be supportive of that, but the EA has been left in a difficult position as a result of the decision that Members took only last week to use the Department of Education as the welfare system.