Official Report: Monday 16 November 2026


The Assembly met at 12:00 pm (Mr Speaker in the Chair).
Members observed two minutes' silence.

Members' Statements

Democratic Unionist Party: Recent Actions

Ms Ennis: As political unionism continues to cannibalise itself over the blocking of a sectarian hate march, back in the real world, the leader of the United States is talking positively about Irish unity, and both government parties in the South have now published blueprints for Irish unity. Meanwhile, the rest of society here is beginning to realise what we have been saying for some time now: the DUP is utterly unserious about and incapable of accepting democratic realities and governing this place in the interests of everyone.

We all know that, for the DUP, Drumcree was the pretext, not the cause. The real target is Michelle O'Neill and the fact that a republican leads the Executive as First Minister. That is the thread that runs through everything. Why block attendance at economic summits that could attract investment and jobs? Why block gestures of reconciliation? Why block support for the Irish-medium education sector and vital environmental protections? Why vote against cost-of-living measures that would support 90,000 children and their families living in poverty?

The pattern of behaviour speaks for itself. Again and again, when progress is being made and delivery is happening, the DUP's instinct is not to help to deliver but to block, because every success of the Executive is a success of a Government led by Michelle O'Neill as First Minister.

When Gavin Robinson talks of profound consequences, the only people who feel the effect of the DUP's threat of profound consequences are workers seeking fair pay and conditions, public-sector workers waiting for a Budget and, of course, the Irish language community. However, fear not: DUP pet projects, funding for flute bands and trips to genocidal Israel remain unaffected.

Where is the self-proclaimed leader of moderate unionism in all of this? When somebody finally lets him be clear, you will find him calling Sinn Féin a cancer on society and our democratic mandate sinister.

When the DUP says that it will not be business as usual, that is, frankly, laughable, because it is exactly business as usual. This is what you do, this is who you are, and this is who you have always been. You weaponise cultural issues, attack Irish language rights and hold up progress for everyone else.

It is the same old, tired politics of the past. The only people who suffer are ordinary people. They are the ones who always end up paying the price.

Oakwood Childcare Centre

Mrs Erskine: I highlight the deeply concerning closure of Oakwood Childcare Centre in Derrylin and the devastating impact that it will have on families, staff and the wider economy across County Fermanagh. There are 84 children and 35 staff at Oakwood. Behind those figures are families who now face enormous uncertainty about how they will manage their childcare, their employment and their livelihoods. Since parents were informed of the closure on Wednesday, the scale of the crisis has become increasingly clear. Of those families, 70% have indicated that they will be unable to secure alternative childcare provision. Those fortunate enough to have found alternative places have indicated that they may have to change their working patterns to accommodate that. Perhaps most concerning of all is the fact that 20 mothers have indicated that they may have to give up work altogether.

In the Chamber, we talk about growing our economy, increasing employment and supporting working families, yet here we have a situation where parents — predominantly mothers — could be forced out of the workforce simply because childcare provision is disappearing from their community. Local businesses will feel the impact. Childcare staff will themselves be unemployed. The loss of Oakwood will not be felt just in Derrylin; the ripple effect will be felt across County Fermanagh, where rural childcare provision is already under significant pressure.

I have met the provider, corresponded with Ministers and Departments and continue to pursue the issues raised in recent weeks. I thank the Education Minister, who was the only Minister to have the decency to respond to me. I have not been idle on this. Since the closure announcement, I have been actively exploring whether there is a viable way to retain childcare provision in Derrylin. I recognise that Oakwood is a private business, but that does not absolve the Government of the responsibility to address the wider pressures that face childcare providers.

I am entirely frustrated by the approach of Sinn Féin's Economy Minister and Finance Minister. A meaningful Economy Department support package for childcare providers should have gone hand in hand with the Northern Ireland childcare subsidy scheme. We cannot focus solely on affordability while ignoring sustainability and availability, yet the Finance Minister will not even provide the funding for childcare for which my DUP colleague the Education Minister has been calling for years. Childcare is not the sole responsibility of the Department of Education; it is a cross-departmental issue involving Economy, Health and Finance.

Families in Derrylin deserve more than sympathy at this stage. They deserve urgent action, meaningful engagement and attempts to find a solution. I will ensure —

Mr Speaker: Connie Egan.

Mrs Erskine: — that that is the case.

Blood Spot Monitoring: Prepaid Envelopes

Ms Egan: I will bring attention to yet another issue in our health system. At first, it had the potential to put more pressure on the already stretched pockets of patients and families across Northern Ireland, but we now know that it was the result of an avoidable administrative error. It caused needless distress and is symptomatic of a health system that is on its knees and in need of serious reform.

Last Monday, I received urgent correspondence from constituents regarding the removal of funding for prepaid envelopes from the Royal Victoria Hospital laboratory for blood spot monitoring. Those who got in touch with me mostly either had the condition phenylketonuria (PKU) or were family members of people with the condition. For that condition, blood samples have to be taken at least every two weeks — often much more regularly — and posted immediately for testing. That is the only way in which to monitor conditions such as PKU that call for constant vigilance. Historically, the prepaid envelopes have been funded by the Public Health Agency (PHA) and rightly so, due to its essential contributory role in patient care.

The removal of the funding came out of the blue. It was taken away without any patient consultation. This question was asked: why and how was that decided when the service is relied on so much? I contacted the Belfast Health and Social Care Trust, the PHA and the Minister of Health for answers. Initially, the Belfast Trust redirected me to the PHA.

On Friday, the PHA informed me that funding for prepaid envelopes for conditions such as PKU had been mistakenly removed as part of an ongoing business and budget review of a historical mailing contract for newborn blood spot screening. The PHA is responsible only for screening programmes, with ongoing clinical monitoring falling to the trust, which seemingly had no clue, hence the earlier redirection. The PHA had informed the trust that ownership of the service needed to be formally transferred. Confirmation was not sought, however, nor was an alternative arrangement put in place, so the patients and their care fell through the gap and were forgotten about. That is simply not good enough.

I have received assurances that the PHA and the trust are now working at pace to reinstate the contract, with ownership being transferred to Belfast clinical teams as soon as possible. We still need a timescale and a response from the Minister, but that news will hopefully provide comfort to the patients affected. Many will see the issue as being small, given that those patients will have the service restored, but it shows that our health service, despite our healthcare colleagues' hard work, is on its knees. We need to reform our healthcare system.

Fine Gael: United Ireland

Mr Carroll: Fine Gael has much in common with the unionist parties in this House. They both routinely round on people who rely on social security to get by. They demonise them, attack them, paint them in a really awful light, clamp down on them and put their picture online if they allegedly engage in fraud. As Leo Varadkar and others have said, Fine Gael stands up for:

"the people who get up early in the morning".

They routinely engage in that kind of awful rhetoric. They often pit people who work against people who cannot work. They have both engaged in anti-migrant rhetoric. They have opposed LGBT and women's rights at every point, with Fine Gael occasionally making a last-ditch turn. Despite Fine Gael's rhetoric in recent days, both have opposed a united Ireland quite strongly.

Fine Gael's change in position over the past few days, with its call to make moves to explore a united Ireland through the various measures that it announced in Cork, is late but welcome. It shows that it is paying attention to the changing winds and to how people's views on a united Ireland are changing across the North and the South. What kind of united Ireland, however? If Fine Gael gets its way, I am prepared to put my hat on it that we will have a united Ireland that is still a tax haven, with around a third of government revenue collected in taxes paid by multinational corporations. That is completely unsustainable. It is also worth reminding ourselves that Fine Gael has spent years in court fighting against more public money being given to the public and against billions of euros in taxes being paid by Apple, which robbed the people of wealth created by Irish workers.

There is plenty of wealth around. We hear a lot of conversation about whether the South can afford a united Ireland. It is a question not of whether the South can afford us but of who will pay for it. Who will pay for public services? Who will pay for a national health service, whether people live in Donegal, Derry, Belfast, Cork or elsewhere? We have lots of wealth across the island. We have billionaires and multimillionaires. If we tax those people properly, we can have a united Ireland that is worth fighting for.

Fivemiletown Cattle Cull

Mr Gaston: The events that took place in rural Fivemiletown in June will forever be a stain on the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs under the leadership of Andrew Muir and Katrina Godfrey. When the Minister came before the Committee in August, he hid behind his not-so-independent external review. Now that Dr Martin Blake has carried out that review, there is a series of questions that still have not been answered.

Minister Muir must come clean.


12.15 pm

Most notably, the Minister has failed to confirm how many bullets were used during the massacre of 51 healthy cattle. In August, Minister Muir told the Committee that no animal was shot multiple times. We now know from his report that, at best, his answer was incompetent and, at worst, misled the Committee. The report confirms that secondary shots were made and that:

"no records were kept of secondary shots".

Hiding behind security reasons is not an acceptable answer. Failing to state the calibre and number of bullets used cries "Cover-up". Knowing the calibre of the bullets used and the number of shots fired is essential to understanding the risks to which members of the public were exposed. Every shot must be accounted for to ensure that it was discharged safely.

I want to know how many miles any stray bullets would have travelled; how many of the 51 healthy cattle were shot multiple times; and how many of the 51 healthy cattle were shot without a suitable backstop. I want to know whether any of the shots were fired within 18 metres of the centre of a public road. I want to know how a calf that was shot through the neck without the Department knowing turned up days after the massacre had taken place. I want to know how two other calves rose from the dead to turn up days later and how the Department allowed them to be transferred to another herd.

I believe that the public and local landowners were put at risk, and, for that alone, officials need to be held to account. Katrina Godfrey told the Committee:

"If you are looking to know who is responsible, it is me."

If that is the case, the next question from the Committee should have been, "When will you resign, Mrs Godfrey, and take that awful AERA Minister, Andrew Muir, with you?".

Oakwood Childcare Centre

Ms D Armstrong: I will talk about the cost of childcare in rural areas and, like my colleague from Fermanagh and South Tyrone, specifically about what is about to happen in Derrylin.

As Members have heard, Oakwood Childcare Centre announced last week that it would close on 23 December, which is two days before Christmas. Oakwood has looked after children in the south Fermanagh area for almost 20 years. It has kept going through recession, the pandemic and the loss of jobs in the area, but it can no longer make the figures add up.

Thirty-five staff will lose their jobs, and 84 children will lose their places. That would be a serious blow anywhere, but, in a village the size of Derrylin, it is devastating. There is no other nursery round the corner with spare places, and, for many parents, the nearest alternative is a long drive in the opposite direction from where they work. For some, there is no alternative at all. Some will cut their hours, and others will give up work altogether. We all know that it is usually mothers who end up doing that.

Childcare is an economic issue as well as a family one. When a childcare place goes, a parent may not be able to work, a local employer is left short of staff and a wage stops being spent in local shops. In rural areas, childcare is as much a part of the infrastructure as roads and broadband. When it goes, young families start to move away, and then the local schools, clubs and businesses feel it too. Rural providers face the same rising costs as everyone else, be it in wages, insurance, food or heating, but they have fewer children across whom they can spread those costs and the families whom they serve cannot afford higher fees.

Being on the border makes it harder again. Oakwood is four miles from County Cavan. Across the border, the Irish Government fund providers directly, cap their fees and give parents an hourly subsidy. A family living in the Republic loses that support as soon as it uses a provider in Northern Ireland. Oakwood's owners have said that they completely understand, as I do, why parents go where the support is, but a provider here simply cannot compete with that. The two systems take no account of each other, and, as a result, a border community will lose its childcare.

I call on the Minister of Education and any Minister around the Executive table who can help to do three things. First, I call on them to meet Oakwood's owners, staff and parents urgently — before 23 December — to see whether the centre can be saved and, if not, to help those families to find other places. Secondly, they need to make sure that the early learning and childcare strategy is properly rural-proofed, with border communities in mind, and that it has the funding that it needs.

Thirdly, they need to raise the issue of the cross-border funding gap with the Irish Government and give serious consideration to a rural cross-border pilot, which Oakwood suggested in August. The families of Derrylin did not cause the problem, and they cannot fix it on their own. Those of us in the Chamber who are in a position to help need to do so, and we will need to do that before 23 December.

Papal Audience: Families of the Disappeared

Mr McNulty: I want to recognise and empathise with the families of the disappeared, who are meeting Pope Leo XIV for a papal audience this week in Rome. It is an extraordinary papal audience for the families of the innocent people who were abducted, murdered and secretly buried by the IRA during the Troubles.

Four of the 17 victims who are known as the disappeared remain missing to this day. My heart goes out to all the families. Their bravery and strength are remarkable. Some of the families have had to endure multiple false horizons of hope, where information has been provided and search teams have been deployed, only for that hope to wane over weeks when the remains of their loved ones stay unfound. Not knowing where your loved one is buried presents a terrible grief and loss that none of us would want to experience. I hope that the papal audience brings comfort to the grieving families and encourages anyone with any information to come forward.

Dympna Kerr, whose brother Columba was 19 when he was abducted and killed on Halloween night in 1975, spoke with pain, eloquence and power on the radio this morning when she said:

"We know there's people out there who haven't come forward with information yet. They would want the dignity of a Christian burial when they die. Why should my brother or any of the other disappeared be different to them?"

The deceased and their families deserve to have the dignity of a Christian burial.

Irish Reunification

Mr Kearney: Last week, in the European Parliament, a new report was published by Mark Bassett and Colin Harvey that details how the European Union institutions can and should prepare for Irish reunification. That came on the back of the Lucid Talk poll, which, for the third consecutive year, demonstrated that the gap between those who support the Union and those who support Irish reunification is closing.

Days after the Fine Gael ard-fheis last weekend, when that party announced its blueprint for unification, Simon Harris wrote to the leaders of all the political parties across the island inviting them to engage in talks about the future. That is to be welcomed. It indicates that the discussion on Irish reunification and constitutional change has become mainstream throughout the island, and all that follows on from Sinn Féin's repeated calls for the establishment of a citizens' assembly, the creation of a constitutional forum and the drafting of a Green Paper on preparing and planning for Irish unity.

Mapping the transition for the future will be challenging, but it is replete with opportunity for us all. It is a chance for every section of our society to grasp the opportunity to design a new future in all our interests, so inclusive engagement is absolutely critical. Unionists should get involved. The unionist parties and leaders should become involved in the discussion, because so many Protestant people are already staking a claim to the future and bringing forward their ideas and visions. Support for Irish unity and support for the Union are equally legitimate, albeit support for the Union is entirely illogical. However, refusing to engage in the discussion will not slow down the momentum for change. It will not make the momentum for national self-determination go away, so my message this morning is this: let us accept the reality that change is on the horizon and let us plan for the future together.

Abortion: Belfast City Hall Illumination on Easter Sunday

Ms Forsythe: Today, I rise again in the House to give voice to the voiceless. The DUP is, and always has been, a firmly pro-life party, dedicated to advocating at every turn for the right to life of babies from the moment that they are formed in the womb. Every life matters.

It has been devastating to see the republican agenda at work in recent days, with Sinn Féin, the SDLP, the Greens and Alliance voting to light up Belfast City Hall on 28 March — Easter Sunday — to celebrate abortion. Easter Sunday is the most sacred day in the Christian calendar. For Christians, it marks the Resurrection and the hope of new life. To choose that day to turn the city's most prominent civic building into a billboard for abortion is so offensive. City Hall belongs to everyone. It should never be used to offend people of faith on the holiest day of the year.

This comes just weeks after DUP councillors stopped a similar plan in September. They were backed in doing so by more than 20,000 people who signed a petition. I understand that the Easter Sunday illumination date has potentially been moved, but our Belfast city councillors will continue to oppose that lighting-up, because abortion is not something to celebrate. Belfast City Hall should not be illuminated in support of an international campaign seeking further liberalisation and the removal of restrictions. Belfast City Hall is a significant civic symbol that represents the people of Belfast and those right across Northern Ireland. It belongs to everyone. It should not be turned into a billboard for abortion. It should be a place where the value, dignity and well-being of every person are recognised and protected.

Although we are devastated by this action, it is also a reminder of what can happen on such issues when unionists cannot apply the brake. We have the most liberal abortion law in Europe, which was imposed on us in Northern Ireland by Westminster while Stormont was down. Not one MLA voted for it. This shows that, if we return to direct rule, the woke agenda could be foisted on our schools, our public sector and every other part of our lives, with no ability to stop it.

Since abortion services were introduced to Northern Ireland under the regulations in 2020, 11,192 abortions had been carried out here up to 31 March 2025. The 2025-26 figures are still to be published, and they may show some 14,000 babies' lives lost since the services were introduced. Those are innocent lives lost, and it is too late for them and their parents, but it is not too late for us to stop and reflect. We will stand up for every baby, because they are faithfully and wonderfully made in God's image. Every life matters.

Northern Ireland Best Kept Awards: Royal Hillsborough, Aghalee and Annahilt

Mrs Guy: I am really proud this morning as a Lagan Valley MLA to recognise the recent success of Hillsborough, Aghalee and Annahilt at the Northern Ireland best kept awards. The prompt to make this statement came from a catch-up that I had with Dawn, the chairperson of the Hillsborough and district committee, who was so proud and thrilled that Royal Hillsborough was awarded best kept large village. On behalf of everyone who lives and works in the village, I say a huge thank you to the members of the committee and to Andy and the wider grounds maintenance team at Lisburn and Castlereagh City Council. The team's hard work, season after season, in maintaining the floral displays, verges, green spaces and public areas is so appreciated.

Aghalee received the prestigious Welcome award, with the Aghalee Meet Up and Clean Up initiative highlighted as a wonderful example of community action making a tangible difference. I cannot acknowledge that award better than by quoting Aghalee resident and local councillor Claire Kemp, who said:

"This award reflects the incredible community spirit that exists within the village and the dedication of residents who go above and beyond to make it such a welcoming place."

As a new rep for the area, I absolutely endorse those words. I thank the residents for how welcome they have made me feel since taking on this role. It is a genuinely special community.

Last but not least, congratulations to Annahilt, which was named runner-up in the best kept small village category. It is another close-knit community that comes together and takes real pride in its village. It is a lovely place with real character, dedicated volunteers and elected reps, and I am delighted that it has been recognised in that way. It is wonderful to see communities across Lagan Valley receiving this recognition. Well done to everyone who played a part. You have every reason to be proud, and we are grateful for everything that you contribute.


12.30 pm

Richhill AFC: Funding Questions

Mrs Mason: A serious whiff of cronyism surrounds Paul Givan's attempts to direct £30,000 of Education funding to Richhill AFC. Before visiting the club, his officials advised that schools made limited use of its facilities and that no existing funding mechanism applied. However, Paul Givan appears to have changed that assessment overnight. His Department pressed ahead, asking the Education Authority (EA) to explore sources of funding, including funds used to run our schools, and he has the barefaced cheek to talk about the state of his budget. We have now also learnt that a DUP politician has sponsorship links to Richhill AFC through his company. That raises serious questions about why that particular club received such extraordinary attention from the Minister. Why were important discussions about the proposed funding not properly recorded? While, as we all know from the areas that we represent, schools were struggling with crumbling buildings, stretched budgets and urgent repairs, the Minister's Department was busy exploring ways to find £30,000 for a football club that had absolutely nothing to do with the Department of Education.

We welcome the end of Givan's boycott of the Education Committee, but we remain deeply concerned that, in his sheer arrogance, he believes that he can dictate which questions elected representatives can and cannot ask. That is not how accountability works. The Minister insists that no money was paid. Following sustained scrutiny, the Department has now ruled out funding the club, but that is not the point. The question, surely, is why Givan and his Department went to such lengths to try to make it happen. It is cronyism, and make no mistake: Richhill is only the tip of the iceberg.

Mr Speaker: I call Jonathan Buckley. You have two minutes, Mr Buckley.

Robert McCartney Murder

Mr Buckley: What is it with Sinn Féin when it comes to silence when silence suits? Silence on brutality, silence on murder and silence on cover-ups. Today, the families whose loved ones were disappeared at the hands of republican terrorists continue their campaign to break the silence. As barbaric as those crimes were, they do not stand in isolation. The recent BBC documentary 'Murder in Belfast: Sisters Seeking Justice' shone a light on one of the most shameful episodes in our recent history, and it should be uncomfortable viewing for some Members of the House. On 30 January 2005, Robert McCartney walked out of Magennis's Bar in Belfast and was butchered in Market Street. He was 33 years old, a father of two and engaged to be married.

He was murdered by a gang of thugs, but it is the actions afterwards that should have every law-abiding citizen asking questions. It was a packed bar, yet nobody panicked afterwards. They followed a routine. While paramedics worked on Robert in the street, the clean-up was already under way. The CCTV tape was taken, the bar was scrubbed with bleach, and the knife disappeared. Then came the silence. Around 70 people were in the bar that evening. Not one of them has given a full account to the police. Seventy people and a toilet that apparently held most of them. The current Sinn Féin MLA for South Belfast, Deirdre Hargey, was among those in the bar that night. She was there when police arrived, yet she maintains her silence to this day. The culture of silence continues.

Mr Speaker: The Member's time is up

Mr Buckley: I pay tribute to the McCartney family in their quest for justice. The courage that they have demonstrated —

Mr Speaker: The Member's time is up.

Mr Buckley: — shames the cowardice of those who were involved —

Mr Speaker: The Member's time is up.

Mr Buckley: — in their brother's murder.

Mr Speaker: Members, please take your ease for a moment while we change the top Table.

(Madam Principal Deputy Speaker in the Chair)

Opposition Business

Mr O'Toole: I beg to move

That this Assembly recognises the huge importance of BBC Northern Ireland (BBC NI) as a source of news, information and shared local experience; expresses concern at sudden cuts to much loved and vital services, including Irish language services as well as long-standing locally produced series, in the absence of a clear and publicly explained strategy being communicated; acknowledges the profound role BBC NI has in relation to news and current affairs coverage; and calls on BBC NI, as a public service broadcaster, to provide a clearer explanation on the allocation and prioritisation of resources amid current public concern on editorial accountability.

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: The Business Committee has agreed to allow up to one hour and 30 minutes for the debate. The proposer of the motion will have 10 minutes to propose and 10 minutes to make a winding-up speech. All other contributors will have five minutes.

Mr O'Toole: We live, I am afraid, in an age of nonsense and technologically driven division. Technology has fundamentally altered our relationship with all content from news and current affairs to music and film. I make that point in order to underpin the Opposition motion on cuts at BBC Northern Ireland, because public service media is more important now than it has ever been at a time when billionaires or even trillionaires are willing to buy social media platforms and wield them as weapons against anyone whom they happen to hate. When we often cannot tell what is real and what is false on the screens in front of us or when many of the traditional ways in which we connected with one another, such as local newspapers, are struggling to cling on or are simply dying out, it is critical that we have impartial public service media to provide accurate information, rigorous journalism and a space for people to come together in a cultural sense but also to disagree, challenge and debate.

The BBC's stated mission based on its current royal charter, which runs until the end of next year is:

"to act in the public interest, serving all audiences through the provision of impartial, high-quality and distinctive output and services which inform, educate and entertain".

Added to that is this specific public purpose:

"To reflect, represent and serve the diverse communities of all of the United Kingdom’s nations and regions".

That mission, however, is now made much harder by the BBC's decision to sharply cut services.

To be clear up front, we believe in a healthy BBC that is funded by the licence fee; we believe in public service broadcasting. Indeed, just as we press now for RTÉ to better serve the many people in the North who use and trust its service, I say that, in any new constitutional future, I would hope that the BBC would play a continued part for users in this part of the world. The SDLP believes in public service media, whether that is provided by the BBC, RTÉ or any other media outlet, offering content that is designed to serve diverse audiences and not simply to maximise profits.

Public service broadcasting can be a huge force for good, but that does not make it immune from scrutiny. In fact, when we pay a levy or tax to fund that service — we do that in the North — we are entitled to ask questions about the choices that are made. Choices are now being made about cuts. In the North, those cuts have included the remarkable decision to effectively shut down the corporation's in-house Irish language programming unit and, in the process, make more than half of its staff — 60% — redundant. Irish language programming here already pales in comparison with that offered by BBC Cymru and Radio nan Gàidheal in Scotland. Now, the Irish language community is being asked to believe that a massive downsizing in in-house expertise is not a diminution of service or status: that is simply implausible. While the Gaeilgeoir community is a minority, it is a fast-growing minority and an expanding community of interest, which should be exactly the kind of group served by public service media.

The decision to end in-house Irish language production cannot be seen as anything other than a diminution, as is the decision to shut down the entirety of the factual programming department. The BBC may say that that change will mean more opportunities for independent production companies to tender, but there are no guarantees of that. Again, that cannot be viewed as anything other than a diminution of the BBC locally. That comes as we hear further news about UTV factual programming being drastically cut and jobs being lost. People will also have seen news of the cancellation of much-loved local comedy programmes, most notably 'Give My Head Peace' and 'A Perforated Ulster', both of which were summarily ended after decades via email. That comes after years of the slow unwinding of Radio Foyle, making it less relevant. That is an important service for the people of Derry that has been whittled down gradually over the years.

The local leadership of the BBC may say that it is obliged to deliver £4 million of savings and that that, inevitably, means difficult decisions. It may say that, but the truth is that it has said very little.

There is a striking absence of public accountability at BBC Northern Ireland, despite the hugely important position that the BBC holds in the North, especially now that other local media, including UTV news, has shrunk. It is also a cultural resource and an economic player. Virtually nothing, however, has been said publicly about the strategy, if there is one, underpinning the cuts.

Across the water, Matt Brittin, the new BBC director general, has already appeared in front of a Commons Committee to explain his thinking. Brutal as the UK-wide cuts are, he at least recognises that, for a public service broadcaster whose mandate to levy a fee and deliver its content comes from a charter before Parliament, public accountability is a necessity. South of the border, Kevin Bakhurst, the RTÉ director general, has been a regular attendee at Oireachtas Committees, recognising that a public service broadcaster owes the public an explanation for choices made on its behalf. That recognition does not always seem to apply in Northern Ireland, however. Cuts to Irish language services, cuts to factual programming, cuts to local comedy and satire and the long-running cuts to Radio Foyle are simply imposed with little or no explanation or accountability. The Irish language, humour with a local accent and programmes made by people who understand this place are the very things that local licence fee payers have a right to expect to be protected. Instead, we have cuts without consultation and even without explanation.

I have heard from people inside the BBC, as, I am sure, others have, that part of the reason that the cuts concern people is that they can see or, more accurately, hear the extraordinary resource and platform offered after 9.00 am every day to a narrow set of hard-line views: if not every morning, many mornings. That was most acutely apparent during recent events surrounding Drumcree. On 3 September, a large section of 'The Nolan Show' was given over to coverage of the issue, as has a large section of its entire output over the past month or two. Jamie Bryson, an unelected blogger and regular guest, well known in this place, was interviewed for nearly 20 minutes. At 10.00 am, the programme went live to a press conference. That is an unusually early time for any press conference. It was by Portadown Orange lodge, and Mr Bryson was a participant. He was then interviewed afterwards. Executive, official Opposition and political party press conferences are not routinely broadcast live, yet that one was.

Between 19 and 26 October, the top story on five out of six broadcasts related to Carla Lockhart. On 4 November, the Member for Upper Bann Mr Buckley, who is no longer in the Chamber, was given 45 uninterrupted minutes to explain his philosophy on the future of unionism. To provide balance and diversity of perspective, that was followed immediately by a response from Jim Allister. It is not that those are not stories, are not of interest to the public or should not be covered, but the people who pay for and care about the BBC — those who pay for the BBC are all of us — have a right to ask whether such stories are being covered in a way that reflects the BBC's core mission, which, I repeat, is:

"to act in the public interest, serving all audiences through the provision of impartial, high-quality and distinctive output".

There are hundreds of talented journalists, producers, programme makers and production staff at BBC Northern Ireland. They produce high-quality, world-class news and entertainment at a time of huge pressure on the industry and, indeed, on the idea of impartial news and public service broadcasting. They also have a right to accountability on decisions that affect the reputation of the corporation that they have helped build and clarity on strategic decisions that will affect whether they have a job.

If we believe in the principle of public service broadcasting as a public good — we do — the Assembly, like other devolved legislatures, has a right to make its voice heard, not least because the BBC charter is under review and will be updated next year. As we all know, in order to have our voice heard in London, we need to speak loudly. I am sure that most Members in the Chamber agree with that. As a strong supporter of public service broadcasting, of the BBC's mission and of the idea of impartial public service media, I call on us to protect public service broadcasting and enhance public trust in it. I commend the motion to the Assembly.


12.45 pm

Mr Gildernew: My speech will be partly in Irish and partly in English.

The BBC has again shown how poorly it understands this place. Decisions shaped by priorities in London are felt here by people whose jobs are on the line and by communities who already struggle to hear their voices on air. People here remember what it meant to have decisions made in Britain about which Irish voices deserved to be heard, which reminds us what happens when people making decisions about broadcasting here are far removed from the communities affected. The people whose jobs are at risk know this place, and I caution that, once their expertise is lost, it will be difficult to replace. The same questions apply to wider cuts: what local programmes will audiences lose, and how does the BBC decide which are worth protecting? Tá imní faoi leith orm faoi thionchar na gciorruithe sin ar an tsoláthar don Ghaeilge.

[Translation: I am particularly concerned about what this could mean for Irish language provision]

We have a strong, thriving arts sector, which we see if we look at 'Crá', the Irish language crime drama shot in Gweedore, or 'Aontas', a thriller produced by TG4 and the BBC. They show what our writers, actors and crews can do when broadcasters back them. The BBC says that spending and Irish language radio output will stay the same, but a promise about the number of hours does not tell listeners whether they will still hear the programmes that they look forward to, nor does it guarantee continuity in the future. An áit a mbíonn craoltóireacht, bíonn deis an teanga a chluinstin agus a úsáid sa ghnáthshaol ag an té atá líofa, ag an té atá ag foghlaim agus ag an teaghlach atá ag tógáil páistí trí Ghaeilge. Cuireann sí saibhreas na teanga agus an chultúir roimh lucht mór féachana fosta.

[Translation: For fluent speakers, learners and families raising children through Irish, broadcasting provides an opportunity to hear and use the language in everyday life. It also brings the richness of our language and culture to wider audiences.]

The BBC's charter requires it to support the Irish language and pay attention to under-represented communities. The focus and framing of the BBC's output already often excludes swathes of our society from its narrative.

Ms K Armstrong: Will the Member give way?

Mr Gildernew: Yes: go ahead.

Ms K Armstrong: I will take the Member back to June 2024, when the BBC removed sign language from our lunchtime news, leaving BBC Northern Ireland with no sign language provision. Does he agree that it is difficult for BBC Northern Ireland to argue that it covers all communities when it has completely left out the sign language community?

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: The Member has an extra minute.

Mr Gildernew: As Chair of the Communities Committee, I fully agree. I have raised the matter with the BBC. Disgracefully, it removed sign language's only element of mainstream visibility. That should be restored.

How does cutting a dedicated language team help the BBC to meet its responsibilities? Cuirfidh Sinn Féin in éadan iarracht ar bith an soláthar sin a lagú. Tá freagraí soiléire uainn maidir leis na himpleachtaí a bheidh ann don fhoireann, don mhaoiniú, agus do chláir bheo agus rialta.

[Translation: Sinn Féin will challenge any attempt to weaken that provision. We need clear answers about the implications for staffing and funding as well as live and regular programming.]

Tá infheistíocht leanúnach agus tiomantas soiléir do bhuaine na dtionscal cruthaitheach agus na seirbhísí Gaeilge de dhíth.

[Translation: Our creative industries and Irish language services need sustained investment and a clear commitment to their future.]

The BBC should reverse its staffing cuts, sit down with staff, the Irish language audience and sector representatives and commit to protecting regular live Irish broadcasting. The people who make the programmes and those who listen to them deserve nothing less.

I will meet senior BBC staff in the near future to discuss the issue further. I thank the Member who tabled this important motion.

Mrs Erskine: I thank the proposer of the motion for tabling it. The central premise is that the BBC licence fee is paid by ordinary hard-working households, many of whom already face considerable financial pressures. It is reasonable for those households to expect their money to be spent wisely, efficiently and in a way that delivers the best public service.

The BBC should not be immune from scrutiny when it comes to how public money is spent. Questions about management structures, staffing arrangements and production costs are legitimate; indeed, they are necessary. If efficiencies can be made, they should be made. The BBC must be transparent, however, about where those savings come from, the alternatives that have been considered and, crucially, the impact that the savings will have on the services that people rely on. Behind every proposed restructuring are hard-working journalists, reporters, producers and support staff whose livelihoods face uncertainty. They deserve proper engagement, transparency and reassurance throughout the process.

I want to raise a particular concern about the changes: BBC Northern Ireland must not become "BBC Belfast". Those living in rural communities in towns such as Enniskillen, Coleraine, Kilkeel and Londonderry deserve the same quality of coverage and attention as those living in the capital city. As a representative of Fermanagh and South Tyrone, I know just how important local journalism is. The stories that matter to people in communities are not always the political headlines that come out of this place; they are the stories about our schools, hospitals, farmers, local businesses, community organisations and the people who make a difference every day. Those stories deserve to be told. We must ensure that any restructuring does not result in regional voices being pushed further to the margins or news coverage becoming increasingly Belfast-centric.

BBC Northern Ireland has a responsibility to reflect the rich heritage, culture and diversity of traditions that exist in Northern Ireland. One tradition that has not been mentioned in the Chamber today is that of the Ulster Scots. Their traditional music, local history, cultural events and traditions have shaped our communities for generations. Public service broadcasting has a duty to ensure that those voices and stories continue to have a platform. They must not become casualties of cost-cutting exercises.

I fully recognise that broadcasting is changing. Audiences consume news and programmes differently. Technology is evolving, and financial pressures are real. The BBC must adapt to those realities, but modernisation must not become an excuse for centralisation, and efficiency must not come at the expense of quality. Quality: that is the standard that licence fee payers deserve and against which the proposals should be judged.

Mr Kingston: Will the Member give way?

Mrs Erskine: Just as I finish. Yes, I will give way.

Mr Kingston: Does the Member agree that it is great to see programmes made in Northern Ireland having national appeal across the UK? This evening, the BBC Northern Ireland programme 'Peelers: The PSNI for Real' commences being broadcast nationwide on BBC Two, and it was good to see Stephen Nolan on the BBC's 'Breakfast' this morning, along with PSNI officers Jade and Sergeant Dave, trailing that programme. Along with the success of 'Blue Lights', that shows that programmes made here have appeal across the UK if they are of the right quality, as the Member said.

Mrs Erskine: I thank the Member for the intervention. Yes, I enjoy 'Peelers'. That programme shows the importance of quality, as I said, for licence-fee payers, whether in shows or news. It can showcase Northern Ireland not just here but across the board.

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: I was going to give you an extra minute, Deborah, but you had already indicated that you had finished.

I remind Members that interventions are meant to be short. Well done to Brian for his brass neck. Good stuff.

Ms Mulholland: BBC Northern Ireland has such an important place in our lives. Its journalism helps people to understand decisions that affect their lives and holds people in public office, such as us, to account. Its programmes also provide a shared local experience, as Mrs Erskine said. It reflects the places, people and stories that make Northern Ireland what it is.

I am particularly concerned about the impact on our creative workforce: the writers, performers, producers, researchers and technical staff. Last week, I heard from representatives of the Musicians' Union who explained just how important the BBC is to their members. That work supports livelihoods. It develops new talent and sustains expertise in Northern Ireland. When commissions disappear and production teams are reduced, the consequences reach far beyond any individual programme. There are fewer opportunities for people who are starting their career. There is a real risk that there will be an end to the pipeline of people coming into the industry, because the skills and relationships that are built up over many years can be lost extremely quickly, especially if experienced people leave the sector.

The proposed changes to the Irish language services that some Members have mentioned raise a particular concern for me. The reported reduction from five full-time posts to two represents a substantial change to an already small team. We have heard from Conradh na Gaeilge and Foras na Gaeilge about their concerns about future provision. Those programmes do not just support children in Irish-medium education to hear conversation through their local broadcaster but help adult learners to build confidence and give fluent speakers access to news, discussion and entertainment in their own language. I can only see that helping Irish to thrive as a part of everyday life. Therefore, we need clear assurances on how the proposed changes will protect and develop that provision. The BBC has said that spending on radio output in Irish will be maintained overall, with more programming being commissioned from the independent production sector, but we need assurances from the BBC about how that will work in practice. Independent producers make a hugely important contribution to our creative industries — we see and hear it on the airwaves daily — and their involvement should be supported through a commissioning approach that is fair and that provides continuity. Audiences need to see that plan.

More broadly, the BBC should publish an accessible explanation of its priorities, the alternatives that have been considered and what impacts it foresees there being on the service. That should include how it assesses whether the changes deliver public value and how audiences can be consulted and help to shape future provision.

The motion also raises the important issue of editorial accountability. People need to be able to trust that the BBC, our national broadcaster, is getting the facts right, being fair and making room for a broad range of views and for diversity. We need to know that, when things go wrong, people's complaints will be taken seriously and that mistakes will be put right. We need that now more than ever, particularly in Northern Ireland. It matters to the health of our democracy. Editorial independence is central to that. As politicians, we should expect the BBC and its journalists to ask us difficult questions and to hold us to account without fear or favour. That scrutiny has to work both ways, however. It is vital to our democracy, and we should welcome it —.

Mr K Buchanan: Will the Member give way?

Ms Mulholland: Yes, absolutely.

Mr K Buchanan: I watch the BBC fairly regularly. Does the Member agree that it is not always fair? Politicians should be put under scrutiny, but we watch some programmes where they hold politicians to account, and in the next programme, the same presenter does not. Why do you think that is?

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: Sian, you have an extra minute.

Ms Mulholland: Thank you.

Unfortunately, I cannot comment on the individual editorial choices of each programme. For me, there are definitely more programmes that I feel less anxious about going on, because I know that, as a politician, I might get a fairer hearing. However, I think that that comes down to individual approach and what drives listeners and viewers. [Interruption.]

Mr Gaston, you are chuntering. Do you want an intervention? Would you like to —?

Mr Gaston: I am all right.

Ms Mulholland: Have I said something that you disagree with?

Mr Gaston: No, you are doing a good job. [Inaudible.]

Ms Mulholland: Apologies. Through the Chair, I say that Alliance wants a strong, independent and sustainably funded BBC Northern Ireland with the capacity to serve the full diversity of our society. We support the calls for BBC Northern Ireland to explain clearly its decisions and to engage with and explain to staff and audiences how it is going to protect the quality and breadth of its services, which people value.

The debate is ultimately about more than staffing structures or budgets; it is about whether we value the voices, stories and cultures that make up our society, whether those are Ulster Scots, Irish language or my own personal passion, local music, for which there is output through 'Across the Line' and 'BBC Introducing'. BBC Northern Ireland has a vital role to play in reflecting the richness and diversity of Northern Ireland and, in doing so, to support local talent. I urge the BBC to pause the cuts, engage meaningfully and provide a credible plan that protects and strengthens broadcasting, including Irish language output, for future generations. We should be building cultural confidence and opportunity, not diminishing it. For those reasons, we thank the proposers and support the motion.

Mr Nesbitt: I commend the leader of the Opposition on this motion, particularly given the inclusion of a call for a clearer public explanation for the rationale behind the cuts. I declare an interest in that I worked for BBC Northern Ireland for around 10 years. During that time, I observed one of the periodic cuts to headcount at the BBC. The BBC put on the noticeboard an A4 sheet with the cuts broken down by department: newsroom, minus x; current affairs, minus y; religion, minus z; and so on across all the departments, including audio, film and editing. At the bottom was personnel, which was what we called human resources in those days, and it said personnel, plus two. It was employing two extra people to administer the cuts. At no point was there an explanation from BBC management of why those cuts were being made or why they were being made in that way. The motion calls for the public to have clarity. That is important because, as Members have pointed out, the BBC is funded by the public via the licence fee.


1.00 pm

I am afraid to say that there are occasions when, perhaps, BBC management does not fully understand where the costs of making programmes lie. At one point, I presented 'Sportsound', Radio Ulster's Saturday afternoon sports programme. In those days, it ran for three and a half hours — 2·30 pm to 6·00 pm. The last half hour was the results part of the programme, when reporters gave their eyewitness accounts of the main sporting fixtures of the day. At one point, management said, "We're going to cut out three hours. We'll just have the results show". However, the vast majority of the cost was sending reporters to the matches, so the first three hours cost very, very little, but that is where the proposed cut was to be made. It did not happen, of course.

I felt that the same was, perhaps, being applied to Radio Foyle's morning show back in 2022, when the proposal was to cut it from two hours to 30 minutes. Once again, the question was, "Are you going to cover fewer events?", because, if you are not, you are still going to have to send out reporters, pay a presenter, fire up a studio and have engineers and technical support. That is a good example of why the BBC should be more public about stating its strategy, because, in the case of Foyle's radio show, the BBC miscalculated the number of hours of news and current affairs that Foyle was broadcasting. The BBC's website records:

"Under the terms of its operating licence, the BBC was required to deliver 1,043 hours of news and current affairs on Radio Foyle every year.

But the cuts ... meant it only broadcast 651 hours ... in 2023/24.

That led to Ofcom ruling the BBC had breached a condition of its operating licence.

According to Ofcom, the BBC told the regulator the mistake was due to an 'internal miscommunication', which meant programmes broadcast on Radio Ulster were mistakenly included when calculating its output for Radio Foyle."

I suggest that that is a compelling argument for being more open and transparent about cuts in broadcasting.

Having spent a decade at the BBC and slightly longer at UTV, I feel that local programming presented by local people is incredibly important. I have always had the impression that UTV is viewed by the population of this place as being a truly local station, with such presenters as Gloria Hunniford, Eamonn Holmes and Gerry Kelly, whereas the BBC, particularly during the horrible years of what we so euphemistically call the Troubles, had people such as Jeremy Paxman, Nick Witchell and James Robbins presenting the news, making it look like a branch office of its central London base. That is why local output is so important and, therefore, why it is so important that we understand the strategy and rationale behind changes of this nature being made. On that basis, I am very happy to support the motion.

Miss Brogan: Public service broadcasting is an essential aspect of any democratic society. It is vital that there are public platforms that people can turn to for information and education and that they are motivated solely by the enhancement of the public good, not by profit or shareholders. It is essential not only that those are platforms that people can trust but that the reporting is thorough and rigorous and that it is impartial, with its only loyalty being to the truth. Unfortunately, the BBC has often fallen below those standards. Here in the North, it displays institutional bias against Irish nationalism and in favour of the status quo. While that has improved in recent years, it came as no huge surprise that, when the BBC made cuts here, the axe fell firmly on the Irish language department, with the number of staff there being cut by an astonishing 60%, while the number of staff cut across the organisation more broadly hovered around 10%.

BBC reporting on international issues has also sought to toe the Government line, with the coverage of the genocide in Palestine displaying a particularly shameful level of cowardice. However, despite its institutional failures, there remain many talented, principled and hard-working people in the BBC. Indeed, many of its staff called out the inaccurate framing of Israel's genocide, and I commend them for their courage and commitment to journalistic integrity.

There have also been important improvements in the BBC's entertainment programming in recent years, with shows such as 'Crá', which Colm mentioned, and 'Tall Tales and Murder' being incredible success stories. Incidentally, both were produced in collaboration with TG4 and RTÉ, further highlighting how the future of the arts here is all-Ireland in nature. That gives even greater emphasis to our motion calling for an end to geoblocking that was debated in the House a few weeks ago.

One of the main purposes of public broadcasting is to tell local stories and platform local voices. It is therefore particularly disappointing that a range of locally made and produced programmes have also been axed. We are told that that is all part of essential cost-cutting, but it is very frustrating that such cost-cutting measures always seem to land on the arts or vital public services. That all points to a much deeper, more insidious problem with the priorities of the British Government when it comes to public spending.

The BBC has its problems, but the answer to those shortcomings is not to hollow out local journalism, local arts and minority language provision. If public service broadcasting matters, investment in those services is not an optional extra; it is the very reason for the existence of public service broadcasting. I am happy to support the motion.

Mr McGlone: Tá athstruchtúrú riaracháin tar éis éirí ina chonspóid mhór chultúrtha agus pholaitíochta ar fud Thuaisceart Éireann le cúpla seachtain anuas. Is é BBC Thuaisceart Éireann an príomhphointe, áit a bhfuil pleananna curtha chun cinn le suas le 60% den tsainfhoireann inmheánach laistigh dá Aonad beag Gaeilge a ghearradh. As cúig phost lánaimseartha, tuairiscítear go bhfuil trí cinn i mbaol a ndífhostaithe. Maidir leis an fhoireann inmheánach a bhí ag croílár craoltóireachta teanga dúchais leis an BBC le fada an lá, ní laghdú áitiúil amháin atá ann: chuir grúpaí teanga agus abhcóidí cultúrtha síos air mar bhuille tubaisteach don chraoltóireacht seirbhíse poiblí i nGaeilge.

Lena thuiscint cad chuige ar spreag na ciorruithe fearg chomh géar sin, caithfear breathnú ar a bhfuil de sheirbhís ann cheana féin. Murab ionann agus sa Bhreatain Bheag ná in Albain, áit a bhfuil sainseirbhísí teanga ann, amhail BBC Radio Cymru, S4C nó BBC ALBA, seibhísí a fhaigheann na milliúin punta mar mhaoiniú spriocdhírithe, ní raibh stáisiún raidió BBC tiomnaithe riamh ag Tuaisceart Éireann. Ina áit sin, braitheann cainteoirí Gaeilge ar thart ar 30 nóiméad sa lá — sin, 30 nóiméad sa lá, nó thart ar chúig uair an chloig sa tseachtain, a chraoltar ar BBC Radio Uladh agus Feabhail. Tá cláir bheo shuaitheanta, cláir a bhuaigh duaiseanna, ar nós ‘Blas’, tá sin i ngreim an dá bhruach anois.

Nuair a tháinig an scéal chun solais, d’fhreagair comhlachtaí polaitíochta agus cultúrtha go pras. Chuir eagraíochtaí amhail Conradh na Gaeilge agus Foras na Gaeilge, mar aon le hionadaithe polaitíochta ó pháirtithe éagsúla, chuir sin go mór i gcoinne na gciorruithe: ag am a bhfuil fás ollmhór faoi oideachas trí mheán na Gaeilge, faoi líon na gcainteoirí Gaeilge, faoi ranganna foghlama do dhaoine fásta agus faoi úsáid na Gaeilge sa phobal, is cosúil go bhfuil an craoltóir náisiúnta ag dul ar a chúl sa tsoláthar don Ghaeilge.Tá brúnna forleathana airgeadais ar an chorparáid, agus í ag feidhmiú faoi spriocanna coigiltis leathana ar fud na corparáide.

Mar fhreagra ar an bhfrithghníomh, mhaígh urlabhraí ón BBC go bhfuil an craoltóir go hiomlán tiomanta go fóill do na seirbhísí Gaeilge. Is é an phríomhargóint ón lucht bainisteoireachta ná go bhfanfaidh an caiteachas iomlán agus an méid aschuir foriomlán ar ardáin amhail Raidió Uladh gan athrú. Seachas seirbhísí a ghearradh go hiomlán, tá sé beartaithe ag an BBC dul i muinín samhail seachfhoinsithe — is é sin le rá céatadán i bhfad níos airde den táirgeadh a aistriú chuig an earnáil neamhspleách, rud a léirionn an chaoi a láimhsítear na hábhair theilifíse.

Mar sin féin, tá amhras mór ar abhcóidí teanga. Áitíonn siad nach féidir brath ar chomhlachtaí seachtracha léiriúcháin nach bhfuil an chuimhne institiúideach, an saineolas eagarthóireachta ná an chomhsheasmhacht laethúil acu agus atá ag foireann inmheánach. Tá an-taithí ar fad ag an fhoireann inmheánach. Deir daoine atá ina choinne sin nach bhfanfaidh ach beirt sainbhall foirne inmheánach don Ghaeilge i ndiaidh na gciorruithe i measc lucht leathan saothair de chuid BBC a bhfuil na céadta ann i dTuaisceart Éireann.

Sa deireadh thiar, níl sa díospóid seo ach cleachtadh simplí i gclár comhardaithe. Tá dualgais reachtúla faoi Chomhaontú Aoine an Chéasta, ar BBC agus ar Rialtas na Ríochta Aontaithe araon gníomh diongbháilte a dhéanamh leis an Ghaeilge a chosaint agus a chur chun cinn, agus aitheantas ceart a thabhairt don Ghaeilge. Táthar ag iarraidh idirghabhálacha díreacha ó Airí oidhreachta agus meán, chomh maith le comhionannas struchtúrach le craoltóireacht teangacha eile Ceilteacha i gcodanna áirithe den Ríocht Aontaithe. De réir mar a théann an t-aistriú ar aghaidh, fanann an cheist lárnach seo: an féidir le samhail dhigitithe, sheachfhoinsithe freastal i ndáiríre ar riachtanais pobal teanga —

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: Sin é, a Patsy. Tá an t-am istigh.

Mr McGlone: — atá ag fás?

[Translation: Administrative restructuring has become a major cultural and political controversy across Northern Ireland over the past few weeks. At the heart of the issue is BBC Northern Ireland, where plans have been put forward to cut up to 60% of the dedicated internal staff within its small Irish language unit. It is reported that three out of the five full-time positions are at risk of redundancy. For the internal team that has long been central to the BBC’s native-language broadcasting, that is not merely a localised reduction: language groups and cultural advocates have described it as a devastating blow to public service broadcasting in Irish.

To understand why the cuts have provoked such intense anger, one must look at the existing level of service. Unlike in Wales or Scotland, where dedicated language services such as BBC Radio Cymru, S4C or BBC ALBA exist, receiving millions of pounds in targeted funding, Northern Ireland has never had a dedicated BBC radio station. Instead, Irish speakers rely on approximately 30 minutes a day — that is, 30 minutes daily or about five hours a week broadcast on BBC Radio Ulster and BBC Radio Foyle. Flagship, award-winning live programmes, such as ‘Blas’, are now under threat.

When the news emerged, political and cultural bodies responded promptly. Organisations such as Conradh na Gaeilge and Foras na Gaeilge, along with political representatives from various parties, strongly opposed the cuts. At a time when there is significant growth in Irish-medium education, the number of Irish speakers, adult learning classes and the use of Irish within the community, it appears that the national broadcaster is regressing in its commitment to the Irish language. The corporation is facing widespread financial pressure, operating under broad cost-saving targets across the entire organisation.

In response to the backlash, a BBC spokesperson maintained that the broadcaster remains fully committed to its Irish language services. The main argument from management is that total expenditure and the overall volume of output on platforms such as Radio Ulster will remain unchanged. Rather than cutting services entirely, the BBC intends to adopt an outsourcing model, shifting a much larger percentage of production to the independent sector, mirroring the approach taken with television content.

However, language advocates are highly sceptical. They argue that one cannot rely on external production companies, which lack the institutional memory, editorial expertise and day-to-day consistency of an in-house team — the in-house team possesses a wealth of experience. Critics point out that, following the cuts, only two specialised in-house staff members dedicated to the Irish language will remain, within a broader BBC workforce in Northern Ireland numbering in the hundreds.

Ultimately, this dispute is merely a exercise in balancing the books. Under the Good Friday Agreement, both the BBC and the United Kingdom Government have statutory obligations to take decisive action to protect and promote the Irish language and to accord it proper recognition. Direct interventions are being sought from heritage and media Ministers, as well as structural parity with Celtic language broadcasting in certain parts of the United Kingdom. As the transition progresses, this central question remains: can a digitised, outsourced model truly meet the needs of a language community —

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: That is it, Patsy. Your time is up.

Mr McGlone: — that is growing?]

Mr Gaston: I will be abundantly clear from the start of my remarks that the BBC should be defunded for its continued bias, which, at times, it does not even try to hide. In the spirit of the motion before us, however, I will focus my brief remarks on the part of it that acknowledges:

"the profound role BBC NI has in relation to news and current affairs coverage".

That is undoubtedly the case. The BBC, by virtue of its unique right to rob everyone who watches live TV through the licence fee, has vast public finances to bolster its resources, which dwarf those of other outlets. Much to the displeasure and annoyance of Andrew Muir and the Alliance Party, however, GB News outperforms BBC News when it comes to average audience figures, and it does so quite comfortably.

The licence fee allows the BBC to show free-to-view content on its website, thus giving it an unfair advantage over outlets that rely on subscriptions from people who want to read their content. The BBC, at our expense, has an unmatched power to shape stories. Let me give the House an example that, for some reason, Mr O'Toole missed. In the summer of 2025, BBC coverage linked the cancellation of a children's GAA and cricket camp to a statement that Goldsprings of Comber Orange lodge made. Its statement made no mention of children, but it did raise legitimate concerns about the politics and culture of the GAA. North Down Cricket Club had decided to cancel the summer camp before the Comber lodge's statement had been issued, so its decision was independent of it, yet UTV and subsequently the 'Belfast Telegraph' repeated the BBC falsehood that there was a link between the two.

To their credit, UTV and the 'Belfast Telegraph' apologised, albeit, in the case of the 'Belfast Telegraph', only after the Independent Press Standards Organisation got involved. The BBC, on whose false reporting the UTV and 'Belfast Telegraph' stories were based, apologised only after nine months of dithering and delay, and it has never acknowledged on air the errors that it made. If the BBC expects us to defend it as an institution, it has to be prepared to own up when it gets things wrong.


1.15 pm

The TUV should not have a live complaint with the BBC about Adrian Dunbar being given a platform to peddle a blatant falsehood. He said that he remembered the tensions around the Drumcree parade in the 1970s, when the dispute only arose during the 1990s. That complaint is still live almost two months after it was lodged.

Errors will be made: everyone knows that. However, it is noticeable that, when it comes to the BBC, the errors are always to the detriment of unionism and loyalism. When an error reaches an audience, the correction should almost always reach the same audience. It is not good enough, as happened in the live example that I gave you regarding Comber, to lead with a falsehood for two full days and then correct it by sticking a notice on the corrections and clarifications section of the BBC website nine months after the error took place.

The BBC has cut its coverage of the Twelfth, but, at the same time, it is ramping up its coverage of GAA matches. Indeed, its 30 minutes a day of spoken Irish shows you the narrative and bias of BBC NI.

Mr Carroll: I declare an interest as a listener to the BBC — quite often to Radio 6 and Radio Ulster, depending on the day. I have been on picket lines with NUJ staff and with Broadcasting, Entertainment, Cinematography and Theatre Union (BECTU) staff over the years.

Let me say to the Member for North Antrim that bias works the other way. Despite the editorial positions that the BBC has taken over the years — regarding the war on Ukraine, for example, and its disastrous reporting in attempting to pretend that the violence in Palestine started on 7 October 2023 — and real criticisms of and problems with its shaping of narratives on global conflicts, the public broadcasting that the BBC engages in is worth defending. However, the BBC cannot continue to do what it has always done, because it is not working.

The first issue that has to be raised is the licence fee. The BBC licence fee is a totally unfair and unsustainable way to fund public broadcasting. Millionaires pay the same as people on a medium wage. That is completely unfair and unjust and needs to be rectified. I have said several times on the BBC that the licence fee should be linked to income: the wealthier should pay more; people on low wages should pay very little or nothing at all. It is totally unfair. Pensioners who are not on pension credit, which is a lot of pensioners, are forced to pay the licence fee. Again, that is totally unfair and unsustainable.

In years gone by, the BBC had labour correspondents. Why does it no longer have them, given the growth of trade unionism and the on-off strikes of the past few years? The BBC rightly has health correspondents and sports correspondents, so why not labour correspondents?

I thank the Members for tabling the motion. Disgracefully, the decimation of the Irish language section of the BBC, which was announced recently, is happening at a time of a growth in the Irish language in the North that has not been seen in decades, if ever.

Members would do well to read a recent report, cited in today's 'Irish News', which shows that one in four Protestant teenagers — or teenagers from a Protestant background who may not still be religious — wants to learn Irish. That shows that it is moving beyond certain places. Some Members in the House may be terrified of that, but it is a positive thing. It shows that the language is actually breaking through. At this time, and in that context, while the BBC is taking a hammer to services, the calibre of programmes and its Irish language section, it has said that it plans to increase Irish language content — specifically to increase radio hours — but Cá bhfuil an plean?

[Translation: Where is the plan?]

As yet, there is no plan and no current open calls for commissions from the independent sector. I could go on.

Before those cuts were implemented, the BBC's Gaeilge team provided four live-speech shows per week on a range of topics, including literature, art and current affairs, two music shows a week and a podcast. Will the BBC's new plan protect live output, and will it be made to the same standard? The Member is shaking her head. I totally agree: I do not think that the BBC will go down that path. I will not hold my breath waiting to see that.

There is a concerning general trend in the media whereby the majority of programming and staff are being pushed to independent companies. Obviously, those companies have an important role in the sector. I am worried, however, about the over-reliance on and use of independent companies at the expense of public broadcasting, especially when it leads to job losses, as we are talking about here. In that sector, workers are paid less on average. They have fewer maternity rights, if any, little or no pensions and fewer rights generally. I am concerned about that trend. It has not been factored into the equation enough. If there is no one employed in the BBC who knows how to make Irish-medium programmes, who will be there to keep the BBC in check on its decisions when they impact on the Irish-speaking community more generally?

My final point is on geoblocking. It is disgraceful and despicable that people in the North still cannot access programmes that exist as Gaeilge

[Translation: in Irish]

when they are raising their families through Irish, as I and many others are doing. People in the BBC need to put their heads together with people in RTÉ and others to sort that out.

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: I call Matthew O'Toole to conclude the debate and make the winding-up speech on the motion. Matthew, you have 10 minutes.

Mr O'Toole: Thank you, Madam Principal Deputy Speaker. I thank everybody who participated in the debate and for the spirit in which they did so. It is clear that people engage with and, perhaps, care about different aspects of BBC content. People will have different views about BBC coverage of different things, as they will about different media. I share some of the concerns that people have expressed about BBC coverage on Gaza. I understand that, perhaps, Timothy Gaston would have a different perspective on the BBC and BBC news coverage of certain things. As serious as those concerns are, it is the case that public-service media still matters. It still has to serve a diverse range of audiences. That is particularly the case in a society and community as complex as this one.

I care about the BBC. Just to be clear: as I said earlier, this is not about the fact that the BBC's title has the word "British" in it. I would say the same about Raidió Teilifís Éireann and ensuring that it is accountable. As I said earlier, in a new dispensation on this island, I would still like the BBC, in whatever form it may be in then, to be able to offer a service and be part of the lives of people on this part of the island and, indeed, other parts of the island, should they want that. Therefore, it is not about that. Nor is it about the idea that, as politicians, we should not be held to account. I welcome that. Indeed, in conjunction with Mr Nesbitt, we had, for a while, an all-party group on press freedom and media sustainability. I care about people holding us to account, including people who work for the BBC and, for that matter, UTV news. In a sense, I wish only that there were more of them there, and at local newspapers, to hold us all, and our counterparts in local council chambers, Westminster and Dáil Éireann, robustly to account.

The debate has touched on the huge importance of the BBC in a range of areas. I just want to reflect on some of those comments, because it has been a good debate. I want people who are paying attention to it in the BBC locally and in London to hear the diversity of views in this place and to hear about the frustration with the way in which some of those cuts have been handled and announced, the lack of clarity and public accountability and the desire for more clarity and public accountability.

The Chair of the Communities Community, Colm Gildernew, talked about the deep frustration in the Irish language community, as, of course, did my colleague Patsy McGlone, as Gaeilge,

[Translation: in Irish]

, about the extraordinary situation of more than half of your in-house Irish language staff effectively being made redundant and being told that you simply have to accept an assurance that the service will not be disrupted: that is implausible. It is also the case that it is our job to hold those people to account. If that is the BBC's line, it needs to explain to us how that will work. It needs to explain to us how it will ensure that there is the capacity in the independent production sector to ensure continuity of service or, at least, continuity of volume of service. As was said, including by Patsy, the volume of service is not great shakes at the minute. It pales in comparison not just with what is offered by, for example, Raidió na Gaeltachta but what is offered in Scotland and Wales in respect of their native languages.

Some other points were touched on, including the reduction of service in Foyle and the slow unwinding of BBC expertise, including in factual programming. We are now in a situation that did not come up in the debate too much: effectively, the entire BBC factual programming unit will be closed down, which means that no factual programming will be made in-house in Belfast, as far as I understand it. It will all be commissioned externally. I think that that will be unique. As far as I am aware, that is not happening in Scotland or Wales. That is a profound reduction. We have not had a serious public explanation for that.

People talk about local content that matters to them, and there are a huge number of things that we all care about in relation to BBC Northern Ireland content — not just news content but local content — that has emerged over the years. We cannot simply be asked to accept the production of 'Blue Lights', which is a wonderful and terrific show, or, indeed, the odd podcast, brilliant as it is — there is brilliant journalism happening throughout the BBC — and be told that we cannot ask questions about a broad-based slashing of services. We need to understand it, and we need to be told the rationale for that.

Sian Mulholland also talked about the importance of the BBC as an incubator and a platform for music services. She talked about 'Across the Line' and about 'BBC Introducing'. It is hugely important for local musicians at a time when our arts scene is so critically underfunded. That is creating a challenge for local creatives. Diminution of services is really worrying. It is not that we think that the world is not changing. Obviously, back in the late 1990s, when I listened to 'Across the Line' in my parents' garage, there was no Spotify. There were not even iPods then. There were not all those things. Of course the world is changing and technology is changing, but the BBC is a public service broadcaster. It is a critical public service, and we pay for it. If services have to change and transform locally, the BBC owes this place an explanation for how and why it is changing and what it expects to be able to deliver afterwards, including how local and distinctive the service is and how that will enable it to deliver on its mission.

Of course, Mike Nesbitt is probably the most professionally experienced person in the Chamber. I hope that he will not take that as a euphemism for age, but he is the most professionally experienced in the area. Having worked at both the BBC and UTV, he gave us the benefit of that experience and what it could mean. There is a challenge at UTV as well: in the past week, we found out that UTV is effectively shutting down its factual programme-making. There is a potential crisis emerging in our traditional broadcasters here, who have public service remits. That goes for UTV as well as the BBC.

Obviously, Mr Gaston talked in his own distinctive way about his criticisms and critique of the BBC. He is entitled to make them; he is entitled to be robust. That is the purpose of having a debate, even if I disagree in large part with what he says.

Gerry Carroll talked about members of unions — NUJ and Bectu — potentially being out on picket lines. I want those union members to be given a clear explanation, because, at the minute, they are not being given one. They are worried about further cuts. They are worried about further redundancies — potentially, compulsory redundancies — but they have no explanation yet either way. Would you like to come back in briefly?

Mr Carroll: I thank the Member. I was talking about previous strikes, but I would support them if they came out again. Does the Member share my concerns about people working in the independent and private-sector organisations in media? If you talk to anybody, they are under more stress, and the BBC, while maybe not a gold standard employer, tends to be much better than those private and independent media organisations.

Mr O'Toole: There are brilliant producers who do amazing work. They are world-leading, and many of them are terrific employers too. I do not want to cast aspersions, but Mr Carroll is right: the BBC is clearly an employer that offers pension rights and stability for its workers. You would worry about that being diminished over time and people not getting the same rights.


1.30 pm

I want to come back to the point about accountability. The BBC and public service broadcasting matter enormously, and they matter in a place such as this, which is a contested space in which we need to find spaces where we can come together, whether that is through music or culture. We need to find ways to mediate our differences and have robust accountability for all of us in the Chamber, while also discussing the difficult things that we have to deal with in the here and now and where we are going in the future. That will be challenging at times too.

Mr McGlone: Will the Member give way?

Mr O'Toole: I will give way very briefly, yes.

Mr McGlone: I emphasise the point that the Member, Mr Carroll and others have made: if you cut back on proper, balanced, fair and impartial news, you leave a void that will be filled by the truly fake news on social media.

Mr O'Toole: My colleague is exactly correct, and that is the point. We need strong public service media staffed by trained journalists, broadcasters, programme makers and production workers who are bound by a published mission that is clear to the public and serves this diverse community.

The truth is that BBC Northern Ireland needs to explain how its cuts are equal. It also needs to provide an explanation in response to the real public concern that the cuts are happening in the context of other things that have happened on its platform over the past number of years — things that have prioritised and platformed extremely divisive content and hard-line voices, particularly on a certain morning radio programme. We have had cuts to Irish programming, cuts to factual programming, cuts to Radio Foyle and cuts to local comedy, yet the same divisive voices and hard-line actors, backed by big salaries, are given a big platform day after day and are ring-fenced, protected and promoted.

A review of the charter is coming next year. We need to be clear about protecting what is right in public service broadcasting, and I am glad that we have had this useful debate. Thank you very much. Cheers.

Question put and agreed to.

Resolved:

That this Assembly recognises the huge importance of BBC Northern Ireland (BBC NI) as a source of news, information and shared local experience; expresses concern at sudden cuts to much loved and vital services, including Irish language services as well as long-standing locally produced series, in the absence of a clear and publicly explained strategy being communicated; acknowledges the profound role BBC NI has in relation to news and current affairs coverage; and calls on BBC NI, as a public service broadcaster, to provide a clearer explanation on the allocation and prioritisation of resources amid current public concern on editorial accountability.

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: Members, please take your ease until we move on to the next item of business. Thank you.

(Mr Deputy Speaker [Mr Blair] in the Chair)

Ms McLaughlin: I beg to move

That this Assembly recognises the enormous potential of all-island tourism to drive economic growth, create jobs and revitalise local communities; welcomes the extension of Ireland's Hidden Heartlands into Fermanagh as a positive example of North/South cooperation; expresses concern that Northern Ireland continues to miss out on opportunities to maximise its share of Ireland's international tourism success; supports greater ambition in linking the Wild Atlantic Way with the Causeway coastal route, positioning the Derry City and Strabane District Council area as a gateway to the north-west and extending Ireland's Ancient East into counties Armagh and Down; further recognises the UK Government's electronic travel authorisation (ETA) scheme as an unnecessary barrier to seamless cross-border tourism; calls on the UK Government to scrap the ETA requirement for visitors travelling to Northern Ireland from the Republic of Ireland; and further calls on the Minister for the Economy to work with the Irish Government to deliver a jointly funded all-island tourism growth plan with clear commitments on investment, connectivity and job creation.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): The Business Committee has agreed to allow up to one hour and 30 minutes for the debate. The proposer of the motion will have 10 minutes to propose and 10 minutes to make a winding-up speech. As an amendment has been selected and is published on the Marshalled List, the Business Committee has agreed that 15 minutes will be added to the total time for the debate. Before we proceed, I point out that junior Minister Reilly will respond to the debate.

Ms McLaughlin: I am pleased to move the motion on behalf of the SDLP. Tourism represents one of the greatest economic opportunities available to this island. We have extraordinary natural beauty, a rich cultural heritage, historic cities and towns and communities that offer so much to visitors from across the world. However, tourism is about much more than attracting visitors; it is about creating jobs, supporting local businesses, sustaining rural communities and bringing investment to places that have too often been overlooked. We are failing to realise the full potential of what tourism can deliver, particularly when it comes to greater cooperation across the island, and that is what the motion seeks to address. It is about recognising opportunities that exist, challenging the barriers that hold us back and calling for a more ambitious approach to developing tourism on an all-island basis.

Tourism Ireland is one of the clearest examples of what North/South cooperation can achieve. It recognises that this island is best promoted internationally as a single destination, and we have seen the enormous success of initiatives such as the Wild Atlantic Way, Ireland's Ancient East and Ireland's Hidden Heartlands. Those have become internationally recognised tourism brands. They encourage visitors to explore new destinations, and they bring economic opportunities to communities across the island. However, there is clear inconsistency in our approach. We promote Ireland internationally as a single destination, yet, when it comes to extending successful tourism initiatives across the border, that ambition is often missing. I welcome the extension of Ireland's Hidden Heartlands to Fermanagh. That is a really positive example of practical North/South cooperation. However, why have proposals to extend Ireland's Ancient East to Armagh and Down not been taken forward? Those are areas with extraordinary historical, cultural and natural attractions, yet we are failing to capitalise on their potential. We already have successful tourism brands and established organisations that are responsible for promoting the island internationally. We need greater cooperation and a willingness to deliver.

I will also address the role of Fáilte Ireland. I was really disappointed by its decision not to attend the Economy Committee to discuss the issues. Tourism Ireland and Tourism NI engaged with the Committee, and it is entirely reasonable to expect similar engagement from Fáilte Ireland. I recognise that it operates in a different jurisdiction and has its own responsibilities, but we are talking about matters of clear mutual economic interest with the potential to benefit businesses and communities on both sides of our border. If we are serious about strengthening all-island tourism, there must be a willingness to engage in those discussions. I encourage Fáilte Ireland to reconsider its approach and engage constructively with the Committee, because there are legitimate questions about why some opportunities have progressed while others have not, and those questions deserve answers.

Nowhere is the potential of greater cooperation more obvious than in the north-west. Derry occupies a unique position between the Wild Atlantic Way and the Causeway coastal route. To our west, we have Donegal and one of the most beautiful tourism initiatives on the island. To our east, we have the Causeway coast, which has attractions that are recognised across the world. Between them sits Derry, a city of extraordinary history and vibrant cultural offering, with enormous potential to further tourism growth. There is a compelling case for strengthening the connection between those two internationally recognised destinations, with Derry at the centre of the offering. Doing so would encourage visitors to stay longer, travel further and spend more across the region. It would benefit hotels, restaurants, independent retailers and tourism operators on both sides of the border.

We cannot expect such opportunities to develop by themselves. We need investment, coordination and a genuine commitment to developing the north-west's tourism potential. That includes our transport infrastructure. I welcome the planned commencement by March 2027 of the Derry-Dublin air route, which has the potential to improve significantly the north-west's connectivity as an international aviation hub. It is a positive development, but it must be part of a wider commitment to improving connectivity across the region. We also need better rail and road connections to ensure that visitors can travel easily between destinations on both sides of the border. Tourism, transport and economic development are fundamentally connected and cannot be treated as separate issues. If we are serious about unlocking the north-west's tourism potential, we need an approach that recognises all those structures.

Tourism is also a regional balance issue. I have spent considerable time progressing the Regional Balance Bill, which, I hope, will come back to the House after it has gone through Committee scrutiny. Economic opportunities should not be determined by where someone happens to live. Tourism is a clear example of why that matters. For too long, economic investment has been concentrated in particular parts of Northern Ireland while others have been left behind. Tourism offers an opportunity to address those inequalities by creating employment, supporting independent businesses and bringing economic activity into communities that have too often been overlooked.

Success cannot simply be measured by visitor numbers. We must look at where visitors spend their money, which communities benefit and whether tourism is creating good, secure and properly paid employment. Growing the tourism industry means little to workers who are struggling on low wages or to communities that see little benefit from visitors arriving on their doorsteps. Tourism must deliver for local people, and regional balance must be central to how we develop the sector.

Another major obstacle to unlocking tourism's potential is the electronic travel authorisation scheme. The SDLP has consistently opposed the unnecessary barriers that the ETA creates for cross-border tourism. We know that a significant proportion of international visitors to Northern Ireland arrive from across the land border, yet we now have a system that creates additional administrative requirements for many who are travelling north. We promote Ireland internationally as a single destination, yet the British Government impose barriers that undermine that very proposition. It makes absolutely no sense. It is border communities, particularly those in places such as Derry and Fermanagh, that risk being disproportionately affected. That is why the motion calls on the British Government:

"to scrap the ETA requirement for visitors travelling to Northern Ireland from the Republic".

The Economy Minister must continue to press the British Government to deliver that change. We should be making it easier for visitors to explore the island, not harder.

What is needed now is a very serious commitment to delivery. That is why the motion calls for:

"a jointly funded all-island tourism growth plan",

agreed between the Executive and the Irish Government: a plan with clear commitments on investment, connectivity, regional development and job creation. It should establish a pathway for extending successful tourism initiatives across the border, recognise the Derry City and Strabane District Council area as a gateway to the north-west and address the infrastructure barriers that hold back tourism growth.

Crucially, it must have measurable objectives and clear accountability. We have had enough of strategies that identify our opportunities without any way of actually delivering them.


1.45 pm

We know that the potential exists; what has been missing is the ambition and political will to realise it. We have an extraordinary tourism offer on this island, but we are not making the most of the opportunities. Too often, it is the communities with the greatest potential that are left waiting for investment, and that must change. The motion is about ensuring that tourism delivers for every part of this island. The success of tourism should not be measured simply by how many people come to visit; it should be measured by the opportunities that we create for the people who call this place home. That is the ambition of the motion, and I encourage Members from across the Chamber to support it.

Mr Nesbitt: I beg to move the following amendment:

Leave out all after "; and further calls on" and insert

"the UK Government to urgently address the disparity in VAT rates on hospitality between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, which places hospitality and tourism businesses, particularly those in border counties, at a significant competitive disadvantage.".

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): You will have 10 minutes to move and five minutes to make a winding-up speech. All other contributors will have five minutes.

Mr Nesbitt: Deputy Speaker, thank you very much. I thank the Opposition for bringing the debate. I am a member of the Economy Committee, not for the first time, and I will touch on that in a moment. Before taking up membership of the Committee this time, I had a spell as Minister of Health, in which, as I hope Members will be aware, one of my first public statements was to say that I had no ideological or party political objection to cross-border cooperation. I very much enjoyed working with Minister Stephen Donnelly and then Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill on the North/South Ministerial Council in sectoral format. The potential is there, and the motion calls for our Minister for the Economy to work with her counterpart in the Government of Ireland for mutual benefit on tourism.

In health, the last thing that the border defines is difference. I suggest that the same may well be true for tourism, with one very important exception: value added tax. There are differential VAT rates between here and the Republic, which gives the Republic a very solid and demonstrable advantage when it comes to attracting tourism. The sector of tourism that is one of the hardest hit, if not the hardest hit, is wedding venues, which generate an awful lot of money. I understand that, for a wedding or wedding breakfast for 100 guests, the average cost in the UK is at least £20,000. That is because of items that are subject to VAT such as venue hire, food and drink, photography and entertainment. Twenty per cent VAT on £20,000 is another £4,000. In the Republic, with a 9% rate, it is only £1,800. Therefore, going across the border for your wedding will save you £2,200. I have been briefed by Hospitality Ulster and by hoteliers in this jurisdiction who say that that is real and that it is hitting them and hurting them. They say that bookings in Northern Ireland are down, and we are calling on the UK Government to acknowledge and address what is happening.

As I said, I was previously on the Economy Committee. In fact, I joined it when I was first elected in 2011. I remember the Committee getting a briefing from the Northern Ireland Tourist Board, as it was called in those days before it became Tourism NI around, I think, 2015. The briefing included a word cloud of all the activities that attract tourists to Northern Ireland, including walking, cycling, angling, historical venues, the countryside and culture. One activity that was missing, which surprised me, was golf — golf was absent. Anybody who understands anything about golf tourists knows that they are on a mission to spend money. They spend an awful lot of money. Of course, we have caught on now: we have had the Open, and we are working hard to increase our take there.

However, we have a big challenge coming up with golf tourism in the immediate future. This year, the Irish Open was held at Trump International in Doonbeg, County Clare. It was very popular, particularly with American golfers who may be attracted to come to play Trump International. After that, further up the coast, the Walker Cup, which is the amateur equivalent of the Ryder Cup, was held at Lahinch. A lot of Americans will have watched Great Britain and Ireland, unusually, beating America and will want to come and play that course. Next year, of course, the Ryder Cup will be played at Adare Manor. Those three events, particularly the Ryder Cup, will give the Republic a huge advantage, and the differential in VAT rates will play into those calculations.

There is a precedent for giving concessionary VAT rates. Around 15 years ago, I looked at the 5% VAT rate that was applied in the Isle of Man for repair, maintenance and improvement (RMI) of properties, which was a huge success. People who wanted to move home but could not afford to do so decided that they would, perhaps, put in an attic conversion or an extension to their property because they were getting a 5% VAT rate. That also increased the levels of apprenticeships and skills in the building industry. Today, I understand that the Isle of Man has a 5% rate on holiday and hotel accommodation, which is very attractive. Remember, when you have a 20% VAT rate, it is very easy to calculate the additional cost.

The proposer of the motion talked about the electronic travel authorisation. I have been briefed by representatives of the hospitality and tourism sector who are deeply concerned about the negative impact that that will have on tourism. So many people who visit Northern Ireland do so having flown into the Republic of Ireland at Shannon Airport or Dublin Airport. The fear is that tour and coach operators will say that it is too much hassle and they cannot be bothered saying to people who want to book a tour that they will have to apply for an ETA and pay for it before they arrive on this island. Again, we call on the Minister for the Economy to act in that regard. She and her predecessor both tried extremely hard to get the Government in London to acknowledge and address the problem, and I hope that the junior Minister will update us on efforts in that direction. I am happy to support the motion but also to put a focus on the differential VAT rate and the potentially devastating impact that that will have on our tourism potential.

Mr Delargy: I support the motion because tourism presents a real opportunity to grow our economy, support local businesses and create jobs across Ireland. We need to start by properly recognising what visitors around the world recognise, which is that Ireland is one entity. Visitors want to experience the whole island, and we should be making that easier for them, not more difficult. Tourism was identified as a key area for North-South cooperation in the Good Friday Agreement, yet we still have practical barriers that need to be addressed. One of those barriers, as has been mentioned by the previous two contributors, is around VAT. Our hospitality businesses are competing with neighbouring businesses in the South but under very different circumstances. Our MP and ministerial teams have been making that argument loud and clear, and we need to make the case for an all-Ireland approach to VAT across the island.

I am glad that the UUP's amendment acknowledges the need for all-Ireland working. I was, however, disappointed that the amendment takes out the strongest element of all-Ireland working. We need to ensure that we give businesses a fair chance to compete and encourage more people to visit, stay and spend. I also recognise the work of our Economy Minister, Caoimhe Archibald. The Ireland's Hidden Heartlands programme has been extended into Fermanagh, with £2·7 million invested to support 13 projects through the Shared Island coast-to-coast initiative. There is now real potential to expand Ireland's Ancient East into Armagh and Down and to make sure that east Antrim is included.

In Derry, we see what that investment can achieve. Derry's Halloween celebrations, which are supported by Tourism NI's events funding, attract huge numbers of visitors and bring millions into our local economy. It is now an internationally renowned festival, which is recognised across the world and brings visitors from America.

I challenge the use of the word "ambition" in the motion. It is important that we recognise the metamorphic changes that have happened in tourism over recent years and the hard-working staff who make that happen. That is what can be achieved when we work together on a multi-agency and multi-departmental basis, but particularly on an all-Ireland basis. The vision and ambition that I have seen from Tourism Ireland, Tourism NI, Visit Derry, the Department and councils has been extraordinary, and I know that that will continue to go from strength to strength in the years ahead. The imperative is on us to listen to the tourism experts and to those hospitality businesses on the ground, because all strategies must be co-designed to ensure that we have policies that deliver but are also deliverable.

We also need to continue challenging the British Government on the ETA scheme, which continues to create unnecessary barriers for visitors arriving in the South who want to travel North. That is the reality of Brexit and of the shortsighted nature of those in the Chamber who voted for Brexit. We all know the stats on how many visitors travel from the South to the North. We need to ensure that those barriers are removed and that the North is as accessible as possible. We should not be competing with the South for the same visitors. We should be working together on an all-Ireland basis to attract more people to make sure that that benefit and the benefit of the tourism sector reaches all our communities.

I commend the Minister for the progress that has been made. I recognise the important work of the tourism agencies, and I support the motion.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): Question Time begins at 2.00 pm, so I suggest that the Assembly takes its ease until then. The debate will continue after Question Time, when the next Member to speak will be Diane Forsythe.

The debate stood suspended.


2.00 pm

Oral Answers to Questions

Economy

(Mr Speaker in the Chair)

Dr Archibald (The Minister for the Economy): The innovation devolution funding announced by the Prime Minister is a welcome recognition of the need for increased levels of innovation funding from the British Government and the fact that places should have greater influence over how innovation funding is utilised locally. Historically, we have been underfunded in innovation funding relative to our population size. It is therefore essential that we receive a fair share of future investment.

Details on the funding, including the quantum of funding available, timelines and how it will be issued remain unclear. I have written to the Minister of State for Science, Innovation and Investment seeking early and meaningful engagement on the funding. While it is disappointing that formal discussions here have not yet commenced more than a month after the announcement, my officials continue to press for clarity.

We have demonstrated our ability to design and deliver ambitious, place-based innovation investment through the £30 million local innovation partnerships fund allocation. The devolution of further funding would allow us to build on that experience and ensure that the North benefits fully from the next phase of innovation investment.

Mr McReynolds: I thank the Minister for her response. Minister, given the mayoral structures in place in England, what will the devolution of innovation funding look like here? Mayors here operate differently from those in England.

Dr Archibald: That is one of the issues that we want to explore more fully. As part of the local innovation partnerships fund, we set up a structure that includes representatives of industry, academia and government. That has been highly successful in developing projects to the point of submission and then engaging with the funding bodies to achieve funding. Three projects have been funded that are particularly innovative and forward-thinking, and we want to build on examples such as those. It is important that we get the structures right, however, and we need engagement as soon as possible on how this will roll out, so I will continue to push for clarity.

Mr Kearney: Minister, entrepreneurship is key to innovation. What are you and your Department doing to ensure that our local entrepreneurs continue to be supported to make an even greater strategic contribution to the regional economy?

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for his question. Entrepreneurs are central to my economic vision because they create jobs, bring new ideas to market and strengthen our local economies. That is why, just this morning, I launched a new SME entrepreneurship action plan designed to help entrepreneurs to start, sustain and grow innovative businesses across the North. My plan contains nine actions across four key areas: improving the business support landscape; building a stronger pro-entrepreneurship culture; strengthening local entrepreneurial ecosystems; and improving coordination across government and the wider ecosystem. Importantly, it is about addressing the practical barriers that entrepreneurs face. We will explore a single, user-centred entry point so that entrepreneurs can more easily navigate the support available to them.

I am pleased to say that there is real momentum to build on. Total early-stage entrepreneurial activity here reached a record 11·9% in 2025. There is clearly more to do, however, and the action plan will help to support that.

Mrs Erskine: The cost of doing business is an issue that the Prime Minister has previously raised. When we look at our small local businesses, we see that high costs are prevalent. A business in my area, Oakwood Childcare Centre, is due to close its doors in December. Minister, given the cost of doing business, what intervention are you looking at putting in place for childcare, particularly in rural areas? Not having childcare facilities will have a knock-on impact on our local economy, so please do something for Oakwood Childcare Centre in Derrylin.

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for that question. I completely agree with her about how important childcare is to the local economy and to helping families ensure that both parents can continue in work. It is obviously really important from a child's perspective as well. I, too, have had representations from childcare businesses in my constituency that are really feeling the pressure because inflation has impacted, in essence, on everything across their cost base.

We have seen some important investment in childcare across the Executive, including through the childcare subsidy scheme. My Department undertook research into the advice and guidance that would be needed to help childcare businesses, and, out of that, we are developing a childcare business support system. That is in progress. It is about getting it right to support those businesses to understand exactly what type of support and guidance they need that is specific to their sector and all the types of childcare facilities across it. That work is in progress, and I hope to see it rolled out in the near future.

Mr Speaker: Mr McCrossan is not in his place.

Dr Archibald: The Irish language not only is an important part of our cultural heritage but has significant potential to act as an economic driver. It can support skills development and employment opportunities and contribute to our growing tourism and creative sectors. I want those who speak and celebrate Irish to see themselves reflected in our economic ambitions.

Following my intervention, Queen's University's NI Place-Name Project has been enabled to continue. NI Screen works closely with the Irish Language Broadcast Fund to support the production of high-quality Irish language content. Tourism NI provides support and funding for annual events that celebrate the Irish language and culture, including Féile an Phobail, TradFest and, of course, the fleadh. Earlier this year, I launched a consultation on a new draft Irish language policy for my Department, the responses to which are now being considered. Critically, my Department is also working with Gaelchursai and other Irish language providers to understand the challenges and opportunities in vocational pathways for Irish-medium learners.

Ms Ennis: Go raibh maith agat,

[Translation: Thank you]

Minister. It is really great to hear you list all the positive work and actions that your Department is undertaking on the Irish language.

Will the Minister outline what, if any, further actions her Department has planned to promote and support the Irish language?

Dr Archibald: A programme of work is coming online across my Department to ensure that the Irish language is embedded in the economy. Shortly, I will launch plans to work proactively with Irish language providers to expand vocational support for Irish-medium learners. I have also commissioned a range of research reports to inform departmental policy decisions on the economic potential of the Irish language. Earlier this year, I launched a consultation on a new draft Irish language policy for the Department that provides a draft framework focused on removing barriers and creating greater opportunities to learn, use and celebrate the Irish language in support of economic prosperity. Some 310 responses have been received to that consultation and are being considered. I and departmental officials continue to work closely with the Irish Language Commissioner, Pól Deeds, on our contribution to the Executive's Irish language strategy, which I hope to see progress as soon as possible.

Mr Speaker: Question 4 has been withdrawn.

Dr Archibald: I recognise the importance of having an adequate supply of development land to support local business growth, attract inward investment and create jobs. Through its regional property programme, Invest NI is taking a strategic approach to addressing identified market failure and gaps in the wider supply of industrial land across the North, including in the wider Lisburn area.

As part of that work, Invest NI engages with councils and other stakeholders to identify future requirements, explore opportunities for development and help ensure the availability of suitable land to support investment, productivity and economic growth. That engagement helps to inform strategic property priorities and ensures that investment opportunities can be accommodated as demand emerges.

It is important to understand that Invest NI cannot provide information on any new areas where it plans to acquire land, as that could impact negatively on its ability to carry out value-for-money transactions.

Mr Honeyford: I feel sorry for the Minister having to answer without having a glass of water.

The Blaris lands in Lisburn are essential for the area. They are right on the A1/M1 corridor. I will be meeting Invest NI in the next couple of weeks to look at the issue. Minister, what actions will the Department take to ensure that the capital funds are in place and that all the rest is done in the background to make sure that we see such land creating opportunities for people in the area?

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for his question. Unfortunately, capital funding is something that is hard to come by, given the current Budget outlook. How we can support Invest NI to acquire land is a continual challenge for us. We support the local economic partnerships (LEPs) in all 11 councils. Lisburn and Castlereagh City Council is looking at industrial land as part of its LEP action plan. We will continue to support LEPs while also looking at other innovative ways in which to identify capital funding to ensure that Invest NI is able to do its important work.

Invest NI is working with different agencies to identify where development can proceed unconstrained by grid or waste water connection issues. We are therefore trying to get an overview of all the constraints that we face and, at the same time, make progress by identifying where there are ideal locations for development to happen.

Ms Murphy: Minister, you referred to some of the steps that Invest NI is trying to take. Given that businesses cannot expand and that new investors cannot locate suitable land, what concrete steps can Invest NI take?

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for her question. As I said, Invest NI is still making progress on identifying additional industrial land for development and, where possible, acquiring it through its regional property programme. There are some projects that are live. Three major city and growth deal projects are the 95-acre site at the Mandeville industrial estate in Craigavon and two sites associated with Mid South West growth deal projects, which comprise approximately 43 acres at Desertcreat in Cookstown and 30 acres in Omagh. Those growth deal projects will provide modern, development-ready sites with enabling infrastructure and proportionate low-carbon energy solutions. Those are the types of projects that we are continuing to progress. The three projects remain at an early stage and are subject to all the necessary business case and planning approvals. As I said to Mr Honeyford, Invest NI will continue to explore all opportunities to acquire and develop additional land, where a need is identified.

Mr Martin: Continuing the theme of economic investment, or perhaps disinvestment, I ask the Minister how concerned she is about the fact that our waste water system is critically failing and will cost Northern Ireland over a quarter of a billion pounds in lost GVA over the next three years?

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for his question. We are all aware of the challenges facing our water and waste water infrastructure, which are critical enablers, not only for industrial development but to support indigenous businesses and housing development. Responsibility for that sits directly with NI Water, but Invest NI continues to engage with it on the operational issues that are affecting its existing business parks and, more strategically, as I said to Mr Honeyford, on how future infrastructure investment can be aligned with our economic development priorities and, as far as possible, with unconstrained areas. Ultimately, we need to address those constraints. As we all know, doing that will require sustained investment in waste water infrastructure. We will all continue to make the case that we need to see the Executive properly funded not just with resource so that they can deliver public services but with capital so that they can invest in infrastructure and access some of the other available funding streams, be that through the National Wealth Fund, the British Business Bank or the GB Energy community fund.

All of those are critical to our ability to sustainably plan our capital investment.


2.15 pm

Dr Archibald: The local growth fund is a British Government fund administered by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG). MHCLG sets the overarching funding parameters, including the outcomes and outputs that projects must meet.

On 8 July 2026, the Minister of Finance obtained Executive agreement to the local growth fund investment plan and departmental capital allocations for 2026-27. The investment plan included an indicative list of projects and organisations proposed for support. Subsequent to that Executive agreement, individual Departments assessed projects on five key areas: strategic fit with the local growth fund; deliverability within this financial year; measurable outputs and outcomes; value for money; and compliance with relevant legal, financial and subsidy control requirements. Any projects that do not meet those requirements satisfactorily will not receive funding, and flexibility is retained to redirect funding where necessary within the financial year.

I have already announced funding of £1·7 million for Go Succeed and £7 million for Invest NI to support business. I will be announcing other projects in the coming months.

Mrs Cameron: I thank the Minister for her update. My question is on Mallusk Enterprise Park's Springvale project at Ballyclare, of which, I know, the Minister is aware. It has a huge potential to increase economic growth in my South Antrim constituency. Have any letters of offer been issued to other projects under this year's local growth fund? When will the Minister know if there is any funding left in the pot that could support Mallusk Enterprise Park's £700,000 bid?

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for that question. She is right: I am aware of Mallusk Enterprise Agency's bid. I see huge potential in it, and I understand why the Member is advocating on its behalf. I had the opportunity to visit the existing site and to hear about the plans for expansion. I very much support them. I was supported in that visit by my colleague Declan Kearney. I am keen to see that project progress. There is limited funding available for this financial year, but I have had correspondence from Mallusk Enterprise and, if underspends become available, we will look towards that. If the Member wants to correspond with me on the particulars, I am happy for her to do so.

Mr Boggs: Given the balance between resource and capital funding within the local growth fund, how are you seeking to maximise the benefits of the funding that is available?

Dr Archibald: We all know that the balance between capital and resource funding has been a particular challenge in this financial year. The envelopes of capital and resource funding were established by the British Government, and there is no flexibility for the Executive to move funding across the two. I fully appreciate the concerns that have been raised regarding the level of resource funding that is available, and, along with all of my Executive colleagues, I argued for that position to be revisited. However, I intend to make use of the capital allocation to make long-term investments in the sustainability of organisations and communities.

This year, experience has shown that many organisations are in a position to make use of capital funding in this way, and, as we have just heard from Mrs Cameron, the demand for funding is high. Capital investment can provide organisations with the assets, facilities and infrastructure that they need to become more sustainable and resilient while also supporting economic growth and creating lasting benefits beyond the immediate funding period. My focus is on ensuring that we can maximise the impact of the funding that is available this year and the two coming years in a way that secures long-term benefit for organisations. I want to see the process through which organisations can apply and bring forward proposals become more transparent.

Mr Nesbitt: Was consideration given to using the fund to create or expand clusters?

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for his question. As I said, the overarching objectives of the local growth fund were set by the MHCLG. Projects have therefore been assessed against those objectives and the relevant criteria. Neither the creation nor the expansion of clusters were among the assessment criteria, and they were not given a separate weighting in the process. My Department is actively supporting industry-led clusters through Invest NI and InterTradeIreland. The Invest NI £11 million cluster acceleration programme supports the development of priority clusters, while InterTradeIreland also supports cross-border collaboration. Those are important initiatives that we will seek to further build on, because they strengthen collaboration, not just between sectors but right across the economy.

Mr Speaker: Mr Buckley is not in his place.

Dr Archibald: We are getting through the questions rightly.

Trade unions can give workers an effective voice, provide workplace support and promote constructive employment relations. The proposed employment rights Bill would establish a modern statutory framework tailored to our economy, giving qualifying trade unions a right to seek workplace access, including appropriate safeguards for workers, employers and unions. Similar rights took effect in Britain on 30 October 2026. Workers here now lack comparable arrangements, leaving them at a disadvantage and opening up a sea border on workers' rights. That employment rights gap will continue to widen while our legislation is delayed.

Polling here has shown substantial public support for core good jobs measures. In July, a LucidTalk poll showed that 70% of respondents supported giving workers the right to request the support of their trade union in the workplace.

The draft Bill was submitted to the Executive in April. I regret that the Executive have not yet been able to reach a decision, preventing the Assembly from scrutinising those important proposals.

Ms Sheerin: Gabhaim buíochas leis an Aire as an fhreagra sin.

[Translation: I thank the Minister for that answer.]

Minister, it is outrageous that the DUP has blocked your attempts to improve important workers' rights. Despite its wreckers' agenda, will you outline what you are continuing to do to protect the rights of working families?

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for her question. While the 'good jobs' Bill has not progressed as we had hoped within the current time frame, we are still pursuing a number of other advances in workers' rights, particularly for working families. As I announced previously, one of the measures that we are bringing forward is domestic abuse safe leave. The regulations on that will be shared with the Economy Committee, I believe, next week so that scrutiny of that important advance in workers' rights can be progressed.

We are also developing regulations to make paternity leave and pay more flexible. The proposals will allow the existing two-week entitlement to be taken as two separate blocks or one continuous block. We will extend the period for taking leave to 52 weeks following birth or adoption and reduce the notice requirements for each period of leave related to birth or surrogacy to 28 days. Drafting of the regulations is at an advanced stage, with a proposed commencement date of 6 April 2027, subject to agreement and completion of all the necessary legislative processes.

Ms Nicholl: I thank the Minister for that interesting update. The 'good jobs' Bill should have been decided in this Assembly mandate. There is a narrative that it is all dangerous. There was, however, only one bit that people disagreed on. What can the Minister do, possibly through regulations, on flexible working, which is an issue that keeps coming up?

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for her question. The right to request flexible working from day one of employment was included in the 'good jobs' Bill, which, unfortunately, has not progressed. We can look at what more we can do, but we require primary legislative change to make that possible. If there are other things that we can do, we will, of course, do them; for example, via the likes of the Labour Relations Agency (LRA), we will encourage employers to provide flexible working for workers as much as possible. Ultimately, however, we need legislative change to make that happen.

Mr O'Toole: Minister, I agree with you. It is deeply frustrating that the 'good jobs' Bill was not introduced. We, as the Opposition, said that we supported it in principle and wanted to work with you on it. However, I come back to the point about your responsibility as Minister and the responsibility of the whole Executive. The DUP clearly has form for blocking, and it has created a sea border on workers' rights. Was it a mistake for you and your party to print thousands, if not tens of thousands, of leaflets saying that Sinn Féin's 'good jobs' Bill would transform workers' rights when the Bill had not even been drafted? The DUP blocked it, but did you and your party make a promise that has not been delivered on?

Dr Archibald: I do not accept the premise of the question. The 'good jobs' Bill would improve workers' rights and entitlements, which is why we were bringing it forward. Numerous important advances on workers' rights are contained in the Bill, such as, amongst other things, carer's leave, neonatal care leave and the right to flexible working. As you have indicated, among the vast majority of Members in the Chamber and, as has been shown by polling outside the Chamber, across society, there is huge support for the provisions in the Bill, but the place to have that conversation and debate was in the Chamber. Unfortunately, the Bill was blocked from getting to that point, which was entirely down to the DUP and its agenda.

Dr Archibald: Transitioning to a more circular economy offers significant economic benefits for the North, including higher productivity, lower business costs, new employment opportunities, increased innovation and investment, and greater resilience to external supply-chain and commodity-price pressures. There are particular opportunities in manufacturing, construction and the bioeconomy, including agriculture, supported by enabling activities in finance, research, design and digital services. By developing circular business models, we can grow new markets in a sustainable way to meet international demand for goods and services that minimise environmental impact while retaining the value of materials here at their highest value for longer. I have approved the draft circular economy strategy, and, given its cross-cutting nature, Executive approval for it has been sought. I intend to publish the strategy as soon as possible after Executive approval. I hope that it is included on the Executive's agenda as soon as possible.

Ms D Armstrong: I thank the Minister for her response. Minister, thank you for outlining the strategy, which is awaiting approval. What time-bound actions, funding commitments and performance targets will the strategy contain?

Dr Archibald: I would be getting ahead of myself if I set out what was in the strategy prior to the Executive having the opportunity to consider it. Obviously, I want to see the strategy published as soon as possible, so I hope that the Executive get the opportunity to discuss it and, ultimately, approve it at the soonest date possible.

Ms Finnegan: How will the circular economy strategy be implemented?

Dr Archibald: Transitioning to a more circular economy will require a system change in our thinking. It cannot be delivered by only one Department; it will require a whole-of-government approach, which is why we need Executive approval. Delivery is expected to happen across the Departments. Without getting into the detail of the strategy, it is set at a high level to preserve flexibility and avoid prematurely constraining cross-cutting delivery. My Department will coordinate the overall delivery of the strategy through its circular economy strategic direction unit, and that will be supported by cross-departmental governance arrangements to oversee implementation, monitor progress and ensure that there is alignment across all the different departmental policies and programmes. That unit will lead on the overall implementation, with individual Departments developing their own implementation plans and setting out the actions that they will take in their respective areas of responsibility. Moving to a more circular economy type of approach brings a significant opportunity, particularly for waste reduction, but also in aligning different business needs across our whole economy. I hope that we see that progressed as soon as possible.

Dr Archibald: For those experiencing domestic abuse, safe leave will provide vital time and security when they need it most. On 23 October, I published the policy response to the domestic abuse safe leave consultation, setting out how this important new employment right will operate in practice. Eligible employees and workers, whether full-time or part-time, will be entitled to 10 days of safe leave in each leave year, paid at their normal rate of pay. The entitlement will apply from the first day of employment and may be taken flexibly, including in half days.

I remain committed to putting the safe leave regulations in place before the end of the mandate, subject, obviously, to the necessary scrutiny and Assembly processes, and I intend the new right to come into operation in April 2027.


2.30 pm

Mr Speaker: We will now move on to topical questions.

T1. Ms McLaughlin asked the Minister for the Economy, with 24,000 young people in Northern Ireland not in education, employment or training (NEET) and Alan Milburn's review in England set to examine how to tackle youth unemployment, how she expects to address the crisis when the Executive have failed to agree a Budget and her Department continues to cut opportunities for our young people. (AQT 2801/22-27)

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for her question. The increase in the number of young people falling into the category of not being in education, employment or training should concern us all. We have seen the numbers increase significantly since before the pandemic. I will have to consider the outworkings of the Milburn review when it is launched, particularly how it will impact on devolved responsibilities and existing provision. However, we all recognise that, to tackle the problem, we need investment in the programmes that work, and we have some really effective programmes here that have been shown to work.

I am concerned about some of what I hear about the Milburn review, including the removal of personal independence payments (PIP) for young people under 25, but we will have to see the detail of that once the review is published. I am keen to see an approach that reflects the individual circumstances of the young person and supports them to make progress and overcome any barriers to entering training or employment. We need to focus on grappling with those issues in particular.

Ms McLaughlin: I thank the Minister for her answer. I agree: we all need to look at this with a sense of urgency, because too many of our young people are being left behind. However, the Executive cannot even agree a Budget, and we cannot even protect the services that we already have. Does she not recognise that every college place lost and every training opportunity cut risks placing more young people in the category of long-term economic inactivity? Once that happens at the very beginning of their career, it is really difficult to claw it back. I see no urgency from the Executive to address that issue.

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for her supplementary. It is not necessarily fair to say that the Executive cannot agree a Budget: the Executive are united in their position on the Budget. What is on the table is not a fair and sustainable funding package, and agreeing a Budget would have institutionalised the potential damage to our public services. Ministers were not prepared to sign up to that.

From my perspective, when I looked at the impact that the draft Budget would have on our colleges and universities, I saw in the contingency allocations, in some respects, what would, in effect, have been what our provision looked like. That, to me, was not acceptable, which is why we have continued to pursue negotiations with the British Government.

We have been successful in obtaining additional funding. It is still not enough to deliver public services in the way that our citizens rightly expect. That is why we continue to pursue those negotiations, and I recognise, as Minister, that we need to see investment in our young people and in the colleges, universities and training providers that support them. That is what has driven me to take the position that I have on the Budget.

T2. Ms Nicholl asked the Minister for the Economy, having acknowledged that this question is similar to one that she asked earlier and commented that it is interesting that, following the removal of the 'good jobs' Bill, the Minister has said that it is her intention to bring forward elements of it via regulations, to outline what she will prioritise in the coming months that would have been in the Bill. (AQT 2802/22-27)

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for her question. What we continue to progress are not things that were in the 'good jobs' Bill itself, because those things would all have required primary legislation to make the necessary changes, but other elements that we had planned to look at, such as domestic abuse safe leave and paternity leave, so that we continue to pursue the changes that we have the ability to make by regulation. It is only right that we do so in the short time that we have left in the mandate. I want us to make as much progress as possible in respect of workers' rights. I am deeply disappointed that the 'good jobs' Bill will not progress in the way in which it should have done. That is absolutely shameful. As I said, that lies squarely at the feet of the DUP. We see similar rights being progressed in Britain. Workers here are now at a disadvantage, and that is a disgrace.

Ms Nicholl: I thank the Minister for her answer. I agree that the Bill should have been here and that we should have progressed things. Given the importance of workers' rights, has the Minister considered bringing forward elements of the Bill? My colleague the Justice Minister brought forward a shortened hate crime Bill, for example. Given that the DUP has held up the 'good jobs' Bill, basically over the part on trade union access, has the Minister considered bringing forward elements of it?

Dr Archibald: Yes, of course; I gave that consideration. From my perspective, however, it would have been entirely unbalanced to bring forward advances to workers' rights without the ability for workers to access their trade unions in order to exercise those rights. It was about getting the balance right between workers and employers. I tried to strike that balance throughout the entire engagement that we had in respect of the Bill, which was very considerable.

Hundreds of engagements have happened. We listened to and reflected quite a lot of the concerns that we heard, including those from employer organisations and the business community. Some of those business organisations recognised that their concerns had been reflected in the proposed legislation. It is a matter of regret to me that the Bill did not get to the Floor of the House so that people could see in detail how we had reflected their concerns. If Members wanted to make changes to the Bill, the place to do that was here in the Assembly Chamber through amendments.

T3. Mrs Cameron asked the Minister for the Economy, further to her statement last week on the home heating oil market study, what arrangements are in place to prioritise delivery to vulnerable households during supply disruptions this winter. (AQT 2803/22-27)

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for her question. As she mentioned, last week, I set out the measures that we intend to take to fulfil the recommendations that were made by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA). Obviously, that is work in progress. We will seek to progress particular elements of that, such as the one that she mentioned, as quickly as possible, because it is important that our vulnerable households have that level of protection. The Consumer Council will continue to support people. We will do additional awareness-raising work so that people know where they can go to access support. I hope that, by the very fact that we have had the home heating oil study and are talking about a number of those issues, such as payment plans and minimum value orders, people will simply be more aware of that by the nature of the discussion. However, we need to ensure that people are aware of it and know that they can pursue it with their oil suppliers.

Mrs Cameron: I thank the Minister for her answer. The Communities Minister has already opened up the £100 home heating oil voucher scheme: will the Minister for the Economy commit to opening her register for vulnerable heating oil customers before Christmas?

Dr Archibald: I do not have a time frame in respect of that yet. I am happy for the Member to correspond with me on that issue. As I said, we want to move forward at pace certain elements of the measures that we want to take, because there is a need for our vulnerable households, in particular, to be protected. I am happy for there to be some correspondence on the timelines in respect of that issue.

Mr Speaker: Dr Aiken is not in his place.

T5. Mr Bradley asked the Minister for the Economy to set out what specific measures her Department is taking to attract new investment and create sustainable, well-paid employment opportunities in East Londonderry, particularly Coleraine, Limavady and the surrounding rural areas. (AQT 2805/22-27)

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for that question. Of course, I have a constituency interest in making sure that that happens. The main measure that we are taking to ensure that areas are able to attract investment is through the local economic partnerships.

I am very familiar with the Causeway Coast and Glens Borough Council local economic partnership action plan and a number of the measures that the council is taking through it that will be beneficial for attracting investment and supporting local businesses to create and sustain jobs. Along with Invest NI, we will continue to work with that council and, indeed, all councils to support progress on their plans.

Mr Bradley: Thank you for that answer, Minister. Will you provide details of the investment secured throughout East Londonderry over the past two years, including the number of jobs created, and explain what further action Invest NI is taking to ensure that towns outside Belfast get their fair share of investment?

Dr Archibald: I do not have in front of me the detail that the Member has asked for on investment and the number of jobs created, but, if he wishes to correspond with me, I will be happy to provide it. As for ensuring that areas outside Belfast get their fair share, one of the things that we implemented through the subregional economic plan was a target for Invest NI of 65% of investment to be made outside the Belfast metropolitan area by the end of the three-year business plan period. We are now two years in and have seen good progress against the target, but we need to see that progress continue. Progress has to be made on all the types of investment that will support local areas, be it R&D funding or job creation funding.

Mr Speaker: Topical question 6 has been withdrawn.

T7. Mr Chambers asked the Minister for the Economy whether her Department has a plan in place to address the worrying situation whereby a number of students who are in further education to learn a trade and are committed to following a career in that trade are required to secure what are scarce apprenticeship posts in order to be permitted back in the third year to complete their college course. (AQT 2807/22-27)

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for his question. I am not familiar with the particular detail to which he refers, but if he wants to correspond with me, I will be happy to furnish him with that detail. If there are young people whose cases he is dealing with and he wants to refer those cases to the Department, I will be happy to support him.

Mr Chambers: I really appreciate that and will take you up on that offer, Minister. Are there any inducements in place to help and encourage employers to take on apprentices in order to enable them to finish their formal college training?

Dr Archibald: Again, I do not have in front of me the detail of the support that is available, but, again, I am happy to furnish him with it. There is support for employers in respect of taking on apprentices, and I will be happy to correspond with the Member about it.

T8. Mrs Dillon asked the Minister for the Economy, who will be aware that Mid Ulster District Council has written to her Department about joining Ireland's Hidden Heartlands, whether she can confirm how that can be progressed? (AQT 2808/22-27)

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for her question. Question Time interrupted the debate that we were having on tourism in the Chamber. The inclusion of Fermanagh in Ireland's Hidden Heartlands last year has proven to be a huge success. I recently had the opportunity to engage with some businesses in Fermanagh about their experiences, so I fully understand why Mid Ulster District Council is seeking to pursue that opportunity. Members will be aware that ownership of the Ireland's Hidden Heartlands brand sits with Fáilte Ireland, so a licensing agreement needs to be put in place in order to allow areas to participate in the strategy. We continue to pursue conversations with Fáilte Ireland, and I would certainly support that council's inclusion in Ireland's Hidden Heartlands and the extension of the other tourism brands into the North.

Mrs Dillon: I thank the Minister for her answer. Minister, you mentioned that the motion that is being debated in the Chamber today is on the potential:

"to deliver a jointly funded all-island tourism growth plan".

Unfortunately for us, we are being funded or not funded, as the case may be, by the British Government, while the South has money to invest in tourism. Do you agree that tourism's real potential across the island will be fully realised only when the constitutional position of having a united Ireland is realised?


2.45 pm

Dr Archibald: I thank the Member for her question. I do not think that she would expect me to do anything but agree with her on that issue. There is huge potential across the island for tourism. We have seen the Irish Government's significant investment in tourism infrastructure. We have secured some of that through Shared Island projects, which are important infrastructure investments. We continue to work with the Government in the South, Tourism Ireland and the other agencies to do the best that we can to promote the island in the current context. The fleadh, which took place in August, was one of the best examples of that. We will have the opportunity to do that again next year when the fleadh comes back. When we look at the outworkings of the fleadh, we see the potential that we have. Through the fleadh, we wanted to showcase this place so that people would want to come back or, indeed, come to visit it in the first place. We will shine the spotlight on it next year also.

Justice

Mrs Long (The Minister of Justice): I am aware that the Chief Constable has expressed concern about the potential use of drones and other airborne unmanned vehicles and devices to carry out criminal or terrorist attacks. The proliferation of such technology for the purposes of attack is, of course, a matter on which I share his risk perspective. International conflicts and other incidents have clearly demonstrated the potential for that technology to be used for hostile purposes.

The wider threat is real and remains subject to active counterterrorism arrangements. Recent attacks, including those at Lurgan and Dunmurry police stations, demonstrate the continuing capability and intent of those who seek to target police officers and undermine community safety. They are prime examples of the continuing dissident threat to the security forces. I utterly condemn those attacks and those who attempt them.

Mrs Dodds: Thank you, Minister, for your answer and your condemnation of the dissident attacks. Will you reassure the public of Northern Ireland, victims of terrorism and all those who believe in the rule of law that, as Northern Ireland's Justice Minister, you will oppose the much-hyped recent conversation among the chattering classes that dissidents should be offered a deal and that the release of prisoners should form part of it? Can you shed any light on the recovery of the weapons that the Chief Constable said were available on the Garvaghy Road and that prevented him from upholding the rule of law and allowing the Orangemen to walk their return journey to Carleton Street?

Mrs Long: On the first point, I have always been clear in my condemnation of all terrorism and paramilitarism in Northern Ireland and on the need for a justice-led response to those issues. You will be aware that the Government took the view that there should be a review of how they might engage with loyalist paramilitaries and dissident republicans about bringing their campaigns to an end. I was not in favour of that approach at the time, and I remain highly sceptical about whether it would work and, perhaps more importantly, highly concerned about the impact that it would have on our understanding of the rule of law.

With respect to the Chief Constable's security assessment, it is important to differentiate between a factual arms find that the PSNI pursues actively and an intelligence assessment that weaponry may be or is likely to be available for use in a particular area. Distinguishing between those two things is important when it comes to the police response. However, given, for example, the discovery of pipe bombs in Belfast over recent weeks and other munitions across Northern Ireland in previous months, I have no doubt that the PSNI, at an operational level, is absolutely committed to ensuring that all weapons are taken off our streets and dealt with in a way that keeps everyone in our community safe.

Ms Egan: Minister, will you outline how additional security funding impacts on the PSNI's abilities and resilience when it comes to responding to terrorist attacks and threats, such as those referenced in your answer?

Mrs Long: While the PSNI receives additional security funding from the UK Government to allow for the local circumstances, that funding alone will not make a difference if, at Executive level, the Department does not receive the policing and justice funding that it needs in order to address wider policing pressures. We know that much counterterrorism activity is also based on local knowledge, neighbourhood policing and relationships within the community, which are key to being able to undertake those operations successfully.

I have been making the case for additional funding, both to Executive colleagues and to the Northern Ireland Office, and I will continue to do so. Additional security funding remains critical to facilitating the capacity of the PSNI to disrupt terrorism in all its forms and to respond in the event of attempts and attacks, whether on the PSNI or on members of the public. Obviously, I cannot talk about the specific operational capabilities or countermeasures and how those are resourced and deployed because that is a matter for the Chief Constable, but I am confident that the additional security funding that we receive is an important part of ensuring that the counterterrorism unit and the activities that go on in Northern Ireland, including the work around, for example, the paramilitary task force and the organised crime task force, work to the same end: to ensure that people in Northern Ireland are kept safe.

Mr Beattie: Minister, to get back to the original question, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) — drones — are an increasing threat. Has the Department looked to the private sector to see whether it can get any counter-UAV training or equipment to counter that threat?

Mrs Long: Civil aviation, including the regulation of unmanned aircraft, is a reserved matter, so legislative and policy responsibility lies principally with the Department for Transport, and the UK Civil Aviation Authority is the regulator responsible for administering and enforcing the applicable aviation strategy and framework. It issues guidance and operates registration regimes for drones and other unmanned aircraft. The implications extend beyond policing and security. Hostile drone use can present risks to a wide range of critical infrastructure, public services and other sensitive sites, whether through surveillance, disruption or the delivery of harmful payloads. Therefore, it is important that those emerging risks are considered not just in DOJ but as part of a wider UK response.

DOJ and PSNI officials are engaged with the Home Office on the development of the UK counter-drone strategy. My officials participated in cross-Government meetings hosted by the Home Office that covered the regulation and enforcement of drone use, public safety and threats to critical interests. Therefore, while we have an interest in the issue and will engage on it, when it comes to the regulatory and enforcement landscape, it will ultimately be for the UK Home Office and the Westminster Government to make decisions on what can and cannot be deployed through a counter-drone strategy.

Mrs Long: The integrity of the Policing Board is critical in allowing it to effectively undertake the required accountability functions relating to the PSNI. The board members' code of conduct sets out the standards that are expected of all board members and is designed to maintain public confidence in the board's oversight role of the PSNI. At this juncture, it would be inappropriate for me to provide commentary on alleged criminal activity to individual board members. There is an active police investigation under way, and I urge all Members to be mindful of that when commenting on those matters.

On 1 October, the Policing Board chair highlighted the fact that all political representatives have an interest in the matters unfolding on the Garvaghy Road but said that, given that there are ongoing police matters, no member should raise questions or speculate regarding potential breaches, prosecutions or outcomes. On the same date, the vice chair was given the task, in the first instance, of conducting an investigation in accordance with the code of conduct around alleged conflicts of interest and breaches of the code of conduct. Under the code, a referral could then be made by the board to the Justice Minister to consider the removal of a board member if the breach is sufficiently serious to warrant the Minister of Justice using removal powers under paragraph 9 of Part III of schedule 1 to the Police (Northern Ireland) Act 2000. It would be inappropriate for me to speculate on whether that will happen, but I will emphatically stress that due process must be followed and allowed to take its course, with police being given the time and space to conduct any necessary investigations. I will, however, keep the matter under review and consider any issues arising.

Mr Frew: The Justice Minister will have no doubt seen the TV footage, the same way as I saw it with my own eyes, of the actions on the Garvaghy Road and the enticing of people out on to the street. Is it not somewhat worrying, Mr Speaker, that the Justice Minister cannot, will not and is reluctant to criticise Sinn Féin, but, when it comes to DUP Ministers allegedly breaching rules of ministerial conduct, she and her party are very quick to join Sinn Féin in the Lobbies? Can the Justice Minister explain that activity and explain to the House why she is so reluctant to condemn Sinn Féin?

Mrs Long: I do not accept the premise of the Member's question, which is that I am reluctant to condemn anyone whom I believe has acted unlawfully. Indeed, I said many weeks ago in the Chamber that, whilst the protest may have been peaceful, it was nevertheless unlawful. I do not think that I can be any clearer than that. The Member is comparing two things that bear no relation to each other. In the case that he refers to involving Ministers from his party and condemnation from me — in a party political capacity, rather than as Justice Minister — those were matters that were not under police investigation. Therefore, the issue of due process simply did not arise in that context. The fact that the Minister of Education entered what was an illegally occupied territory, again, was prima facie evident, and it is a political judgement as to whether someone who does so ought to hold ministerial office. It certainly would not be permitted in any other part of the United Kingdom.

When it comes to issues around the Garvaghy Road, of course, there are live police investigations. People have been summoned for questioning, and files are being passed to the Public Prosecution Service. As Justice Minister, it is important that I allow due process to take its course. I am sure that, if I were to do anything that could prejudice that investigation or, for example, cause the collapse of a case, the Member would be the first on his feet to condemn me for engaging in that way.

Mr Dickson: Minister, will you confirm to the House that you do not have the general power to remove a member of the Policing Board simply because their conduct is politically controversial or because the Assembly has expressed disapproval of that member?

Mrs Long: The Police (Northern Ireland) Act 2000 provides very specific grounds on which a Minister can remove a political member of the Policing Board. It is not a general power to remove a member because their conduct is controversial or because the Assembly has expressed disapproval. Under the code of conduct, the board may make a referral to the Minister to consider the powers of removal if it is judged that a breach of the code of conduct is so serious that a referral to the Minister is warranted. The legislation provides me, as Minister of Justice, with statutory powers concerning membership of the Policing Board and sets out the circumstances in which I may remove a person from office as a political member. Those are legal powers that must be exercised lawfully, on the basis of the relevant evidence and with appropriate regard to procedural fairness.

The statutory grounds include conviction for a criminal offence committed after appointment, lack of commitment to non-violence and exclusively peaceful and democratic means, and being otherwise unable or unfit to discharge the functions of a board member. That last catch-all term must be read in the context of the seriousness of the two preceding clauses. The application of any ground must be considered against the available evidence and the particular facts. Due process must be followed before any decision on removal can even be considered.

Mrs Long: The five-year speeding up justice programme, driven by the Criminal Justice Board, aims to reduce avoidable delay and supports the Programme for Government's priorities of safer communities and the reform and transformation of public services. Its five projects include out-of-court disposals, early engagement, committal reform and digital. Early engagement and out-of-court disposals also benefit from £20·5 million of transformation funding.

On out-of-court disposals, no-file decisions are now business as usual. The digital community resolution notice application was rolled out across the PSNI in September. I intend to extend penalty notices to common assault and possession of class A, B and C drugs, and to increase existing penalties. An Assembly debate is planned for December, with commencement on 1 February 2027, subject to Assembly approval. Officials will next move on to prosecutorial fines. I intend to introduce direct committal before the end of the mandate, allowing the most serious cases to reach the Crown Court sooner, subject to IT testing and legal and operational preparations.

Early engagement focuses on charging, better case management, and file quality and standards. Indictable file build standards are now business as usual, with the indictable gateway approach being expanded. Work on the 28-day charging protocol and prosecutorial advice framework supports earlier charging decisions and better-prepared cases, while stakeholder engagement informs more consistent case management. Following pre-consultation engagement, public consultation on the remit of the Magistrates' Court is planned for November 2026, seeking views on concluding appropriate cases at that level. The digital project board is identifying barriers to the greater use of technology, including legislative barriers, to improve information sharing and reduce duplication across the programme.

These reforms aim to resolve lower-level cases proportionately, release capacity for serious offending and improve the experiences of victims, witnesses and court users. Despite encouraging Crown Court processing times, delay remains too high, and recovery from the Criminal Bar Association's (CBA) withdrawal of services continues to put pressure on the system. However, I remain committed to sustained improvement with justice partners.


3.00 pm

Mrs Guy: I thank the Minister for her answer, and I acknowledge the good progress that is being made. Can the Minister say more about how the Department is looking to expand the use of out-of-court disposals?

Mrs Long: They are a Programme for Government commitment, and they are central to tackling delay in the criminal justice system, which is under significant pressure due to years of underfunding. They have been recognised by Lord Leveson as being a central measure in reducing demand on the criminal courts and stabilising a system at risk of collapse, offering a faster, more proportionate and cost-effective approach to lower-level offending while improving victim satisfaction and creating opportunities for early rehabilitation. Out-of-court disposals are long-standing essential tools for helping to divert appropriate cases that involve low-level offending from prosecution through the courts and ensuring that finite criminal justice resources are used effectively.

To deal more swiftly with the most serious cases, which are heard in the Crown Court, including murders and serious sexual offence cases, we need to create capacity across the system and free up police, prosecutor and court time. It will be vital, therefore, that cases are dealt with professionally and prosecuted at the right court tier or, if appropriate, dealt with through an out-of-court disposal. The disposals are not about leniency; they are about delivering timely, meaningful and sustainable justice, which can reflect outcomes in similar cases when they are heard before the courts. For example, a monetary penalty may ensue, but it will do so more quickly.

Ms Finnegan: Minister, we know that reforms of direct committal are due to be under way this month to ensure that serious offence cases are dealt with more efficiently and expeditiously. Will you outline how committal reform can be managed in a way that will not shift delays from the Magistrates' Court to the Crown Court and ensure that victim satisfaction is improved?

Mrs Long: The intention was that we would go live with committal reform in November. However, in engaging with partners, a number of issues have arisen. The first is the readiness of the technology, which I referenced in my original answer, and the other is, obviously, the impact of the withdrawal of service from the CBA, which has placed the Crown Court in particular under extraordinary pressure in comparison with what we would have anticipated at this juncture.

We have delayed pressing go on committal reform implementation. However, we hope to still be able to do so within this mandate, and we are working closely with judicial colleagues in particular to ensure that they are adequately prepared and resourced to be able to deal with the change. The Member is, of course, right that there is no point moving a backlog from one court tier to another unless we have a programme in place to ensure that we can drive that backlog down.

Mrs Long: Over the past 10 years, the Executive programme on paramilitarism and organised crime has supported thousands of vulnerable people, strengthened communities and helped to disrupt paramilitary groups. However, the need to tackle paramilitary harm remains. The programme team has drawn on lessons from 10 years of delivery, a detailed review of the programme and extensive stakeholder engagement to develop a new proposal for what should follow. The Executive have agreed that the proposed approach should be tested through public consultation, which I plan to launch early in the new year. The responses will inform detailed proposals for the incoming Executive to consider early in the new mandate.

The proposed new model is not another time-limited programme. The aim is to support public bodies, services and existing partnerships to make tackling paramilitary harm increasingly part of their ongoing responsibilities. To ensure that there is no gap in service for vulnerable communities and individuals, the Executive have also agreed to a closure-and-bridging year in 2027-28, prior to the implementation of the proposed new model.

Ms Bradshaw: Thank you, Minister, for that update. Can you please outline how that new approach will differ from the current programme?

Mrs Long: First, it will not be another time-limited programme. The new approach builds on the learning that we have and what has worked — we have discovered that through the Executive programme to date — rather than simply seeking to recreate the same programme. We also want tackling paramilitary harm to become everyone's responsibility across government and its partners, rather than relying on a temporary programme. That is one of the reasons why we invited Executive colleagues to try to mainstream those activities that we know were effective in dealing with paramilitary vulnerabilities in communities.

Subject to the views expressed in response to the consultation, the proposed approach will focus on three issues: people, place and problem-solving. It will support people at risk, bring partners together in the communities most affected and tackle wider issues that, as we know, no single organisation will be able to resolve alone. That should give us a more flexible and sustainable way of responding to paramilitary harm as that changes over time. It is also to be said, however, that the Northern Ireland Office, which is the match funder in this instance, is keen to see the roll-out of the harm reduction model. While, of course, paramilitarism is a particular issue here, there are many other kinds of threat to safety and stability in Northern Ireland that also need to be addressed, including, for example, extreme ideologies, which we want to be able to look at. This is about moving forward, with the learning that we have already garnered, into a different dispensation.

Mr O'Toole: Minister, thank you for that update. In the context of the racist violence that we have seen on the streets over three successive years, which has, we are told, been orchestrated to some extent by loyalist paramilitaries, and the clear linkages between those paramilitaries and organised crime not going away — it appears that there is division as to whether those organisations want to transition or move away from illegality — are we making actual progress in clamping down on and ending paramilitarism? Is the programme working, and can the Minister say, hand on heart, that she thinks that progress has been made?

Mrs Long: We have the evidence, so it is not about whether I think that progress has been made. The evidence base shows that progress has and can be made. Those are, however, small interventions that have been used in order to test theories and see how they would work in practice in a Northern Ireland context. They are not societal-wide programmes, and that is where the rubber hits the road when it comes to what comes next. We have tested the theory and have found the theory to work in those cases where we have applied it. It has been successful, even around such an intractable problem. If the Member refers to some of the recent assessments of paramilitary activity throughout Northern Ireland, he will note that there has been a decline.

The Member is right to note that the activity has often mutated into engagement in other high-risk and high-harm activities, and that is what the next iteration of the programme is about. It is about widening the scope of what we do in order to look at other high-risk and high-harm activities, so that we are not simply looking backwards to what we know as paramilitary activity but are looking at the wider harms of organised crime, exploitation and, as I said, extreme ideologies, including the far-right threat. All those activities need to be addressed as part of the work that we do to ensure that the people in our community are safe.

The independent assessment suggests that the programme has been very effective, but I share the Member's scepticism when it comes to just how willing some of those organisations are about going out of business by themselves. That is why I am not a supporter of the approach that has been taken to date by both Governments. I would rather see them give the resources to the Department of Justice, so that we can continue to bear down on those organisations through the justice system, which has proven to be very effective.

Mrs Long: The first phase of the Right Care, Right Person (RCRP) initiative involved the publication of a revised code of practice to the Mental Health (Northern Ireland) Order 1986 and became operational on Tuesday 1 September. Phase 2 was launched on 1 November by PSNI and Health partners. The aim of RCRP is to ensure that people of all ages who have health and/or social care needs receive the right care and are responded to by the right person with the right skills, training and experience to best meet their needs at the right time. Throughout the initiative's development and implementation, my Department has supported the work of an operational working group by jointly chairing a strategic group with Department of Health counterparts. That strategic group provided a coordination and supportive function to the PSNI and partner agencies in developing the RCRP policy initiative.

As, I am sure, Members will appreciate, the PSNI cannot continue to routinely attend incidents where there is no policing purpose and where police lack the legal power or training to resolve the presenting health care needs. Such situations are better handled by health or social care professionals, and scarce police resources need to be focused on policing and public safety. The Chief Constable has, however, repeatedly assured the public that the PSNI will continue to attend where there is a risk to life.

Mr Dunne: I thank the Minister for her answer. There is no doubt that the programme is of much benefit as long as other Departments and agencies have the resources to step up where the PSNI may not now be able to, particularly to avoid any potentially vulnerable people falling through the cracks. Has the Minister had any discussions with the Health Minister to ensure that his Department is fully on board with the programme, given the ongoing pressures that it is also faces?

Mrs Long: The scheme is ultimately a PSNI operational scheme, and, therefore, the direct contact has been between healthcare professionals and the PSNI.

However, I met the former Minister of Health when the Chief Constable initially raised the initiative with me. We discussed how we might support a cross-departmental strategic group to support the operationalisation of what is intended. The Member spoke about the resources that are available to other Departments: the resources are not available to the police to continue to be the last point of contact. When people fall through other Departments' nets, it is my Department, be it through prisons or policing, that has to pick up the slack. That is not sustainable when we are so critically underfunded. It is therefore important that all Departments step up to the plate.

I have not spoken to the new Health Minister, but I had a good understanding with the previous Health Minister that this was not simply about offloading further responsibilities on to the Department of Health, which itself faces a significant challenge, but about working collectively to ensure that, for example, when someone is in need of a therapeutic intervention rather than a policing intervention, that therapeutic intervention can be sourced and delivered in a way that results in a better outcome for the person and the community without placing everyone else at greater risk.

Mrs Long: With your permission, Mr Speaker, I will answer questions 7 and 9 together. I also seek your indulgence to give an answer that is slightly longer than usual.

The adult male prison population in Northern Ireland has continued to increase at a sustained and unprecedented rate, placing severe pressure on the prison estate. Those pressures are being felt most acutely at Maghaberry, where the Prison Service has had to adjust the accommodation in use, increase cell sharing and adapt staff deployment and service delivery. A significant factor in that pressure is the high number of people being held on remand. While decisions on bail are a matter for the independent judiciary, I am working with partners across the justice system to reduce the use and duration of remand, where it is safe and appropriate to do so, to improve the progress of cases through the courts and to maintain public safety.

The Criminal Justice Board has established a dedicated task and finish group to identify immediate steps to alleviate pressures on the Prison Service. That complements the delivery plan developed by the Justice-wide working group on remand. Work that is under way includes reviewing remand cases, expanding the use of electronic monitoring and considering potential legislative changes. A new bail support scheme for women in Belfast and Ballymena was introduced last month to provide support to address issues, including addiction and mental health, that can contribute to people being remanded in custody.

Alongside that system-wide work, the Prison Service continues to manage the immediate pressures from the rising population while maintaining a clear focus on rehabilitation and reducing reoffending. I want to acknowledge the staff working across our prisons. They perform an incredibly important role for our community in challenging circumstances, and I remain committed to supporting them. The scale and pace of the increase in the prison population and the number of people on remand mean that that must remain a priority across the justice system. I will continue to work with justice partners to address the immediate pressures and their underlying causes.

Mr Donnelly: I thank the Minister for her answer. How is she seeking to understand the causes of the high levels of remand?

Mrs Long: The Justice-wide working group on remand has developed a programme of actions, including the expansion of electronic monitoring and the potential for legislative changes. I mentioned the new bail support scheme for women. Given the current critical pressures, however, the Criminal Justice Board has established a task and finish group to focus closely on immediate steps that could alleviate pressures on the Prison Service. I am aware that similar pressures are being faced not just across these islands but across Europe. We recently had an international conference on prisons at which all present spoke about the increased pressure on the prison system. I am, however, not minded to consider the approach taken in England and Wales, where prisoners are being released before the end of their sentence, because that causes victims significant problems.

The scale and pace of the increase in remand mean that it is a key priority, and there is no single answer for why remand figures are so high. We do not fully understand why our remand figures are so much higher, so it is important that we understand why and that we look at ways in which we can abate them. Undoubtedly, the speed of justice is part of the reason but not all of it. There can, at times, be a different interpretation of the risk of reoffending. Someone may be at a high risk of reoffending, but the risk of their offending may in itself be quite low. It is about having conversations in which we ask, "What is the risk of harm if that person is released on bail? If they are released on bail, are there mitigations, such as electronic monitoring, that will allow us to do that more effectively and reduce our remand population?".

To be clear, the remand population is one with which we cannot really engage in any kind of rehabilitation, with the result that those who are released time-served never get the opportunity for rehabilitative intervention.


3.15 pm

Mr McGlone: Gabhaim buíochas leis an Aire.

[Translation: I thank the Minister.]

Minister, you mentioned that you were seeking to reduce the number of prisoners on remand. Will you indicate how you will do so?

Mrs Long: I hope that I have indicated that. First, we are looking at the potential for increasing the use of electronic monitoring. There may be people on remand who could be released on bail if we were to increase our use of that. We know that there are people who are on remand because of their social conditions rather than the nature of their offending. Often, people are on remand because of homelessness or mental health and addiction issues. We are looking at our bail support scheme for women in particular at this stage and trialling that as an option. It may give the community, the judiciary and other justice partners more confidence about releasing people if they know that that extra support is there.

We are also looking, obviously, at speeding up justice. In a previous answer, I talked about the need to see remand cases progress more swiftly. Again, it is about looking at why we place people on remand. There are some good reasons to remand people in custody, but the presumption should always be that, where possible, someone is bailed, because that means that, if they are sentenced, they will serve their sentence as a sentenced prisoner and therefore benefit from the rehabilitative interventions that we can offer. As a remand prisoner, they are unable to do so unless they opt in, and it is highly unusual for a prisoner on remand to opt in to rehabilitation, because that is almost like admitting guilt. There are real challenges for us in this, but we are working closely with partners.

We are also working closely with our partners on additional accommodation. My reading of what is happening across prison systems globally is that there is an uptick in the number of custodial sentences and the number of prisoners. While remand is our current focus, we are therefore also looking at the need for additional accommodation.

Mr Speaker: I call Patsy McGlone to ask a topical question this time.

Mr McGlone: We could probably continue that conversation for quite a while, Minister.

T1. Mr McGlone asked the Minister of Justice what action has been taken following publication of the recent domestic homicide review report. (AQT 2811/22-27)

Mrs Long: Domestic homicide reviews are first and foremost an opportunity for us to reflect on the individual loss of life and the circumstances that led to that. As the Member is aware, the purpose of domestic homicide reviews is to enable us to look at what contact the individual who died may have had with statutory agencies and public services in the period prior to the homicide and whether there were opportunities for earlier intervention that might have prevented homicide.

All reports are referred to the statutory agencies that were part of those discussions, and the agencies look at how they can implement the recommendations. It is important to say that, as a rule, we have found Health, Justice and, indeed, organisations on the wider spectrum that may have had contact with a victim to be open and willing to take learning from domestic homicide reviews and to change their processes and procedures where that would help prevent similar circumstances in other cases.

Mr McGlone: Thanks very much, Minister. You have answered a good part of my supplementary question. Given that many of the domestic homicide cases involved previous interaction with public agencies, are you confident that lessons will be learnt this time and that action will be taken?

Mrs Long: I am. I get reassurance from the fact that we ensure that progress on the reports is monitored. I look, for example, to the exceptional report that I commissioned on the death of Katie Simpson. Unusually, I asked Jan Melia to continue with the supervision of the implementation of the recommendations. Her feedback has been heartening. In particular, she highlighted the PSNI's willingness to look again at its means of investigation, how it approaches such things and the professional curiosity that is required. Her work also suggests that that is the case with the health trusts.

There has also been a real passion, for example, in the equine sector, which is much more complicated because of the different spheres of regulation, to step up and look at the vulnerability of some of the people who work in that sector. That is not unique to Northern Ireland. For example, I have shared those findings with the Taoiseach and the Agriculture Minister in the South. I have also shared them with, and have had information from, the equine industry in GB, where other young people have suffered similar, although perhaps not so tragic, outcomes from exploitation. A huge amount of good work is going on in that space.

It has to be said that such reviews represent a point in time. Many of them will make the same recommendations, and people looking at them may wonder why the recommendations have not been implemented. It is because those things happened before the first domestic homicide review was commissioned. If, in five years' time, we are still getting the same recommendations, there will be genuine questions to be asked as to whether the recommendations have been adopted as fully as they ought.

T2. Ms Forsythe asked the Minister of Justice to confirm in simple and clear terms whether, as Justice Minister, she condemns the actions of Sinn Féin Ministers in taking part in an unlawful protest on the Garvaghy Road, encouraging others to take part in that protest and streaming it across the media and social media. (AQT 2812/22-27)

Mrs Long: I have been clear on that point, and there is nothing that I can add that will satisfy the Member. The Member wants to continue the war of attrition across the Chamber. She is at liberty to do that, but I am at liberty to choose not to be part of it. As I said earlier, there is the matter of due process. There is the matter of a police investigation. There is, potentially, the matter of the Public Prosecution Service deciding whether prosecutions will ensue and, potentially, whether court cases will be completed. It would be wholly inappropriate for me or, I would argue, any other politician to seek to influence the outcome of any of those elements of the justice system. You cannot stand for law and order only when it suits. Part of law and order is due process.

Ms Forsythe: I am disappointed in that response from the Minister. Back in June this year, when I attended a lawful protest in Scarva, the Minister was one of the first people to attack unionist elected representatives on social media for attending the protest, and she did so on the basis of photographs on social media, without getting the full facts. The police met us, admitted mistakes in their policing and thanked us, as elected reps, for our role in that. Why, therefore, is the Minister so quick to condemn unionist elected representatives but will not condemn the Sinn Féin representatives today?

Mrs Long: First and foremost, the incident to which the Member has referred was not subject to a police investigation. My giving my opinion on it was therefore entirely appropriate. Secondly, the Member's characterisation of what the PSNI thought of her colleagues' interaction is not the characterisation that has been shared with me as Justice Minister. Thirdly, I will continue, as I would whether it were Sinn Féin, the DUP, the SDLP, the Ulster Unionist Party, the TUV or members of the Alliance Party, to condemn those who gather in public, breach those regulations and cavort around any town with masked men.

T3. Mrs Dodds asked the Minister of Justice, after noting a lot of double standards in the Minister's responses to the previous questions, including the fact that she was quick to condemn Paul Givan over his visit to Israel but remained silent when four Sinn Féin Ministers openly defied the authority of the courts, the police and the Parades Commission by blocking the Garvaghy Road, which led to the Chief Constable's saying that he could not police the law, why she is so selective and whether she does not like the country that Paul Givan visited or just wanted to kick a DUP Minister. (AQT 2813/22-27)

Mrs Long: First, I have already answered that question. I am slightly disappointed, because Mrs Dodds was in her place when I answered it, so she heard the answer. Her question is more performative repetition, no doubt for social media purposes.

I will be absolutely clear: there is no comparison to be made with a Minister making a political decision to enter illegally occupied territory. I will take no lectures about the state of Israel from anyone in the Chamber. Mr Givan did not enter the legal state of Israel. I have no problem with that; he is entitled to do that at a political level, and that is his choice. He entered illegally occupied territory, and it would be illegal for any Minister in Government in any part of these islands to do that. To be clear, that is the issue, not the use of departmental resources, which is what the Commissioner for Standards looked at.

Secondly, the issue is that there was no police investigation. I do not know how many ways I can say that I believe that blocking roads is wrong. I have said it before. I have said that it can be peaceful but also unlawful. I will not be drawn or provoked into trying to second-guess the police investigation, the Public Prosecution Service's assessment or what a court may decide. I would apply exactly the same test were any of the issues that the Member has erroneously raised subject to police investigation. They were not, and that is the distinct difference. It is not that it is two-tier but that the DUP has an inability to distinguish between two different sets of circumstances. I am afraid to say that, if DUP MLAs have not already picked up on that during this Question Time, I am not in a position to help them with that.

Mrs Dodds: I understand that the Minister is annoyed, because Alliance can get very annoyed by the exposure of double standards. The fact is, Minister, that you tripped through that Lobby to vote that Paul Givan should be suspended from office for a period of 12 months, yet the independent Commissioner for Standards found that he had breached no law. Before the investigation took place, you went ahead and voted, but you failed to offer any explanation in the House for Sinn Féin Ministers breaking the law. Why do you have a different approach to Michelle O'Neill and Sinn Féin? Is it about the Sinn Féin transfers in the May election?

Mrs Long: I never fail to be disappointed, although I am not annoyed. What Sinn Féin does has nothing whatsoever to do with me, and what the DUP does has nothing whatsoever to do with me. It is, however, very clear that this is about elections. The DUP wants to make what happened on the Garvaghy Road about the Alliance Party, because that suits its political purposes. Those in the DUP know that they will not be wrestling votes from Sinn Féin in the election, but they will need to wrestle them off us, and I say come ahead.

Some Members: Ooh.

Mrs Long: Come ahead, because we are more than ready to defend our record. I have been clear on my position when it comes to blocking roads lawfully and to legality. I look forward to the Members on those Benches being as outspoken when it comes to the illegal displays of flags and emblems, illegal bonfires and all the other illegality to which they are blind all year round. You can pick the speck from others' eyes whilst leaving the log in your own.

With all due respect, what I did as leader of the Alliance Party is not open for questioning on this site. If you have questions about my role as Justice Minister, ask them: I am more than capable of answering them fully, as I have been doing. I respectfully ask that the Member go back and read my answers. There are no double standards; there is one set of standards being applied to two sets of circumstances.

T4. Mr Chambers asked the Minister of Justice for an update on any efforts to encourage the NIO to pick up the tab for the recent policing operation at Drumcree, having stated that, as the Minister will be aware, it currently stands at around £5·5 million. (AQT 2814/22-27)

Mrs Long: Yes, I have written to the Northern Ireland Office and asked it to do that. I also raised that at recent meetings with the Secretary of State.

Mr Chambers: Thank you for that, Minister. The reported deficit in the PSNI budget is around £80 million. In the absence of any monitoring round funding becoming available due to the current situation with the Budget, will the Minister give an assessment of the consequences to policing if the deficit is not addressed before the end of the current financial year?

Mrs Long: The consequences are not just for the policing budget but the Justice budget as a whole. It will, I think, have dire consequences. There is no point, for example, in me getting funding from the Executive to allow the PSNI to recruit new members to try to rebuild the organisation from the low point that it reached during the most-recent Assembly suspension if we do not have the money to run the PSNI day to day and sustain what we already have.

Therefore, there is a real challenge on PSNI funding, but that is the subject of an ongoing conversation with the Secretary of State, Treasury and the Executive; indeed, after Question Time, I will meet Executive colleagues to discuss it.


3.30 pm

My Department is not the only Department facing an overspend. It is the first time that the Department of Justice has seen itself in that position. We are careful with our money; we are frugal in how we spend; and, before we make commitments, we ensure that we have them properly resourced. Thus, we have managed to come in on budget. That is not possible now because Northern Ireland is underfunded by the UK Government relative to need. Were we even to be funded at the level of the Welsh Government, we would find ourselves significantly better off — to the tune of about £1·5 billion this year alone — and, were we to be funded to the extent that Scotland is funded, we would be in even greater surplus.

I have no easy answers. We cannot spend money that we do not have. We do not have access to the Treasury reserve, as has been made clear by the Secretary of State. Unless something changes in that regard, we are where we are.

T5. Mr Bradley asked the Minister of Justice to outline what further measures she intends to introduce to strengthen the detection, prosecution and sentencing of drivers who operate vehicles while under the influence of illegal drugs. (AQT 2815/22-27)

Mrs Long: Where responsibility for that lies depends on which vehicles we are talking about. The Member will be aware that, following the most recent review of sentencing, work is ongoing around people who are found guilty of dangerous driving due to incapacity because of alcohol or drugs. That is going forward as part of the Justice Bill.

(Mr Deputy Speaker [Mr Blair] in the Chair)

In general terms, responsibility for road traffic offences lies with the Department for Infrastructure. Where the vehicles or machinery are being operated in a commercial setting, responsibility lies with the Department for the Economy. On devolution, every Department was given the responsibility to create offences and penalties within its remit. The Department of Justice is taking forward the current legislation on causing death or serious injury by driving whilst intoxicated only on the basis that it would do so with the support of the Department for Infrastructure. We had a legislative vehicle, but it is not for us to do that routinely. Our role is to advise any Department of what the relevant offences and penalties ought to be in order to ensure that they are proportionate.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): Time for questions is up.

Opposition Business

Debate resumed on amendment to motion:

That this Assembly recognises the enormous potential of all-island tourism to drive economic growth, create jobs and revitalise local communities; welcomes the extension of Ireland's Hidden Heartlands into Fermanagh as a positive example of North/South cooperation; expresses concern that Northern Ireland continues to miss out on opportunities to maximise its share of Ireland's international tourism success; supports greater ambition in linking the Wild Atlantic Way with the Causeway coastal route, positioning the Derry City and Strabane District Council area as a gateway to the north-west and extending Ireland's Ancient East into counties Armagh and Down; further recognises the UK Government's electronic travel authorisation (ETA) scheme as an unnecessary barrier to seamless cross-border tourism; calls on the UK Government to scrap the ETA requirement for visitors travelling to Northern Ireland from the Republic of Ireland; and further calls on the UK Government to urgently address the disparity in VAT rates on hospitality between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, which places hospitality and tourism businesses, particularly those in border counties, at a significant competitive disadvantage.

Which amendment was:

Leave out all after "; and further calls on" and insert

"the UK Government to urgently address the disparity in VAT rates on hospitality between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, which places hospitality and tourism businesses, particularly those in border counties, at a significant competitive disadvantage.".

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): We return to the Opposition motion on unlocking the potential of all-island tourism. I call Diane Forsythe.

Ms Forsythe: Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker. I love Northern Ireland, and, as someone who lives at the foot of the Mourne Mountains — a natural tourist attraction that has untapped tourism potential — I will speak up for it at every opportunity. We have a unique offering across Northern Ireland, and my concern is always that we do not lose the Northern Ireland brand when it comes to tourism.

Tourism is not only a mainstay of the Northern Ireland economy but a key economic driver. Between 2007 and 2021, DUP Economy Ministers worked to develop and grow the sector. That culminated, prior to the pandemic, in record numbers of overseas visitors and tourism spend, the creation of hundreds of jobs and the attraction of major and international sporting events to our shores. We want the Executive to go even further in promoting Northern Ireland as a must-see destination for travellers across the British Isles and globally. Our long-term objective must be to make tourism a £2 billion industry. Tourism has a central role to play in making Northern Ireland one of the small elite economies of the world.

We fully support practical and mutually beneficial cross-border cooperation. That includes cohesive messaging on either side of the border. However, that needs to be taken forward with a recognition of the importance of Northern Ireland's brand. We have seen that eroded in my area of South Down, and I do not want to see that for the rest of Northern Ireland. Partnerships between the Assembly and our councils are critical. It has been disappointing to see well-known and well-recognised tourism branding in the Newry, Mourne and Down District Council area being eroded over a period. Visit Mourne was a renowned brand domain. It is clearly recognised that people who come to Northern Ireland want to go to the Mourne Mountains, and Visit Mourne was well tapped into. That has been removed; it is no longer the branding. The council has instead moved towards a more generic term: Ireland's True Nature. It has also leaned into Ireland's Ancient East. I am really disappointed that the unique natural assets of my home area — the Kingdom of Mourne — its Ulster-Scots culture and the many things that surround it have been very much eroded.

The Festival of Flight in Newcastle, which included a performance by the Red Arrows, drew huge crowds to the local area. Again, the council moved away from supporting that event. I am very disappointed that we have lost such a successful tourism offering in the south Down area that was attended by many people from over the border in the Republic of Ireland. That is the cost of leaning too much into a wider idea and a wider brand. As I said, we fully support mutually beneficial cross-border cooperation, but Northern Ireland should never be absorbed by that and left behind.

Embrace a Giant Spirit was launched by Tourism NI at the end of 2019 to help Northern Ireland stand out among our competitors. It is instantly recognisable as distinctively Northern Irish, building on our unrivalled natural assets and rich industrial heritage. The emotional connection between a tourism offering that is unique and distinct to Northern Ireland and potential visitors has been crucial to increasing our visitor numbers, and it must be retained.

Northern Ireland has so much to offer: the Mourne Mountains, the Giant's Causeway, the Fermanagh lakelands, Carrickfergus Castle, the centre of Belfast with all its history and the Causeway coastal route. I want to see brand Northern Ireland on the global stage. I had family over from Australia last year, some of whom are not from here originally. In order to plan their trip, they googled what to do and Tourism Northern Ireland, but it was really difficult for them to pull out the information. It is important that we make sure that brand Tourism Northern Ireland is not lost in any of this. I fully recognise, however, the value of leaning into shared things such as the Hidden Heartlands. I know that Sinéad, who moved the motion, feels strongly about the Causeway coastal route and has raised it in Committee.

The motion also undervalues the contribution of UK-wide tourism. There is a strong case that, on a UK-wide basis, Northern Ireland's place is under-developed. The Minister should focus on that as well as looking at the opportunities for Northern Ireland tourism as a brand and the cross-border linkages. I want to see Northern Ireland thrive through tourism, especially in my constituency of South Down, which has so much to offer. We need to harness the opportunities and work closely with the Assembly and the councils to make sure that Northern Ireland's natural assets are promoted across the board.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): The Member's time is up.

Mr Honeyford: I have raised the issue so many times in the Chamber and in Committee. I welcome the motion from Sinéad and the SDLP. For context, it is about getting our share of international tourists. We are not talking about local tourism or tourists from the South or GB; we are talking about international tourists from America, Japan, Germany or wherever. When you market something, you start by communicating to the person with whom you are trying to connect. You do not start with barriers; you do not create difference. No business in the world would market its product like that. You start by looking at what they are coming to visit and trying to make that attractive. We need to put this in context. It is about international visitors who will come to Ireland and those who already come to the island. Our job is to enable more of them to come to Northern Ireland by making it easier for them to do so. The success from that will reach our local communities.

Tourism does not see the constitutional divisions that we live with. I regularly think that we look inwards rather than looking outwards at how to deliver better for people here in whatever way we can. It about taking the focus off ourselves and putting it on those whom we are trying to engage with. They come to experience the island, the scenery, the people and the stories that we all tell.

I recommend that, if they want some feel-good TV, everyone should watch Bill Murray's 'A Course Called Ireland', because they will feel unbelievably proud to be from here by the end of it. He highlighted places such as Ardglass — I am looking at Colin — and the story of the people here, which is what tourists come here for.

In the show, the Wild Atlantic Way is mentioned. I have talked about the Wild Atlantic Way so many times that I am beyond frustration. In Committee, it came out in answer to my questions why Fáilte Ireland is not letting its branding be used here, and that is disgraceful. I have continually asked Fáilte Ireland to come to the Committee, but it will not engage with us. There is an issue there, because tourism is one of the North/South areas of cooperation, yet the Committee cannot work on a North/South basis to bring about change. The Wild Atlantic Way should be extended across the whole of the Atlantic coast, including the Giant's Causeway. I recently listened to something from the South in which it was said that, as they travel north from Galway up the Wild Atlantic Way, there is nothing to attract people north. The Giant's Causeway is there, and it would be the attraction. It should be used, and we should not double up on promoting it.

Ireland's Ancient East should take in my constituency. How can it be the "Ancient East" if Carrickfergus, Hillsborough, Armagh and the Mourne Mountains are not included? It is farcical to market the Ancient East and then exclude part of it. Over the summer, I was in Donegal, and, every time I met a tourist in a pub, as I sat with my pint of Guinness, quietly enjoying my own company and getting away from it all, I asked them where they had been to in Northern Ireland. One guy from Belgium was on his fifth visit to the Wild Atlantic Way, yet he had never once visited anything in Northern Ireland. That is the sort of thing we have got to change.

I will quickly mention the Ulster Unionist amendment. Everyone in the House agrees with what is in it. Alliance MLAs and Sorcha have been to the forefront in raising the issue. The amendment, however, takes away from the motion. It turns it into a debate on a different motion. Nobody disagrees with it, but it would take away the ask in the motion and replace it: I have an issue with that. Jon Burrows wrote a pretty juvenile letter to Simon Harris on Friday — as someone who sits on the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly (BIPA), I found it embarrassing — but buried in his hissy fit was a line about North/South cooperation. You cannot ask for North/South cooperation on a Friday and then seek to amend a motion on the Monday to remove it. That is wrong. Although nobody disagrees on the VAT issue, the motion is about international tourism, not about a wedding somewhere. We support the motion.

Ms Murphy: I welcome today's motion. As an MLA for Fermanagh and South Tyrone, I acknowledge the work that has already been done to make all-Ireland tourism a reality for businesses across County Fermanagh. A prime example of that, as has been mentioned, is the extension of the Ireland's Hidden Heartlands brand into Fermanagh. The Department recently secured a licensing agreement between Tourism NI and Fáilte Ireland to allow eligible businesses in Fermanagh to use the brand. That was backed by £300,000 of funding to promote Fermanagh to visitors across the island. When the Minister visited Fermanagh in September, she had the opportunity to meet some of the businesses and see some of the attractions that featured in the campaign. From the Marble Arch Caves and the Cuilcagh Lakelands Geopark to the operators bringing visitors on to Lough Erne in boats and other forms of transport, such experiences give people a reason to visit County Fermanagh and, importantly, a reason to stay longer. The partnership's early results are encouraging. Eight out of 10 people surveyed said that the campaign made Fermanagh seem worth visiting. For local businesses, that means an opportunity to turn interest into bookings and visitors into customers.

In 2025, visitors spent almost one million nights in the Fermanagh and Omagh District Council area, and those stays brought an estimated £97 million into our local economy. Tourism spending has a real impact on rural communities. An extra night may mean another booking for a family-run guest house, another table filled at a local restaurant or another drink poured in a bar.

That is why an all-Ireland approach makes sense. A family can stay in County Fermanagh and spend time in Cavan, Donegal or Monaghan. When we promote those experiences together, we give people more reasons to stay longer and to spend more. Businesses on both sides of the border benefit. That extra trade helps to sustain our jobs and services across Fermanagh and, in particular, rural Fermanagh.


3.45 pm

We should build on that model elsewhere. Most visitors do not plan their holidays around jurisdictional boundaries; they go where the attractions, landscapes and experiences take them. That is why linking the Wild Atlantic Way and the Causeway coastal route makes sense, particularly with Derry and Strabane acting as a gateway to the north-west. Likewise, bringing Counties Armagh and Down into Ireland's Ancient East would encourage visitors to extend their stay and explore more of our island.

The Minister has already established an all-Ireland tourism steering group, bringing together agencies and officials from across the North and South. The next steps should include a jointly funded growth plan with clear commitments on investment, connectivity and job creation.

Tourism businesses also need a fair chance to compete, as is referenced in the amendment. I am on record speaking in the Chamber about the hospitality VAT gap, particularly in our border areas. A hotel, restaurant or tourism business in Fermanagh competes directly with a business just a few miles away in Cavan, Monaghan, Leitrim or Donegal. The Economy Minister and the Finance Minister have already raised that issue with Treasury, and the British Government should act. In fact, the VAT issue highlights exactly why joined-up planning matters. We are asking businesses to compete in a shared tourism market, while decisions on taxation and travel continue to create barriers. The same applies to the ETA scheme. Someone travelling around the island should be able to add a night in Enniskillen or Derry without facing an additional travel requirement simply because their journey crosses the border.

I welcome the work carried out in relation to Fermanagh's inclusion in the Fáilte Ireland Hidden Heartlands brand and the fact that a jointly funded plan can build on that work.

Mr Martin: As others have reflected, tourism is not just a mainstay of Northern Ireland's economy; it is a key driver of economic growth, investment and job creation. Our ambition across the Chamber must be to ensure that Northern Ireland attracts as many visitors as possible from across the British Isles and globally. The Member for Strangford mentioned golf tourism, which, alone, accounted for £86 million net investment into Northern Ireland in 2024. As has already been referenced, we want to encourage visitors from the South, but, as the previous contributor said, there are practical issues with that.

While we support tourism growth and practical cooperation, we do not support the approach set out in the motion. It places too much emphasis on an all-island strategy and fails to sufficiently recognise Northern Ireland's very distinctive tourist identity, as outlined by my colleagues, whilst overlooking the closer links with the rest of GB that we could endeavour to create.

It also struck me that there is an omission in the motion: where is the wider ambition for Northern Ireland's place in the wider UK market? There is considerable opportunity to attract more visitors from GB. We know from NISRA statistics that a lot more visitors come to Northern Ireland from GB than from the Republic of Ireland. The more interesting fact is that, last year, visitors from GB spent an additional £131 million in Northern Ireland, demanding services and creating jobs. The Minister for the Economy should not be blinded by an overwhelming focus on North/South cooperation that comes at the expense — at the opportunity cost — of ignoring what I have just outlined.

Mr Delargy: Will the Member give way?

Mr Martin: I will in a second. Let me address one more thing. Will I get another minute if I give way, Mr Deputy Speaker?

Mr Martin: That is exciting. Good. In that case, I will give way to the Member for Foyle.

On ETA, we understand that there are concerns around cross-border tourism. However, we cannot support the call in the motion for the UK Government to scrap requirements for visitors travelling from the Republic to Northern Ireland. I will give way to the Member for Foyle in a second. I listened to him earlier. He made the point that, somehow, the ETA scheme is completely unique here, does not happen anywhere else in the world and applies only to visitors coming up from the South to Northern Ireland. In fact, when I looked up ETA systems, I saw that they operate in the United States, Canada, Australia and throughout the European Union. I will give the Member his intervention.

Mr Delargy: I thank the Member for giving way. I am glad that he listened to me for, probably, the first time in his career.

Everyone else in the Chamber has made this about working together. We have all talked about inclusion and how we can bolster our tourism by working together. Yet again, the DUP has tried to make it about isolationism. You are trying to make it about only British visitors, only international visitors or only visitors from the South. Do you not recognise that the biggest barrier to tourism is looking at it through one lens? Everybody else here is talking about working collaboratively. Your party championed Brexit, the ETA scheme and that isolationism. Can you not get on to the same page as the rest of us and start working together?

Mr Martin: I thank the Member for Foyle. I would remind him of the comments that I made right at the start of my contribution, when I actually welcomed tourism right across the British Isles, which includes all elements of the UK and, obviously, the Republic of Ireland. I stated that of course I support visitors coming up from the Republic of Ireland. They are very welcome. I want to make that clear.

He referred to the ETA scheme in his own statement. Of course, I always listen to him. As I have just stated, the scheme is not unusual. The ETA system runs across the globe. When he talked about it, he seemed to think that it was unique to here in some way. It is clearly not unique at all. The alternative to applying ETA requirements to people making cross-border journeys would be to require authorisation for people to travel from Northern Ireland to the rest of the United Kingdom. Obviously, for a number of reasons, that would be wholly unacceptable to us. We are, however, cognisant of the need to minimise disruption for tourists — I am sure that everyone would agree on that — and tour operators when they visit both jurisdictions. The Government must honour their commitments to clear communication so that visitors understand the requirements in that area.

We actually need the people and skills to develop growth in our tourism sector, as has been well evidenced throughout the debate. The Economy Minister should therefore bring forward specific strategies to strengthen hospitality — the previous Member to speak mentioned discrepancies when it comes to Fermanagh and South Tyrone — and promote tourism careers throughout Northern Ireland. We want an ambitious tourism industry that protects Northern Ireland's very distinct identity and also develops opportunities for tourism across the United Kingdom and, of course, in the Republic of Ireland as well. Unfortunately, the motion does not strike that balance. For those reasons, my party will not support the motion, but we will support the amendment.

Ms Nicholl: Tourism is one of the most compelling stories on the island. It is really important not to look at it through an orange or green lens. Supporting tourism across the island of Ireland does not make you a united Irelander: you just realise that visitors do not plan their trip around a border. They see one island and one holiday. It is right that our policy works in the same way. Of course, we all want to see Northern Ireland get as great a share as possible.

I give credit to the tourism sector, which is already doing a lot of work. I had the privilege of sitting on the Visit Belfast board when I was on Belfast City Council. I saw how hard the sector works collectively. Last year, the number of overnight trips rose by 9% to 5·1 million. Visitors spent £1·2 billion. Seventy per cent of those trips were outside Belfast. Few sectors spread growth so widely, from Lough Erne to the causeway to the Mournes. It is good to see that work in the fullest sense.

The NI Tourism Alliance has talked previously about how more than half of the number of workers in tourism are women. Often, it is a young person's first job. The sector employs disabled people at a higher rate than average across UK industries. With Northern Ireland having the highest economic inactivity rate in the UK, we must pay close attention to that.

I am a little bit flabbergasted by my Economy Committee DUP colleague's points about the ETA. Seventy per cent of our international visitors arrive through Dublin and come across the border. Most of them now need a £20 travel authorisation before they come here. Three quarters of tour operators surveyed say that that has hit their business, and Westminster's NI Affairs Committee has called for an exemption for tour operators' customers. That is a welcome first step, but the Government need to go further. We need to listen to the industry. It does not like the ETA, and it is really important that that is scrapped.

We also underinvest. The NI Tourism Alliance says that Fáilte Ireland's budget is around six times the size of Tourism NI's. I echo the point that my colleague made about its failure to come to Committee. It is seriously disappointing. It is important to note that businesses cannot plan around a one-year budget. If the sector is given multi-year funding, it will invest with confidence.

In relation to VAT, I think that it does —.

Mrs Dillon: I thank the Member for taking an intervention. On the funding issue, and particularly around the tourism budget, does the Member agree that a British Government who have no interest in funding tourism outside of London are highly unlikely to give two hoots about tourism in the North, South, or anywhere along our border corridor?

Ms Nicholl: I would like to see more engagement from Westminster and recognition of the importance of Northern Ireland as part of the wider tourism offer. I hope that, with the new Prime Minister being so committed to devolution, we will see more of it. However, I can understand the Member's scepticism.

In relation to VAT, with 9% on one side of the border and 20% on the other — something that David mentioned — our colleague Sorcha has been really campaigning to make Treasury take it seriously. Margins like that can decide whether someone spends one night on one side or two nights on the other, so it has a big impact.

Hidden Heartlands in Fermanagh has shown what works. A simple licensing deal and a £300,000 campaign that puts local businesses in front of visitors who never would have found them is really important. We should look at how we do that at scale and how we link the Wild Atlantic Way with the Causeway coastal route; make Derry and Strabane the gateway to the north-west; bring Ireland's Ancient East into Armagh and Down — I agree that Hillsborough should absolutely be in there — and include Navan Fort and St Patrick's Country. That all needs to be on the map. It is something to celebrate.

Visitors also need to be able to get around. We know the demand is there for the hourly Enterprise service. Faster journeys and proper EV charging would build on that. When we look at the long-haul markets, with visitors from places such as India, rather than the handful that we rely on now, that connectivity is really important. A jointly funded all-island growth plan, with clear targets on investment, connectivity and jobs that would let us measure whether this cooperation is delivering, is really important. We need the data.

Finally, stability matters most of all. We have so many amazing things on this island, so much to celebrate, so much richness and so much to be proud of, but, so often, the international perception of this place is one of dysfunction. We want to show visitors and investors that this place works. Every time that these institutions deliver and North and South cooperate on something practical, it does more for this place than any ad campaign can. For me, it is about how we get jobs in Fermanagh, four hotels in Derry and young people in Saintfield who can build a career without leaving. It is a remarkable place and a remarkable island. Let us show people. Let us make it easier for people to come and see it.

Mr McNulty: Ireland's Ancient East is a flagship international tourism initiative, marketed by Tourism Ireland, with four key pillars: ancient Ireland; early Christian Ireland; medieval Ireland; and Anglo-Ireland. The Ancient East branding is a hugely successful international initiative that celebrates Ireland's ancient myths and legends and presents them alongside the modern and vibrant Ireland that we have today. As it stands, Ireland's Ancient East stops at a line that currently divides North and South. I have long campaigned to change that.

Between the two counties of Armagh and Down, we boast the resting place of the last high king of Ireland, Brian Boru; Cu Chulainn's stomping ground around our mythical mountain, Slieve Gullion; the Ring of Gullion AONB; and St Patrick's grave in Downpatrick.

Navan Fort — Eamhain Mhacha — in Armagh features prominently in Irish mythology. We have the tales of the Red Branch Knights, the Macra, Conchobhar mac Nessa and Cú Chulainn. Eamhain Mhacha features particularly in the tales of the Ulster Cycle. It was mapped almost 2,000 years ago by the Greek astronomer and mapper Ptolemy, yet it does not feature in Ireland's Ancient East offering.


4.00 pm

We have a rich and diverse mythical, traditional and built heritage to bring to the table, which would serve to considerably strengthen the tourism offering of Ireland's Ancient East, but it is not just about monuments. The Armagh Rhymers are preserving a tradition that is older than Christianity through Irish mumming, storytelling and traditional music. Surely, their unique cultural tradition should be included, celebrated and protected as the shining jewel in our shared heritage as part of Ireland's Ancient East.

The expansion of that branding to Armagh and Down would be a game changer for the local tourism industry and economy. The previous two Sinn Féin Economy Ministers stated that incorporating the three Fáilte Ireland experience brands in the North was a key priority, but their words have not been matched by action for counties Armagh and Down.

At 2,000 feet, the highest surviving passage grave in Ireland sits on the summit of our mythical mountain Slieve Gullion. It is more than half a century since, with the help of Sean O'Grady's tractor, that ancient monument was excavated by archaeologists. Just recently, it reopened after refurbishment work. It has links to spellbinding mythology, such as the story of Fionn Mac Cumhaill, who was tricked by the Cailleach Bhéara at the lake on Slieve Gullion's summit. Fionn Mac Cumhaill saw a beautiful maiden at the lakeside, and she told him that she had lost her ring in the waters. He dived in, and he came out an old and withered man. He realised that he had been tricked by the witch, the Cailleach Bhéara.

The passage tomb has the potential to be a national and global tourism feature where visitors can witness how the magical setting sun on the winter solstice shines through to the back of the chamber. Through Fáilte Ireland branding, investing in the Northern Ireland rail network — the hourly Enterprise service has been a huge success — and promoting the incredible ancient heritage of Armagh and Down, we can tap —.

Mr McGlone: Will the Member give way?

Mr McNulty: Of course.

Mr McGlone: Does the Member accept that a key element of what unionism deems to be an integral part of the Northern Ireland identity is, in fact, in the Twenty-six Counties: the site of the Battle of the Boyne?

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): The Member has an extra minute.

Mr McNulty: Yes, of course. That is a celebrated site on this island, and the Irish Government have done enormous work to celebrate the heritage of the Battle of the Boyne site. That should be recognised, as should the shared heritage that we all enjoy, including that of the Armagh Rhymers, which celebrates a tradition that predates Christianity. We should all celebrate that and be proud to be part of it.

Mr Gaston: I oppose the motion and the Ulster Unionist amendment. I will start with the short-sighted substance of the SDLP motion. Northern Ireland's tourism offering is second to none. If marketed appropriately and effectively, its tourism pull will continue to punch well above its weight for years to come. In fact, I would go so far as to say that North Antrim cannot be rivalled when it comes to what it offers visitors through its tourism and, indeed, its political leadership. [Laughter.]

North Antrim proudly boasts two UNESCO world heritage sites in the form of the iconic Giant's Causeway and the Moravian village of Gracehill, which is, I believe, the unsold diamond of Northern Ireland. I also highlight the often overlooked heritage railway line that runs between Bushmills and the Giant's Causeway. Part of the original 1883 Giant's Causeway tramway, it offers stunning views of the north coast through the lens of that historic setting. The Giant's Causeway to Bushmills railway line deserves greater promotion, not less and certainly not less because of an ideology-driven all-Ireland tourist offering. That is what the SDLP offers through the motion.

The iconic Dark Hedges has been made famous through its appearances in 'Game of Thrones' and continues to draw vast numbers of tourists up to North Antrim. When we get people to North Antrim, we have many world-class hotels and golf offerings, with further investment to be announced in the coming months on what we are doing for the golf sector in North Antrim. When thinking about hotels, no one in this Building can think of a more famous one than the Galgorm. The Galgorm Resort and Spa is located on the banks of the River Maine and is only one of eight luxury hotels that we have to offer.

With all of that located in North Antrim alone, why is the SDLP trying to package tourism as something that must be sold as an extra or an addition on an all-island basis while attaching it to County Kerry or Cork? I have confidence in my constituency and what it has to offer. To me, the motion speaks of poverty of ambition from the SDLP, which insists that Northern Ireland cannot stand on its own two feet and needs an all-Ireland tourism market. I say that that is wrong and misguided. We should be confident in what Tourism Northern Ireland has to offer and promote here in this country.

When I speak of poverty of ambition, that brings me nicely to the Ulster Unionist Party amendment. Why is the Ulster Unionist Party fixated on what the VAT rate is across the border? Surely, with having representation in Westminster — an MP and a number of peers — its ambition should be much greater. It should be joining us in saying that we want to see a reduction in VAT for hospitality right across our United Kingdom. It is a fundamentally anti-unionist position to say that we should simply peg ourselves to the VAT rate in the Republic of Ireland. We have seen enough in Northern Ireland, with foreign laws being imposed on our wee country via the protocol, without also trying to outsource our VAT policy to Dublin. I say, "No, thank you" to the motion and, "No, thank you" to the amendment.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): I now call — [Interruption.]

Members, I now call junior Minister Reilly to respond to the debate.

Mr Martin: On a point of order, Mr Deputy Speaker. I suspect that you might rule that this is not a point of order, but I am just wondering whether Finn McCool got the ring. The Member did not answer. I am not sure whether somebody could answer that for me. It sounded very interesting. I just was not sure.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): We will move on. A point has been made.

I call junior Minister Reilly to respond to the debate.

Ms Reilly (Junior Minister, The Executive Office): Go raibh maith agat, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle.

[Translation: Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker.]

I welcome the opportunity to respond to the debate on behalf of the Minister for the Economy.

Tourism is a major economic driver that supports jobs, businesses and communities throughout Ireland. The industry has flourished as part of the peace process, and, since 1998, the number of external overnight visitors has more than quadrupled; spending by visitors has increased more than sixfold in real terms; and all-Ireland working has been key to that success.

The Good Friday Agreement identified tourism as an area for North/South cooperation. Tourism Ireland was subsequently established to market Ireland overseas as a single proposition, and that has been hugely successful. Every pound spent on marketing by Tourism Ireland delivers £25 to the economy. On taking control of the Economy Department, the Minister, Dr Caoimhe Archibald, and her predecessor put a new-found emphasis on tourism. The industry is a key contributor to the Minister's economic vision and particularly to her regional balance objective, as 70% of tourism jobs are located outside Belfast. The Department for the Economy has set up a tourism partnership board, developed a dedicated action plan and set an ambitious target to reach £2 billion of spend from overnight visitors by 2035.

In order to better realise the industry's potential, we have stepped up our all-Ireland working. The Department for the Economy's contribution to Tourism Ireland has increased core funding by 50%. Tourism Ireland's corporate plan 2026-28 provides for a unified approach to overseas tourism marketing and is firmly aligned with tourism policy North and South. The ambitions outlined in the plan are supported by established joint machinery. Tourism Ireland provides the all-island overseas marketing platform, with its corporate and business plans approved through the North/South Ministerial Council. The all-island strategic tourism group brings together the Department for the Economy, the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment and the three tourism agencies to provide a strategic approach to all-island initiatives, identify priority areas for North/South cooperation and develop opportunities for sustainable tourism growth.

An example of that collaboration in practice is the work to connect the Causeway coastal route and the Wild Atlantic Way, supported by Shared Island funding. That has established Derry as the gateway between Donegal and the Causeway coast. Supporting that, Tourism Ireland promotes Derry overseas through international media, travel trade engagement, familiarisation visits and seasonal campaigns. Five attractions along the Causeway coastal route also share approximately £860,000 of investment to enhance the visitor experience.

Another excellent example of North/South cooperation is Fermanagh's addition to the Ireland's Hidden Heartlands regional brand, which was announced in December 2025. The Department for the Economy provided £300,000 to support Tourism NI's first Ireland's Hidden Heartlands campaign in Fermanagh. The evaluation of that campaign found that 82% of respondents recognised that Fermanagh is now part of Ireland's Hidden Heartlands, while 80% agreed that the campaign made Fermanagh appear to be worth visiting. In addition, more than 95% of businesses surveyed agreed that the campaign strengthened Fermanagh's position as an attractive short break destination.

The Minister for the Economy visited Enniskillen in September to hear directly from local businesses, including the Marble Arch Caves, Lough Erne Resort, Cuilcagh Lakelands UNESCO Global Geopark, Erne Water Taxi and the Boatyard Distillery. The feedback that the Minister received was overwhelmingly positive. The addition of Fermanagh has strengthened the brand, and Fermanagh has reached potential visitors. That success has reinforced the Minister's desire to see further progress on all-Ireland branding. The cultural, historical and heritage offering in Counties Armagh and Down has a clear connection with Ireland's Ancient East. The St Patrick story, Navan Fort, Downpatrick, Strangford lough, the Mournes and the wider heritage of the area all have the potential to attract additional domestic and international visitors.

Mrs Dillon: I thank the Minister for taking an intervention. Does she agree that, rather than just warm words, Sinn Féin has been proactive in putting in place the real-life infrastructure that could develop that Ancient East, in particular the bridge that is to go between Omeath and Warrenpoint? That could massively benefit both areas and, much more widely, the entire south Down and Louth areas. Indeed, it could go well beyond that and really benefit the communities right along our border corridors as well.

Ms Reilly: I absolutely agree. That is the whole purpose of all-island cooperation.

Mr McNulty: Will the Minister give way?

Ms Reilly: I will.

Mr McNulty: It is a little rich for Sinn Féin to claim the Irish Government's success as its own. The Department of the Taoiseach, through the Shared Island Fund, is delivering the Narrow Water bridge, not Sinn Féin. Just accept that.

Ms Reilly: Thank you. I did not know that you were a representative of the Taoiseach's office, but I am glad to see that you are.

The Department for the Economy continues to have discussions with Fáilte Ireland, which owns the Ireland's Ancient East and Wild Atlantic Way brands. In the meantime, Armagh and Down benefit from existing cross-border initiatives and Shared Island funding, including Shared Island destinations activity around Carlingford lough and the Mournes, work to assess the Loop of the Lough concept, activity under Great Lighthouses of Ireland and the wider investment associated with the Narrow Water bridge.

It is deeply regrettable that the success of our tourism industry is being undermined by the British Government. Their ETA scheme threatens seamless travel across the island, and it should be scrapped. The industry has proposed modest mitigations, but the British Government have shown no flexibility. The NI Affairs Committee's call for an exemption for customers of approved tour operators is also entirely reasonable. The Economy Minister hopes that the British Government will listen to the people here. As recently as last month, she wrote to the new Home Office Minister on the issue.

Local hospitality and tourism businesses also face a 20% VAT rate imposed by the British Government, compared with a rate of 13·5% in the South. As of July 2026, the Irish Government's further reduction in the VAT rate for food-led hospitality from 13·5% to 9% has created an 11% difference in VAT rates between North and South for those businesses.

That has widened the gap further and exacerbated the challenges faced by businesses in the North.


4.15 pm

Earlier this year, the Economy Minister met Hospitality Ulster and the NI Food to Go Association about a VAT reduction pilot scheme to address differences between the North and the South. Following that meeting, the Minister of Finance and the Economy Minister wrote to the Chief Secretary to the Treasury seeking a meeting on the issue. No response has been received to date, unfortunately, but they will keep pressing on that issue for our hospitality sector.

I know that the Economy Minister shares the ambition to unlock the full potential of tourism across this island. The Economy Minister will continue to deepen all-Ireland collaboration and to press the British Government to remove the constraints that they are imposing on the industry.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): I call Diana Armstrong to make a winding-up speech on the amendment. You have up to five minutes.

Ms D Armstrong: Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker. We have had a whistle-stop tour of Northern Ireland this afternoon, hearing about the best that Northern Ireland has to offer in a tourism sense. I thank Members for their contributions to the debate.

Let me begin by saying that I recognise the positive intentions behind the motion. Northern Ireland has enormous tourism potential. We have world-class natural assets; a rich cultural and historic heritage; a thriving food and drink offering; and a hospitality sector that consistently delivers a warm welcome to visitors. As a representative of the border constituency of Fermanagh and South Tyrone, I understand very well the benefits that tourism can bring to local communities. I therefore welcome efforts to strengthen tourism links across the island, particularly the expansion of Ireland's Hidden Heartlands into County Fermanagh, to promote Northern Ireland and to encourage greater numbers of visitors to discover all that Northern Ireland has to offer.

However, if we are serious about increasing visitor numbers and growing our tourism economy, we must also be serious about addressing the challenges facing the businesses that are expected to deliver that growth. That is why the amendment focuses on a very practical issue that is having a direct impact on hospitality businesses throughout Northern Ireland, particularly in our border regions. As Members have heard, hospitality, food and accommodation in Northern Ireland are generally subject to 20% VAT. In the Republic of Ireland, qualifying restaurant and catering services are taxed at 9%, while accommodation attracts a VAT rate of 13·5%. That is a difference of 11% on food and of 6·5% on accommodation.

Mr Chambers: Will the Member give way?

Ms D Armstrong: Certainly.

Mr Chambers: Does the Member agree that every sector of the hospitality industry in Northern Ireland has been vigorously calling for a reduction in VAT to at least echo the rate in the Republic of Ireland and that that would include all of the hospitality industry that is based in north Antrim?

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): The Member has an extra minute.

Ms D Armstrong: Thank you for your intervention. Yes, a one-size-fits-all approach should be taken. We need the reduction to be across the sector. I will refer to that later.

For many of us, those may sound like just percentages on paper, but, for a hotel owner, a restaurant owner or a tourism provider, they can represent the difference between investment and postponement, expansion and contraction and confidence and uncertainty.

The motion asks how Northern Ireland can secure a greater share of the tourism market. That is an entirely legitimate objective, however there is little point discussing how we can attract extra visitors if we fail to address one of the factors that makes it harder for our hospitality businesses to compete once those visitors arrive. I see that reality at first hand in my constituency. As my colleague mentioned, hotels in Enniskillen compete directly with hotels in Donegal, Monaghan and Cavan, particularly in the wedding trade. Restaurants, cafes and hospitality providers compete for many of the same customers. Visitors compare prices, accommodation options and overall value for money. Visitors do not distinguish between competing VAT systems; they simply decide where to spend their money.

Hospitality Ulster's August survey of operators across Northern Ireland found that 92% believe that a reduction in hospitality VAT is necessary for their business to grow, while 86% identified VAT costs as a key concern for the year ahead. The sector is clearly telling us that the issue matters. At a time when businesses here already face increased wage costs, National Insurance contributions, energy bills and so much more, that additional disadvantage is becoming increasingly difficult to absorb.

I recently spoke with a range of hospitality operators across Fermanagh and South Tyrone, and their message was remarkably consistent. They are not asking for special treatment or handouts; they want to invest and expand, create jobs, improve facilities and strengthen the visitor experience. Quite rightly, they question why, in addition to all those pressures, they should have to carry a significant tax disadvantage when competing for the same customers as the businesses that are located just a few miles across the border. That has now become an economic issue.

Hospitality supports local farmers, food producers, wholesalers, transport providers and countless small businesses throughout our towns and villages. When hospitality businesses struggle, the impact is felt well beyond their own front door. This is particularly true in rural constituencies where tourism and hospitality play a vital role in sustaining employment and supporting local economic activity. Indeed, the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee recognised the strength of that argument when it recommended a four-year pilot to reduce VAT on hospitality, food and accommodation to 10%. While that is ultimately a matter for the British Government, it falls to our Executive Minister to continue to make the case for Northern Ireland tourism and the hospitality sector. I recognise the efforts that have been made to this point, but more needs to be done.

The motion speaks to unlocking tourism potential, attracting visitors and growing the economy. Those ambitions are shared across the House, but if we genuinely want to realise that potential, we must ensure that the businesses that are at the heart of our tourism offering are not being asked to compete with one hand tied behind their back. Our amendment recognises a real disadvantage facing businesses today and calls for practical action to address it. I hope that Members can support our amendment.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): I call Patsy McGlone to conclude and make a winding-up speech on the motion. You have up to 10 minutes.

Mr McGlone: Go raibh maith agat, a LeasCheann Comhairle.

[Translation: Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker.]

As Ms Armstrong mentioned, we took quite a tour across the North and further afield. I mentioned the Boyneside, which, it should be recognised, has tremendous historical importance for many people in the House. We are not confined solely to the border around the six north-eastern counties; economically and politically, that is the way things are. Indeed, my colleague Mr McNulty rightly referred to the Irish Government's Shared Island unit's €100 million investment at Narrow Water. There are some others that stand out, such as the £250,000 investment in the 'Derry Girls' experience; the £250,000 investment in the Giant's Causeway visitor centre; the visitor experience at The Gobbins at Islandmagee in County Antrim, which received a £200,000 investment; the Courthouse in Bushmills, which received £103,000; and the Museum of Free Derry, which received £57,000. Those are but a few of the examples of collaboration, cooperation and investment where we have a Government acting positively, as we should be doing here with each other, to make sure that we take full advantage of the overall package.

The phrase that comes to mind is "no man, or woman, is an island". When it comes to packaging tourism here, we are an island. That is a fact. That is the reality, and that is how people see us and buy into us. As Mr Honeyford said earlier, that is what people want to buy into and that is what they see.

When she proposed the motion, my colleague Sinéad McLaughlin referred to the need for our towns, cities and countryside to capitalise on various locations. The role of Fáilte Ireland must be more expansive; in fact, the clue is in the title.

Mrs Dillon: I thank the Member for taking an intervention. He is right; the proposer of the motion talked about our towns and villages, but the one place that was not mentioned in the motion is Mid Ulster, which is literally the middle and the beating heart of Ulster. That is regrettable, because as the Member knows, it is known for the Hill of the O'Neill as well as for Tullaghoge and Seamus Heaney. All of that has an all-island context at its heart, so it is important that we recognise in the Chamber that Mid Ulster has a very important part to play in the collaboration across the island that is mentioned in the motion.

Mr McGlone: You are hardly going to get me to disagree with that, Linda, are you? Thank you very much for that.

The question of the ETA came up on numerous occasions. When people are coming into Dublin, you want to make sure that they travel as far as they can and come North. A lot of the travel comes through Dublin. That is a fact; that is reality. All you have to do is go down there anytime and look at the registration numbers on the cars and see the outgoings, let alone the incomings.

Mike Nesbitt referred to the VAT issue. It is a big problem, as Diana will know, in some of the border areas where the competition between the various hospitality sectors is obvious. When people where I live are booking weddings, they are looking at the competitive nature of the prices. Often there is a significant difference, because some of those weddings can be big and expensive, and the difference of 10%-odd off VAT can be quite a benefit when people are arranging their wedding. Pádraig Delargy also referred to the issue of VAT for the hospitality sector, and, of course, the reality of Brexit, which is where we have landed with the ETA. Diane Forsythe referred to Newry and Mourne and the Kingdom of Mourne. I hope that that new bridge will facilitate and help to increase tourism into the area. That is what it is there for. It is a positive investment in the area, and another example of key cross-border working together to make sure that everybody benefits. All boats are lifted by a rising tide.

With regard to the Northern Ireland tourism brand, David Honeyford referred to international tourism and his experiences in Donegal, which I hope were truly enjoyable, David. Áine Murphy, referring to geographic location, mentioned a number of places at Lough Erne. I often go on holiday there myself. It is a beautiful, lovely place. Peter Martin said that the motion placed too much emphasis on the all-island aspect. When it comes to tourism promotion, there could not be enough, and there could not be enough investment in it. I think that we all know that. Everybody benefits from that.

Kate Nicholl took us down the route of the requirement for stability. I will give you some anecdotal evidence as to where we are with stability. My brother was in Spain about three weeks ago. A guy from eastern Europe picked up on his accent and asked, "Are you English?" My brother said, "No, I'm Irish". He said, "What's that Drumcree place?" That was a guy from eastern Europe. I was talking to a gentleman just a fortnight ago who had been to a marriage in a small village in Zambia. He went down the street to a bar, and what did he hear at the far end of the bar but a discussion about Drumcree. He could not believe it. If anybody thinks that anything positive came of that, that is seriously not the message that we want sent out across the world, with people having second doubts about coming here or looking at the negativity and saying, "Nah, I don't want to go there". We want to send out a message of stability and about working and living together positively and respectfully.

The Minister referred to commitments from respective Ministers in the Executive to work with the Irish Government, and she referred to the Shared Island unit. I thank everyone for their commentary.

Tourism is a major contributor to the economy on the island of Ireland. It supports employment, hospitality and local businesses in often neglected rural areas and coastal communities. Its success is one of the standout peace dividends of the Good Friday Agreement. That success was enabled by cooperation on an all-island basis. It was in recognition of its economic importance that tourism was one of the areas chosen for formal cooperation through the North/South Ministerial Council. I have given a number of examples of that successful cooperation. Plenty of people on a lesser scale are being successful in their own right in their own areas, trying as best they can to run businesses. The North has benefited hugely from that cooperation, not least through the increase in the number of trips by visitors from the South to the North.

In 2025, there were 1·3 million of those trips, compared with 1·1 million in the previous year. Visitors on those trips spent £317 million in 2025, compared with the £243 million spent in 2024. That is as good a reason as any for increasing cooperation and beneficial North/South working. It is a win-win, so why not? And that was before Belfast successfully hosted this year's Fleadh Cheoil na hÉireann. The benefits of that growth are not centralised. It is estimated that there were 5·1 million overnight trips in 2025, 70% of them to locations outside Belfast.


4.30 pm

There are significant opportunities to ensure that more communities benefit more fully from international tourism on this island. The Wild Atlantic Way, Ireland's Ancient East and Ireland's Hidden Heartlands have shown the value in connecting destinations and investing in their potential. While the recent inclusion of Fermanagh in Ireland's Hidden Heartlands is a welcome example of practical North/South cooperation, there is more that we can do. The failure to extend Ireland's Ancient East into Armagh and Down is a missed opportunity, as is the lack of progress in connecting the Causeway coastal route with the Wild Atlantic Way. Derry and the wider north-west sit as a natural gateway between those internationally recognised destinations.

Our motion and the amendment identify potential barriers to the continued growth of the all-island tourism sector, particularly for the North. Significantly, the keys to unlock those barriers are held by the British Government in London. They now require international visitors to the island to pay a fee for official permission to travel to the North before —.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): The Member's time is up.

Mr McGlone: Yes. Thank you. On that note, maybe I will wind up. There is a lot more to say and, probably, a lot more to do.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): Thank you. I will reflect that Members have not held back on tourism promotion tonight, especially from a constituency perspective.

Question, That the amendment be made, put and agreed to.

Main Question, as amended, put.

Some Members: Aye.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): With one dissenting voice to be noted, the Ayes have it.

Main Question, as amended, accordingly agreed to.

Resolved:

That this Assembly recognises the enormous potential of all-island tourism to drive economic growth, create jobs and revitalise local communities; welcomes the extension of Ireland's Hidden Heartlands into Fermanagh as a positive example of North/South cooperation; expresses concern that Northern Ireland continues to miss out on opportunities to maximise its share of Ireland's international tourism success; supports greater ambition in linking the Wild Atlantic Way with the Causeway coastal route, positioning the Derry City and Strabane District Council area as a gateway to the north-west and extending Ireland's Ancient East into counties Armagh and Down; further recognises the UK Government's electronic travel authorisation (ETA) scheme as an unnecessary barrier to seamless cross-border tourism; calls on the UK Government to scrap the ETA requirement for visitors travelling to Northern Ireland from the Republic of Ireland; and further calls on the UK Government to urgently address the disparity in VAT rates on hospitality between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, which places hospitality and tourism businesses, particularly those in border counties, at a significant competitive disadvantage.

Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Blair): I ask Members to take their ease before we move to the next item of business.

(Madam Principal Deputy Speaker in the Chair)

Mr McGrath: I beg to move

That this Assembly recognises the serious failings identified in the Southern Health and Social Care Trust’s cervical screening programme; acknowledges the distress, uncertainty and loss of confidence caused by these systemic failures; commends the work of the Ladies with Letters campaign group in seeking answers, accountability and justice; believes that there must be full transparency regarding the circumstances that allowed these failures to occur, the adequacy of oversight and the response of those responsible; and calls on the Minister of Health to establish a statutory public inquiry into the failures in Northern Ireland’s cervical screening programme with a view to determining the facts, ensuring accountability and preventing such failures from ever happening again.

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: The Business Committee has agreed to allow up to one hour for the debate. The proposer of the motion will have five minutes in which to propose and five minutes in which to make a winding-up speech. All other Members who are called to speak will have three minutes.

Mr McGrath: There are few things more frightening than being told that you may have cancer, but imagine being told that the screening test that you trusted and that gave you reassurance may not have been as reliable as you believed. Then imagine being one of the 17,000 women receiving a letter telling them that there may have been a problem. Imagine the worry that that would cause, the questions that you would have and the fear for yourself and your family. Then imagine being told that, despite everything that had happened, there would be no public inquiry. That is why we are here today.

I begin by recognising the courage and determination of the Ladies with Letters campaign group. I have met the women and listened to their experiences, frustrations and concerns. They did not choose to become campaigners. They did not want to spend their time challenging reports, meeting politicians and fighting to get answers. They simply wanted to know that the screening service that they had trusted was safe and that, when things went wrong, someone would take responsibility. What struck me most from meeting them was that it is not about seeking retribution; it is about making sure that what happened to them does not happen to another woman. I say this directly to them: the SDLP stands with you and supports your demand for a statutory public inquiry.

The facts are deeply troubling. We have seen reports identifying failures in performance management, staffing, quality assurance, oversight and governance in the Southern Health and Social Care Trust's cervical screening programme. Professor Sir Frank Atherton's review identified serious management and governance failings in the Southern Trust and in the Public Health Agency (PHA). One of the concerns that were raised with me by the Ladies with Letters was that it was, in essence, a review of reviews. The women affected were not interviewed as part of the review, and nor were the screeners. That raises a basic question: how can we be confident that we have got to the bottom of what happened if we have not properly listened to the people at the centre of it? The women also raised concerns about training, underperforming screeners and, importantly, those who were supposed to oversee their work. If warning signs were there, why were they not acted on? Why did it take a whistle-blower to bring those matters to light? The responsibility for protecting women through cervical screening is regional, involving the Public Health Agency and the Department of Health. We need to know whether the failures were confined to one trust or whether there were weaknesses in the wider system. While improvements have been made, including the introduction of primary HPV testing, the women have raised concerns about how the changes are being implemented.

The Minister has accepted Professor Atherton's recommendation that a statutory public inquiry is unlikely to provide further technical clarity. I respect Professor Atherton's expertise and acknowledge the work that was undertaken, but I fundamentally disagree with the conclusion that an inquiry is unnecessary. This is not simply about revisiting technical evidence; it is about establishing who knew what, when they knew it and what they did about it. It is about giving women the opportunity to be heard through a genuinely independent process and about making sure that lessons are learned so that this cannot happen again.

When we met, the Ladies with Letters told me something very simple: the bedrock of the screening programme is trust. They are right. Women are encouraged to attend screening because it can save their life. They put their faith in the system and in the professionals responsible for delivering it. When that trust is damaged, it cannot be restored simply by publishing another report and telling people that enough has been done. Those women have already lived with years of uncertainty, fear and unanswered questions, and now they feel that the book has been closed before their concerns have been properly addressed.

I will finish where I began, with the women: the Ladies with Letters and the families who have lived with the worry and uncertainty that the situation has caused.

We can express sympathy in the Chamber, but sympathy alone is not enough. A statutory public inquiry would offer the opportunity to establish the truth, restore confidence and help prevent such failures from happening again. Ladies with Letters has refused to give up. In memory of Erin Harbinson and Lynsey Courtney, and for their families, the SDLP will not give up. Members, vote for the motion and do not give up either.

Mrs Dillon: I thank the proposer of the motion for speaking to it in the Chamber. It is sad that we are again discussing a serious failure in women's healthcare. This, however, is much more than a failure in women's healthcare, because it cost women their lives. It has taken mothers, daughters and wives away from their families and left people absolutely devastated. It has also damaged confidence in the cervical screening programme, and that is what I am most concerned about. Let us be real: although the programme has been imperfect, it will save lives. I have said this before, but I again appeal to all women to attend their cervical smear appointments, particularly now that we have HPV screening, which is much more accurate than the previous screening was. I say to those women, if they are concerned and symptomatic, not to think, "I got a result that says that I am clear" and let their concerns be washed away. Do not let your GP or any other health professional say, "You have had a smear test, and you are OK". If any woman thinks that she is not OK, I tell her to go back and insist that she wants to be seen again. It happens all too often in our health system that women's fears and concerns about their health are ignored. Women are not being believed when they say that something is not right. We therefore need to give women the confidence that they will be listened to when they raise concerns.

There is much more that I could say on the issue, but, given that we are limited to three minutes, I will simply say that the proposer is right that we need to have that inquiry. It would give those women, and in particular the families left behind, the confidence that everything that the Assembly can do to restore confidence in the system was being done and that whoever got it wrong for whatever went wrong would be held to account. Those women do not have that confidence. Many of us have met them on many occasions. The proposer is right to say that they should not have to fight for this, but they have fought, and they deserve to be listened to. Ladies with Letters and all the other women who have raised concerns with us deserve to be listened to. This is an opportunity for the Minister of Health to show that he is really listening to those women and that he will do something different from all the Health Ministers before him by delivering for women's healthcare in this place.

I am delighted that we now have HPV testing, but we did not have it when the issue with the screening programme first came to light. I persevered with asking the permanent secretary for HPV screening at the time, because we were the only part of these islands that did not have it. I will finish by asking young girls to get their HPV vaccine. I am not known for being a person who is in favour of vaccines, and —

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: The Member's time is up.

Mrs Dillon: — I do not shout about them, but, on this one, I say this: please get it.

Mrs Dodds: I support the motion, and everyone in the House will be very clear that I have supported an independent public inquiry that could compel people to come and answer questions. I am delighted that Sandra Courtney is in the Public Gallery.

Minister, we are all extremely disappointed that you and your colleagues are ruling out holding a public inquiry. In the Southern Trust, 17,500 women had their cervical smears recalled. Two people, whom we know of, Lynsey Courtney and Erin Harbinson, have passed away, but many more — I have attended some of the serious adverse incident (SAI) reviews — have been through an enormous amount because of the lack of answers.

Mr Buckley: I thank the Member for giving away. Does she agree that the issue has caused a huge crisis of confidence among women in our constituency of Upper Bann?

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: You have an extra minute, Diane.


4.45 pm

Mrs Dodds: It has, of course, proved to be an issue of confidence. However, I agree with the Member opposite: screening saves lives. If you have a screening appointment, you should attend it.

In May, following the publication of the Atherton report, the Minister's predecessor said:

"A Statutory Public Inquiry is a means to an end, that end being answering key questions. I believe those answers have been addressed ... We know what happened" —

and we know —

"who was responsible".

Minister, that is demonstrably not the case. We do not have the details of anyone who was responsible, particularly those who had management responsibilities. There is no reference to where they are working or the roles that they have had since. It would raise concern more broadly if the level of oversight, management and follow-up action was so limited that that might be reflective of the approach across other specialities and services. What signal does the failure to hold management to account send out about accountability for present-day or future programmes and services? Poor screening performance was one thing, but the broader failures in management and oversight are simply inexcusable.

There is a lack of accountability. I agree with the Member opposite that nobody wants a witch-hunt, but people need to be held accountable. How on earth were we ever in the situation that we found ourselves in from 2008 until October 2021, when the trust, by its own account, took its first robust action? How on earth could the trust have known about the monitoring of the performance of screeners being so poor but never checked the performance of screeners in the years before or the years after? We now know that all of the improvement programmes had no measurable impact. Furthermore, we know that no one in management has been held to account for all of that.

I finish by saying that it is worrying that we have waited for so long for the HPV screening programme, when other parts of the United Kingdom had the programme as early as 2015. It was recommended, but it was not in situ in Northern Ireland —

Mrs Dodds: — and that has led to part of the problem. Minister, I hope that you will have some good news for those women today and will answer questions —

Mrs Dodds: — on the issue.

Mrs Guy: I thank those who tabled the motion. I start by making something clear: I welcome the advances in cervical screening. The introduction of primary HPV testing and the HPV vaccination programme are hugely important developments. I want to see a future in which cervical cancer is eradicated. However, welcoming progress is not the same as accepting that the past can be put behind us without accountability. System change was essential and overdue in Northern Ireland, but system change is not accountability.

The failures in the Southern Trust were not simply the consequences of an imperfect screening method. Individuals persistently failed to meet the required standards; there was a negligent failure of oversight; opportunities to identify, challenge and address those failures were missed; and women died. What followed has done little to restore confidence. Three years on, we have had report after report, review after review and recommendation after recommendation, yet, for the women and families at the centre of the scandal, the process has too often felt like delay and obfuscation rather than a determined effort to establish the truth. There is a real concern that that has allowed people to move on quietly, without meaningful consequences or accountability.

These women and their families are not stupid. They know when they are being given answers, and they know when they are being managed. They know the difference between genuine accountability and a process that, right now, risks becoming a whitewash. They do not need more photographs, ministerial handshakes, expressions of sympathy or speeches from MLAs like me. They want some measure of justice for what they have experienced.

This is not simply a question of what happened in one trust. We know of the recent case of Louise Corbett Gibbons, a young woman who died aged 24 after, her family was told, her smear test had been misread. She was a Belfast Trust patient. We also know that the Western Trust has registered 12 serious adverse incidents relating to cervical cancer since 2017. Those incidents require proper understanding and scrutiny. Those cases do not establish that the same failures occurred elsewhere, but they reinforce what we cannot simply assume — that the Southern Trust scandal was an isolated problem — and the idea that we cannot simply close the book. A statutory public inquiry is not about prejudicing individuals or apportioning blame without evidence; it is about establishing the facts, examining individual and institutional responsibility, scrutinising failures of oversight and determining whether there were wider weaknesses in the screening programme.

Again, I welcome the changes that have been made. I want cervical cancer to be eradicated. I encourage every woman who is invited for screening to take up that invitation and every person who is offered the HPV vaccine to accept it. Those advances have, however, come too late for Lynsey Courtney and Erin Harbinson.

The Ladies with Letters and their families have waited long enough. That is why I support the motion. I call on the Minister to initiate a statutory public inquiry.

Mr Chambers: I begin by acknowledging the women and families at the heart of the matter, particularly the families of Lynsey Courtney and Erin Harbinson. The courage of the women and families who have spoken publicly and the persistence of the Ladies with Letters group deserve our full respect. I applaud the efforts of local representatives from all the parties for keeping the issue to the fore, including those of my colleague Councillor Julie Flaherty, who has been a powerful advocate.

More than 17,000 women were included in the review. It is reassuring that the vast majority of results were confirmed to be normal. However, that does not erase the report's findings: persistent underperformance, poor management and serious failures in governance and quality assurance. The serious adverse incident review found that poor performance was allowed to continue, resulting in significant harm to some women. As we all know, screening is not a diagnostic tool and cannot detect every case. However, that does not excuse weak oversight or a failure to act, and uncertainty over an individual diagnosis should not close down questions about how the system was managed.

The report identifies serious organisational failings, even when every outcome cannot be established. Professor Frank Atherton's independent review helpfully and importantly brought together the significant breadth of earlier work. He has acknowledged that a statutory inquiry could provide greater assurance through full disclosure and truthful testimony. The question is whether the existing reports provide the fullest account of what happened and who was responsible. I have faith that the Minister will approach the entire issue with an open mind, along with a willingness to listen. All voices, views and opinions matter, especially those of the women affected. I know that he will do what he considers to be right.

Primary HPV testing is now in place, and services have been brought together in one regional laboratory. Those are important steps. However, the structure alone does not prove resilience. Equipment problems and contingency testing in recent years underline the need for oversight of capacity, turnaround and quality assurance. Women need to see that the service works reliably and that problems are addressed quickly.

As public representatives, we have a responsibility to try to maintain and, where necessary, rebuild confidence and to encourage women to attend screening when invited. There is no doubt that screening saves lives, but confidence will not be restored by repeating that message alone. The public deserve to have confidence that such failures will not be repeated. I wish the Minister well with his further engagement on the issue.

Mr McGuigan: My thoughts today are, first and foremost, with the women and families who have endured unimaginable distress as a result of failures in our cervical screening programme. For the 17,500 women who received letters, the experience has been marked by anxiety, uncertainty and trauma, and for some families, it has been marked by heartbreaking loss. I extend my deepest sympathies to the families who have lost loved ones.

I commend the extraordinary courage and determination of the Ladies with Letters campaign. Those women have been failed by a system that was supposed to protect them, and they are rightly demanding answers, accountability and justice. I make it absolutely clear that I fully support their call for a public inquiry. The previous Health Minister argued that an inquiry was unlikely to uncover any new information, but how can anyone possibly know that without first holding an inquiry? Surely that is precisely the purpose of an inquiry: to examine all the evidence, question those responsible and establish whether there are facts that are yet to come to light.

As a member of the Health Committee, I have been involved in scrutinising some of the failures, questioning officials and examining reports, but there is a fundamental difference between scrutiny and a statutory public inquiry with the powers to compel evidence and establish accountability. Women should not have to prove that there is more information to uncover before they are entitled to the fullest possible investigation. I have previously spoken in the Chamber about my concerns regarding the repeated failings across women's healthcare. Whether the issue is cervical screening, vaginal mesh, maternity services, endometriosis or the unacceptable gynaecological and breast cancer waiting lists, a common theme emerges: too many women have felt unheard, with their concerns dismissed and their symptoms minimised. Too often, women who should be concentrating on their own health and recovery are, instead, forced to become activists and campaigners. That should never happen. We must restore confidence in cervical screening, because screening saves lives. Women need to have confidence in their results and timely follow-up care.

In conclusion, I commend the Ladies With Letters campaign again. A public inquiry should be seen not as a threat to our health service but as an opportunity to strengthen it. Justice cannot be delivered by telling women that there is nothing more to discover; it requires us to be willing to uncover the full truth. That is why I support the motion and urge the Minister to establish a public inquiry.

Mr Wilson: I rise in support of the motion and the call for a statutory public inquiry into the failures in the Southern Health and Social Care Trust’s cervical screening programme. This debate is about far more than systems, processes or reports; it is about women who placed their trust in our healthcare system, families who have been left seeking answers, and a public who deserves to have the confidence that such failings can never happen again.

For those of us who represent constituencies that are served by the Southern Trust, this issue is deeply significant. Women and families from Newry and Armagh have been affected by the failings, while local people have also been at the forefront of the campaign to seek answers, transparency and accountability. They have shown immense courage and determination in pursuing the truth, and they deserve recognition for their efforts. I pay tribute to the Ladies With Letters campaign group. Their persistence, dignity and determination have ensured that the issue has remained in the public spotlight. They have spoken for not only themselves but the many other women who continue to live with uncertainty and unanswered questions.

While public apologies have been made and a series of reviews undertaken, many women remain dissatisfied with the answers that they have received. Tragically, lives have been lost, and this is not a matter of policy or procedure for those families; it is a matter of loss, grief and a search for accountability. We have seen a number of reports published on various aspects of the scandal, yet, despite that, confidence has not been restored. Many women are still waiting for the transparency and accountability that they were promised. That alone should give us pause for thought. The recommendations made by the Royal College of Pathologists highlighted concerns about staffing levels, workload pressures, performance management and oversight arrangements. Those findings raise serious questions about how problems were allowed to persist and whether warning signs were acted on quickly enough.

It is also concerning that those seeking answers have had to battle for access to information that is central to understanding what went wrong. Openness and transparency should never have to be fought for; they should be the default position of our public services. The Minister has argued that a statutory public inquiry is unlikely to provide any further clarity. However, the women affected, their families and those campaigning on their behalf clearly believe that there is more to uncover. More importantly, they believe that accountability still needs to be delivered. A statutory public inquiry would provide the highest level of independent scrutiny; it would allow the evidence to be examined in full, give those affected the opportunity to have their voices heard and establish a comprehensive account of what happened and why. Above all else, it would help to restore trust in a screening programme on which thousands of women across Northern Ireland rely every year. Those women deserve reassurance and confidence, and those affected by these failings deserve answers. For those reasons, I support the motion and urge the Minister to establish a statutory public inquiry.


5.00 pm

Miss McAllister: I support the motion and the call for a statutory public inquiry. It is not the first time that we have spoken about the issue in the Chamber, but I hope that it will be the last. I hope that most of the House will unite around the call for a statutory public inquiry.

In 1997, an independent inquiry chaired by Sir William Wells re-examined major cervical screening failures at Kent and Canterbury Hospital in England. The proportion of failures there per head of population was much lower than in Northern Ireland, yet the women who were affected received justice, there was justice in relation to the deaths that occurred, and people were held accountable. Why can that not be the case for our women here in Northern Ireland? There may have been only two deaths, but Lynsey and Erin mattered not only to the politicians in the Chamber but to the Northern Ireland public as a whole.

When mistakes happen in public life, as a bare minimum, the expectation should be that those impacted on get the truth about what happened and that someone and some organisations take responsibility and accountability. It is the least that those women and their families deserve, yet they have been failed here again.

Implemented and further proposed changes to the screening programme have been welcomed by parties across the House, but we cannot expect the thousands of women who were impacted on by the scandal to simply draw a line under it and move on. At this point, I pay tribute to the Ladies with Letters, who have been truly inspirational in their campaign for truth and justice not just for them but for women who will come forward in the future for screening tests and vaccines. As a society, if we work together, this is a disease that we can eradicate.

The Health Committee and the Northern Ireland Assembly previously agreed on the issue. Therefore, it is really disappointing that the previous Minister did not commit to a statutory inquiry. I understand that Sir Frank Atherton's report accepted that a statutory public inquiry would provide "a greater degree of assurance" for those impacted on, but I question why he went on to state that it was not necessary. Both statements simply cannot be true. When there is no accountability, there is no learning.

On many occasions, the Alliance Party has stood with women on the steps of this Building and in our constituencies to call for a public inquiry, and so has the Health Minister's party. Now is the time to work together and ensure that we bring final truth and justice to all the women involved now and in the future.

Mr Buckley: I am sure that all parties will agree that it is very hard to give the debate the serious scrutiny that it deserves in three-minute speeches.

At the heart of the issue are women who placed their trust in the health service, who did everything that was asked of them and who had every right to expect that the system designed to protect them would do just that. Instead, we have seen failures, failings, devastating consequences and families left searching for answers. There are many families at the heart of the failure. Each one has their own immensely personal story to tell, but I will speak about one family today, and that is the Courtney family, whom I have had the immense privilege of knowing my entire life, from primary school through to today. I have had the immense privilege of representing them as their local Assembly Member, and I place on record my personal thanks and gratitude to Sandra Courtney, mother of the late Lynsey Courtney — Sandra is in the Public Gallery today — and the entire Courtney family.

Lynsey was a shining star in Portadown. She lit up every room that she entered. Tragically, she lost her life at 30 years of age. Behind all the reports, reviews and discussions in the Chamber is the heartbreaking reality of a family who lost a much-loved mother, daughter and friend. No mother should ever have to experience the heartbreaking loss of a daughter and then find herself having to fight for answers, accountability and justice.

I personally thank Sandra, Ron and Callum for their courage, dignity and determination. In speaking out, they are not only honouring Lynsey's memory but helping to ensure that other families do not suffer the same heartbreak. Lynsey was not simply a name in a report or a statistic in a review. She was a daughter, a mother, a loved one and somebody whose life mattered immensely.

I commend the Ladies with Letters campaign group. Those women and their families have shown extraordinary courage in their pursuit of truth. They have had to relive painful experiences and challenge the very institutions in which they had placed their trust.

Mrs Dodds: I thank the Member for giving way. In light of the ongoing campaigns, is it not now time to stop the rhetoric and simply get on with instigating the public inquiry that will help us to get to the truth?

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: The Member has an extra minute.

Mr Buckley: I thank the Member for that intervention. She is so right. We have heard the women's stories, and it is right that we echo their words in the Chamber. Whether it has been out in the Great Hall, on the steps or on the radio, those families have clearly demonstrated the need for an inquiry of that magnitude. It should never fall upon grieving families to force the system to confront its own failures.

That brings me to the fundamental questions that remain. How were those failures allowed to happen? Were opportunities missed to identify them sooner? What did those who were responsible for oversight know? How and when did they know it? Crucially, could some of the devastating consequences have been prevented? That is why I support a statutory public inquiry to get to the truth, ensure that it never happens again and restore the faith and trust of women up and down this country in a service that must be there to protect their needs.

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: Minister, you have up to 10 minutes to respond to the debate.

Mr Butler (The Minister of Health): Thank you, Madam Principal Deputy Speaker. I welcome the opportunity to respond to the motion. I want to begin with the women and families who have been affected, and I thank Members for speaking so passionately, eloquently and sensitively about what was a significant failure.

There were serious failures in the management, governance and quality control of the laboratory services that were provided by the Southern Trust to the NI cervical screening programme. Those failures caused understandable distress and have damaged confidence, as has been set out by a number of Members. I am sorry about what happened and the distress that was caused to women and their families. I had the privilege to meet the Ladies with Letters at the start of their campaign. For the record, I know personally some of the women who were affected and received letters. From the outset, I also acknowledge the work that has been done by Members collectively, right across the political piece. Understandably, the call from the Chamber is unanimous. I am faced with other challenges, however, and I will get to some of those. Members have continued to seek answers and accountability, and rightly so, often while dealing with deeply personal and painful experiences. I am very sorry to hear the remarks from the Member for Upper Bann Mr Buckley. You know one of the families on a personal level; that can only add to your frustration. A meeting had been arranged between the group and me earlier this month. Sadly, it did not go ahead. I still hope to have that meeting with the group shortly to hear the women's experiences directly. I have said previously that I will be a listening, learning Minister, and I intend to uphold that.

The Assembly has already received a substantial body of work on the issue. Some of that has been mentioned. Reports have examined the Southern Trust's laboratory cytology service, the review of previous screening results and the quality assurance arrangements for the NI cervical screening programme. A serious adverse incident review examined the cases of 12 women who had received services from the Southern Trust. Professor Sir Frank Atherton then reviewed all the earlier work. He also considered whether a statutory public inquiry was likely to provide significant further insight into the complex considerations that were set out in the earlier report. Sir Frank was independent of the health service in Northern Ireland. Before finalising his terms of reference directly with the previous Minister, he met representatives of the Ladies with Letters group. During his work, he also heard from clinicians, managers, officials and other people with relevant information, including the whistle-blower who has been referred to throughout the debate.

Sir Frank's findings must be read in full. They do not say that nothing went wrong. They identity clear management and governance failings in the Southern Trust and Public Health Agency.

Mrs Dodds: Will the Minister give way?

Mr Butler: I will not. I have only 10 minutes. Sorry.

The serious adverse incident review found that poor performance had been allowed to persist, with inadequate oversight, and that harm was caused to some women. At the same time, Sir Frank explained why the evidence cannot provide a reliable answer in every individual case. The Southern Trust laboratory pathway differed from the nationally recommended process, and the data that was used to assess screening performance within the laboratory service therefore had its limitations.

Sir Frank, however, noted that findings from the look-back at previous slides, known as the cervical cytology review (CCR), makes it unlikely that large numbers of women had been adversely affected or came to harm. A screening result cannot always be linked conclusively to a later diagnosis of cancer, but I have to reiterate the calls that have been made across the Chamber that screening is a vital tool. We encourage all women to get screened early and to have the HPV vaccination, because that is the best barrier available at this time.

That uncertainty should not be used to minimise the impact on women, and it does not mean that we must be careful not to claim more or, indeed, less than the evidence establishes. I really recognise why campaigners and some Members believe that a statutory inquiry is necessary. Sir Frank acknowledged the point that an inquiry would, by its nature, provide greater assurance on full disclosure and the truthfulness of testimony. That is a serious point, and I do not dismiss it. Sir Frank also said that he had seen nothing to suggest that any requested data or documents were withheld from any review team. He also asked specifically whether an inquiry would add significant insight or responsibility and improve the future safety of the programme. His conclusion was that an inquiry would be highly unlikely to make further progress in unravelling the technical aspects of the historical failures in the screening programme. The differences in the way in which the programme was delivered in the trust and the way in which data was recorded would continue to limit what could be established, and there remains the difficulty of distinguishing between the inherent features of a screening programme that will never be fully able to identify all cases of future diseases and a diagnostic programme that is expected to give a more definitive conclusion.

The reports have identified where the responsibility lay at an organisational level — in management, governance, quality control and quality assurance — but Sir Frank did not recommend seeking further sanctions against individual screeners or managers. That is not the same as saying that there was no responsibility. It reflects the limits of what the evidence can fairly establish about individual cases and individual conduct. We understand that that may not satisfy everyone who understandably wants a fuller process of accountability.

A few issues were raised in the debate. One, concerning the action of screeners and the subsequent investigation, is important to read into the record. In meeting my officials over the past few weeks on the matter, I had not been aware of it. I cannot remember which Member raised the issue, but I understand that the Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC) is looking at a number of people connected to the cervical screening programme. It is an ongoing investigation and adjudication process. It would be inappropriate to comment on it, but there is a process that that may well be in train.

Sir Frank’s advice does not mean that an inquiry could add nothing. He judged that it was highly unlikely to resolve the technical questions further, given the differences in the historical laboratory pathway and the limitations of the data. Taking that advice together with the work already completed, I do not propose today to establish the statutory public inquiry. I recognise that Members will disagree with that position, but, to be clear, it is not a closed position. My decision is based on the evidence before me today. I will remain in listening mode and take the time to consider everything carefully.

From the start, I have said that I will be honest with people and do what is within my power on the basis of the evidence that is available to me. I will listen, however. In the meantime, my responsibility is to address the failings that have been identified, to ensure that changes have been made, to sustain those changes and to make all progress open and transparent. The point about a lack of confidence in services has been well made. Mrs Dillon has repeatedly made the point about women's health to me, in particular the lack of confidence that women have in how their health has been treated over many decades. I fundamentally want to see that reversed.

The cervical screening programme has changed significantly since the events occurred. Many Members touched on that. The programme that is delivered today is a very different programme. Primary HPV testing was fully introduced in December 2023, with cytology now used as a second-line test where HPV is found. Since November 2024, one regional laboratory service has provided the laboratory testing part of the screening pathway. Those changes have improved consistency and oversight across the screening programme.

Recommendations from the Royal College of Pathologists have been implemented. Recommendations from the NHS England review and the Southern Trust’s review of serious adverse incidents have either been fully completed or are actively being implemented. My officials are working with the Public Health Agency, the strategic planning and performance group (SPPG), which is the commissioning body, and the trust to take forward all of Sir Frank's recommendations. I will keep the Assembly and the Committee updated on that work, setting out which recommendations have been completed, what work remains under way and, importantly, how the system is checking and demonstrating that the improvements are working in practice. That is the bare minimum that we can do for the legacy of those who have suffered and lost.

The Department's cervical screening oversight and assurance group will continue to seek and receive assurances that the steps that are being taken are working and that public confidence in the programme is restored and then maintained.

I know that a new laboratory pathway and new oversight arrangements cannot undo what women have experienced, nor should women be asked simply to trust that things have improved. We need to demonstrate that. We must show, through open reporting and continued scrutiny, that lessons have been acted on.


5.15 pm

The screening programme is not a diagnostic test, and no screening programme will identify every case of disease, but that fact does not excuse weak management or inadequate quality assurance. That was Mrs Dodds's point, with which I concur. The current programme is different from the one that operated during the period under review, and we must continue to make our current programme as safe and effective as possible.

I am also aware that some women still have questions about their screening history. Women diagnosed with invasive cervical cancer before 2019 who want to know whether an audit of their screening history was carried out can and should contact the Public Health Agency.

In 2025-26, the programme's coverage was 66·7%, which was broadly consistent with previous years, but it is not enough. More women should be encouraged and supported to attend screening when invited, and we must keep addressing the barriers that prevent them from doing so.

I recognise the strength of feeling behind the motion and the questions that remain for women and families. I am sorry for the failures and the distress that was caused. I will keep listening. I will meet the Ladies with Letters group in the near future and try to ensure that the Assembly can learn from what went on in the past and see what remains to be done. As I have stated, I remain in listening mode, and I look forward to meeting the Ladies with Letters group in the very near future.

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: I call Justin McNulty to conclude and wind up the debate. Justin, you have five minutes.

Mr McNulty: Go raibh maith agat, a Phríomh-Leas-Cheann Comhairle.

[Translation: Thank you, Madam Principal Deputy Speaker.]

I thank all Members who spoke with such passion on the motion.

Trust in our health service is central to delivering skilled and compassionate healthcare. When that trust is broken and eroded, those who were harmed deserve answers and tangible action plans that show the work that is being done to ensure that that trust is never broken again. My thoughts are first and foremost with all the patients and families who were harmed by this abysmal failing by our health service. I recognise the Ladies with Letters, who, despite their distress and hurt, have campaigned with determined and dedicated advocacy to shine a light on an unacceptable violation of women's health and trust.

Women's health is under-researched, underfunded and under-resourced. The North still does not have a dedicated women's health strategy, and a 2022 report by Nurofen found that over half of women felt that their pain was ignored or dismissed by healthcare professionals. Those grave injustices have severe consequences for women's health and well-being.

The cervical cancer screening programme in the Southern Trust is a shocking and tragic example of critical failure in women's health. The women affected have suffered immense trauma not only from the initial failures by cytology staff but as a result of the continued lack of trauma-informed practices that have impacted them and their families throughout the review, particularly the women who received serious adverse incident reports. The families of Erin Harbinson and Lynsey Courtney, who tragically lost their lives as a result of the scandal, do not want sympathy and empty promises; they want answers.

Mrs Dodds: I thank the Member for giving way. I am glad that he mentioned the cytology staff. Does he agree, in reference to the Minister's comment, that the screeners were referred to their professional body by the Ladies with Letters group, not by their managers?

Madam Principal Deputy Speaker: Justin, you have an extra minute.

Mr McNulty: That is an important point well made

I met Sandra, Lynsey Courtney's mother, today, and she is in the Public Gallery. I pay tribute to her strength in fighting for answers for her daughter and her determination to ensure that no other woman has to experience what her daughter and her family have experienced. Lynsey sought an SAI review of her case, and Sandra was committed to her daughter's wish to ensure that the SAI review would be undertaken, thinking, all the while, that Lynsey would be OK and make a full recovery. Tragically, however, Lynsey passed away, and, unforgivably, no SAI review was conducted. There was no look-back review, and the family felt that the trust did not want Lynsey's case to see the light of day.

Serious questions need to be answered, particularly on screening practices. It is unacceptable that the failing happened in the first place, but it is inexcusable that the issue has been inflamed by denial, delays and distraction. It is disappointing to hear today the Minister's position of not committing to a full statutory public inquiry. If the Minister is not going to establish a statutory public inquiry, how will he, his Department and the Southern Trust re-establish trust with women? How will they ensure that women are encouraged to continue to attend screening in a timely manner? How can the Department think that trust can be repaired without a full and transparent public inquiry and an investigation that shows that the Health Department is serious about upholding the highest standards in women's health? How can the Department reassure women that the issue is confined to the Southern Trust, which does not track with tragic stories from women in the Western Trust and the Belfast Trust?

Mrs Dillon: I thank the Member for taking an intervention. Does he agree that it may be beneficial for the Minister to meet Dr Gabriel Scally, who carried out the review in the South? He has said that he does not believe that the reviews that have been carried out to date meet the needs or answer the questions that need to be answered. I would like to understand from Dr Gabriel Scally why exactly he thinks that, because he carried out the review in the South and would have something to add.

Mr McNulty: That is another point very well made, and I think that the Minister will take that on board.

There is a need to examine not only the circumstances in the Southern Trust but also the effectiveness of wider oversight and accountability arrangements across the North's cervical screening programme. Women need to have total faith in screening processes and in the healthcare system that is caring for them and listening to their concerns. That can be achieved only through a public inquiry during which all failings are identified and addressed and all lessons learned so that those impacted can get the answers that they deserve.

I commend the motion.

Question put and agreed to.

Resolved:

That this Assembly recognises the serious failings identified in the Southern Health and Social Care Trust’s cervical screening programme; acknowledges the distress, uncertainty and loss of confidence caused by these systemic failures; commends the work of the Ladies with Letters campaign group in seeking answers, accountability and justice; believes that there must be full transparency regarding the circumstances that allowed these failures to occur, the adequacy of oversight and the response of those responsible; and calls on the Minister of Health to establish a statutory public inquiry into the failures in Northern Ireland’s cervical screening programme with a view to determining the facts, ensuring accountability and preventing such failures from ever happening again.

Executive Committee Business

Health and Social Care (Staffing) Bill: First Stage

Mr Butler (The Minister of Health): I beg to introduce the Health and Social Care (Staffing) Bill [NIA Bill 49/22-27], which is a Bill to require the Department of Health to develop policies relating to the staffing of health and social care services; require Health and Social Care trusts to carry out workforce planning; require the other health and social care bodies to have regard to guidance relating to the staffing of those bodies; and for connected purposes.

Bill passed First Stage and ordered to be printed.

Adjourned at 5.23 pm.

Find Your MLA

tools-map.png

Locate your local MLA.

Find MLA

News and Media Centre

tools-media.png

Read press releases, watch live and archived video

Find out more

Follow the Assembly

tools-social.png

Keep up to date with what’s happening at the Assem

Find out more

Subscribe

tools-newsletter.png

Enter your email address to keep up to date.

Sign up